This chapter examines innovation skills and training in the Estonian public sector. It presents the OECD public sector innovation skills framework for leaders and practitioners and uses it to assess current capability. The chapter finds that leaders report moderate to high confidence in innovation skills, but that their demand for these skills exceeds the confidence of more junior staff and their teams in applying them. It also finds that public servants see practical and work-based learning as more relevant than formal training for developing innovation capabilities. The chapter recommends developing an integrated human resource development plan across different levels, embedding innovation skills in public service management, improving the quality and relevance of training, and creating organisational conditions that help staff use new skills in their daily work.
Strengthening the Innovative Capacity of the Public Sector of Estonia
5. Skills and training
Copy link to 5. Skills and trainingAbstract
Innovation skills sit within the broader OECD Innovative Capacity Framework (Kaur et al., 2022[1]), a systemic model covering the individual, organisational and public-sector-system levels. The Innovative Capacity Framework describes the preconditions for public sector innovation as a system-level property. Innovation skills are one individual-level component of that wider framework. The OECD developed its Public Sector Innovation Skills Model in 2017 (OECD, 2017[2]). Starting in 2024, the OECD’s Observatory of Public Sector Innovation (OPSI), together with an international Working Group on Skills and Applied Capabilities for Public Sector Innovation, updated and broadened the framework (see Box 5.1 below). This work sits within broader institutional guidance under the OECD Declaration on Public Service Innovation, which provides a legal instrument for member countries to improve the organisation and management of their public services and make them more agile and responsive (OECD, 2019[3]).
Public sector innovation skills framework
Copy link to Public sector innovation skills frameworkThe forthcoming new OECD public sector innovation skills model was developed using a mixed-methods approach that combined a literature review of more than 70 papers with a data-driven analysis of job postings and training modules worldwide, including Estonia's public sector (Hanson and Collao, 2025[4]). This foundational framework was then quantitatively tested against more than 1,000 successful innovation case studies using natural language processing, before being refined and validated through structured workshops with senior government officials from 18 countries (OECD, Forthcoming[5]). The update reflects changes in public sector innovation, particularly on skills related to digital transformation, data-driven approaches, and the adoption of AI in the public sector. While the updated model is still forthcoming, it is already informing country reviews across the Governance Directorate at the OECD (OECD, 2023[6]; OECD, 2024[7]; OECD, 2024[7]) and it has informed this Innovative Capacity Assessment of Estonia.
The revised framework treats innovation as an applied competency. It recognises that governments need both skilled practitioners who design and deliver innovation projects as well as skilled leaders and managers who create the conditions in which these projects can succeed (see Figure 5.1).
Figure 5.1. Innovation practitioner and public manager competency frameworks (forthcoming)
Copy link to Figure 5.1. Innovation practitioner and public manager competency frameworks (forthcoming)
Source: OECD.
For innovation managers and leaders, the framework evaluates the enabling conditions for innovation. It identifies the skills and competencies that leaders need to allocate time, resources and legitimacy to innovation. These are:
Enabling conditions. The organisational practices, resources and signals that give teams the space to explore, experiment and develop new ideas. Leaders create these conditions by protecting time, supporting collaboration and encouraging curiosity.
Knowledge integration. The ability to bring together diverse data, evidence, expertise and perspectives to inform public decisions. Leaders use this capability to make innovation more robust, relevant and forward-looking.
Public impact. The alignment of innovation work with public value, strategic goals and measurable outcomes for citizens and society. Leaders support public impact by managing balanced portfolios and by defining success in terms of benefits, not only outputs.
Innovation orchestration. The coordination of people, processes and resources to design, test, implement and scale innovation. Leaders practise orchestration by structuring innovation processes, securing resources, supporting learning from failure and navigating institutional constraints.
Trust-based leadership. The use of reliable, transparent and supportive leadership behaviours to create confidence under uncertainty. Trust-based leaders encourage constructive dissent, protect teams that take responsible risks and create the psychological safety needed for innovation.
For innovation practitioners, the framework identifies the skills and competencies that describe how practitioners make innovation happen in daily public sector work. These skills are:
Adaptive and future-ready mindset. The ability to frame problems, anticipate change and adapt methods to complex public sector contexts. Practitioners use this competency to learn continuously, manage uncertainty and take responsible risks that improve public outcomes.
