This chapter covers Estonia’s innovation paradox and presents a cascading, scenario-based framework to address its fragmented public sector innovation capacity. It outlines three cumulative pathways – from low-cost baseline standards to a complete systemic overhaul – enabling the government to either fully commit to its ambitious growth targets or manage baseline risks effectively.
Strengthening the Innovative Capacity of the Public Sector of Estonia
8. The way forward
Copy link to 8. The way forwardAbstract
Estonia has reached a turning point in 2026. Long celebrated for its achievements in digital government, the nation has successfully built an image as a global innovation trailblazer. However, beneath this lies a classic innovation paradox. The rapid, project-led digitalisation of the past two decades, coupled with decentralised government, has institutionalised a three-speed administrative architecture, with some organisations exhibiting high innovation maturity while others are lagging behind (see Chapter 4). Meanwhile, a wave of service designers entering the government has led to extensive piloting and service-level improvements. Line ministries excel at deploying front-end solutions in isolation. However, the internal administrative architecture remains constrained by a bifurcated skills development system, an acute overreliance on EU project-based funding, and an efficiency drive through fiscal measures that inadvertently strips away the innovation slack required to execute systemic change. The system relies heavily on individuals who are intrinsically motivated to innovate, but their interests are difficult to align with the government’s strategic aims.
At the same time, the government has extremely ambitious goals connected to economic growth, technology adoption and security challenges that require innovation across the whole system. For example, with the launch of the Eesti.ai national programme, Estonia has set an ambitious macroeconomic target: boosting gross domestic product (GDP) by 25% within five years and 50% by 2035, primarily by doubling labour productivity through artificial intelligence. The fundamental issue, however, is that technological adoption depends on infrastructure, human capability and governance design.
Previous chapters presented the issues that need to be addressed if this is to be achieved. Acknowledging that the level of ambition may vary within the Government of Estonia, this chapter takes a scenario-based approach to implementing the recommendations. In March 2026, stakeholders in Estonia worked on three scenarios – 1) baseline/minimum viable scenario, 2) scalpel scenario and 3) systemic transformation scenario – and connected them to this report’s recommendations.
Adopting a scenario-based approach is prudent. It provides the Estonian Government with a nuanced view of the potential impacts and operational realities it must live with if current capacity issues are left unaddressed. These scenarios simultaneously raise awareness of the severe risks posed by a fragmented, piecemeal approach to reform. The scenarios are not a buffet-style checklist from which initiatives can be isolated; they offer a structured, cascading pathway in which each progressive model fully absorbs and builds on the foundations of the last. Scenario 1 establishes a passive baseline by deploying low-cost, uniform standards to protect intrinsically motivated innovators; Scenario 2 sharpens this focus by layering targeted, outcome-driven ‘scalpel’ interventions for specific ministries and middle management on top of those baseline tools; and Scenario 3 culminates in a comprehensive systemic overhaul that integrates all previous measures into a total re-engineering of the state’s financial, legal and human resources architecture to increase Estonia’s public sector innovation capacity and meet its national ambitions.
The structural challenges facing the public service are deeply interwoven. The scenarios represent different levels of institutional commitment to addressing this problem. Picking and choosing individual elements from Scenario 3 without a wholesale institutional commitment may result in a failed, fractured implementation.
Scenario 1: Optimising the baseline (intrinsic motivation and central standards)
Copy link to Scenario 1: Optimising the baseline (intrinsic motivation and central standards)This scenario adopts a non-interventionist, low-cost baseline approach. It accepts that different public-sector organisations operate at wildly varying levels of innovation maturity and chooses not to enforce structural change or high-cost vertical programmes. Instead, it aims to steady the ship by establishing common, lightweight tools and centre-driven standards that any self-motivated public servant or agency can pick up and utilise. The focus is protecting what innovation already exists, which is predominantly done by individual, intrinsically motivated innovators.
The recommendations in this scenario passively enable and reduce friction for innovation (see Table 8.1). For example, rather than overhauling the state budget, this approach introduces minor protective micro-mechanisms, such as preserving innovation resource buffers within the existing fiscal rules. This funding buffer unlocks the potential of other toolkits in this scenario, such as the guidelines for ethical/trustworthy experimentation decision gates and the mandate for demand-driven innovation planning in annual strategies. No centralised advisory service is funded under Scenario 1, so the framework relies heavily on self-service resources. These include the central repository of innovative procurement templates, comprehensive training modules on outcome-based descriptions, and simple toolkits to institutionalise diverse viewpoints and cross-functional workshops.
