Austria has an extensive tax treaty network with 91 tax treaties and has signed and ratified the EU Arbitration Convention as well as adopted and implemented the Council Directive (EU) 2017/1852 of 10 October 2017 on tax dispute resolution mechanisms in the European Union. It has a large MAP inventory, with a large number of new cases submitted each year and 243 cases pending on 31 December 2023, close to 53% of which are attribution/allocation. Austria has an established MAP programme and has long-standing experience with resolving MAP cases. Overall Austria meets most of the elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard. Where it has deficiencies, Austria is working to address them.
All of Austria’s tax treaties contain a provision relating to MAP. Those treaties mostly follow paragraphs 1 through 3 of Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention (OECD, 2019[1]). Its treaty network is largely consistent with the requirements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard, except mainly for the fact that 22% of its tax treaties neither contain a provision stating that mutual agreements shall be implemented notwithstanding any time limits in domestic law (which is required under Article 25(2), second sentence), nor the alternative provisions that set a time limit for making adjustments under Article 9(1) and Article 7(2).
In order to be fully in line with all four key areas of an effective dispute resolution mechanism under the Action 14 Minimum Standard, Austria needs to amend and update 23 of its tax treaties. In this respect, Austria signed and ratified the Multilateral Instrument, through which 11 of its tax treaties have been or will be modified to fulfil the requirements under the Action 14 Minimum Standard. Where treaties will not be modified, upon entry into force of the Multilateral Instrument for the treaties concerned, Austria reported that it intends to update those tax treaties via bilateral negotiations to be in line with the requirements under the Action 14 Minimum Standard. For this purpose, negotiations are envisaged, initiated or ongoing with 12 treaty partners. Furthermore, Austria opted for part VI of the Multilateral Instrument concerning the introduction of a mandatory and binding arbitration provision in tax treaties.
Austria is partially in line with the remaining elements of the Action 14 Minimum Standard because of the following.
Austria meets the Action 14 Minimum Standard concerning the prevention of disputes. It has in place a bilateral APA programme. This APA programme enables taxpayers to request roll-back of bilateral APAs and such roll-backs are granted in practice.
Austria also meets most requirements regarding the availability and access to MAP under the Action 14 Minimum Standard. It provides access to MAP in transfer pricing cases, cases where there has been an audit settlement (in the form of an agreement) between the taxpayer and the tax administration, although it has since 1 October 2018 not received MAP requests in any cases of the latter category. However, although Austria’s policy is to provide access to MAP in such cases, access to MAP was not granted in one case in which there was a disagreement between the taxpayer and the tax authorities as to whether the application of a domestic law anti-abuse provision is in conflict with the provisions of a tax treaty. In addition, where tax treaties do not include a time limit for submission of a MAP request, there is a risk that applicable rules under the Austria’s domestic legislation will lead to a filing period of less than three years as from the first notification of the action resulting in taxation not in accordance with the provisions of a tax treaty. Austria has clear and comprehensive guidance on the availability of MAP and how it applies this procedure in practice, under tax treaties, the EU Arbitration Convention and the EU Dispute Resolution Directive, and has updated its MAP profile.
Concerning the average time needed to close MAP cases, the MAP statistics for Austria for the period 2018-23 are as follows: