78. During the previous peer reviews, all peers that provided input indicated having a good working relationship with Ireland’s competent authority with regard to MAP, some of them emphasising that Ireland’s competent authority is solution-oriented and referred to a cooperative working relationship.12
79. In this review period, eleven peers provided input on the handling and resolution of MAP cases with Ireland's competent authority. The first peer noted that the peer continues to have a good working relationship with Ireland’s competent authority, characterised by regular communication. The peer highlighted the professional and efficient approach of Ireland's competent authority and praised its helpfulness and cooperative attitude in the MAP resolution process. Overall, this peer noted that the updates provided by Ireland regarding the resolution of MAP cases is consistent with the peer's MAP experience with Ireland and the peer described Ireland’s competent authority as professional and efficient to deal with and as open to engagement, helpful and conscientious. The second peer reported that, since 1 September 2019, the peer's competent authority has further developed its relationship with Ireland’s competent authority, which the peer described as collaborative and pragmatic in searching for solutions to pending MAP cases. The peer emphasised that, despite the complexity of some MAP cases, Ireland's competent authority has always been open to solutions and committed to resolving cases. The peer concluded that the MAP relationship has steadily improved over time, becoming more than satisfactory and noted that in its perspective, Ireland’s competent authority is adequately resourced, trained and committed to solving all type of MAP cases.
80. The third peer explained that the peer recently had four attribution/allocation cases with Ireland, two of which were concluded, while two remain pending. The peer also noted that it has two pending other MAP cases. The peer reported that due to a limited caseload, meetings with Ireland's competent authority are typically held digitally. The peer emphasised that Ireland's competent authority demonstrates high expertise, cooperativeness, and responsiveness, generally replying promptly and politely to communications. This peer also noted that, during the Review Period, the peer’s competent authority resolved approximately 20 other MAP cases with Ireland’s competent authority. The peer acknowledged that position papers for these cases were provided on time, enabling timely resolutions. However, the peer highlighted that for transfer pricing cases, Ireland’s competent authority took relatively longer to provide position papers, which impacted the timeliness of resolutions. The peer welcomed the additional resources provided to Ireland’s competent authority and expressed optimism about their potential positive effects on future MAP timelines.
81. Ireland responded to this input and clarified that both competent authorities share a good and pleasant working relationship. Ireland noted that its competent authority considers the peer's competent authority to be engaging, professional, and cooperative to deal with. Regarding the two pending transfer pricing MAP cases, Ireland stated that its competent authority has communicated regularly with the peer’s competent authority about the status of these cases. Ireland clarified that for one of these cases, Ireland’s competent authority has engaged frequently with the peer’s competent authority, as the transaction that was the subject of the MAP was also the subject of an APA, which was concluded during 2024. For the remaining transfer pricing case, Ireland acknowledged that there has been a delay in responding to the peer's position paper. However, Ireland highlighted that its competent authority has maintained timely and frequent communication with the peer’s competent authority regarding this case, including holding discussions within two months of receiving the peer’s position paper. Ireland explained that additional information was required from the taxpayer, which was received five months after the position paper was provided by the peer’s competent authority, which in turn contributed to the delay in providing a response. Ireland assured that its competent authority is continuing to work on this case and expects to provide a response to the peer’s position paper shortly. In conclusion, Ireland expressed that it looks forward to continued cooperation with the peer to resolve both attribution/allocation and other MAP cases.
82. The peer acknowledges having frequent and pleasant communication with Ireland and appreciates Ireland’s explanation for the delays in some transfer pricing cases.
83. The fourth peer noted that in 2021 and 2023, the average time taken from the start date to the end date for attribution/allocation cases was more than 24 months, which it attributed to the closure of cases that had been initiated in 2017 and 2021, respectively. Overall, this peer reported that its competent authority has a good relationship with Ireland’s competent authority and that, based on discussions during meetings, it considers the resources allocated to Ireland’s MAP function adequate and well-prepared. The fifth peer reported that since 1 September 2019, the peer resolved one Post-2015 attribution/allocation MAP case with Ireland, which was completed within 24 months. The sixth peer only mentioned that the peer had one MAP case with Ireland, but it was referred to another division regarding the decision on whether a permanent establishment existed in the peer jurisdiction. Ireland responded to this input and clarified that this case has been referred to its Tax Treaties Branch within International Tax Division, which deals with all MAP cases regarding the determination on the existence of a permanent establishment and that the peer’s competent authority was provided with the contact details of the appropriate person in the department and that communication has taken place between both competent authorities with respect to this case.
84. The seventh peer noted that, since 1 September 2019, the number of attribution/allocation cases closed between the peer and Ireland is three, and only one of these cases was closed within the average timeframe of approximately 32 months, with the other two cases closed after approximately 46 and 52 months, respectively. The peer further stated that, although bilateral meetings on attribution/allocation cases occurred in a friendly environment and the relationship between both competent authorities is fluent, the peer experienced delays in scheduling bilateral meetings due to several requests for time extensions made by Ireland’s competent authority. Additionally, the peer reported that delays in receiving feedback on the peer's position papers from Ireland’s competent authority have presented an obstacle to resolving cases in a timely manner. In conclusion, this peer noted that, although Ireland’s competent authority is making efforts to improve its resources, the peer regrets that, in its opinion, these resources are still not sufficient to resolve MAP cases in a timely manner. The peer highlighted that the oldest post-2016 cases in the peer’s total inventory involve Ireland as a treaty partner.
85. Ireland responded to this input and clarified that its competent authority is committed to seeking to resolve MAP cases within an average timeframe of 24 months. Ireland noted, however, that this is dependent on various factors, such as the complexity of the case, the cooperation of the taxpayer, and the number of rounds of negotiations required. Ireland explained that the three cases closed during the review period involved complex issues and were discussed at four bilateral meetings between Ireland’s competent authority and the peer’s competent authority. Ireland noted that, during the Review Period, six bilateral meetings were held between its competent authority and the peer’s competent authority in a friendly and cooperative manner.
86. The eighth peer noted that the collaboration with Ireland’s competent authority is very good and productive. The peer reported that efforts are currently ongoing to resolve MAP cases in a timely manner.
87. The ninth peer reported very positive experiences with Ireland’s competent authority since 1 September 2019. The peer described dealings as professional, cooperative, and efficient; and noted that Ireland’s competent authority was proactive in seeking to resolve MAP cases in a timely manner and was available for virtual and in-person discussions to facilitate case progression. The peer also highlighted that Ireland’s competent authority was engaging and principled in resolving attribution/allocation cases. Furthermore, the peer noted that the two competent authorities received a MAP award for “Best Cooperation” in resolving MAP cases during 2021, reflecting their close and collaborative relationship.
88. The tenth peer stated that the peer's experience with Ireland’s competent authority has been positive and consistent with prior feedback. The peer emphasised that both competent authorities work together in a principled manner through regular communication to resolve MAP cases effectively and that in its view, Ireland has committed adequate resources to competent authority in its MAP cases with the peer. The last peer only stated that it has a good working relationship with Ireland’s competent authority.