The knowledge management and motivational frameworks in this scenario protect existing talent without institutional overhead. An annual "reality-check" pulse survey template provides a zero-programme way for organisations to identify culture gaps. Meanwhile, tools like the safe space media guide shield early-stage experiments from premature external criticism, maintaining the psychological safety of individual champions. This baseline scenario achieves impact by making organic, bottom-up innovation slightly safer and structurally easier to execute across a fragmented administrative landscape.
Table 8.1. OECD recommendations connected to scenario 1
Copy link to Table 8.1. OECD recommendations connected to scenario 1Summarising the recommendations presented in chapters 1-7.
|
Topic |
Chapter |
Recommendation |
Actor |
Possible timeframe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Funding |
2 |
Incorporate innovation resource buffers into existing budgeting frameworks (including the Zero-Based Budgeting project) to preserve institutional capacity for creative problem-solving |
MoF |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Strengthen existing innovation planning in annual public sector strategies to screen upcoming tenders for modernisation potential. |
MoF |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Develop comprehensive training on innovation procurement and the use of functional and outcome-based descriptions. |
MoF, EIS |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Create a central repository of innovative procurement templates and proven legal frameworks drawing on established EU frameworks. |
MoF, EIS |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Encourage public sector organisations to buy previously developed market solutions systematically to scale up completed prototypes and pilots. |
MoF, EIS, MEAC |
Ongoing / Continuous |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Review and rebalance intellectual property (IP) clauses in public procurement, moving away from rigid, one-sided IP ownership models. |
MEAC, MoF, MJDA, Patent Office |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Legislative flexibility and experimentation |
2 |
Develop guidelines for governance decision gates for trustworthy experimentation to define when a pilot project can proceed to full implementation. |
GO, MJDA |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Inclusive innovation and policy design |
2 |
Establish a systematic framework for citizen and stakeholder engagement in innovation processes, actively leveraging Estonia’s OGP Action Plan 2025–2029. |
GO, All line ministries |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Inclusive innovation and policy design |
2 |
Leverage insights from participation for cross-departmental insights and learning across different innovation portfolios using a shared portfolio management tool. |
GO |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Innovation theatre |
3 |
Conduct reality-check staff surveys: Provide organisations with a template to run short annual pulse surveys on innovation culture to track gaps between leader and staff perceptions (especially on psychological safety and support). Results should inform leadership action, create accountability, and be collected centrally to identify lagging capacity. |
GO |
Short-term to Ongoing (Annual) |
|
Motivation |
3 |
Foster intrinsic motivation: Work with organisations that demonstrated high intrinsic motivation to preserve it. Accompanying measures to create protected time for innovation work and reinforce it as part of public sector values should be built into executive and mid-level managers' training and competency frameworks. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (12–18 months) |
|
Motivation |
3 |
Use visible recognition, such as innovation awards: Existing innovation awards should be continued, and their profile should be raised to reinforce that innovation is part of public sector values and that the drive to make things better is cherished. |
GO |
Ongoing (Annual) |
|
Inclusion |
3 |
Institutionalise the search for different viewpoints: Encourage organisations to use simple practices (diverse review panels, cross-functional workshops, user engagement) and develop guidance (Design Toolkits, Human-Centred Design guides) to promote diverse thinking in innovation delivery. |
GO |
Short-term (6 months) |
|
Organisational level supports |
4 |
Develop a targeted support programme for different organisational clusters including innovation sprints scoped to support the government’s priorities. |
GO |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Support innovation networks and communities of practice. Sponsor cross-government peer networks and communities of practice for priority innovation capabilities, such as experimentation, human-centred design, behavioural insights, strategic foresight, evaluation and AI in public services. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Embedding skills in management |
5 |
Embed innovation in the Government Office’s annual management quality studies to maintain an overview of innovation capacity development. |
GO |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Quality and relevance of learning |
5 |
Nudge public sector organisations towards participating in better, evidence-informed innovation training that uses practice-based methods. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Quality and relevance of learning |
5 |
Base training on needs assessments conducted by teams before commissioning training so learning responds to their specific capability gaps and operating constraints. The connection between need and training content improves learning outcomes. |
Organisations and teams |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Quality and relevance of learning |
5 |
Set guidance to avoid theoretical or one-size-fits-all training, and to prefer training that is practice-based and work-related, focusing on tasks, cases and projects learners are working on. |
Open / Systemic and GO, MoF for their trainings |
Continuous / Ongoing |
|
Quality and relevance of learning |
5 |
Encourage learners to define in advance how they will apply training content to their work. |
Teams |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Strengthen cross-government learning and diffusion by sponsoring structured opportunities like networks and communities of practice. |
GO, MoF |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Invest in foundational public sector skills (project management, standard procurement, communication) and contextualise them alongside innovation assessments. |
GO, MoF, MJDA |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Embed evidence-informed content and learning formats in central learning strategy, redirecting training allocations toward task-grounded formats. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Project design and governance |
6 |
Strongly encourage evaluation planning and coordination earlier in the kick-off phase of an innovation project to protect baseline data and allow rigorous design. |
GO |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Portfolio-level value for money (short-term) |
6 |
Prioritise incremental improvements to evaluation data by stage-tagging projects by maturity stage at award and reporting periods. |
GO (and all public organisations) |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Portfolio-level value for money (short-term) |
6 |
Introduce a standard post-mortem template for terminated projects to convert closures into structured learning |
GO |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
Source: OECD.
