Luxembourg has an extensive tax treaty network with 93 tax treaties and has signed and ratified the EU Arbitration Convention as well as adopted and implemented the Council Directive (EU) 2017/1852 of 10 October 2017 on tax dispute resolution mechanisms in the European Union. It has a large MAP inventory, with a large number of new cases submitted each year and 251 cases pending on 31 December 2023, close to 71% of which are other cases. Luxembourg has an established MAP programme and has long-standing experience with resolving MAP cases. Overall Luxembourg meets almost all the elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard. Where it has deficiencies, Luxembourg is working to address them.
All of Luxembourg’s tax treaties contain a provision relating to MAP. Those treaties mostly follow paragraphs 1 through 3 of Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]). Its treaty network is largely consistent with the requirements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard, except mainly for the fact that 15% of its tax treaties neither contain a provision stating that mutual agreements shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits in domestic law (which is required under Article 25(2), second sentence), nor the alternative provisions that set a time limit for making adjustments under Article 9(1) and Article 7(2).
In order to be fully in line with all four key areas of an effective dispute resolution mechanism under the Action 14 Minimum Standard, Luxembourg needs to amend and update 18 of its tax treaties. In this respect, Luxembourg signed and ratified the Multilateral Instrument, through which 13 of its tax treaties have been modified to fulfil the requirements under the Action 14 Minimum Standard. For the five treaties that will not currently be modified, upon entry into force of the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg reported that one of them should be updated by the Multilateral Instrument in the future and that it intends to update the remaining via bilateral negotiations to be in line with the requirements under the Action 14 Minimum Standard. For this purpose, negotiations are completed, scheduled or envisaged with three treaty partners and for the remaining treaty, no actions have been planned or taken. Furthermore, Luxembourg opted for part VI of the Multilateral Instrument concerning the introduction of a mandatory and binding arbitration provision in tax treaties.
Luxembourg is almost fully in line with the remaining elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard because of the following.
Luxembourg meets the Action 14 Minimum Standard concerning the prevention of disputes. Although it does not have in place a formal bilateral APA programme, APAs can be conducted by the competent authority and roll-backs may be granted in practice.
Luxembourg also meets the requirements regarding the availability and access to MAP under the Action 14 Minimum Standard. It provides access to MAP in all eligible cases. Furthermore, Luxembourg has in place a documented bilateral consultation or notification process for those situations in which its competent authority considers the objection raised by taxpayers in a MAP request as not justified. Luxembourg also has clear and comprehensive guidance on the availability of MAP and how it applies this procedure in practice, both under tax treaties and the EU Arbitration Convention, and has updated its MAP profile.
Concerning the average time needed to close MAP cases, the MAP statistics for Luxembourg for the period 2018-23 are as follows:
2018-23
Opening Inventory 1/1/2018
Cases started
Cases closed
End Inventory 31/12/2023
Average time to close cases (in months)
Attribution/allocation cases
24
109
61
72
30.24
Other cases
164
1092
1077
179
12.88
Total
188
1201
1138
251
13.81
Source: OECD
The number of cases Luxembourg closed in 2018-23 is 95% of the number of all cases started in those years. During these years, MAP cases were on average closed within a timeframe of 24 months (which is the pursued average for resolving MAP cases), as the average time necessary was 13.81 months. However, the average time to close attribution / allocation cases is longer (30.24 months) than the average time to close other cases (12.88 months). Further, Luxembourg's MAP inventory as on 31 December 2023 increased by 34% as compared to 1 January 2018, and this particularly concerns its caseload for attribution / allocation cases as they increased by 200% over the same period. In addition, Luxembourg's recent reorganisation may have led to a change in the experience levels of the team dealing with attribution/allocation cases. Therefore, while Luxembourg has already increased the resources available to its competent authority, Luxembourg should monitor whether the additional resources recently provided to the competent authority function, as well as the additional resources already envisaged to be provided in the near future, will remain adequate in order to resolve (current pending and) future MAP cases in an efficient, effective and timely manner. In particular, Luxembourg should ensure that the resources newly added to its competent authority are adequate to be able to resolve its attribution / allocation cases in an efficient, effective and timely manner and to cope with the significant increase in the number of attribution / allocation cases.
Furthermore, Luxembourg meets all of the other requirements under the Action 14 Minimum Standard in relation to the resolution of MAP cases. Luxembourg’s competent authority operates fully independently from the audit function of the tax authorities and adopts a pragmatic approach to resolve MAP cases in an effective and efficient manner. Its organisation is adequate and the performance indicators used are appropriate to perform the MAP function.
Lastly, Luxembourg also meets the Action 14 Minimum Standard as regards the implementation of MAP agreements.
Available mechanisms in Luxembourg to resolve tax treaty-related disputes
Luxembourg has entered into 93 tax treaties on income (and/or capital), 86 of which are in force.1 These 93 treaties are being applied to an equal number of jurisdictions. All of these treaties provide for a mutual agreement procedure (“MAP”) for resolving disputes on the interpretation and application of the provisions of the tax treaty. In addition, 18 of the 93 treaties provide for an arbitration procedure as a final stage to the mutual agreement procedure.2 Furthermore, Luxembourg is a signatory to the Convention on the elimination of double taxation in connection with the adjustment of profits of associated enterprises (90/436/EEC) of July 23, 1990 (“EU Arbitration Convention”)3, which provides for a MAP supplemented with an arbitration procedure for settling transfer pricing disputes and disputes on the attribution of profits to permanent establishments between EU Member States. In addition, Luxembourg adopted the Council Directive (EU) 2017/1852 of 10 October 2017 on tax dispute resolution mechanisms in the European Union (“EU Dispute Resolution Directive”).4 The legislation incorporating the directive into Luxembourg’s domestic law was enacted on 20 December 2019.
In Luxembourg, the competent authority function to conduct MAP is delegated to the Executive Committee of the Directorate of the Direct Tax Administration, with the Economic Division and the International Relations Division being responsible for attribution/allocation cases and for all other cases, respectively. In total, 13 staff members work on mutual agreement procedures within the competent authority of Luxembourg, with six of them working on attribution/allocation cases and seven of them working on other cases, where two members in the Economic Division also deal with other corporate income tax issues and the International Relations Division also being responsible for tax treaty negotiations. Both divisions are additionally involved in work at the OECD.
Luxembourg issued guidance on the governance and administration of the mutual agreement procedure (“MAP guidance”) in August 2017, which was last updated in March 2021 and is available at (in French):
Developments in relation to the tax treaty network
In the stage 2 peer review report of Luxembourg, it is reflected that four of Luxembourg’s tax treaties had not entered into force. This concerns the treaties with Albania (2009), Botswana (2018), France (2018) and Kosovo (2017). While the treaties with Botswana, France and Kosovo have now entered into force, the situation remains the same for the remaining treaty with Albania.
In addition, Luxembourg reported that since 1 October 2018 it has signed seven new tax treaties with Argentina (2019), Cabo Verde (2022), Colombia (2024), Ethiopia (2021), Ghana (2021), Montenegro (2024), and Rwanda (2021), which are newly negotiated treaties. These treaties contain Article 9(2) and Articles 25(1-3) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) as amended by the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]). The treaty with Ethiopia (2021) and Rwanda (2021) have entered into force while the remaining treaties have not. Luxembourg has also signed a new treaty with the United Kingdom (2022), which has already entered into force and has replaced the previous treaty of 1967.
Furthermore, on 7 June 2017, Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Convention to Implement Tax Treaty Related Measures to Prevent Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (“Multilateral Instrument”), to adopt, where necessary, modifications to the MAP article under its tax treaties in order to be compliant with the Action 14 Minimum Standard in respect of all relevant tax treaties. Luxembourg deposited its instrument of ratification of this instrument on 9 April 2019, following which the Multilateral Instrument for Luxembourg entered into force on 1 August 2019. With the depositing of the instrument of ratification, Luxembourg also submitted its list of notifications and reservations to that instrument.5 In relation to the Action 14 Minimum Standard, Luxembourg has not made any reservations pursuant to Article 16 of the Multilateral Instrument (concerning the mutual agreement procedure).
For the five treaties that are considered not to be in line with one or more elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard and that will not be modified by the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg reported that it reached an agreement on the text of the amending protocol with one jurisdiction, it has been in contact with one jurisdiction to update the concerned treaty through the Multilateral Instrument, and that negotiations will be initiated with two other jurisdictions. However, no further actions have currently been taken for the remaining treaty.
Other developments
Further to the above, Luxembourg reported that it has made a few changes to the operation of its MAP processes and has updated its MAP guidance. These changes can be summarised as follows:
MAP guidance: The MAP guidance has been updated to include the following four items.
Reference to the Multilateral Instrument and the EU Dispute Resolution Directive.
Further elaboration of Luxembourg’s position in the section on access to MAP.
Clarification that taxpayers have the option to submit a protective MAP request.
Clarification that Luxembourg’s competent authority would close a MAP case with the outcome “objection is not justified” if a taxpayer does not respond within a reasonable period after being asked for further information.
Organisation of competent authority: Luxembourg has increased the number of staff members dedicated to resolving MAPs and APAs from 10 to 14 since the previous review.
Overview of MAP caseload in Luxembourg
The analysis of Luxembourg ’s MAP caseload relates to the period starting on 1 January 2018 and ending on 31 December 2023 (“Statistics Reporting Period”). According to the statistics provided by Luxembourg, its MAP caseload during this period was as follows:
2018-23
Opening Inventory 1/1/2018
Cases Started
Cases Closed
End Inventory 31/12/2023
Attribution/allocation cases
24
109
61
72
Other cases
164
1092
1077
179
Total
188
1201
1138
251
Source: OECD
Basis for the peer review process
The peer review process entails an evaluation of Luxembourg’s implementation of the Action 14 Minimum Standard through an analysis of its legal and administrative framework relating to the mutual agreement procedure, as governed by its tax treaties, domestic legislation and regulations, as well as its MAP guidance and the practical application of that framework. The review process performed is desk-based and conducted through specific questionnaires completed by Luxembourg and its peers.
The initial peer review process consisted of two stages: a peer review process (stage 1) and a peer monitoring process (stage 2). In stage 1, Luxembourg's implementation of the Action 14 Minimum Standard as outlined above was evaluated, which was reflected in a stage 1 peer review report that has been adopted by the BEPS Inclusive Framework on 13 October 2017 and published on the website of the OECD. 6 This report identified the strengths and shortcomings of Luxembourg in relation to the implementation of this standard and provided for recommendations on how these shortcomings should have been addressed. Stage 2 was launched within one year from the adoption of the peer review report by the BEPS Inclusive Framework through an update report by Luxembourg. In this update report, Luxembourg reflected (i) what steps it has already taken, or are to be taken, to address any of the shortcomings identified in the peer review report and (ii) any plans or changes to its legislative and/or administrative framework concerning the implementation of the Action 14 Minimum Standard. These updates were published in a stage 2 peer review report that has been adopted by the BEPS Inclusive Framework on 9 April 2020 and published on the website of the OECD. 7
Following the successful completion of peer reviews for 82 Inclusive Framework member jurisdictions in two stages in 2022, paragraph 41 of the Assessment Methodology states that all Inclusive Framework member jurisdictions (whether previously peer reviewed or otherwise) shall be subject to continued monitoring from 2023 onwards. This continued monitoring process involves a full peer review process for jurisdictions having ‘meaningful MAP experience’ and a simplified peer review for jurisdictions that do not. A jurisdiction would only be considered to have ‘meaningful MAP experience’ if it has ten or more MAP cases in its MAP end inventory as reported in its MAP Statistics over the three previous years on average; or feedback is received from other members of the FTA MAP Forum indicating that the jurisdiction’s policy or practice concerning MAP requires improvement.
