98. During the previous peer reviews, almost all peers that provided input indicated having a good working relationship with Germany’s competent authority concerning MAP, some of them emphasising that Germany’s competent authority is constructive to resolve MAP cases and referred to a professional and efficient working relationship with smooth and timely communications. However, in the period 1 January 2015 to 31 March 2017, a number of peers reported concerns inter alia with respect to delays in receiving communications, delays in receiving position papers and responses, delays in deciding whether complex cases are eligible for MAP and the federal structure of Germany requiring coordination with the competent state tax administration, leading to delays. In the period 1 April 2017 to 30 September 2018, several peers emphasised once again that their competent authorities had positive and fluid working relationships with Germany’s competent authority, but concerns were still raised regarding delays and regarding the adequacy of resources in Germany’s competent authority in light of these delays, particularly concerning the coordination with the competent state tax administration. For both periods, peers in general suggested more frequent and efficient communication including through e-mails, more frequent face-to-face meetings and less involvement by the competent state tax administration to improve the handling and resolution of MAP cases by Germany’s competent authority.24
99. 23 peers provided input on the handling and resolution of MAP cases with Germany’s competent authority. The first peer noted that Germany has been responsive and has worked with its competent authority to resolve MAP matters in a timely way and shared its view that the personnel in Germany’s competent authority are experienced in resolving MAP cases. The second peer reported that Germany is its main MAP partner and shared its view that the working relationship between the two competent authorities is very good. This peer shared its appreciation for the responsiveness of Germany’s competent authority and noted that it is possible to conduct and resolve MAP cases through exchanges of position papers and on the basis of online and in-person meetings that are scheduled regularly and at least twice a year. The third peer noted that its competent authority continues to have a good working relationship with Germany’s competent authority, with regular communications taking place between both competent authority functions using various tools available, including protected e-mails and teleconferencing as well as in-person meetings. This peer noted that Germany’s competent authority to be professional and efficient to deal with and that communications take place in a timely manner.
100. The fourth peer reported that its experience with Germany’s competent authority is positive and that the communication and cooperation has been good. This peer considered it important to highlight that since 1 October 2018 the two competent authorities have held already one face to face meeting to discuss “other cases”, which was very productive and fruitful in its view. This peer highlighted that during this meeting, the two competent authorities exchanged positions with regard to many of their cases and closed some of them. This peer noted that based on this context, it is a pity that Germany’s competent authority has not responded to the proposal of its competent authority to hold another round of face-to-face meetings and shared its view that face to face meetings are very important and a good way to achieve the targeted timeframe of 24 months for the solution of MAPs. Germany responded to this input by also acknowledging the importance of face-to-face meetings for solving cases but noted that in its view, given the workload of the case handlers, telephone or video conferences have proven to be a way to solve cases in a timely as well as a more resource optimised way, especially, if the number of cases to be discussed is limited. The peer responded that it understands the position of Germany’s competent authority in relation to the workload and optimisation of resources but still noted its preference for face-to-face meetings with neighbouring countries owing to the low travel time and budget requirements, which in its view is a more efficient way to solve cases to avoid technical and security issues that come with virtual meetings.
101. The fifth peer reported that its MAP experience with Germany has been good and that the two competent authorities solved three MAP cases in the Review Period all of which were solved within the 24-month average timeframe, in an efficient and effective manner, with two of them being resolved by full agreement between the competent authorities and Germany providing unilateral relief for the other case. The sixth peer noted that the experience of its competent authority since 1 October 2018 with respect to the timely resolution of MAP cases with Germany’s competent authority has been very positive and that all dealings with Germany’s competent authority in resolving MAP cases have been professional, cooperative and efficient. This peer reported that its competent authority maintains regular contact with Germany’s competent authority, that in its view is proactive in seeking to resolve MAP cases in a timely manner and are available to discuss MAP cases both virtually and in-person in order to facilitate progression of MAP cases. This peer also noted that the two competent authorities engage in regular communication, always in a positive and co-operative way with respect to the resolution of MAP cases. The sixth peer reported based on Germany’s reporting that its view that most MAP cases were resolved in a timely manner, with cases that exceeded the average timeframe of 24 months being identified and addressed accordingly to maintain this average timeframe.
102. The seventh peer noted that from the years 2018 to 2022, the average time taken in its cases with Germany was less than 24 months, but that in 2023, the average time taken for attribution/allocation cases was more than 24 months due to the closure of cases started in 2016 and 2017, while the average time taken for other cases was less than 24 months. This peer further reported that in 2023, both competent authorities agreed to arrange meetings more frequently, which has been the case in 2024. The peer also noted that overall, its competent authority has a good relationship with Germany’s competent authority and taking into consideration that the average time taken to resolve the cases is usually less than 24 months, shared its view that the resources allocated to Germany’s competent authority function are adequate and well-prepared.