Limitations and risks
The primary limitation of this baseline approach is the emergence of a restrictive innovation ceiling coupled with a widening performance gap across the public sector. Because this scenario relies entirely on voluntary adoption, there’s a risk of self-selection bias and widening disparity between organisations: high-maturity organisations with intrinsically motivated staff will readily utilise new and existing tools, while low-maturity, resource-constrained agencies may not.
Furthermore, the model is not scalable. Micro-funding mechanisms and self-service templates are excellent for generating localised prototypes, but the absence of centralised scaling pathways or dedicated funding pipelines means that successful pilots will stall or vanish entirely when their individual champions depart. Finally, this passive framework risks promoting procedural compliance over genuine innovation. Relying heavily on standardised checklists and manuals can easily turn creative problem-solving into a bureaucratic box-ticking exercise, where agencies focus on strictly following the ethical decision gates or procurement templates to ensure formal compliance rather than engaging in transformative thinking.
Expected impacts
Despite these limitations, this approach delivers a low-cost mechanism for safeguarding Estonia’s existing innovation capacity. It preserves motivated, frontline innovators, who might otherwise face burnout, by providing them with psychological safety, tools such as the media guide, and modest budgetary buffers. This scenario enables, but doesn’t ensure, system-wide diffusion of better innovation practices. The rollout of centre-of-government templates, outcome-based descriptions, and human-centred design toolkits ensures that even the smallest, most isolated agencies gain immediate, free access to legally sound, EU-aligned procurement and experimentation frameworks, systematically elevating baseline capabilities across the state.
Scenario 2: Scalpel approach (targeted interventions and strategic outcomes)
Copy link to <strong>Scenario 2: Scalpel approach (targeted interventions and strategic outcomes)</strong>Scenario 2 builds on passive enablement with targeted, "scalpel-like" interventions. Uneven capability across line ministries cannot be solved by self-service toolkits alone. So, this scenario bridges the gap by coordinating specific, high-priority national outcomes: productivity and economic growth, crisis resilience, and administrative burden reduction. It focuses on specific target groups – particularly middle managers and specific line ministries – using discrete governance and funding mechanisms (see connected recommendations in Table 8.2).
Scenario 2 forms a virtuous cycle of accountability, execution capability, and project lifecycles. At the top level, the scenario binds public sector innovation goals to the State Plan 2028–2034, creating accountability metrics for senior civil servants. To ensure these senior leaders can deliver, the central Government Office Strategy Unit is given expanded coordinating functions. This central hub then deploys a dedicated taskforce of innovation leads directly into ministries to unblock regulatory bottlenecks, supported by a dedicated policy innovation programme for line ministries. This provides the institutional resources needed to run targeted initiatives, like reforming the Co-Creation Development Accelerator and other initiatives specifically around the three core national outcomes.
The operational recommendations in this scenario are coupled to ensure projects do not stall after initial testing. Extending the public sector innovation fund beyond the testing phase is explicitly linked to the requirement that organisations institutionalise their innovation portfolio management. This ensures that unused project funds are protected by multi-year budgetary flexibility (time premiums) and managed effectively.
In this scenario, training needs to be targeted: middle managers are prioritised as a distinct group to coach teams, and the training must be paired with project-based coaching on live policy problems. To prevent "innovation theatre", organisations need to conduct targeted stock-takes where leader and staff perceptions clash. These interventions are evaluated not by simple box-ticking, but through sophisticated ROI and impact-tracking frameworks, ensuring these “scalpel” measures yield verifiable improvements in public value.