Timing of the process and input received from peers and taxpayers
In line with paragraph 60 of the Assessment Methodology, the full peer review process is conducted in cycles with each cycle constituting a three-year period during which all qualifying jurisdictions would be peer reviewed. Once each cycle of three years of peer reviews is completed, a gap year would be provided to allow the FTA MAP Forum to focus on other areas. Therefore, each qualifying jurisdiction would be subject to the full peer review process once every four years, with around one-third of all qualifying jurisdictions being reviewed in the first, second and third year respectively and the fourth year being a gap year.
Cycle 1 of the full peer review process for Luxembourg was launched on 26 July 2024, with the sharing of an update report by Luxembourg. In this update report, Luxembourg reflected (i) what steps it has already taken, or are to be taken, to address any of the shortcomings identified in the peer review report and (ii) any plans or changes to its legislative and / or administrative framework concerning the implementation of the Action 14 minimum standard. The period for evaluating Luxembourg’s implementation of the Action 14 Minimum Standard ranges from 1 October 2018 to 31 July 2024 ("Review Period”) since Luxembourg has already been reviewed for the period ranged from 1 January 2016 to 30 September 2018.
12 peers provided input on Luxembourg’s implementation of the Action 14 Minimum Standard. These 12 peers represent approximately 64 % of post-2015 MAP cases in Luxembourg’s inventory. While two of these peers only provided input with respect to their tax treaties with Luxembourg and two others only provided limited input in line with their experience, the remaining peers reported that their relationship with Luxembourg’s competent authority is positive and that Luxembourg is co-operative and easy to work with when resolving MAP cases.
Input by Luxembourg and cooperation throughout the process
Luxembourg provided its questionnaire on time and provided informative answers. Luxembourg was responsive in the course of the drafting of the peer review report by responding timely and comprehensively to requests for additional information, and provided further clarity where necessary.
Finally, Luxembourg is a member of the FTA MAP Forum and has shown good co-operation during the peer review process.
General outline of the peer review report
This report includes an evaluation of Luxembourg’s implementation of the Action 14 Minimum Standard. The report comprises the following four sections:
A. Tax Treaty Network;
B. MAP Guidance and MAP Profile;
C. MAP Statistics; and
D. Practical application of the Action 14 Minimum Standard.
Each of these sections is divided into elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard, as described in the terms of reference to monitor and review the implementation of the BEPS Action 14 Minimum Standard to make dispute resolution mechanisms more effective (“Terms of Reference”).8 Apart from analysing Luxembourg’s legal framework and its administrative practice, the report also incorporates peer input and responses to such input by Luxembourg. Furthermore, the report depicts the changes shared by Luxembourg to implement elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard where relevant. The conclusion of each element identifies areas for improvement (if any) and provides for recommendations how the specific area for improvement should be addressed.
1. Luxembourg has entered into 93 tax treaties on income (and/or capital), of which 86 are in force.9 These 93 treaties are being applied to an equal number of jurisdictions. All of these treaties provide for a MAP for resolving disputes on the interpretation and application of the provisions of the tax treaty.
2. Luxembourg signed and ratified the Multilateral Instrument, through which 13 of its tax treaties have been or will be modified to fulfil the requirements under the Action 14 Minimum Standard.
3. The following table provides an overview of Luxembourg’s tax treaty network and the compliance of those tax treaties with the Action 14 Minimum Standard, including the impact of the Multilateral Instrument.
Treaty
In force
Article 25(1)
Article 25(2)
Article 25(3)
Article 9(2)
Arbitration
1st sentence
[B.1]
2nd sentence
[B.1]
1st sentence
[C.1]
2nd sentence
[D.3]
1st sentence
[A.1]
2nd sentence
[B.7]
[B.3]
Taxpayer request
CA request
1
Albania
N
O
2
Andorra
Y
E
3
Argentina
N
E
4
Armenia
Y
O
5
Austria
Y
O
X
X
Y
6
Azerbaijan
Y
O
7
Bahrain
Y
E
8
Barbados
Y
E
9
Belgium
Y
E
X
X
X
X
X
Y
10
Botswana
Y
E
11
Brazil
Y
O
X
X
12
Brunei Darussalam
Y
O
13
Bulgaria
Y
E
X
14
Cabo Verde
N
E
Y
15
Canada
Y
O
X
X
Y
16
China (People's Republic of)
Y
O
17
Croatia
Y
O
18
Colombia
N
E
Y
19
Cyprus
Y
E
20
Czechia
Y
E
21
Denmark
Y
E
Y
22
Estonia
Y
E
Y
23
Ethiopia
Y
E
24
Finland
Y
E
X
Y
25
France
Y
E
Y
26
Georgia
Y
E
27
Germany
Y
O
28
Ghana
N
E
29
Greece
Y
E
30
Guernsey
Y
E
Y
31
Hong Kong (China)
Y
E
Y
32
Hungary
Y
O
Y
33
Iceland
Y
E
34
India
Y
O
35
Indonesia
Y
O
X
X
X
36
Ireland
Y
E
X
X
Y
37
Isle of Man
Y
E
Y
38
Israel
Y
O
39
Italy
Y
X
X
X
X
X
Y
40
Japan
Y
E
X
Y
41
Jersey
Y
E
Y
42
Kazakhstan
Y
E
43
Korea
Y
E
44
Kosovo
Y
E
Y
45
Kuwait
N
E
46
Laos
Y
O
47
Latvia
Y
O
48
Liechtenstein
Y
E
Y
49
Lithuania
Y
E
50
Malaysia
Y
E
51
Malta
Y
E
Y
52
Mauritius
Y
E
X
Y
53
Mexico
Y
E
X
X
Y
54
Moldova
Y
E
55
Monaco
Y
O
56
Montenegro
N
E
57
Morocco
Y
O
X
X
X
58
Netherlands
Y
E
X
X
Y
59
North Macedonia
Y
O
60
Norway
Y
E
X
61
Panama
Y
O
62
Poland
Y
O
63
Portugal
Y
O
X
X
X
64
Qatar
Y
E
X
65
Romania
Y
E
66
Russia
Y
E
67
Rwanda
Y
E
Y
68
San Marino
Y
O
X
X
Y
69
Saudi Arabia
Y
E
70
Senegal
Y
E
71
Serbia
Y
O
72
Seychelles
Y
E
Y
73
Singapore
Y
O
Y
74
Slovak Republic
Y
O
75
Slovenia
Y
O
Y
76
South Africa
Y
O
77
Spain
Y
O
X
78
Sri Lanka
Y
O
79
Sweden
Y
E
Y
80
Switzerland
Y
E
X
X
Y
81
Chinese Taipei
Y
O
82
Tajikistan
Y
O
83
Thailand
Y
O
X
X
84
Trinidad and Tobago
Y
O
85
Tunisia
Y
E
X
86
Turkey
Y
O
X
87
Ukraine
Y
E
X
88
United Arab Emirates
Y
E
89
United Kingdom
Y
E
Y
90
Uruguay
Y
E
Y
91
United States
Y
O
92
Uzbekistan
Y
E
93
Viet Nam
Y
O
Notes : X = the full equivalent of the concerned provision is not included in the treaty tax treaty elements are not in line with the Action 14 Minimum Standard
Green = tax treaties have been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument and for elements A.1, B.1, B.7, C.1 and D.3 brought in line with the Action 14 Minimum Standard
Yellow = tax treaties have been or will be superseded by the Multilateral Instrument to the extent of incompatibility and for elements A.1, B.1, B.7, C.1 and D.3 brought in line with the Action 14 Minimum Standard
O = 2014 version of Article 25(1), first sentence of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]), with green highlight where it will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include the 2017 version, which is in line with the Action 14 Minimum Standard
E = 2017 version of Article 25(1), first sentence of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]), with green highlight where it has been modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include this version, which is in line with the Action 14 Minimum Standard
Y = under the arbitration column, where the treaty concerned contains an arbitration provision that is initiated by a request by a taxpayer (Taxpayer request) or a request made by or approved by one or both competent authorities (CA request)
The inclusion of element B.3 is for information only as Article 9(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention and arbitration provisions is for information only as including those provisions is not a best practice and not part of the Action 14 Minimum Standard.
4. For the five treaties that will not be modified, upon entry into force of this Multilateral Instrument for the treaties concerned, Luxembourg reported that it works to update these tax treaties to be in line with the requirements under the Action 14 Minimum Standard as follows:
For one treaty, it reached an agreement on the text of the amending protocol with the treaty partner.
For one treaty, as reported in the last peer review report, the treaty partner and it could not reach an agreement on revising the treaty. No further actions are planned at the moment.
For one treaty, while the treaty partner initially informed Luxembourg that, upon ratifying the Multilateral Instrument in their respective jurisdiction, the treaty would align with the Action 14 Minimum Standard, which could then be formalised through a Memorandum of Understanding (“MoU”) between the treaty partner and Luxembourg, a process to which Luxembourg agreed. However, should changing the treaty through the Multilateral Instrument not be possible, Luxembourg plans to reach out to the treaty partner to request further information and ultimately initiate discussions on an amending protocol.
For the remaining two treaties, discussions will be initiated once negotiations with treaty partners with which actions are ongoing are completed.
5. In addition, Luxembourg reported it will seek to include the articles of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) relevant to the Action 14 Minimum Standard in all of its future tax treaties.
[A.1] Include Article 25(3), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention in tax treaties
Jurisdictions should ensure that their tax treaties contain a provision which requires the competent authority of their jurisdiction to endeavour to resolve by mutual agreement any difficulties or doubts arising as to the interpretation or application of their tax treaties.
Current situation of Luxembourg’s tax treaties
6. To be in line with element A.1, tax treaties should include a provision equivalent to Article 25(3), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]). This provision requires competent authorities to work together to resolve any issues in the interpretation or application of tax treaties, reducing the likelihood of future disputes and ensuring the consistent bilateral application of these treaties.
7. All of Luxembourg’s tax treaties contain a provision equivalent to Article 25(3), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or have been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision and are thus, in line with element A.1. One of the treaties did not contain such a provision, but has been modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
Recent developments
Multilateral Instrument
8. Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Instrument and has deposited its instrument of ratification on 1 April 2019. The Multilateral Instrument has entered into force for Luxembourg on 1 August 2019. Accordingly, one treaty has been modified to be in line with element A.1.
[B.1] Include Article 25(1) of the OECD Model Tax Convention in tax treaties
Jurisdictions should ensure that their tax treaties contain a MAP provision which provides that when the taxpayer considers that the actions of one or both of the Contracting Parties result or will result for the taxpayer in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the tax treaty, the taxpayer, may irrespective of the remedies provided by the domestic law of those Contracting Parties, make a request for MAP assistance, and that the taxpayer can present the request within a period of no less than three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the tax treaty.
Current situation of Luxembourg’s tax treaties
Inclusion of Article 25(1), first sentence of the OECD Model Tax Convention
9. To be in line with this part of element B.1, tax treaties must include a provision equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]), either as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]) or as amended by that report. This provision allows taxpayers to submit a MAP request to the competent authority of the jurisdiction in which they are resident (or national in specific cases), or to the competent authority of either jurisdiction, to resolve cases of taxation not in accordance with the treaty provisions, regardless of the remedies provided by domestic law.
10. The table below provides a summary of Luxembourg’s tax treaties in relation to this part of element B.1.
Provision
Number of tax treaties
In line with Element B.1: Contains a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]), as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]) or as amended by the report, or has been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision. Among these:
15 treaties contain a provision equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]), as amended by the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]) and allowing taxpayers to submit a MAP request to the competent authority of either state.
30 treaties contain a provision equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]) as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]), allowing taxpayers to submit a MAP request to the competent authority of the state in which they are resident or in their state of nationality for nationality non-discrimination cases.
four treaties contain a provision based on Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]) as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]), allowing taxpayers to submit a MAP request only to the competent authority of the state in which they are resident and not their state of nationality for nationality non-discrimination cases, but there is no non-discrimination provision or the non-discrimination provision only covers nationals that are resident of one of the contracting states.
