94. During the previous peer reviews, all peers that provided input indicated having a good working relationship with the United States’ competent authority with regard to MAP. Some of these peers suggested possible improvements to further strengthen this working relationship in the stage 1 report which appeared to have been followed up by the stage 2 report, such as being more proactive in finding solutions before bilateral meetings or modernising the channels of communication.
95. Five peers stated in cycle 1 that the update report provided by the United States fully reflects their experiences with the United States since 1 September 2018 and/or there are no additions to the previous input given in stage 2. However, two of these peers also reported that they enjoy a good working relationship with the United States’ competent authority.
96. 11 additional peers provided input on element C.3. One peer reported that it continues to have an overall positive, professional and cooperative working relationship with the United States’ competent authority and that periodic communications and timely exchanges have taken place between both competent authorities allowing for numerous cases to be resolved within reasonable timeframes, many in less than 24 months, during the covered period. This peer further noted that it appreciates the United States’ efforts to resolve their common MAP cases and that it finds the United States’ competent authority to be open to engagement, helpful and committing adequate resources on the resolution of their MAP cases.
97. One peer reported that it still has a very good and constructive relationship with both APMA and TAIT with regular exchanges taking place either via conference calls or in-person. Further, this peer considers that the United States’ competent authority has more than adequate resources as well as excellent and experienced staff.
98. One peer reported that its experience since 1 September 2018 with respect to the timely resolution of MAP cases with the United States’ competent authority has been very positive with their dealings in resolving MAP cases being professional, cooperative and efficient and its working relationship with the United States’ competent authority well-established, strong, positive and respectful. This peer added that it considers the United States’ competent authority to be proactive in seeking to resolve MAP cases in a timely manner and available to discuss MAP cases both virtually and in-person in order to facilitate the progression of MAP cases with both competent authorities engaging in regular communication, always in a positive, collaborative and co-operative way with respect to the resolution of MAP cases.
99. One peer reported that it has, since October 1, 2018, significantly enhanced its relationship with the United States’ competent authority with the communication between both jurisdictions’ case handlers being not only frequent but also highly collaborative. The peer noted that meetings between the competent authorities were exceptionally effective and productive, playing a crucial role in the timely resolution of MAPs as well as in reaching an agreement in bilateral APAs and that despite the complexity of some cases, the United States’ competent authority has always been committed to resolving them in a principled manner, at the same time proving to be flexible and open to mutually satisfactory solutions. The peer considers its MAP relationship with the United States strong, effective and trust grounded and is very happy to work and collaborate with the United States’ competent authority that it believes adequately resourced, funded and properly trained to handle all MAP cases.
100. One peer reported that it has a longstanding relationship with the United States in resolving MAP cases, which is considered to be very good. Both competent authorities hold one in-person competent authority meeting per year for transfer pricing cases. In addition, the peer reported that it holds video conferences with the United States’ competent authority on specific transfer pricing cases if needed but that for other MAP cases, so far no competent authority meetings were held and that due to the increase of pending cases, scheduling (virtual) meetings could be helpful to timely resolve MAP cases. Regarding communication, the peer considers the email communication to be generally good and quick, except in some transfer pricing cases where communication is less quick and position papers are not always timely submitted. The peer added that since a few years, it has agreed with the United States that for transfer pricing cases, position papers will be shared one month in advance of a competent authority meeting, although for other cases, experience is too limited to provide any input. The peer is of the view that MAP cases can be resolved with the United States and that its competent authority is solution-oriented and clear in its argumentation, although timeliness of resolving MAP cases can deviate and, in some cases, it takes the United States’ competent authority substantial time to internally align on a position as compared to the past. Further, the peer expressed that it welcomes the United States’ statement that electronic platforms are leveraged to ensure a swifter MAP process. Lastly, the peer noted that it would welcome, in practical terms, a further dialogue with the United States to optimize the exchange of encrypted documents between the competent authorities. The United States responded that it acknowledges this constructive feedback and is already taking steps to manage inventory to reduce the instances of its competent authority sending position papers less than a month before the bilateral meeting such as reviewing case load by analyst. Additionally, they had a virtual meeting with this peer in November 2024 and are planning an in-person meeting for the Spring of 2025.
101. One peer indicated that it is very pleased with its cooperation with the United States’ competent authority and that their common MAP cases are generally closed in a timely and effective manner. Another peer reported that for its two MAP cases with the United States, both position papers were received in a timely manner.
102. One peer noted that under the period covered by the peer review both competent authorities have had several bilateral meetings related to attribution/allocation cases which were held in a friendly environment and with a fluent relationship between both competent authorities. However, this peer added that, in its experience, when the adjustment that originates the MAP request is based on a “Closing agreement” agreed by the United States’ tax administration, the impossibility of the United States’ competent authority to deviate from such decision could be an obstacle to the satisfactory resolution of the MAP case. The United States responded to this peer input and explained that this impossibility to deviate is not a policy decision but a statutory limitation described in Section 7121 of the Internal Revenue Code (“IRC”), which is a law of general applicability that applies beyond the competent authority context. The United States added that if a taxpayer voluntarily enters into a closing agreement with the IRS pursuant IRC Section 7121, the statute states that the closing agreement is final and conclusive for both the IRS and the taxpayer, except upon a showing of fraud or malfeasance, or misrepresentation of a material fact. Further the United States noted that it is the policy of the IRS to inform taxpayers during the examination process that an adjustment may lead to double taxation and of their right to competent authority assistance with this taxpayer notification by the examiners occurring before the taxpayer voluntarily enters into a binding closing agreement with the IRS. The United States indicated that its MAP guidance clearly explains this result in its section 6. Lastly, the United States stated that in situations where the IRS examination team and the taxpayer agree to the resolution of an audit issue and do not enter into a binding closing agreement under IRC Section 7121, then its competent authority is not legally bound by that resolution when resolving a MAP case for that issue.
103. One peer reported that even though it appears there has been some turn-over among managers, the members of the TAIT team are competent, helpful and timely in their work. Another peer noted that its collaboration with the United States’ competent authority is very good and productive and that MAP cases are resolved in a timely manner.
104. One peer indicated having a positive working relationship with the United States and reaching resolutions which resolve double taxation in the majority of cases. It considers that the United States’ competent authority has very experienced members in its team who provide valuable technical insight when discussing MAP cases and believes that the United States has a well-resourced competent authority function.
105. The last peer that provided input stated that it enjoys an overall positive, cordial and professional relationship with the United States' competent authority with regular and collaborative communication through status update calls and in-person meetings at least twice a year on a reciprocal basis. This peer further noted that both competent authorities manage to discuss and agree on principled stands while maintaining adequate flexibility, ensuring mutually agreeable solutions and strengthening cooperation between the two jurisdictions.