Table 8.2. OECD recommendations connected to scenario 2
Copy link to Table 8.2. OECD recommendations connected to scenario 2Summarising the recommendations presented in chapters 1-7.
|
Topic |
Chapter |
Recommendation |
Target actor |
Possible timeframe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Strategic vision and planning |
1 |
Embed the unified national vision’s targets directly into the State Plan 2028–2034. Bind specific public sector innovation goals to this national planning document as a delivery mechanism and establish clear accountability metrics for senior civil servants. |
GO, MoF |
Short-term (2026 – 2027, during plan drafting) |
|
Governance and coordination |
1 |
Expand the coordinating functions of the central Government Office team. Provide the Strategy Unit and its innovation area with greater authority to align cross-departmental activities, reduce duplication, and scale local initiatives nationally. |
GO (Strategy Unit) |
Short-term (2027) |
|
Governance and coordination |
1 |
Deploy a dedicated taskforce of innovation leads across all ministries. Form a team structurally distinct from existing strategy heads and bottom-up innovation cells to focus entirely on execution, portfolio management, and unblocking cross-departmental regulatory bottlenecks. |
GO |
Medium-term (2027) |
|
Governance and coordination |
1 |
Develop a dedicated programme for line ministries to do policy innovation. Provide stable funding support to integrate anticipatory policy frameworks and experimentation, allowing ministries to design long-term initiatives without relying on short-term grants. |
GO, MJDA |
Medium-term (2027 – 2028) |
|
Knowledge management and monitoring |
1 |
Develop an internal platform to share and retain innovation knowledge. Compel public sector organisations to document successful pilot methodologies and innovation cases before key personnel depart to transform individual insights into permanent institutional capacity. |
GO |
Medium-term (2027 – 2028) |
|
Funding |
2 |
Extend the public sector innovation fund beyond the initial testing phase and formulate explicit scaling pathways for initial ideas. |
GO |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Introduce multi-year budgetary flexibility (time premiums) for innovation procurement to allow unused funds to carry forward. |
MoF |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Establish an ROI and impact-tracking framework and public communication loop for innovation procurement to measure socio-economic impacts over a rolling 3-to-5-year window. |
MEAC, MoF |
Medium-term (1–3 years) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Improve contracting authorities’ practices regarding the use of quality criteria, such as mandating a minimum 20% to 30% quality weighting. |
MoF |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Establish dedicated support mechanisms for innovation procurement to provide specialised legal and technical advisory services. |
MoF, EIS |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Engage the National Audit Office and internal auditors early in the procurement design phases to create a shared understanding of experimental risks. |
MoF |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Legislative flexibility and experimentation |
2 |
Require legislative drafting teams to justify technology-specific references in new legislation to avoid embedding specific technologies directly into statutory texts. Instead, default to outcome-based obligations, performance standards and functional requirements. |
MJDA |
Ongoing / Continuous |
|
Legislative flexibility and experimentation |
2 |
Set up a taskforce to develop a legal experimentation framework for the public sector to institutionalise safe experimentation and temporary regulatory exemptions. |
GO, MJDA |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Inclusive innovation and policy design |
2 |
Launch a central advisory, training, and funding service for stakeholder engagement to equip senior management with practical risk-management tools. |
GO |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Inclusive innovation and policy design |
2 |
Reform the Co-Creation Development Accelerator around government priorities (economic growth, crisis resilience, and reduction of administrative burden). |
GO |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Inclusive innovation and policy design |
2 |
Develop standardised evaluation frameworks and metrics that move beyond quantitative engagement tallies to track qualitative indicators. |
GO |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Innovation theatre |
3 |
Target ‘innovation theatre’ organisations: Support an innovation stock-take in innovation theatre organisations where leadership and staff perceptions differ. Staff should brief senior leadership on actual innovation and blockers, and leadership should use this to raise awareness and remove barriers. GO should support determining where theatre is substantive vs apparent. Baseline figures should be deployed in monitoring. |
GO |
Short-term (3–6 months) |
|
Motivation |
3 |
Invest in collaboration infrastructure: Work with digital teams to understand and remove barriers to collaboration across organisations, potentially tied to internal innovation case or consultation platforms. Publish a high-level collaboration guide to help organisations action these changes. |
GO, IT houses |
Medium-term (6–12 months) |
|
Motivation |
3 |
Conduct systemic ‘sludge’ audits: Regularly identify and remove internal administrative frictions that slow or discourage innovation, focusing on approvals, reporting requirements, handovers, and other routine processes. |
GO |
Medium-term (Recurring every 12 months) |
|
Psychological safety |
3 |
Strengthen psychological safety through blameless post-mortems: Create a template process for analysing unsuccessful experiments as learning outcomes by examining systems, decisions, and assumptions rather than individual fault. Disseminate via training and project management and collate results bi-annually in a “Failure Report”. |
GO |
Short-term (3–6 months) for template; Bi-annual for report |
|
Psychological safety |
3 |