43 treaties have been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include a provision equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]).
92
Not in line with Element B.1: Considered not to contain the full equivalent of Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]) as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]) and is not expected to be modified by the Multilateral Instrument. This treaty contains a similar provision but whereby pursuant to a protocol provision the taxpayer is required to initiate domestic remedies when submitting a MAP request.
1
Inclusion of Article 25(1), second sentence of the OECD Model Tax Convention
11. To be in line with this part of element B.1, tax treaties must include a provision equivalent to Article 25(1), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) allowing taxpayers to submit a MAP request within a period of no less than three years from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the particular tax treaty.
12. All of Luxembourg’s tax treaties contain a provision equivalent to Article 25(1), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or have been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision or include a provision that includes no filing period and are thus, in line with this part of element B.1. Among these:
80 treaties include a filing period of three years.
Seven treaties include a filing period that is less than three years but have been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
Four treaties did not contain such a provision but have been modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
Two treaties do not contain such a provision.
Practical application
Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention
13. All but one of Luxembourg’s tax treaties allow taxpayers to file a MAP request irrespective of domestic remedies. In this respect, Luxembourg reported that taxpayers are entitled to apply for the opening of the mutual agreement procedure and to simultaneously lodge a judicial or administrative appeal, as provided for by domestic law. When a final judicial decision is rendered before the MAP process is concluded, Luxembourg reported that its competent authority is able to continue the MAP process and can enter into MAP agreements, but such agreement must incorporate the court decision rendered and cannot lead to an additional (upward) adjustment of the taxpayer’s position. This policy is confirmed in Section 9.2. of Luxembourg’s MAP guidance. Luxembourg further reported that its competent authority is allowed to proceed with MAP cases while an appeal is ongoing and that its competent authority is allowed to deviate in MAP from a decision at the administrative appeal level.
14. In addition, section 2.3 of Luxembourg’s MAP guidance also clarifies that access to MAP would only be denied by Luxembourg’s competent authority when the case is not eligible under the conditions prescribed under the provision based on Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) in the concerned treaty.
Article 25(1), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention
15. Luxembourg reported that for treaties that do not include a filing period for a MAP request, it would adopt a pragmatic approach and that it would not apply a period shorter than three years starting from the notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the relevant tax treaty.
Recent developments
Multilateral modifications
Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention
16. Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Instrument and has deposited its instrument of ratification on 1 April 2019. The Multilateral Instrument has entered into force for Luxembourg on 1 August 2019. Accordingly, three treaties have been modified to be in line with this part of element B.1.
Article 25(1), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention
17. Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Instrument and has deposited its instrument of ratification on 1 April 2019. The Multilateral Instrument has entered into force for Luxembourg on 1 August 2019. Accordingly, seven treaties have been or will be modified to be in line with this part of element B.1.
Bilateral modifications
18. For the one treaty identified that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and will not be modified by the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg reported that it has been in contact with the treaty partner concerned to agree to revise this treaty through the Multilateral Instrument, but should this not be possible, bilateral negotiations will be initiated.
Peer input
19. For the treaty identified that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention, the relevant peer provided input that it is considering taking all necessary actions to ensure that, following the entry into force of MLI, the treaty with Luxembourg will be modified in line with all the elements at issue (with particular reference to element B.1).
[B.7] Include Article 25(3), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention in tax treaties
Jurisdictions should ensure that their tax treaties contain a provision under which competent authorities may consult together for the elimination of double taxation in cases not provided for in their tax treaties.
Current situation of Luxembourg’s tax treaties
20. To be in line with element B.7, tax treaties must include a provision equivalent to Article 25(3), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]), enabling competent authorities to consult together for the elimination of double taxation in cases not provided for by these treaties. This ensures that tax treaties operate effectively and allows for competent authorities to be able to respond quickly to unanticipated situations.
21. All of Luxembourg’s tax treaties contain a provision equivalent to Article 25(3), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or have been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision and are thus, in line with element B.7. Among these:
Three treaties did not contain such a provision but have been modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
One treaty does not contain such a provision but will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
Recent developments
Multilateral Instrument
22. Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Instrument and has deposited its instrument of ratification on 1 April 2019. The Multilateral Instrument has entered into force for Luxembourg on 1 August 2019. Accordingly, four treaties have been or will be modified to be in line with element B.7.
[C.1] Include Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention in tax treaties
Jurisdictions should ensure that their tax treaties contain a provision which requires that the competent authority who receives a MAP request from the taxpayer, shall endeavour, if the objection from the taxpayer appears to be justified and the competent authority is not itself able to arrive at a satisfactory solution, to resolve the MAP case by mutual agreement with the competent authority of the other Contracting Party, with a view to the avoidance of taxation which is not in accordance with the tax treaty.
Current situation of Luxembourg’s tax treaties
23. In addition to allowing taxpayers to request for a MAP, competent authorities must engage in discussions with each other in MAP to resolve cases of taxation not in accordance with the provisions of a tax treaty in situations where the taxpayers' objections are considered justified and where cases cannot be unilaterally resolved. Thus, to satisfy element C.1, tax treaties should include a provision that is equivalent to the first sentence of Article 25(2) in the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]).
24. The table below provides a summary of Luxembourg’s tax treaties in relation to element C.1.
Provision
Number of tax treaties
In line with Element C.1: Contains a provision equivalent to Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or has been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision. One of these treaties did not have such a provision but has been modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
92
Not in line with Element C.1: Considered not to contain a provision that is based on or equivalent to Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and is not expected to be modified by the Multilateral Instrument. This treaty contains a provision that is based on Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]), but also contained additional language requiring the competent authority that receives a MAP request to notify the other competent authority concerned within a certain time limit.
1
Recent developments
Multilateral Instrument
25. Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Instrument and has deposited its instrument of ratification on 1 April 2019. The Multilateral Instrument has entered into force for Luxembourg on 1 August 2019. Accordingly, one treaty has been modified to be in line with element C.1.
Bilateral modifications
26. For the one treaty identified that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and will not be modified by the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg reported that it reached an agreement on the text of the amending protocol with the treaty partner.
Peer input
27. For the treaty identified that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention, the relevant peer did not provide input.
[D.3] Include Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention in tax treaties or both alternative provisions
Jurisdictions should either (i) provide in their tax treaties that any mutual agreement reached through MAP shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits in their domestic law, or (ii) be willing to accept alternative treaty provisions that limit the time during which a Contracting Party may make an adjustment pursuant to Article 9(1) or Article 7(2), in order to avoid late adjustments with respect to which MAP relief will not be available.
Legal framework and current situation of Luxembourg’s tax treaties
28. In order to provide full certainty to taxpayers it is essential that implementation of MAP agreements is not obstructed by any time limits in the domestic law of the jurisdictions concerned. This certainty can be provided by either including the equivalent of Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) in tax treaties, or alternatively, be willing to accept treaty provisions that limit the time during which a Contracting Party may make an adjustment pursuant to Article 9(1) or Article 7(2), in order to avoid that late adjustments obstruct granting of MAP relief.
29. The table below provides a summary of Luxembourg’s tax treaties in relation to element D.3.
Provision
Number of tax treaties
In line with Element D.3: Contains a provision equivalent to Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or has been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision or contains both alternative provisions that limit the time during which adjustments may be made pursuant to Article 9(1) and Article 7(2). Among these:
Nine treaties have been modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
Three treaties will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
90
Not in line with Element D.3: Considered not to contain a provision that is based on or equivalent to Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and is not expected to be modified by the Multilateral Instrument and does not contain both alternative provisions. Among these:
One treaty does not contain such a provision.
Two treaties do not contain such a provision and only have one alternative provision setting a time-limit in Article 9.
3
Recent developments
Multilateral Instrument
30. Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Instrument and has deposited its instrument of ratification on 1 April 2019. The Multilateral Instrument has entered into force for Luxembourg on 1 August 2019. Accordingly, 12 treaties has been or will be modified to be in line with element D.3.
Bilateral modifications
31. For the three treaties identified that do not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and will not be modified by the Multilateral Instrument or both alternative provisions, Luxembourg reported that for one treaty, as reported in the last peer review report, the treaty partner and it could not reach an agreement on revising the treaty and no further actions are planned at the moment. For the remaining two treaties, discussions will be initiated once negotiations with treaty partners with which actions are ongoing are completed.
Peer input
32. For the three treaties identified that do not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention, or both alternatives, one of the relevant peers provided input that it intends to bring this treaty fully in line with the Action 14 minimum standard.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[A.1]
-
-
[B.1]
One out of 93 tax treaties does not contain a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]), either as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report or as amended by that report (OECD, 2015[2]). For this treaty, the relevant treaty partner has been engaged by Luxembourg with a view to have the treaty modified by the Multilateral Instrument. However, where this is not possible, bilateral negotiations will be initiated.
For the one treaty that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]), either as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report or as amended by that report (OECD, 2015[2]) and will at this time not be modified by the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg should continue to work in accordance with its stated intention to include the required provision via the Multilateral Instrument and where this is not possible, request via bilateral negotiations the inclusion of the required provision in accordance with its plan. This concerns a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]) either:
a) As amended by the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]); or
b) As it read prior to the adoption of Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]).
[B.7]
-
-
[C.1]
Two out of 93 tax treaties do not contain a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]). One of these two treaties has been modified the Multilateral Instrument to include the required provision. With respect to the remaining treaty, Luxembourg reached an agreement on the text of the amending protocol with treaty partner.
For the one treaty that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and will at this time not be modified via the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg should sign the amending protocol as soon as possible to ensure the inclusion of the required provision.
[C.1]
-
-
[D.3]
15 out of 93 tax treaties contain neither a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) nor both alternative provisions provided for in Article 9(1) and Article 7(2). 12 of these 15 treaties have been or will be modified the Multilateral Instrument to include the required provision. With respect to the remaining treaties:
For two treaties, discussions will be initiated once negotiations with treaty partners with which actions are ongoing are completed.
For the remaining treaty, no actions have been taken nor are any actions planned to be taken.
For the three treaties that do not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or both alternative provisions provided for in Article 9(1) and Article 7(2), and will at this time not be modified via the Multilateral Instrument Luxembourg should :
For two treaties, request the inclusion of the required provision via bilateral negotiations or be willing to accept the inclusion of both alternative provisions in accordance with its plan.
For the remaining treaty, without further delay, request the inclusion of the required provision via bilateral negotiations or be willing to accept the inclusion of both alternative provisions.
[B.8] & [B.9] Publish clear and comprehensive MAP guidance & make MAP guidance available and easily accessible and publish MAP profile
Jurisdictions should take appropriate measures to make rules, guidelines and procedures on access to and use of the MAP available and easily accessible to the public and should publish their jurisdiction MAP profiles on a shared public platform pursuant to the agreed template. Jurisdictions should publish clear rules, guidelines and procedures on access to and use of the MAP and include the specific information and documentation that should be submitted in a taxpayer’s request for MAP assistance.
33. Transparent and clear rules, guidelines, and procedures on accessing and using a jurisdiction's MAP regime are crucial in informing taxpayers and other stakeholders of its functioning and facilitating timely initiation and resolution of MAP cases. It is essential for a jurisdiction's MAP guidance to provide a comprehensive explanation of how a taxpayer can request a MAP, including what information and documentation should be included, to ensure timely review by the competent authority. Moreover, the public availability and accessibility of a jurisdiction's MAP guidance can increase public awareness and understanding of the MAP regime. Finally, making MAP profiles publicly available on a shared platform promotes the transparency and dissemination of the MAP programme.10
Luxembourg’s MAP guidance
34. Luxembourg’s MAP guidance was published in August 2017 and updated in March 2021. The MAP guidance is available at (in French):
35. Luxembourg’s MAP guidance can easily be found on the website of the tax administration of Luxembourg, by searching for the keyword “mutual agreement procedure” in English or by searching on a search engine for “Luxembourg MAP Guidance” in English.
36. Luxembourg’s MAP guidance contains the following information:
Chapter
Content
1. Introduction
The purpose of the MAP guidance.
2.1. Request to initiate MAP
The information required to request MAP.
2.2. Competent Authority
Composition of the Competent Authority of Luxembourg.
2.3. Access to MAP
Situations where MAP access would be denied i.e. when not eligible under the tax treaty.
Whether MAP is available in cases of: (i) transfer pricing cases, (ii) the application of anti-abuse. provisions, (iii) bona fide foreign-initiated self-adjustments and (iv) multilateral disputes.
3.1. Measures to initiate MAP
Clarification of “actions” in the equivalent to Article 25(1) 1st sentence.
The rights and role of taxpayers in the process .
3.2. Time limit for MAP
Time limit for MAP request.
Protective MAP request.
How the MAP operates in Luxembourg, the timing and rules for accessing MAP.
3.3. Initiation of MAP
Notification to the other CA.
3.4. Process for MAP
The role of the competent authorities and how the competent authority applies the process in practice.
The fact that there is no fee charged for MAP.
The steps of the MAP process and the timing of such steps.
3.5. Closing a MAP case
The categories of outcomes.
3.6. Conditions for implementing a solution proposed to the taxpayer
The implementation of MAP agreements, including actions to be taken by taxpayers .
3.7. Follow-up on implementation of MAP
The follow-up for the implementation of MAP agreements.
4. Interest and penalties
The consideration of interest and penalties in the MAP.
5. Suspension of collection procedures
The possibility of suspension of tax collection during the course of a MAP.
6. MAP concerning the interpretation or application of a tax treaty
MAP agreements under Article 25(3) would be published.
7. Elimination of double taxation in cases not covered by a tax treaty
The example of the case that is covered by MAP under Article 25(3).
8. Arbitration
The availability of arbitration (including the EU Arbitration Convention).
9. Relationship with available domestic remedies
The relationship between MAP and audit function.
The relationship with available domestic remedies.
The relationship between MAP under the tax treaties and MAP covered by the EU Arbitration Convention.
The relationship between MAP provided for by tax treaties and those falling under the scope of the law of December 20, 2019, establishing a mechanism for the resolution of tax disputes.
37. The above-described MAP guidance of Luxembourg includes detailed information on the availability and the use of MAP and how its competent authority conducts the procedure in practice. This guidance includes the information that the FTA MAP Forum agreed should be included in a jurisdiction’s MAP guidance, which concerns: (i) contact information of the competent authority or the office in charge of MAP cases and (ii) the manner and form in which the taxpayer should submit its MAP request.11 However, information on whether taxpayers can request for the multi-year resolution of recurring issues through MAP is not specifically addressed.
38. In addition, the MAP guidance contains all of the elements agreed by the FTA MAP Forum on guidance that jurisdictions could use in their domestic guidance on what information and documentation taxpayers need to include in a request for MAP assistance.12 The relevant items are noted below:
Included
Item
Yes
Identity of the taxpayer(s) covered in the MAP request.
Yes
The basis for the request.
Yes
Facts of the case.
Yes
Analysis of the issue(s) to be resolved via MAP.
Yes
Whether the MAP request was also submitted to the competent authority of the other treaty partner.
Yes
Whether the MAP request was also submitted to another authority under another instrument that provides for a mechanism to resolve treaty-related disputes.
Yes
Whether the issue(s) involved were dealt with previously.
Yes
A statement confirming that all information and documentation provided in the MAP request is accurate and that the taxpayer will assist the competent authority in its resolution of the issue(s) presented in the MAP request by furnishing any other information or documentation required by the competent authority in a timely manner.
MAP profile
39. The MAP profile of Luxembourg is published on the website of the OECD and was last updated on 10 June 2024.
40. This MAP profile is complete and often with detailed information. This profile includes external links that provide extra information and guidance where appropriate.
Peer input
41. One peer reported that the information on Luxembourg’s MAP programme is easily accessible and complete.
Recent developments
42. Luxembourg has updated its MAP guidance in March 2021. This updated guidance replaced the previous MAP guidance, issued in August 201713. The update to its MAP guidance inter alia was performed to reflect:
A reference to the Multilateral Instrument and the EU Dispute Resolution Directive.
Further elaboration of the section on access to MAP.
A clarification that taxpayers have the option to submit a protective MAP request.
A clarification that Luxembourg’s competent authority would close a MAP case with the outcome “objection is not justified” if a taxpayer does not respond within a reasonable period after being asked for further information.
43. Luxembourg has updated its MAP profile in November 2024 to reflect these changes and to include other minor updates.
[C.2] Seek to resolve MAP cases within a 24-month average timeframe
Jurisdictions should seek to resolve MAP cases within an average time frame of 24 months. This time frame applies to both jurisdictions (i.e. the jurisdiction which receives the MAP request from the taxpayer and its treaty partner).
44. Swift resolution of MAP cases is essential in avoiding uncertainties and costs for both taxpayers and jurisdictions, as well as potential issues for future years. A period of 24 months is considered as an appropriate time period to resolve MAP cases on average.
Reporting of MAP statistics
45. The FTA MAP Forum has agreed on rules for reporting of MAP statistics (“MAP Statistics Reporting Framework”) for MAP requests submitted on or after 1 January 2016 (“post-2015 cases”). Also, for MAP requests submitted prior to that date (“pre-2016 cases”), the FTA MAP Forum agreed to report MAP statistics on the basis of an agreed template.
46. Luxembourg provided its MAP statistics for 2018-23 pursuant to the MAP Statistics Reporting Framework within the given deadline. However, the MAP Statistics filed for 2018 and 2022 provided incorrect data with respect to pre-2016 cases and for 2019, 2020 and 2022 provided incorrect data with respect to post-2015 cases. The full statistics for Luxembourg can be found in Annex A & Annex B attached to this report.
47. With respect to post-2015 cases, Luxembourg reported having reached out to all of its MAP partners with a view to have their MAP statistics matching. In that regard, Luxembourg reported that it could match its post-2015 MAP statistics with all of its treaty partners. In that regard, based on the information provided by Luxembourg’s MAP partners, its post-2015 MAP statistics actually match those of its treaty partners as reported by the latter.
48. Eleven peers provided input concerning the matching of MAP Statistics with Luxembourg. Three of these peers noted that their competent authorities have successfully matched MAP statistics with Luxembourg’s competent authority or have no issues in this regard for the years 2018-23. The fourth peer reported that even though it has a large number of cases with Luxembourg, it was always able to match its statistics. The fifth peer noted that to date it has not encountered any specific issues regarding the matching of statistics and that Luxembourg’s competent authority has been responsive to its requests and is available to modify the data whenever it appeared necessary in order to be consistent with the respective records. This peer additionally noted that overall, this peer and Luxembourg have effective contacts, aimed to match the statistics in a prompt manner.
Monitoring of MAP statistics
49. Luxembourg has a system in place with its treaty partners that communicates, monitors and manages with its treaty partners the MAP caseload. Luxembourg reported that it monitors on a continuous basis (i) the number of cases in its MAP inventory, (ii) the number of new MAP requests and (iii) the time taken to resolve MAP cases.
Analysis of Luxembourg’s MAP caseload
50. The analysis of Luxembourg’s MAP caseload relates to the period starting on 1 January 2018 and ending on 31 December 2023.14
Global overview
51. The following graph shows the evolution of Luxembourg’s MAP caseload over the Statistics Reporting Period.
Figure 4.1. Evolution of Luxembourg’s MAP caseload for 2018-23
52. At the beginning of the Statistics Reporting Period Luxembourg had 188 pending MAP cases, of which 24 were attribution/allocation cases and 164 were other MAP cases. At the end of the Statistics Reporting Period, Luxembourg had 251 MAP cases in its inventory, of which 72 are attribution/allocation cases and 179 are other MAP cases. Luxembourg’s MAP caseload has increased by 34% during the Statistics Reporting Period whereby attribution/allocation cases have increased by 200% and other MAP cases have increased by 9%.
53. The breakdown of the end inventory can be shown as follows:
Figure 4.2. End inventory on 31 December 2023 (251 cases)
55. At the beginning of the Statistics Reporting Period, Luxembourg’s MAP inventory of pre-2016 MAP cases consisted of 73 cases, of which 10 were attribution/allocation cases and 63 were other cases. At the end of the Statistics Reporting Period the total inventory of pre-2016 cases had decreased to two cases, both of which are attribution/allocation cases. The decrease in the number of Pre-2016 MAP cases is shown in the below table:
Pre-20XX cases only
Evolution of pre-2016 MAP caseload in 2018
Evolution of pre-2016 MAP caseload in 2019
Evolution of pre-2016 MAP caseload in 2020
Evolution of pre-2016 MAP caseload in 2021
Evolution of pre-2016 MAP caseload in 2022
Evolution of pre-2016 MAP caseload in 2023
Cumulative evolution of total MAP caseload over the five years (2018-23)
Attribution / allocation cases
-20%
-38%
-60%
No Cases Closed
No Cases Closed
No Cases Closed
-80%
Other cases
-33%
-38%
-23%
-25%
-33%
-100%
-100%
Source: OECD
Post-2015 cases
56. The following graph shows the evolution of Luxembourg’s Post-2015 MAP cases over the Statistics Reporting Period.
Figure 4.4. Evolution of Luxembourg’s MAP inventory for 2018-23 – post-2015 cases
57. In total, 1201 MAP cases started during the Statistics Reporting Period, 109 of which concerned attribution/allocation cases and 1092 other cases. At the end of this period the total number of post-2015 cases in the inventory was 249 cases, consisting of 70 attribution/allocation cases and 179 other cases. Accordingly, Luxembourg closed 1067 post-2015 cases during the Statistics Reporting Period, 53 of them being attribution / allocation cases and 1014 of them of them being other cases. The total number of closed cases represents approximately 89% of the total number of post-2015 cases that started during the Statistics Reporting Period, with this number being 49% for attribution/allocation cases and 93% for other cases.
58. The number of post-2015 cases closed as compared to the number of post-2015 cases started during the Statistics Reporting Period is shown in the below table:
Post-2015 cases only
% of cases closed in 2018 compared to cases started in 2018
% of cases closed in 2019 compared to cases started in 2019
% of cases closed in 2020 compared to cases started in 2020
% of cases closed in 2021 compared to cases started in 2021
% of cases closed in 2022 compared to cases started in 2022
% of cases closed in 2023 compared to cases started in 2023
Cumulative % of cases closed compared to cases started over the years (2018-23)
Attribution / allocation cases
6%
44%
92%
66%
63%
22%
49%
Other cases
97%
81%
105%
95%
91%
86%
93%
Source: OECD
Age of inventory
59. The age of Luxembourg’s pending post-2015 MAP cases on 31 December 2023 is shown in the below table on an aggregate basis:
Categories for age of MAP cases
Aggregate number of cases remaining in MAP inventory on 31 December 2023 falling under each category based on “Start”
<2 years old
186
>=2 and <4 years old
50
>=4 and <6 years old
10
>=6 years old
3
Source: OECD
60. In total, 63 post-2015 cases have been in Luxembourg’s MAP inventory for a period longer than 24 months. Added to the two pre-2016 cases, 26% of Luxembourg’s MAP inventory on 31 December 2023 consists of cases older than 24 months, although the majority of these cases are still less than four years old.