103. The eighth peer reported that its competent authority has a good working relationship with Germany’s competent authority and especially so in recent times as the two competent authorities have held one online and one live meeting recently. This peer further noted that the exchange of documents and positions with Germany has been proceeding in a timely and efficient manner and shared its view based on experience that Germany’s competent authority endeavours to resolve MAP cases and that adequate resources have been provided to the competent authority function. The ninth peer reported that Germany is monitoring its MAP caseload efficiently and that exchanges take place with its competent authority on a regular basis in order to discuss cases or define next steps and based on this, shared that its competent authority has a very good relationship with Germany’s competent authority. The tenth peer noted that Germany’s competent authority is remarkably cooperative, amicable and professional and shared its belief that Germany seeks the timely resolution of its MAP cases. The peer also highlighted that Germany is one of its peers with which it has a big caseload, but that the two competent authorities have always had a good and amiable collaboration and are able to discuss cases on a regular basis during competent authority meetings. The eleventh peer reported that Germany is an important MAP partner for it, both regarding attribution/allocation and other MAP cases and that there are currently 65 pending MAP cases with upwards of 200 cases being closed during the period under review. This peer noted that it has a good and pleasant working relationship with Germany and that Germany’s competent authority is principled, solution oriented and pragmatic, making the relationship between the competent authorities cooperative and constructive in seeking to timely resolve MAP cases, which results in most cases being resolved in good time. The peer shared its view that for attribution/allocation MAP cases, face-to-face meetings are very productive and are generally held twice a year, supplemented by teleconferences on individual cases, if required. The peer noted that for other MAP cases as well, the two competent authorities have a very good and productive working relationship ensuring that face to face and remote meetings are held on a regular basis.
104. The twelfth peer commented that its competent authority has a positive, transparent, and cooperative relationship with Germany’s competent authority, and that most cases are resolved within reasonable time frames, many in less than 24 months. In this regard, this peer shared its belief that the arbitration provisions of the tax treaty have the intended effect of bringing the two competent authorities together towards resolution prior to arbitration. However, the peer noted that even apart from arbitration, Germany’s competent authority is also committed to continuously improving the timeliness of the resolution of MAP cases in a principled manner. The peer reported that it welcomes the opportunity to continue to explore ways in which the two competent authorities can increase efficiencies and decrease the MAP case cycle time. In this regard, the peer commented that its competent authority continues to welcome the exchange of position papers, soon after a case is received, as a way to springboard into discussions on the case and narrow the scope of issues for which more extensive discussion is required. With regard to the adequacy of resources, this peer noted that it continues to see delays in the issuance of position papers by Germany’s competent authority.
105. The thirteenth peer reported that Germany`s competent authority is fully cooperative in resolving MAP cases, but that in some cases, initial position papers or scheduling may take longer than expected, which made it difficult for cases to be closed within the timeframe of 24 months. Germany responded to this input and noted that its competent authority is aware of the problem and that due to the workload of the responsible case handlers, it may be difficult to process cases instantaneously. The fourteenth peer commented that it has four active MAP cases with Germany that have not been solved yet, one of which is at an early stage and two of which are cases under the concerned tax treaty that have been pending for more than the prescribed 24-month period. This peer noted that replies from Germany’s competent authority take a long time, sometimes even more than a year. This peer further reported that one attribution/allocation case under the EU Arbitration Convention has already been pending for more than four years and that there were several times where the response from Germany’s competent authority took longer than six months. This peer noted that while this case has not been solved yet because of a substantive disagreement, it has not received a substantiated explanation from Germany as to why the positions of its competent authority are unsatisfactory. Accordingly, the peer reported that this case will be presented before an Advisory Commission under the EU Arbitration Convention. This peer also shared its belief that there could be several issues why the resolution of MAP cases takes a long period of time in Germany. This peer noted that since Germany has more than 1000 active MAP cases which is very high, although its competent authority function has 88 staff members, there is still a risk factor that some cases might not be evaluated as quickly as others. Germany responded to this input and noted that while it is aware of these delays, this was the situation before additional case handlers were employed. Germany further clarified that the reasons for the longer running case are complex and that its competent authority has substantiated the adjustment in the same thorough manner as it has with other treaty partners.