Foster psychological safety through training: Develop a training course that equips top public sector leaders and middle-level managers to create psychologically safe environments. Include the development of safe-to-fail signals to help staff apply innovation skills in practice. |
GO |
Medium-term (12 months) |
|
Collaboration |
3 |
Map and market the support ecosystem: Expand the current innovation methods and resources website to create a dynamic, single-entry 'Innovation Navigator' portal for funding, legal, technical, and methodological support. Public sector organisations should actively promote it. |
GO, all public sector organisations |
Short-to-medium term (6–9 months) |
|
Collaboration |
3 |
Refine Estonia’s participation in international exchange programmes: Tailor participation in inter-governmental forums and exchange programmes with peer countries (e.g., Finland, Singapore) to better promote innovation, such as focusing selection criteria on emerging risks/anticipatory governance or using it as a reward. |
GO |
Short-term / Next cycle |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Develop a guide for public sector organisations for innovation portfolio management outlining clear lifecycles for state-funded innovation. |
GO, MoF |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Integrate portfolio reporting into the state budget strategy process to ensure funding for scaling experiments is tied to portfolio performance metrics. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Create shared structures and resources for practice-based innovation learning. Establish system-level support that helps organisations develop innovation skills through live work, not just classroom training. This could include a centrally funded pool of facilitators, coaches and methodological experts who support teams working on real policy or service challenges. |
MoF, GO |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Embedding skills in management |
5 |
Embed innovation skills in workforce management and renew associated competency frameworks across recruitment, development and career management. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Embedding skills in management |
5 |
Target middle managers as a priority group to equip them with the innovation skills to coach teams and remove implementation barriers. |
MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Embedding Skills in Management |
5 |
Use performance management to signal that innovation matters by developing performance review templates that recognise experimentation and learning. |
GO, MoF |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Quality and relevance of learning |
5 |
Pair training with opportunities to apply skills, linking training to real work and protected time for experimentation. |
Open / Systemic and GO and MoF for their training |
Continuous / Ongoing |
|
Quality and relevance of learning |
5 |
Assess the long-term knowledge and behavioural impact of training through frameworks such as the Kirkpatrick Model to scale up or discontinue programmes. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Create practical learning-by-doing opportunities, shifting the training budget from seminar-based learning to project-based coaching on live policy problems. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Integrate innovation skills with foundational public sector capability building. Ensure that strategies to build innovation skills are designed alongside capability building in project management, procurement, communication, evaluation and other core public sector skills. Innovation projects often fail when teams lack these enabling capabilities. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Strengthen inclusion in innovation processes through mixed-seniority project teams, structured idea calls, and diverse solution design participation. |
GO |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
System-wide guidelines and lifecycles |
6 |
Disseminate guidelines on what types of evaluations are appropriate to answer questions of ROI, impact, scaling and ongoing investment across different lifecycle points. |
GO, MoF |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
System-wide guidelines and lifecycles |
6 |
Encourage innovators to limit theory and process-based evaluations to early-stage questions, and push for greater use of experimental, quasi-experimental, CBA and VfM evaluations to demonstrate impact. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Academic integration and science advice |
6 |
Evolve ministerial science advisors into the public sector innovation ecosystem, redefining their job profiles to include innovation competencies and onboarding them into agile cross-ministerial teams. |
GO, MER, ERC |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Academic integration and science advice |
6 |
Formalise a workflow where science advisors act as the principal conduit to academia, translating scientific publications into experimental design and helping establish rigorous KPIs. |
GO, MER, ERC |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
Source: OECD.
Limitations and risks
The targeted nature of the scalpel approach introduces a risk of administrative siloing. Banding resources and political will exclusively around three pillars – productivity, resilience and administrative burden reduction – risks starving other vital, non-aligned public service sectors of modernisation funding. This scenario also places an immense execution burden on middle managers and ministry-level innovation leads. If these target groups are not granted sufficient political backing or statutory authority to override entrenched bureaucratic inertia, they will rapidly become overstretched bottlenecks rather than effective enablers of change. There is also structural friction with central oversight mechanisms. Granting specific line ministries individual policy innovation budgets and multi-year budgetary flexibility to carry forward unused funds may face sharp resistance, particularly if these flexible timelines clash with traditional annual performance budgeting, reporting structures or the organisations’ short-term goals.