Overview of cases closed during the Statistics Reporting Period
Reported outcomes
61. During the Statistics Reporting Period Luxembourg in total closed 1138 MAP cases for which the following outcomes were reported:
62. This chart shows that during the Statistics Reporting Period, 481 out of 1138 cases (42.3%) were closed through an agreement that fully eliminated double taxation or fully resolved taxation not in accordance with the tax treaty. In addition, 476 out of the 1138 cases (41.8%) were resolved through the granting of unilateral relief.
Reported outcomes for attribution / allocation cases
63. In total, 61 attribution / allocation cases were closed during the Statistics Reporting Period. The main reported outcomes for these cases are:
agreement fully eliminating double taxation/fully resolving taxation not in accordance with the tax treaty (61%)
withdrawn by taxpayer (20%)
Reported outcomes for other cases
64. In total, 1077 other cases were closed during the Statistics Reporting Period. The main reported outcomes for these cases are:
unilateral relief granted (44%)
agreement fully eliminating double taxation/fully resolving taxation not in accordance with the tax treaty (41%)
Average timeframe needed to resolve MAP cases
All cases closed during the Statistics Reporting Period
65. The average time needed to close MAP cases during the Statistics Reporting Period was 13.81 months. This average can be broken down as follows:
Number of cases
Start date to End date (in months)
Attribution / Allocation cases
61
30.24
Other cases
1077
12.88
All cases
1138
13.81
Source: OECD
Pre-2016 cases
66. For pre-2016 cases Luxembourg reported that on average it needed 64.58 months to close attribution/allocation cases and 97.96 months to close other cases. This resulted in an average time needed of 94.20 months to close 71 pre-2016 cases. For the purpose of computing the average time needed to resolve pre-2016 cases, Luxembourg reported that it uses the following:
Start date: the date of receipt of the MAP request.
End date: one of the following ones; the date when the competent authority orders the office responsible for the implementation of the MAP agreement or, if no agreement was reached, the date of receipt of the closing letter from the other competent authority or, in cases where Luxembourg denies access to MAP, the date when the taxpayer is informed of the outcome of the MAP process.
Post-2015 cases
67. For post-2015 cases Luxembourg reported that on average it needed 25.06 months to close attribution/allocation cases and 7.59 months to close other cases. This resulted in an average time needed of 8.46 months to close 1067 post-2015 cases.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[C.2]
-
-
[C.3] Provide adequate resources to the MAP function
Jurisdictions should ensure that adequate resources are provided to the MAP function.
68. Adequate resources, including personnel, funding and training, are necessary to properly perform the competent authority function and to ensure that MAP cases are resolved in a timely, efficient and effective manner.
Description of Luxembourg’s competent authority
69. Under Luxembourg’s tax treaties, the competent authority function is designated to the Minister of Finance, which function is then delegated to the Executive Committee of the Directorate of the Direct Tax Administration. The Executive Committee consists of the director of the Direct Tax Administration and four deputy directors. Under the responsibility of the Executive Committee, the Economic Division handles Transfer Pricing cases and the International Relations Division handles all other cases. Luxembourg reported that the MAP function of Luxembourg is more specifically organised as follows:
Six people are responsible for MAP cases related to transfer pricing within the Economic Division while one of them is the Head of division. Among those six people, several members have recently been replaced with new staff members, albeit with less experience in MAP. Among the six people, four predominantly work on MAP cases whereas the other two primarily work on other issues related to corporate income tax and are available to assist in the resolution of MAP cases. The members of the Economic Division attend, among others, the following working group meetings: (a) within the OECD: Working Party 6 on the Taxation of Multinational Enterprises; FTA MAP Forum; Forum on Harmful Tax Practices; ICAP and (b) within the European Union: Joint Transfer Pricing Forum; Code of Conduct and subgroups of the Code of Conduct; ETACA. In the last quarter of 2024 and first quarter of 2025, four additional hires will increase the Economic Division’s TP capacity, resulting in a team of nine with one Head of Division dedicated to handling attribution/allocation cases and bilateral APAs in 2025.
Seven people including two new members are responsible for other MAP cases within the International Relations Division, while one of them is the Head of division. Some members of this team have extensive experience in dispute resolution. In addition to their work on MAP cases, members of the International Relations Division are actively involved in tax treaty negotiations for Luxembourg. The team also participates in working group meetings: (a) within the OECD: Working Party 1 on Tax Conventions and Related Questions; Task Force on the Digital Economy; FTA MAP Forum and (b) within the UN: the Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters. In the International Relations division, the team has been reinforced with two additional members as already mentioned, and another new member joined in autumn 2024. As highlighted in the stage 2 report, while the division handles MAP cases, its responsibilities also include tax treaty negotiations.
70. The staff of Luxembourg’s competent authority is given a global training within the tax administration as well as specific modules such as those proposed by the OECD. In addition, the budget that is dedicated to travel has always been sufficient for all the meetings that the competent authority wished to attend.
71. Luxembourg indicated that it regularly informs its treaty partners of any change in this respect. In addition, the contact information is published on the OECD website and the EU Joint Transfer Pricing Forum website.
Monitoring mechanism
72. Luxembourg indicated assessing both on a continuous basis whether the resources allocated to the competent authority are adequate. In addition, the heads of division would inform their director in case of need of additional resources (staff, budget or training) on a yearly basis. This assessment is made with regard to (i) the number of MAP cases in inventory, (ii) the number of new MAP cases, (iii) the current time needed to resolve MAP cases and (iv) any circumstance that would have an impact on the means needed to perform the required tasks.
Practical application
MAP statistics
73. As discussed under element C.2 Luxembourg closed its MAP cases during the Statistics Reporting Period within the pursued 24-month average. However, the average time taken to close attribution / allocation cases is higher than the average time needed for other cases. This can be illustrated by the following graph:
Figure 4.6. Average time (in months) to close cases in 2018-23
74. Based on these figures, it follows that on average it took Luxembourg 13.81 months to close MAP cases during the Statistics Reporting Period, including 30.24 months to resolve attribution / allocation cases this and 12.88 months to resolve other cases.
75. The stage 2 peer review report of Luxembourg analysed the 2016-17 statistics and showed an average of 12.87 months to close 682 MAP cases, comprising seven attribution/allocation cases in 40.74 months and 675 other cases in 12.58 months. In addition, Luxembourg’s MAP inventory decreased by 47 % during this period. Consequently, it was concluded that Luxembourg’s competent authority was adequately resourced.
76. For this peer review report, the 2018-23 MAP statistics are taken into account. The average time to close MAP cases for these years are:
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2018-23
Attribution/Allocation cases
28.46
28.66
28.59
31.48
34.08
26.21
30.24
Other cases
10.81
11.89
9.75
12.12
12.14
24.76
12.88
All cases
11.02
12.86
10.99
14.07
13.42
24.80
13.81
Source: OECD
77. The 2018-23 statistics of Luxembourg show that the average completion time of MAP cases showed a slight increase from 12.87 months in 2016-17 to 13.81 months. Taking into account all cases closed by Luxembourg since 1 January 2016 until 31 December 2023, its competent authority has now closed 1,820 MAP cases in an average time of 13.56 months (with 68 attribution/allocation cases being closed in 31.32 months on average and 1,752 other cases being closed in 12.88 months on average). Further, Luxembourg has managed to close about 94% of all cases started during the statistics reporting period. In addition, only 26% of Luxembourg’s MAP inventory on 31 December 2023 consists of cases older than 24 months. However, it took Luxembourg 30.24 months to resolve attribution / allocation cases in 2018-23 and Luxembourg has experienced a significant increase in its inventory for both attribution / allocation cases (200%).
Clarifications provided by Luxembourg
78. Luxembourg reported that the two pre-2016 MAP cases were recently discussed during a competent authority meeting, and it is expected that an agreement may be reached in due course.
79. Luxembourg reported that regarding the fact that it took on average 30.24 months to close attribution/allocation cases, these cases are often more complex than other MAP cases, sometimes requiring additional time for fact-finding and to reach agreements among competent authorities and that the Economic Division that is responsible for handling attribution/allocation cases has recently undergone a reorganisation, which may also impact proceedings.
80. In addition, Luxembourg reported that its inventory has increased by 34% since the number of MAP requests submitted to Luxembourg has increased during that period and that this trend appears to reflect a broader global pattern, particularly for attribution/allocation cases.
81. Luxembourg reported that some other MAP cases have remained in the inventory for more than 24 months due to extended exchanges with treaty partners and/or taxpayers (e.g., receiving position papers, updating status with the other competent authority, obtaining taxpayer agreement on case settlement, cases pending at the unilateral stage in Luxembourg).
82. In order to manage the increasing number of MAP cases being requested, Luxembourg reported that it has increased the number of staff working on MAP and is expecting hiring additional MAP staff in 2024-25.
Peer input
83. During the previous peer reviews, all peers that provided input indicated having a good working relationship with Luxembourg and one of them emphasises that Luxembourg’s competent authority aims at resolving MAP cases in a timely and efficient manner.
84. Six peers provided input for the current period and commented about their positive experiences with Luxembourg in resolving the MAP cases. The first peer reported that its competent authority continues to have a good working relation with Luxembourg’s competent authority. This peer added that regular communications take place between both competent authority functions using various tools available, including electronic tools such as protected emails and video conferencing and that it wishes to recognize the very helpful and cooperative approach of Luxembourg’s competent authority in the MAP resolution process. Accordingly, this peer indicated that it considers that Luxembourg has adequate resources to address MAP cases. The second peer reported that since 1 October 2018 it continued to develop the MAP relationship with Luxembourg’s competent authority. This peer noted that the competent authorities’ meetings were effective and productive and that Luxembourg’s competent authority showed a principled as well as a pragmatic approach in resolving MAP cases as well as handling APA cases. The third peer noted that during 2018-23 the average time taken to close was zero days for two cases and less than one month for a third other case and that in these cases, Luxembourg’s competent authority notified its competent authority regarding the taxpayers’ requests and at the same time informed this peer that Luxembourg’s competent authority granted these cases unilateral relief. Accordingly, this peer indicated that it has a good relationship with Luxembourg’s competent authority and that taking into consideration the average time taken to resolve the cases, it believes that the resources allocated to the MAP functions are adequate and well-prepared. The fourth peer indicated that it has limited experience in resolving cases with Luxembourg because the inventory of cases between both jurisdictions is small although it has increased recently in attribution/allocation cases. The fifth peer reported that the collaboration with Luxembourg’s competent authority is very good and productive and they are currently working to resolve MAPs in a timely manner. The sixth peer reported that all of the MAP cases resolved with Luxembourg during the review period were resolved unilaterally by Luxembourg in a timely manner.
Anticipated modifications
85. Luxembourg reported that in the last quarter of 2024, four additional hires will increase the Economic Division’s TP capacity, resulting in a team of nine with one Head of Division dedicated to handling attribution/allocation cases and bilateral APAs by the end of 2024.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[C.3]
While Luxembourg's MAP cases were closed in 13.81 months on average, which is under the 24-month average timeframe (which is the pursued average for resolving MAP cases), attribution / allocation cases were closed on average in 30.24 months which is above the aforementioned 24-month target timeframe. Luxembourg’s total MAP inventory also increased by 34% between 2018 and 2023 and its caseload for attribution / allocation cases increased by 200% over the same period. In addition, Luxembourg's recent reorganisation may have led to a change in the experience levels of the team dealing with attribution/allocation cases.
While Luxembourg has already increased the resources available to its competent authority, Luxembourg should monitor whether the additional resources recently provided to the competent authority function, as well as the additional resources already envisaged to be provided in the near future, will remain adequate in order to resolve (current pending and) future MAP cases in an efficient, effective and timely manner, In particular, Luxembourg should ensure that the resources newly added to its competent authority are adequate to be able to resolve its attribution/allocation cases in an efficient, effective and timely manner and to cope with the significant increase in the number of attribution / allocation cases.
