This batch comprises six Cycle 1 full peer review reports under the BEPS Action 14 Minimum Standard covering Austria, Germany, Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta and the United States. Collectively, the reviewed jurisdictions administer extensive treaty networks and established MAP programmes. The reports conclude that Austria meets most elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard, Germany meets the majority of its elements, and Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta and the United States meet almost all elements. Remaining areas for improvement across the batch primarily relate to treaty-network alignment, resource capacity and the timely resolution of MAP cases.
The six jurisdictions collectively administered approximately 2,700 MAP cases at the end of 2023. Inventories ranged from 23 cases in Malta to 1,332 cases in Germany. Germany and the United States together accounted for almost three-quarters of the cases administered across the batch, reflecting the scale and maturity of their MAP programmes.
A common finding across the reports is that treaty networks are largely aligned with Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention but are not yet fully brought in line. Jurisdictions continue to address these issues through the Multilateral Instrument, bilateral treaty negotiations or both.
The reviews consistently conclude that access to MAP is generally available in eligible cases, although certain restrictions remain, notably in Germany in relation to certain audit-settlement cases. The reports also show that jurisdictions have published comprehensive MAP guidance and MAP profiles. The competent authorities of these jurisdictions are generally viewed positively by treaty partners and in most cases operate independently from audit functions. Bilateral APA programmes and roll-back mechanisms are also widely available.
Performance in resolving MAP cases varies considerably. Ireland and Luxembourg reported average completion times of approximately 13 and 14 months respectively, substantially below the 24‑month target. Germany achieved an overall average of 23.89 months, meeting the 24-month target as well. Austria, Malta and the United States remained above the target, reporting averages of approximately 33 months, 46 months and 37 months respectively. Resource adequacy, ageing inventories and delays in communication and exchange of position papers emerged as recurring concerns among peers for a number of these jurisdictions.
Notwithstanding the overall compliance of each jurisdiction's policy and practice with the Action 14 Minimum Standard, several jurisdiction-specific observations merit attention:
Austria reduced its inventory and maintained a mature MAP programme but continues to face resource and timeliness challenges. Further, although Austria’s policy is to provide access to MAP in cases involving a disagreement as to whether the application of a domestic anti-abuse provision conflicted with the provisions of a tax treaty, access was not granted in one case. In addition, there is a risk that, where a tax treaty does not specify a filing period for MAP requests, Austria’s domestic rules may result in a filing period of less than three years from the first notification of the action giving rise to taxation not in accordance with the treaty.
Germany administered the largest MAP inventory in the batch and closed MAP cases within the average timeframe of 24 months. However, peer input suggest that taxpayers may be required to mandatorily waive their right to access MAP by implication, to obtain an audit settlement or a similar specific agreed outcome as part of the audit process in Germany. Peer input also highlights that the requirement for Germany’s competent authority to obtain the consent of the competent state tax administration, which also serves as the audit and examination function, before agreeing substantive positions or solutions in MAP, causes the staff in charge of MAP processes to not have the authority to resolve MAP cases independently of the personnel who made the adjustments at issue.
Ireland closed MAP cases overall within the 24‑month target; however, its overall inventory increased significantly, indicating that additional resources and further action are needed to ensure timely MAP resolution.
Luxembourg maintained an average MAP case resolution time below 24 months and expanded competent authority resources, notwithstanding significant growth in its inventory, particularly for attribution/allocation cases.
Malta reported an average MAP completion time above the 24‑month target and experienced a significant increase in its MAP inventory. Although it took efforts to resolve MAP cases, provided extensive clarifications regarding its pending inventory during the peer review process, and addressed most treaty-network deficiencies, it still faces capacity and timeliness constraints.
The United States achieved a substantial reduction of its MAP inventory, despite an average resolution time remaining significantly above the 24-month target and is overall mostly in line with the Action 14 Minimum Standard except for close to a third of its tax treaties as well as some issues regarding the timely implementation of MAP agreements
Overall, the reports demonstrate substantial progress in implementing the Action 14 Minimum Standard. Future efforts should focus on completing the alignment of treaty-networks with Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention, ensuring sufficient and independent competent-authority resources, and improving the management and resolution of MAP cases, especially older cases.