106. The fifteenth peer reported that in the experience of its competent authority, when MAP cases are initiated after Germany’s tax administration has made an adjustment, the first position paper provided by Germany`s competent authority usually upholds the view of Germany’s tax administration in its entirety. However, the peer clarified that despite this, during further negotiations, Germany`s competent authority has been open to hear substantiated arguments which may lead to the need to change this and is thus, cooperative in reaching a mutual agreement. In addition, this peer also reported that in its experience, once a proper contact is established in a MAP case with Germany`s competent authority and the designated person remains the same, the process of handling the case is fluent in terms of communication. The peer also clarified that in one case, the peer’s competent authority was informed about case handler changes in advance and separately, when there has been any delay, its competent authority has been informed of the reasons for the delay, which in most cases relates to Germany’s large caseload, and the time expected to progress. However, the peer noted that there have been delays in receiving position papers from Germany’s competent authority, with the first position paper being received for one case only after 22 months from the start date of the MAP case. The peer shared its view that this may be an obstacle to having thorough negotiations in MAP cases initiated under the EU Arbitration Convention, where the taxpayer may not consent to extend the case beyond two years. In addition, the peer shared that in one recent case filed in October 2023, its competent authority has experienced some troubles in establishing the right contact within Germany’s competent authority with the case handler only being identified ten months after receiving the MAP request, where the peer is unaware of the reasons for this delay. Germany responded to this input and noted that additional resources have been allocated since the delays indicated by the peer and that the delay arose in the case from October 2023 owing to an internal misunderstanding.
107. The sixteenth peer reported that Germany is one of its most important MAP partners, concerning both attribution/allocation and other MAP cases with numerous MAP requests being submitted and resolved annually. This peer commented that overall, its competent authority has a pleasant and constructive working relationship with Germany’s competent authority and that Germany’s competent authority is co-operative, clear in its argumentation and flexible and constructive in seeking to resolve MAP cases in a timely manner. The peer also noted that Germany’s competent authority can be easily approached by e-mail and via telephone, that communication is smooth and transparent and that communication about pending cases is frequent. In this regard, the peer reported that Germany’s competent authority is very responsive when it comes to prioritising urgent cases if the peer’s competent authority indicates that a case is urgent for whatever reason. Moreover, the peer added that its competent authority holds meetings with Germany’s competent authority once every eight months for attribution/allocation cases and that for other cases, one face-to-face meeting and one online meeting are usually conducted each year. However, the peer clarified that if needed, Germany’s competent authority is always willing to schedule a separate online meeting for a specific case or a specific issue and that all meetings are always conducted in a cordial atmosphere. Overall, this peer noted that it considers Germany’s competent authority to be solution-oriented and that this has resulted in a large number of cases being solved, most of them within the 24-month timeframe. The peer clarified that solutions are found during meetings, based on the exchange of position papers, or even without the exchange of position papers if appropriate and possible, which the peer appreciates as it increases efficiency in its view. The peer shared that it values this pragmatic approach and that MAP cases are generally resolved in a timely manner. However, the peer also noted that generally, Germany’s competent authority needs more than six months to send a position paper and that a position paper is occasionally not sent well in advance of a meeting (generally due to Germany’s competent authority waiting for information from either the competent state tax administration or the taxpayer), which makes it challenging to resolve MAP cases in a timely manner at times. In addition, the peer clarified that a timely resolution does not seem possible in one attribution/allocation case as the mandate of Germany’s competent authority is limited by a position taken by the competent state tax administration. Although the peer noted its understanding that there are internal processes to resolve differences between Germany’s competent authority and the competent state tax administration, it noted that this leads to substantial delays in resolving MAP cases.
108. Germany responded to this peer and noted that while it agrees with the peer that MAP cases are generally resolved in a timely manner, it is aware of the problem that position papers cannot be sent within an appropriate time period, mostly owing to missing information. Germany clarified that in the case mentioned by the peer, a timely solution is indeed difficult owing to a difference in position between Germany’s competent authority and the competent state tax administration and that it is continually working on the case to resolve it.
109. The seventeenth peer reported that since 1 October 2018, its competent authority has resolved seven other MAP cases with Germany’s competent authority, six of them within 24 months from the Start Date. This peer noted that the remaining MAP case took more than 24 months to conclude as the dispute pertained to very dated financial periods. The peer also noted that it has received five attribution/allocation MAP cases with Germany since 1 October 2018. The peer reported that for one case started in November 2020, Germany’s competent authority notified it of receipt in December 2020 and received a position paper from Germany’s competent authority in July 2021. The peer noted that there was a delay in resolving the case as it involved a foreign branch of the head office in the peer’s jurisdiction and that the case is now pending review by the peer and the third jurisdiction. The peer further reported that for another case which started in February 2022, Germany’s competent authority notified the peer’s competent authority of receipt in April 2022 and a position paper was received from Germany’s competent authority in March 2024, which the peer’s competent authority is now reviewing. The peer also noted for the remaining three cases that were started in October 2023, Germany’s competent authority notified the peer’s competent authority of receipt in January 2024 and that the peer was waiting for position papers from Germany’s competent authority. Germany responded to this input and noted that while it generally endeavours to resolve cases in a timely manner, it is aware of the problem that in some cases, position papers cannot be sent within an appropriate time period, mostly due to missing information.