PART D: PRACTICAL APPLICATION OF THE ACTION 14 MINIMUM STANDARD
[A.2] Provide roll-back of bilateral APAs in appropriate cases
Jurisdictions with bilateral advance pricing arrangement (“APA”) programmes should provide for the roll-back of APAs in appropriate cases, subject to the applicable time limits (such as statutes of limitation for assessment) where the relevant facts and circumstances in the earlier tax years are the same and subject to the verification of these facts and circumstances on audit.
86. An APA establishes the criteria for determining transfer pricing for controlled transactions before they occur. The methodology used in a bilateral or multilateral APA can be applied retrospectively to determine the treatment of comparable controlled transactions in previous years. The "roll-back" of an APA to previous years can prevent or resolve potential transfer pricing disputes.
Luxembourg’s APA programme
87. Luxembourg does not have a formal bilateral APA programme but considers that bilateral APAs can be concluded by the competent authority of Luxembourg on the basis of Article 25(3), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]).
88. In practice, Luxembourg reported that it applies bilateral APAs from the first year covered by the application, under the conditions set out above, irrespective of the date when the agreement was concluded by the competent authorities.
Roll-back of bilateral APAs
89. Luxembourg may grant an extension of the bilateral APAs for previous financial years, subject to compliance with the applicable statute of limitation.
Practical application of roll-back of bilateral APAs
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
90. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that since 1 April 2017, of all APA requests Luxembourg has received one request for roll-back and the APA request concerned was still in the process of being reviewed.15
91. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that all the peers that provided input were not aware of any requests for roll-back of APA that concerned Luxembourg.
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
92. Luxembourg publishes statistics on APAs on the website of the European Commission.16
93. Luxembourg reported having received 59 requests for bilateral APAs during the Review Period, of which 12 requests included a request for roll-back. Luxembourg added that of the roll-back requests, nine are under consideration, two APA requests including requests for roll-back have been rejected by the other competent authority and the last APA request including a request for roll-back was rejected by Luxembourg’s competent authority. In addition, Luxembourg reported that the case including the request for roll-back that was pending on 30 September 2018 is still under negotiation.
94. Luxembourg filed its APA Statistics for 2023 according to the APA Statistics Reporting Framework. Luxembourg’s APA Statistics for 2023 are shown in the table below:
Start inventory on 1 January 2023
Case started
Cases closed
End inventory on 31 December 2023
Average time taken in months to grant APAs during the reporting period
Granted
Rejected
Other reason
APA cases
45
7
1
0
0
51
21
Source: OECD
95. Three peers provided input with respect to their experience with Luxembourg in bilateral APAs or the roll-back of APAs. The first peer noted that the Luxembourg’s competent authority has been receptive to APA roll-back requests. The second peer reported that in 2021, one APA was signed with Luxembourg, but roll-back was not requested. The third peer reported that its experience has been that Luxembourg’s competent authority is agreeable to roll-backs.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[A.2]
-
-
[B.2] Allow submission of MAP requests to the competent authority of either treaty partner, or, alternatively, introduce a bilateral consultation or notification process
Jurisdictions should ensure that either (i) their tax treaties contain a provision which provides that the taxpayer can make a request for MAP assistance to the competent authority of either Contracting Party, or (ii) where the treaty does not permit a MAP request to be made to either Contracting Party and the competent authority who received the MAP request from the taxpayer does not consider the taxpayer’s objection to be justified, the competent authority should implement a bilateral consultation or notification process which allows the other competent authority to provide its views on the case (such consultation shall not be interpreted as consultation as to how to resolve the case).
96. For effective access to MAP in eligible cases and to ensure that all competent authorities involved are aware of MAP requests, tax treaties must include a provision allowing taxpayers to submit a request to the competent authority of either treaty partner. If such a provision is absent, residents may submit a request to the competent authority of their state or to the state of which they are a national under the non-discrimination article. In these cases, jurisdictions should have a bilateral consultation or notification process to address any objections raised by taxpayers in their MAP requests.
Domestic bilateral consultation or notification process in place
97. Out of Luxembourg’s 93 treaties, 58 currently contain a provision equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) as amended by the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]), allowing taxpayers to submit a MAP request to the competent authority of either treaty partner. This includes those tax treaties that have been or will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument.
98. Luxembourg reported that it has introduced a bilateral consultation or notification process that allows the other competent authority concerned to provide its views on the case when Luxembourg’s competent authority considers the objection raised in the MAP request not to be justified. Luxembourg clarified that the procedure for this notification/consultation has been documented in its internal procedure and that the staff in its competent authority have been briefed on this process.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 31 March 2017
99. It was noted in the previous peer review report that since 1 January 2015, Luxembourg has considered an objection not to be justified in one MAP request (submitted in 2016) and that no notification or consultation regarding this case was performed with Luxembourg’s treaty partners.
100. It was noted in that report that peers generally indicated that they are not aware of cases where Luxembourg’s competent authority has refused to open a MAP since 1 January 2015.17
Period 1 April 2017 – 30 September 2018
101. It was noted in the previous peer review report that between 1 April 2017 and 30 September 2018 Luxembourg considered the objection not justified in four cases involving two treaty partners and that the notification was made to its treaty partners as well as the relevant taxpayers, which was confirmed by the relevant peers.18
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
102. Luxembourg reported that in 37 cases, its competent authority considered that the objection raised by taxpayers in their MAP request is not justified. From Luxembourg’s 2018-23 MAP statistics provided, it follows that in 56 MAP cases, the outcome reported was “objection is not justified”, with the decision being taken by the treaty partner’s competent authority in 19 of those cases. Luxembourg reported that for the majority of the cases, the competent authority of the concerned peers was notified or consulted soon after. One of the peers concerned confirmed this. However, Luxembourg clarified that, although the notification occurred only in the context of the statistics matching exercise for a very small number of exceptional cases, its competent authority did not consider the decision that the objection is not justified as final for those cases and if the treaty partner disagreed and considered the objection justified, it would consider moving to the bilateral phase in MAP.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[B.2]
-
-
[B.3] Provide access to MAP in transfer pricing cases
Jurisdictions should provide access to MAP in transfer pricing cases.
103. For compliance with element B.3, jurisdictions should provide access to MAP in transfer pricing cases, irrespective of whether the equivalent of Article 9(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) is contained in its tax treaties.
Legal and administrative framework
104. The table below provides a summary of Luxembourg’s tax treaties in relation to whether the equivalent of Article 9(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) is included.
Provision
Number of tax treaties
Contains the equivalent of Article 9(2): Contains a provision equivalent to Article 9(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or has been or will be modified or superseded by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
Among these:
12 treaties have been modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
One treaty will be modified by the Multilateral Instrument to include such a provision.
89
Does not contain the equivalent of Article 9(2): Considered not to contain a provision that is based on or equivalent to Article 9(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and is not expected to be modified or superseded by the Multilateral Instrument. Among these:
Two treaties do not contain such a provision but contain the equivalent of Article 9 of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]).
One treaty contains a similar provision, but the word “shall” is replaced by “may”.
One treaty contains a similar provision but require agreement by the competent authorities for the granting of corresponding adjustments.
4
105. Luxembourg indicated that it will always provide access to MAP for transfer pricing cases and is willing to make corresponding adjustments, regardless of whether the equivalent of Article 9(2) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) is contained in its tax treaties. The relationship between access to MAP and transfer pricing can be found in section 2.3. of Luxembourg’s MAP guidance.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
106. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that while Luxembourg has received MAP requests concerning transfer pricing cases, Luxembourg’s competent authority had not denied access to MAP on the grounds that the case concerned a transfer pricing case during this period, which was confirmed by the peers that provided input.19
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
107. Luxembourg reported that since 1 October 2018, its competent authority has not denied access to MAP on the basis that the case concerned a transfer pricing case although it has denied access to MAP in one transfer pricing case on the basis that the request was submitted beyond the time limit for filing contained in the tax treaty.
108. All of the peers that provided input indicated not being aware of a denial of access to MAP by Luxembourg since 1 October 2018 on the basis that the case concerned was a transfer pricing case.
Anticipated modification
109. For one treaty, where the treaty partner has signed but not ratified the MLI, Luxembourg sent proposed amendments, including those related to the Action 14 Minimum Standard and a proposal to include Article 9(2).
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[B.3]
-
-
[B.4] Provide access to MAP in relation to the application of anti-abuse provisions
Jurisdictions should provide access to MAP in cases in which there is a disagreement between the taxpayer and the tax authorities making the adjustment as to whether the conditions for the application of a treaty anti-abuse provision have been met or as to whether the application of a domestic law anti-abuse provision is in conflict with the provisions of a treaty.
110. To prevent arbitrary application of anti-abuse provisions in tax treaties, taxpayers should have access to MAP if they consider the interpretation or application of such provisions as incorrect. Access to MAP is also important to avoid conflicts between domestic anti-abuse legislation and tax treaty provisions.
Legal and administrative framework
111. Of Luxembourg’s 93 tax treaties, none allow competent authorities to restrict access to MAP for cases where a treaty anti-abuse provision applies or where there is a disagreement between the taxpayer and the tax authorities as to whether the application of a domestic law anti-abuse provision is in conflict with the provisions of a tax treaty. In addition, also the domestic law and/or administrative processes of Luxembourg do not include a provision allowing its competent authority to limit access to MAP for cases in which there is a disagreement between the taxpayer and the tax authorities as to whether the conditions for the application of a domestic law anti-abuse provision are in conflict with the provisions of a tax treaty.
112. Luxembourg indicated that it will always provide access to MAP for cases where a treaty anti-abuse provision applies or where there is a disagreement between the taxpayer and the tax authorities as to whether the application of a domestic law anti-abuse provision is in conflict with the provisions of a tax treaty.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
113. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that Luxembourg had not received any MAP requests for cases in which there was a disagreement between the taxpayer and the tax authorities as to whether the conditions for the application of a treaty anti-abuse provision have been met, or as to whether the application of a domestic law anti-abuse provision is in conflict with the provisions of a tax treaty during this period, which was confirmed by the peers that provided input.20
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
114. Luxembourg reported that since 1 October 2018, its competent authority has not denied access to MAP in cases in which there was a disagreement between the taxpayer and the tax authorities as to whether the conditions for the application of a treaty anti-abuse provision have been met, or as to whether the application of a domestic law anti-abuse provision is in conflict with the provisions of a tax treaty.
115. All peers that provided input indicated not being aware of cases that have been denied access to MAP in Luxembourg since 1 October 2018 in relation to the application of treaty and/or domestic anti-abuse provisions.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[B.4]
-
-
[B.5] & [B.10] Provide access to MAP in cases of audit settlements & clarify in MAP guidance that audit settlements do not preclude access to MAP
Jurisdictions should not deny access to MAP in cases where there is an audit settlement between tax authorities and taxpayers. If jurisdictions have an administrative or statutory dispute settlement/resolution process independent from the audit and examination functions and that can only be accessed through a request by the taxpayer, jurisdictions may limit access to the MAP with respect to the matters resolved through that process. Jurisdictions should clarify in their MAP guidance that audit settlements between tax authorities and taxpayers do not preclude access to MAP. If jurisdictions have an administrative or statutory dispute settlement/resolution process independent from the audit and examination functions and that can only be accessed through a request by the taxpayer, and jurisdictions limit access to the MAP with respect to the matters resolved through that process, jurisdictions should notify their treaty partners of such administrative or statutory processes and should expressly address the effects of those processes with respect to the MAP in their public guidance on such processes and in their public MAP programme guidance.
116. Although an audit settlement provides taxpayers with certainty on its tax positions, double taxation may still occur. Taxpayers should have access to the MAP in such cases, except when the issue has already been resolved through an independent administrative or statutory dispute settlement/resolution process accessible only through a taxpayer request. In this regard, a jurisdiction's MAP guidance should clarify that taxpayers have access to MAP in case of audit settlements. In addition, jurisdictions should ensure that treaty partners are notified of a covered administrative or statutory dispute settlement/resolution process if they limit access to the MAP with respect to the matters resolved through that process.