Expected impacts
The main contribution of this scenario is to the government’s macroeconomic targets through concentrated state intervention. By focusing political and financial resources on economic growth, crisis resilience and burden reduction, the state secures highly visible, measurable wins that directly stimulate the domestic technology and GovTech ecosystems through reformed procurement practices (e.g. connected to the development of the drone industry and AI solutions). Operationally, this strategy transitions from isolated project silos to integrated portfolio governance. Implementing formal portfolio management guides alongside multi-year budgetary flexibility ensures that individual ministerial projects are evaluated as an interconnected pipeline. This systematically eliminates duplicate pilots across different ministries, establishes clear scaling pathways and ensures that targeted public investments yield verifiable improvements in public value.
Scenario 3: Systemic overhaul and AI realisation
Copy link to Scenario 3: Systemic overhaul and AI realisationScenario 3 represents a total institutional reconfiguration. True innovation capacity cannot be sustained through isolated projects or individual goodwill; it requires a systemic overhaul across procurement, funding, and civil service skills, tied to an unwavering commitment to realise Estonia’s national AI ambitions. Under this scenario, innovation becomes a core component of the state’s administrative plumbing.
The recommendations in Scenario 3 are profoundly interdependent (see Table 8.3); one cannot succeed without the others or without investments from Scenarios 1 and 2. The foundation rests on establishing a unified national vision with a connected roadmap, structurally funded by a complete overhaul of the institutional innovation portfolio governance architecture and a reformed performance budgeting system. This systemic shift moves funding completely away from volatile, short-term international grants. Instead, it establishes annual targets to transition successful innovations into the main state budget, backed by dedicated central block funding generated from organisational savings.
To match this financial risk-taking, the scenario institutes systemic safety nets: it eliminates financial penalties for experimental failures and sets up a centralised Innovation Procurement Risk Insurance Framework alongside an innovative procurement premium top-up fund.
This structural safety enables the government’s aggressive AI and data goals. Implementing cross-agency regulatory frameworks for secondary data processing and building stronger data infrastructure make ‘augmented administration’ challenges and live AI trials legally and technically viable. Because AI projects require intensive, continuous maintenance, this scenario introduces a revised funding model that mandates lifecycle maintenance and parallel operational funding within the rolling state budget.
Human capital is overhauled at a matching scale through a government-wide rolling national human resources strategy. This involves a complete rewrite of competency frameworks to incentivise "changemaker" behaviours, the launch of a senior innovation management programme, and future-readiness masterclasses for top executives. Meanwhile, systemic gaps are closed by broadening training funding to lower administrative tiers. Finally, this scenario firmly bridges the academic disconnect. By integrating ministerial science advisors into agile cross-ministerial teams and ring-fencing financial envelopes for independent, rigorous academic ex-post evaluations, Estonia transitions into a highly scientific, data-driven, and structurally resilient digital state.
Table 8.3. OECD recommendations connected to scenario 3
Copy link to Table 8.3. OECD recommendations connected to scenario 3Summarising the recommendations presented in chapters 1-7.
|
Topic |
Chapter |
Recommendation |
Target actor |
Possible timeframe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Strategic vision and planning |
1 |
Establish unified national public governance priorities (e.g., under the Organisation of Research, Development & Innovation Act) and change management guidelines to anchor public sector innovation (Government Office). Consolidate separate sector-specific strategies into a single coherent policy and unified theory of change to replace fragmented approaches. |
GO |
Short-term (Late 2026 – 2027) |
|
Knowledge management and monitoring |
1 |
Design a bi-annual monitoring framework to measure public sector innovation capacity. Capture the development of innovation capacity across the public sector to systematically evaluate the value for money of investments and ongoing activities (e.g. every three years). |
GO |
Medium-term (Commencing 2027, recurring bi-annually) |
|
Financial sustainability |
1 |
Set an annual target to move successful innovations to the state budget. Shift core modernisation initiatives away from temporary international grants and fund them through the main state budget on a rolling basis, backed by clear ROI and lifecycle cost analyses. Light-touch templates should cover most projects, while deeper benchmarking and monitoring should apply only to high-cost or strategic innovations. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (Annually, commencing 2028) |
|
Regional and local governance |
1 |
Launch a process to co-design a public sector innovation programme for municipalities. Build dedicated structures and pool technical resources to support local authorities across all 78 municipalities using experience-based learning, small testing grants, and larger collaborative project grants. |
MRAA, MoF, GO, external partners |
Short-to-medium term (Launch in 2027) |
|
Regional and local governance |
1 |
Establish a shared regional innovation platform to reduce duplication and incentivise and commercialise local innovation. Develop digital operational frameworks on unified infrastructure to lower procurement costs while allowing municipalities to capture economic benefits and rewards when their innovations scale. |