110. The eighteenth peer reported that it only has one attribution/allocation MAP with Germany, where despite numerous requests to Germany’s competent authority for an update on the progress and status of the MAP, it has not responded. Germany responded to this peer and noted that due to unfortunate circumstances, the status requests were not forwarded to the responsible case handler and that in the meantime, a central mailbox has been set up and communicated to the peer’s competent authority to ensure that e-mails are received by the responsible case handler in the absence of the addressee. The peer subsequently confirmed that it has received a response from Germany’s competent authority.
111. The nineteenth peer reported that in general, MAP discussions with Germany’s competent authority have taken place in a constructive manner and that the two competent authorities have closed several MAP cases during the period under review. However, the peer pointed that it has faced difficulties in resolving cases through arbitration under the EU Arbitration Convention with Germany, based on its experience in one case where the two competent authorities did not find a solution within two years and arbitration was delayed since Germany had some issues in nominating an independent person of standing, which delayed the resolution of the case by several years. Germany responded to this input and noted that while in general, Germany tries to resolve arbitration processes in a timely manner, in this particular case, this was unfortunately not possible owing to unforeseeable circumstances.
112. The twentieth peer reported that for the period under review, both competent authorities have had bilateral meetings for both attribution/allocation as well as other cases as well as several follow-up calls in preparation for the next meeting, all of which were held in a friendly environment and noted that the relationship between both competent authorities is fluent. The peer noted that there have been delays in the resolution of attribution/allocation cases owing to the fact that Germany’s competent authority has to request information from the competent state tax administration. In addition, the peer reported that based on its limited experience in trilateral attribution/allocation cases with Germany, the exchange of information was not as fluent as it has been in other multilateral MAP cases. Germany responded to this input and noted that it is aware of the issues arising from the fact that consent of the competent state tax administration is required in MAP cases.
113. The twenty-first peer reported that its competent authority has a good working relationship with Germany’s competent authority with two physical meetings held per year and continuing e-mail communication. The peer noted that it especially appreciates the friendly atmosphere during meetings but also the competence, commitment and the hard work of Germany’s competent authority. The peer shared that the two competent authorities can solve most cases based on mutual understanding and in a timely manner. However, the peer also reported that for a limited number of cases relating to Germany’s adjustments based on estimation, its competent authority finds it difficult to find a resolution in a timely manner. The peer shared that in such cases Germany’s competent authority has explained that during tax audits, the taxpayers had not provided sufficient information, but adjustments were still performed in Germany based on estimation. The peer shared its understanding that Germany is of the view that the two-year period of the EU Arbitration Convention has not yet started due to missing information and that the lack of arbitration may delay the resolution of some MAP cases. The peer also observed that the two competent authorities sometimes have different interpretations on what information is needed for a case to be fully informed. The peer shared its view that while Germany has the burden of proof for adjustments made in Germany even if on estimation and while its competent authority tries to assist when possible during the MAP process, when information is missing at the audit stage, it would be more correct to use the Exchange of Information channel to get this information instead of requesting the information for from the entity in the peer’s jurisdiction, Germany responded to this input and noted that where taxpayers did not cooperate sufficiently during the audit, Germany’s approach is to request information at the start of the MAP and that it is hoping for a cooperative exchange between CAs in the MAP to gather all information necessary.
114. The twenty-second peer reported that its experience with Germany in resolving MAP cases has increased significantly since 1 October 2018 and that Germany is one of its most important MAP partners, both in terms of number and type of MAP cases. This peer noted that despite continuous efforts to resolve as many cases as possible, the two competent authorities have not yet managed to reduce the average time to be within the 24-month timeframe. The peer observed that while this may be due to the complexity of the cases or different views on matters of principle, in some cases, it was difficult to find a mutually satisfactory solution since Germany’s competent authority needs to discuss the case with the competent state tax administration before responding to proposals from its competent authority. The peer noted that nevertheless, the two competent authorities manage to organise several meetings each year, both in person and via video conference, and that direct contacts between case handlers of both jurisdictions have increased compared to a few years ago, which has allowed for a streamlining of processes. Overall, the peer shared that its experience is positive and that there is a continuous effort on both sides to improve the capacity to resolve MAPs within the 24-month timeframe. To conclude, the peer also noted in its view, Germany’s competent authority function is adequately resourced, funded and properly trained to handle MAP cases. Germany responded to this input and noted that it is aware of the issues arising from the fact that consent of the competent state tax administration is required in MAP cases.