Legal and administrative framework
Audit settlements
117. Luxembourg reported that audit settlements are not possible under its domestic law or policy.
Administrative or statutory dispute settlement/resolution process
118. Luxembourg reported it does not have an administrative or statutory dispute settlement/resolution process in place, which is independent from the audit and examination functions, and which can only be accessed through a request by the taxpayer.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[B.5]
-
-
[B.10]
-
-
[B.6] Provide access to MAP if required information is submitted
Jurisdictions should not limit access to MAP based on the argument that insufficient information was provided if the taxpayer has provided the required information based on the rules, guidelines and procedures made available to taxpayers on access to and the use of MAP.
119. To cases where there is taxation not in accordance with the provisions of the tax treaty, access to MAP should not be restricted if taxpayers have provided the required information and documentation as per the jurisdiction’s guidelines, which should be made available publicly to facilitate the process.
Legal framework on access to MAP and information to be submitted
120. The information and documentation Luxembourg requires taxpayers to include in a request for MAP assistance are discussed under element B.8.
121. Luxembourg reported that when not all required information/documentation is provided by the taxpayer, the taxpayer is reminded of the requirements and is invited to provide the missing information within a requested time limit. This is further clarified in section 3.4.(a) of Luxembourg’s MAP guidance. Luxembourg clarified that in general, the taxpayer is asked to provide the additional information within a time frame that varies between one week and two months, which varies according to the content of the information required.
122. Luxembourg reported that it provides access to MAP in all cases where taxpayers have complied with the information or documentation requirements as set out in its MAP guidance.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
123. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that Luxembourg’s competent authority had not denied access to MAP in situations where taxpayers complied with information and documentation requirements, which was confirmed by peers.21 The reports further note that access to MAP was denied in one case from 2016 when the taxpayer did not provide sufficient information.
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
124. Luxembourg reported that since 1 October 2018 it has not denied access to MAP for cases where the taxpayer had provided the required information or documentation.
125. All peers that provided input indicated not being aware of a limitation of access to MAP by Luxembourg since 1 October 2018 in situations where taxpayers complied with information and documentation requirements.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[B.6]
-
-
[C.4] Ensure staff in charge of MAP has the authority to resolve cases in accordance with the applicable tax treaty
Jurisdictions should ensure that the staff in charge of MAP processes have the authority to resolve MAP cases in accordance with the terms of the applicable tax treaty, in particular without being dependent on the approval or the direction of the tax administration personnel who made the adjustments at issue or being influenced by considerations of the policy that the jurisdictions would like to see reflected in future amendments to the treaty.
126. Ensuring that staff in charge of MAP can and will resolve cases, absent any approval/direction by the tax administration personnel directly involved in the adjustment and absent any policy considerations, contributes to a principled and consistent approach to MAP cases.
Functioning of staff in charge of MAP
127. Luxembourg reported that when a MAP request is received by its competent authority following a tax audit that occurred in Luxembourg, some information may be obtained from the relevant audit departments as regards the relevant taxpayers, and that nevertheless, both the Economic Division and the International Relations Division make their decisions independently to resolve MAP cases. This is confirmed in section 9.1. of Luxembourg’s MAP guidance. Luxembourg additionally noted that no staff member or superior actively involved in a case at the audit level has ever been involved in the same issue in MAP and interactions with the audit function have only been for fact-finding purposes.
128. As mentioned previously, Luxembourg reported that some people handling MAP cases in the International Relations Division are also in charge of negotiating tax treaties. However, Luxembourg clarified that, in order to resolve MAP cases, its competent authority takes into account the treaty provisions that are in force, the OECD Model Tax Convention and the OECD Transfer pricing guidelines. Accordingly, Luxembourg clarified that any decisions on MAP will be based on the applicable tax treaty and not influenced by any proposed future amendments to the treaty.
129. Based on the above, Luxembourg reported that staff in charge of MAP in practice operates independently and has the authority to resolve MAP cases without being dependent on the approval/direction of the tax administration personnel directly involved in the adjustment and the process for negotiating MAP agreements is not influenced by policy considerations that Luxembourg would like to see reflected in future amendments to the treaty.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
130. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that peers were generally of the view that during this period the staff in charge of MAP processes in Luxembourg have the authority to resolve MAP cases in accordance with the terms of the applicable tax treaty, in particular without being dependent on the approval or the direction of the tax administration personnel who made the adjustments at issue or being influenced by considerations of the policy that the jurisdictions would like to see reflected in future amendments to the treaty.22
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
131. Peers generally reported that no impediments in Luxembourg to perform its MAP function in the absence of approval or the direction of the tax administration personnel who made the adjustments at issue or being influenced by considerations of the policy. One peer specifically reported that all of the MAP cases resolved during the review period were resolved unilaterally by Luxembourg and that this supports a conclusion that Luxembourg’s competent authority has authority to resolve MAP cases.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[C.4]
-
-
[C.5] Use appropriate performance indicators for the MAP function
Jurisdictions should not use performance indicators for their competent authority functions and staff in charge of MAP processes based on the amount of sustained audit adjustments or maintaining tax revenue.
132. Performance indicators for the competent authority function and staff in charge of MAP processes should not be based on the amount of sustained audit adjustments or maintaining a certain amount of tax revenue, to ensure principled and consistent resolution of MAP cases based on individual merits.
Performance indicators used by Luxembourg
133. Luxembourg indicated that it does not use performance indicators to assess the staff in charge of the mutual agreement procedures. However, a multi-year evaluation is carried out by the managers and is based on the cases handled and/or resolved by staff.
134. The Action 14 final report includes examples of performance indicators that are considered appropriate. These indicators are shown below:
Used by Luxembourg
Indicator
No
Number of MAP cases resolved.
Yes
Consistency (i.e. a treaty should be applied in a principled and consistent manner to MAP cases involving the same facts and similarly-situated taxpayers).
No
Time taken to resolve a MAP case (recognising that the time taken to resolve a MAP case may vary according to its complexity and that matters not under the control of a competent authority may have a significant impact on the time needed to resolve a case).
135. Luxembourg also reported that it does not use any performance indicators for staff in charge of MAP that are related to the outcome of MAP discussions in terms of the amount of sustained audit adjustments or maintained tax revenue. In other words, staff in charge of MAP is not evaluated on the basis of the material outcome of MAP discussions.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
136. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that no peers reported any concerns with respect to the performance indicators used to evaluate Luxembourg’s competent authority function.23
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
137. All peers that provided input reported not being aware of the use of performance indicators by Luxembourg that are based on the amount of sustained audit adjustments or maintaining a certain amount of tax revenue.
Anticipated modifications
138. Luxembourg indicated that it is anticipated that the number of solved MAP cases may be used as a future performance indicator.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[C.5]
-
-
[C.6] Provide transparency with respect to the position on MAP arbitration
Jurisdictions should provide transparency with respect to their positions on MAP arbitration.
139. Arbitration provisions in tax treaties can provide certainty to taxpayers and competent authorities by resolving MAP cases within a set timeframe. To ensure full clarity on the availability of arbitration as a final stage in the MAP process, jurisdictions must be transparent about their position on MAP arbitration.
Position on MAP arbitration
140. Luxembourg reported it has no domestic law limitations for including MAP arbitration in its tax treaties. In addition, Luxembourg reported it is committed to include a mandatory and binding arbitration procedure in its tax treaties, as a mechanism to provide that treaty related disputes will be resolved within a specified timeframe and in that respect, its policy is to include in its tax treaties an arbitration clause modelled after Article 25(5) of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]). This is clarified in Luxembourg’s MAP profile. In addition, the availability of arbitration (including the EU Arbitration Convention) is indicated in section 8 of Luxembourg’s MAP guidance.
141. To date, Luxembourg has incorporated an arbitration clause in 18 of 93 treaties as a final stage to the MAP. These clauses can be specified as follows:
Equivalent of Article 25(5) of the OECD Model Tax Convention: 16 treaties.
Mandatory and binding arbitration: one treaty.
Voluntary (i.e. where arbitration may only be initiated with the agreement of the competent authorities) and binding arbitration: one treaty.
142. In addition, Luxembourg is a signatory to the EU Arbitration Convention and has adopted the EU Dispute Resolution Directive.
143. Further, Luxembourg signed the Multilateral Instrument and has deposited its instrument of ratification on 9 April 2019. The Multilateral Instrument has entered into force for Luxembourg on 1 August 2019. Luxembourg opted for part VI of the Multilateral Instrument, which includes a mandatory and binding arbitration provision.24 Part VI of the Multilateral Instrument has modified or will modify 13 of the treaties to insert a mandatory and binding arbitration provision.
Recent developments
144. The domestic legislation incorporating the EU Dispute Resolution Directive into Luxembourg’s domestic law was enacted on 20 December 2019.
145. Luxembourg has signed two new tax treaties that contain a MAP arbitration provision that is based on Article 25(5) of the OECD Model Tax Convention.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[C.6]
-
-
[D.1] Implement all MAP agreements
Jurisdictions should implement any agreement reached in MAP discussions, including by making appropriate adjustments to the tax assessed in transfer pricing cases.
146. In order to provide full tax certainty to both taxpayers and jurisdictions, it is essential that all MAP agreements are implemented by the competent authorities concerned.
Legal framework to implement MAP agreements
147. Luxembourg reported that it will implement all MAP agreements irrespective of its domestic time limits regardless of whether the underlying tax treaty contains the equivalent of Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]).
148. Luxembourg reported that where a MAP agreement is concluded by the competent authorities, Luxembourg’s competent authority requests the taxpayer to give its approval and, where appropriate, to withdraw any administrative or legal appeal in relation to both the substance and the form of the tax concerned. Luxembourg noted that if the taxpayer accepts the MAP agreement, it is then implemented by Luxembourg, subject to the limits described below. In addition, Luxembourg clarified that implementation of the MAP agreement is carried out by the local tax office for the taxpayer concerned, to which its competent authority gives instructions to carry out such implementation. This is clarified in section 3.6. of Luxembourg’s MAP guidance.
149. Luxembourg reported that it implements MAP agreements, with specificities depending on whether the implementation results in upward or downward adjustments. Luxembourg noted that downward adjustments are made irrespective of any time limitations in domestic laws while upward adjustments are only possible within the time limitation provided for in domestic law, generally five years (or ten years under certain conditions) from 31 December of the year for which the tax amount is due.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
150. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that all MAP agreements reached by Luxembourg during this period were implemented, which was confirmed by the peers that provided input.25
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
151. Luxembourg reported that all MAP agreements that were reached on or after 1 October 2018, which required an implementation in Luxembourg, were or will be implemented.
152. All peers that provided input reported that they were not aware of any MAP agreement reached on or after 1 October 2018 that was not implemented by Luxembourg, with one peer noting that all relevant MAP agreements reached were implemented by Luxembourg.
Conclusion
Areas for Improvement
Recommendations
[D.1]
-
-
[D.2] Implement all MAP agreements on a timely basis
Agreements reached by competent authorities through the MAP process should be implemented on a timely basis.
153. Delaying the implementation of MAP agreements can have financial consequences for taxpayers and competent authorities. To prevent this and provide certainty for all parties involved, procedural and statutory delays in the relevant jurisdictions should not obstruct the timely implementation of MAP agreements.
Theoretical timeframe for implementing mutual agreements
154. Luxembourg reported that it has not adopted a theoretical timeframe to follow the implementation MAP agreements. In practice, Luxembourg noted that its competent authority is not itself responsible for the implementation of MAPs. Furthermore, Luxembourg does not monitor and verify the implementation of MAP agreements.