MRAA |
Medium-term (2027 – 2028) |
|
Funding |
2 |
Take steps towards dedicated central budget lines (block funding) for public sector innovation by creating organisational innovation funds from public sector organisations’ annual savings. |
MoF |
Medium-term (1–3 years) |
|
Funding |
2 |
Eliminate strict financial penalties for experimental project failures and move towards portfolio evaluation to tolerate calculated risks in pilot programmes. |
MoF |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Funding |
2 |
Create seed grants for anticipatory innovation specifically for foresight and early-stage experimentation. |
GO |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Funding |
2 |
Reform the performance budgeting system to value long-term capability building and include innovation as a specific topic in budget planning documents. |
MoF |
Long-term (3+ years) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Establish a centralised Innovation Procurement Risk Insurance Framework to act as an internal insurance mechanism covering financial risks. |
MEAC, MoF |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Create an innovative procurement premium top-up fund to allow public sector organisations to bid for funds covering risk premiums. |
MEAC, MoF |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Procurement |
2 |
Develop an AI-driven market consultation platform to accelerate supplier engagement and streamline prior market consultations. |
MEAC, SSSC |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Legislative flexibility and experimentation |
2 |
Develop standardised risk management and data privacy controls for experiments (including AI experiments) to protect citizen data during live trials. |
MJDA |
Short-term (6–12 months) |
|
Inclusive innovation and policy design |
2 |
Reinforce quality control via spot checks and committee oversight, conducting random spot checks on 10% of high-impact reforms. |
GO |
Medium-term (1–2 years) |
|
Motivation |
3 |
Create autonomy for innovation: Revise innovation funding and resource allocation formulae to assess the autonomy of recipient teams, prioritising resources for teams with the autonomy to use them well. Promote the revised scoring and use it as an input into the proposed bi-annual monitoring framework. |
GO |
Short-to-Medium term (6 months) |
|
Psychological safety |
3 |
Foster psychological safety in anticipatory governance: Work with decision-makers who explore radical policy alternatives to build processes which allow them to do so without reputational risk, including scenario testing, foresight exercises, and structured discussion of uncertainty. |
GO |
Medium-term (6–12 months) |
|
Collaboration |
3 |
Bridge the academic disconnect: Strengthen mechanisms connecting government innovation work to academic research and existing evidence-informed policymaking measures. Line ministries should give scientific advisors a clear brokerage role: translating research needs into policy questions, connecting teams with relevant researchers and checking that innovation projects draw on existing evidence before commissioning new work. Understand structural drivers of under-collaboration and structure engagement for horizon scanning. |
GO, MER, MEAC, ERC |
Medium-to-Long term (12–18 months) |
|
Collaboration |
3 |
Incentivise ‘changemaker’ behaviours: Revise competency frameworks on the executive, middle-manager, and professional levels so that innovation-related behaviours (collaborating externally, involving citizens, working across boundaries) are recognised in performance discussions. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-to-Long term (12–18 months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Co-design a uniform, nationwide rolling human resources strategy to align and unify fragmented, agency-specific upskilling efforts across all public service tiers. |
MoF, GO |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Overhaul institutional innovation portfolio governance architecture to transition public sector innovation into a resilient, state-funded administrative pipeline. |
GO, MoF |
Long-term (18+ months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Create an advisory panel for innovation portfolio management to act as internal consultants and train ministry leads in portfolio thinking. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Create a Senior Innovation Management Programme for top executives to train senior executives to manage innovation. |
GO (with potential extension to mid-level managers with MoF) |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Systems-level changes |
5 |
Broaden central funding for training beyond senior levels to rectify the chronic underfinancing of capacity building in lower administrative tiers. |
MoF |
Long-term (18+ months) |
|
Embedding skills in management |
5 |
Strengthen leadership capability in Future-Readiness Masterclasses focused on emerging technology governance and long-term risk management. |
GO (working with top-level civil service training providers) |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Quality and relevance of learning |
5 |
Release a centre-of-government Needs Assessment based on the OECD's skills gap analysis to help organisations align strategically. |
GO, MoF |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Give staff time and permission to use new skills by providing protected time, clear mandates, and support for experimentation. |
Managers |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Organisational conditions |
5 |
Build targeted capability in high-demand skills areas, especially AI literacy, ranging from basic awareness to advanced technical governance. |
GO |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
System-wide guidelines and lifecycles |
6 |
Make impact evaluation a formal requirement for relevant innovation projects, establishing an expectation that innovations progressing beyond initial testing must demonstrate impact. |
GO, MoF |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