155. Regarding the monitoring process for the implementation of MAP agreements, Luxembourg reported that it does not have a formal verification process but that a team member of the International Relations division periodically verifies the implementation of MAP agreements by following up on closed cases, as shown in the internal MAP statistics document, and reaches out to the relevant services responsible for implementing these agreements, if necessary.
Practical application
Period 1 January 2015 – 30 September 2018
156. It was noted in the previous peer review reports that all MAP agreements reached by Luxembourg during this period were implemented in a timely manner, which was confirmed by the peers that provided input.26
Period 1 October 2018 – 31 July 2024
157. Luxembourg reported that all MAP agreements that were reached on or after 1 October 2018, once accepted by taxpayers, have been (or will be) timely implemented and that no cases of noticeable delays have occurred.
158. All peers that provided input have not indicated experiencing any problems with Luxembourg regarding the implementation of MAP agreements reached on a timely basis.
One out of 93 tax treaties does not contain a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]), either as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report or as amended by that report (OECD, 2015[2]). For this treaty, the relevant treaty partner has been engaged by Luxembourg with a view to have the treaty modified by the Multilateral Instrument. However, where this is not possible, bilateral negotiations will be initiated.
For the one treaty that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]), either as it read prior to the adoption of the Action 14 final report or as amended by that report (OECD, 2015[2]) and will at this time not be modified by the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg should continue to work in accordance with its stated intention to include the required provision via the Multilateral Instrument and where this is not possible, request via bilateral negotiations the inclusion of the required provision in accordance with its plan. This concerns a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(1), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2015[3]) either:
a) As amended by the Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]); or
b) As it read prior to the adoption of Action 14 final report (OECD, 2015[2]).
[B.2]
-
-
[B.3]
-
-
[B.4]
-
-
[B.5]
-
-
[B.6]
-
-
[B.7]
-
-
[B.8]
-
-
[B.9]
-
-
[B.10]
-
-
Part C: Resolution of MAP cases
[C.1]
Two out of 93 tax treaties do not contain a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]). One of these two treaties has been modified the Multilateral Instrument to include the required provision. With respect to the remaining treaty, Luxembourg reached an agreement on the text of the amending protocol with treaty partner.
For the one treaty that does not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), first sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) and will at this time not be modified via the Multilateral Instrument, Luxembourg should sign the amending protocol as soon as possible to ensure the inclusion of the required provision.
[C.2]
-
-
[C.3]
While Luxembourg's MAP cases were closed in 13.81 months on average, which is under the 24-month average timeframe (which is the pursued average for resolving MAP cases), attribution / allocation cases were closed on average in 30.24 months which is above the aforementioned 24-month target timeframe. Luxembourg’s total MAP inventory also increased by 34% between 2018 and 2023 and its caseload for attribution / allocation cases increased by 200% over the same period. In addition, Luxembourg's recent reorganisation may have led to a change in the experience levels of the team dealing with attribution/allocation cases.
While Luxembourg has already increased the resources available to its competent authority, Luxembourg should monitor whether the additional resources recently provided to the competent authority function, as well as the additional resources already envisaged to be provided in the near future, will remain adequate in order to resolve (current pending and) future MAP cases in an efficient, effective and timely manner, In particular, Luxembourg should ensure that the resources newly added to its competent authority are adequate to be able to resolve its attribution/allocation cases in an efficient, effective and timely manner and to cope with the significant increase in the number of attribution / allocation cases.
[C.4]
-
-
[C.5]
-
-
[C.6]
-
-
Part D: Implementation of MAP agreements
[D.1]
-
-
[D.2]
-
-
[D.3]
15 out of 93 tax treaties contain neither a provision that is equivalent to Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) nor both alternative provisions provided for in Article 9(1) and Article 7(2). 12 of these 15 treaties have been or will be modified the Multilateral Instrument to include the required provision. With respect to the remaining treaties:
For two treaties, discussions will be initiated once negotiations with treaty partners with which actions are ongoing are completed.
For the remaining treaty, no actions have been taken nor are any actions planned to be taken.
For the three treaties that do not contain the equivalent of Article 25(2), second sentence, of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]) or both alternative provisions provided for in Article 9(1) and Article 7(2), and will at this time not be modified via the Multilateral Instrument Luxembourg should:
For two treaties, request the inclusion of the required provision via bilateral negotiations or be willing to accept the inclusion of both alternative provisions in accordance with its plan.
For the remaining treaty, without further delay, request the inclusion of the required provision via bilateral negotiations or be willing to accept the inclusion of both alternative provisions.
References
[1] OECD (2019), Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital 2017 (Full Version), OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/g2g972ee-en.
[2] OECD (2015), Making Dispute Resolution Mechanisms More Effective, Action 14 - 2015 Final Report, OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264241633-en.
No. of pre-2016 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2018
Number of pre-2016 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of pre- 2016 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2018
Average time taken (in months) for closing pre-2016 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Attribution/ Allocation
10
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
8
41.57
Others
63
0
0
1
2
0
12
0
4
2
0
42
69.97
Total
73
0
0
2
2
0
13
0
4
2
0
50
67.50
Note: Luxembourg’s pre-2016 ‘other’ case reporting differs by 15 cases from the published statistics owing to the treaty partner not reporting these cases to Luxembourg.
2019 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of pre-2016 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2019
Number of pre-2016 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of pre- 2016 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2019
Average time taken (in months) for closing pre-2016 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Attribution/ Allocation
8
0
0
0
0
0
3
0
0
0
0
5
64.87
Others
42
0
1
1
0
1
11
0
0
0
2
26
69.68
Total
50
0
1
1
0
1
14
0
0
0
2
31
68.92
2020 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of pre-2016 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2020
Number of pre-2016 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of pre- 2016 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2020
Average time taken (in months) for closing pre-2016 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Attribution/ Allocation
5
0
0
1
0
0
2
0
0
0
0
2
79.63
Others
26
0
1
0
0
0
5
0
0
0
0
20
96.43
Total
31
0
1
1
0
0
7
0
0
0
0
22
90.83
2021 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of pre-2016 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2021
Number of pre-2016 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of pre- 2016 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2021
Average time taken (in months) for closing pre-2016 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Attribution/ Allocation
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
n.a.
Others
20
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
15
95.95
Total
22
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
17
95.95
2022 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of pre-2016 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2022
Number of pre-2016 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of pre- 2016 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2022
Average time taken (in months) for closing pre-2016 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Attribution/ Allocation
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
n.a.
Others
15
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
0
0
0
10
103.72
Total
17
0
0
0
0
0
5
0
0
0
0
12
103.72
Note: Luxembourg’s pre-2016 ‘Other’ case reporting differs by two cases from the published statistics in 2021 owing to the correction of an error by Luxembourg.
2023 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of pre-2016 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2023
Number of pre-2016 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of pre- 2016 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2023
Average time taken (in months) for closing pre-2016 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Attribution/ Allocation
2
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
n.a.
Others
10
0
5
0
0
0
4
0
0
1
0
0
201.02
Total
12
0
5
0
0
0
4
0
0
1
0
2
201.02
Annex 4.B. MAP Statistics Reporting for the 2018-2023 Reporting Periods (1 January 2018 to 31 December 2023) for Post-2015 Cases
No. of post-2015 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2018
No. of post-2015 cases started during the reporting period
Number of post-2015cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of post-2015 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2018
Average time taken (in months) for closing post-2015 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Column 15
Attribution/ Allocation
14
16
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
29
2.24
Others
101
227
15
8
2
129
3
62
0
0
1
0
108
5.16
Total
115
243
15
8
2
129
3
63
0
0
1
0
137
5.15
2019 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of post-2015 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2019
No. of post-2015 cases started during the reporting period
Number of post-2015cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of post-2015 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2019
Average time taken (in months) for closing post-2015 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Column 15
Attribution/ Allocation
29
18
0
0
2
1
0
5
0
0
0
0
39
15.08
Others
108
199
12
8
5
58
4
74
0
0
1
0
145
6.18
Total
137
217
12
8
7
59
4
79
0
0
1
0
184
6.60
Notes: Luxembourg’s post-2015 ‘Other’ case reporting differs by three cases from the published statistics owing to the correction of an error by Luxembourg.
Luxembourg’s post-2015 ‘Attribution/Allocation’ case reporting differs by two cases from the published statistics owing to the correction of an error by Luxembourg.
2020 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of post-2015 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2020
No. of post-2015 cases started during the reporting period
Number of post-2015cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of post-2015 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2020
Average time taken (in months) for closing post-2015 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Column 15
Attribution/ Allocation
39
12
4
0
2
1
0
2
2
0
0
0
40
14.67
Others
145
183
3
18
3
98
5
65
0
0
0
0
136
7.04
Total
184
195
7
18
5
99
5
67
2
0
0
0
176
7.45
Notes: Luxembourg’s post-2015 ‘Other’ case reporting differs by one case from the published statistics owing to the correction of an error by Luxembourg.
Luxembourg’s post-2015 ‘Attribution/Allocation’ case reporting differs by two cases from the published statistics owing to the correction of an error by Luxembourg.
2021 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of post-2015 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2021
No. of post-2015 cases started during the reporting period
Number of post-2015cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of post-2015 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2021
Average time taken (in months) for closing post-2015 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Column 15
Attribution/ Allocation
40
29
1
0
2
0
0
15
0
0
1
0
50
31.48
Others
136
172
8
3
0
70
5
75
0
1
2
0
144
9.56
Total
176
201
9
3
2
70
5
90
0
1
3
0
194
11.84
2022 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of post-2015 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2022
No. of post-2015 cases started during the reporting period
Number of post-2015 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of post-2015 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 202
Average time taken (in months) for closing post-2015 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
No agreement including agreement to disagree
Any other outcome
Column 1
Column 2
Column 3
Column 4
Column 5
Column 6
Column 7
Column 8
Column 9
Column 10
Column 11
Column 12
Column 13
Column 14
Column 15
Attribution/ Allocation
50
16
1
0
2
0
0
7
0
0
0
0
56
34.08
Others
144
172
4
8
3
69
3
66
0
1
2
0
160
9.2
Total
194
188
5
8
5
69
3
73
0
1
2
0
216
10.70
Notes: Luxembourg’s post-2015 ‘Attribution/Allocation’ case reporting differs by two cases from the published statistics owing to the correction of an error by Luxembourg.
2023 MAP Statistics
Category of cases
No. of post-2015 cases in MAP inventory on 1 January 2023
No. of post-2015 cases started during the reporting period
Number of post-2015 cases closed during the reporting period by outcome:
No. of post-2015 cases remaining in on MAP inventory on 31 December 2023
Average time taken (in months) for closing post-2015 cases during the reporting period
Denied MAP access
Objection is not justified
Withdrawn by taxpayer
Unilateral relief granted
Resolved via domestic remedy
Agreement fully eliminating double taxation / fully resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement partially eliminating double taxation / partially resolving taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
Agreement that there is no taxation not in accordance with tax treaty
← 1. The tax treaties Luxembourg has entered into are available at: https://impotsdirects.public.lu/fr/conventions/luxembourg.html. The treaties that are signed but have not yet entered into force are with Albania (2009), Argentina (2019), Cabo Verde (2022), Colombia (2024), Ghana (2021), Kuwait (2007), and Montenegro (2024).
← 2. This concerns Luxembourg’s treaties with Cabo Verde (2022), Colombia (2024), Estonia (2014), France (2018), Guernsey (2013), Hong Kong (China) (2007), Isle of Man (2013), Jersey (2013), Kosovo (2017), Liechtenstein (2009), Mauritius (1995), Mexico (2001), Rwanda (2021), San Marino (2006), Seychelles (2012), Switzerland (1993), United Kingdom (2022) and Uruguay (2015).
← 14. Luxembourg’s 2018, 2019, 2020, and 2022 MAP statistics were corrected in the course of its peer review and deviate from the published MAP statistics for these years. See for a further explanation Annex A and B.