System-wide guidelines and lifecycles |
6 |
Publish guidance describing why and how innovators should quantify the benefit of their AI investments in terms of return on investment (ROI) to justify scale-up. |
GO |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Enabling infrastructure |
6 |
Help build stronger data infrastructure for evaluation by supporting standardised data collection, reporting requirements and comparisons across initiatives, balanced with a "safe-to-fail" approach. This will ensure impact evaluations can access timely, high‑quality data. |
GO, MER |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Academic integration and science advice |
6 |
Introduce an agile ex-post evaluation methodology specifically tailored for pilot projects and innovative public service rollouts, supported by a dedicated financial envelope ring-fenced for independent academic evaluations 12 to 24 months post-implementation. |
MJDA, MoF |
Long-term (18+ months) |
|
Data governance and legal frameworks |
7 |
Establish an explicit, cross-agency regulatory framework for secondary data processing to alleviate the over-interpretation of data protection laws and issue binding guidance that clarifies compliance parameters for cross-agency service chains. |
MJDA, GO |
Long-term (18+ months) |
|
Skills and capability building (AI) |
7 |
Launch a targeted strategic management programme for middle-tier civil servants focused on algorithmic procurement, process streamlining, and automation risk management to bridge the gap between leadership goals and frontline ambitions. |
GO |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Skills and capability building (AI) |
7 |
Create role-specific playbooks across all administrative tiers on AI adoption and experimentation to address asymmetric adoption by providing uniform guidelines and immediate use cases for professional staff. |
MJDA |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Skills and capability building (AI) |
7 |
Implement cross-generational reverse mentoring schemes to standardise AI literacy across the public service by pairing junior "digital natives" with senior personnel to build institutional confidence and transfer tech competencies. |
MJDA, all ministries |
Short-term (1–6 months) |
|
Process automation |
7 |
Introduce service-wide "augmented administration" challenges to automate low-complexity, high-volume tasks by systematically auditing workflows to reduce administrative burdens and secure visible, quick wins. |
MJDA, GO, all ministries |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Financial sustainability |
7 |
Restructure the funding model for AI public services to include mandated lifecycle maintenance costs and parallel operational funding within the rolling state budget to support long-term maintenance and dual-running of systems for 6 to 24 months. |
MoF, GO, MJDA |
Long-term (18+ months) |
|
Institutional governance |
7 |
Expand core staffing capacity at central levels to secure strategic continuity and execution leadership by creating dedicated personnel lines for multi-disciplinary central AI teams to mitigate "key person risk". |
GO, MJDA |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
Accountability and ROI |
7 |
Develop robust evaluation frameworks and practical guidance to demonstrate ROI on AI investments that measure human-rights impact, accessibility, interoperability, and verifiable public value. |
MoF, GO, MJDA |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
|
AI collaboration |
7 |
Establish structured forms of collaboration and joint proof-of-concept pipelines for university-public sector AI co-design. Establishing clear, bilateral counterparts provides a human interface capable of proactively resolving intellectual property, data access, and procurement barriers before they stall development. |
GO, MJDA, MER |
Medium-term (6–18 months) |
Source: OECD.
Limitations and risks
The sheer scale of a total systemic overhaul carries a significant risk of severe short-term fiscal and political strain. This path demands a significant up-front resource injection to fund structural safety nets like the Innovation Procurement Failure Fund, block funding mechanisms, and the parallel dual-running of AI and legacy infrastructure. In a climate of fiscal tightening, dedicating substantial portions of the main state budget to high-risk, long-term experimental portfolios carries immense political exposure. Furthermore, accelerating secondary data processing and automated service chains increases the hazard of asymmetric AI disruption and ethical slippage. Rushing these systems into live citizen trials without uniform readiness risks triggering algorithmic issues, data privacy breaches, and severe public pushback if automated infrastructure fails. Finally, the simultaneous rewrite of HR strategies, competency frameworks, and evaluation mandates across all administrative tiers can easily trigger systemic exhaustion and institutional resistance, causing civil servants to push back against what could be perceived as a relentless, top-down disruption of established administrative norms.
Expected impacts
When successfully executed, the impacts of this scenario are transformative, firmly positioning Estonia as a global frontier digital state and a world leader in data-driven governance. The deep integration of artificial intelligence into frontline workflows, supported by automated challenge frameworks, systematically eradicates institutional "sludge" and permanently reduces routine administrative overhead. Beyond technological advancement, this scenario builds a fully capitalised, risk-tolerant public sector ecosystem. By removing financial penalties for experimental failures and institutionalising state-funded scaling pipelines within the main budget strategy, the civil service shifts from a culture of strict risk avoidance to one of calculated, data-driven experimentation. This re-engineering establishes a highly resilient administrative pipeline capable of dynamically adapting to future geopolitical, economic, and technological shocks.