Insight-driven action. The ability to use data, evidence, research and expert knowledge to guide innovation work. Practitioners use this competency to make better decisions, test assumptions and improve policies or services through evaluation and learning.
People-powered innovation. The ability to design, test and scale solutions with the people who use or are affected by them. Practitioners use this competency to apply human-centred design, co-creation, behavioural insights and responsible technology, including AI, to create public value.
Changemakers collaboration. The ability to convene people, build partnerships and support collective problem-solving across organisational boundaries. Practitioners use this competency to consult stakeholders, engage citizens and create shared ownership of innovation outcomes.
The framework also applies AI literacy as a cross-cutting capability. It adapts existing AI literacy models to the public sector context and distinguishes the needs of practitioners and leaders. Practitioners need to assess AI outputs, use AI tools responsibly, maintain human oversight and co-design AI-enabled services with users. Leaders need to ask critical questions, identify strategic opportunities, establish governance frameworks and ensure that AI serves public value.
Innovation skills development in Estonia
Copy link to Innovation skills development in EstoniaResponsibility for public sector upskilling is divided between the Government Office Top Civil Service Excellence Centre and the Ministry of Finance. The Top Civil Service Excellence Centre supports the selection and development of Estonia’s top civil servants (state secretaries, heads of agencies, etc.). It develops principles and methods for recruiting and selecting top civil servants, administers the selection process for top public sector positions, organises competency assessments, evaluates development needs, provides guidance and advisory support for top civil servant development and designs and implements development programmes and training initiatives. The Ministry of Finance is responsible for supporting the development of public administration below the top civil servant level (Ministry of Finance, 2026[8]). The Ministry of Finance balances Estonia's decentralised public management model with central coordination to ensure competency standards remain unified across ministries and state agencies.
The specific mandates of the ministry are connected to central training management (developing, commissioning, and financing targeted development programmes to build transversal capabilities that individual agencies cannot efficiently provide on their own). These are funnelled into high-priority public sector cadres: new civil servants (foundational onboarding and public ethics training), mid-level managers and specialists (e.g., strategic capability building, policy design) and top civil servants in coordination with the Government Office. The Ministry is responsible for strategic competency mapping in the civil service and updating central civil service competency models, which are evolving away from rigid checklists, towards new skills and capability requirements such as leadership and innovation. The Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs is responsible for leading the development of data and technological literacy. This work is supported by a dedicated e-learning platform, the Digital State Academy, which provides courses on AI, data literacy, and related topics. The Ministry also leads the Digital Top development programme, which is designed to strengthen technology leadership capabilities among senior public sector officials in Estonia.
Competency frameworks
The Estonian public administration has a central competency framework for the top civil service and another for mid-level managers, but no single government-wide competency framework for general public servants. The current Estonian Competency Framework for Top Civil Service was adopted in 2023 (Republic of Estonia, 2023[9]) and it is built on three pillars: leading the organisation, leading people and leading relations. Leaders are directly tasked with building structures that encourage modern working methods and actively favour modernisation and efficiency that considers technological developments. Prior to the 2023 update, the competency model was more results- and action-oriented, with a checklist style, structured around six core requirements – one of which on driving innovation in an inspiring way – for top civil servants rather than the three current thematic pillars. While the pre-2023 model mentioned innovation directly, the current model integrated it more deeply – instead of making innovation a separate task on a manager's to-do list, it embedded it right into standard daily operations (e.g., explicitly demanding that standard workplace organisation and strategy design must favour tech adoption and modern efficiency).
The Estonian mid-level manager competency model (renewed in 2022) focuses on empathetic, future-oriented leadership (Raun et al., 2022[10]). It condenses management into three main pillars similar to the top civil servant’s competency model with emphasis on strategic thinking, process and result management, team leadership and motivation, talent development, cooperation and network management, self-management and resilience. The model also does not define innovation as a separate task but instead weaves it throughout. Managers are expected to foster a safe culture where teams feel secure to test new ideas, challenge old routines, and actively use modern digital technologies to improve public value (Ministry of Finance, 2026[11]).
Below the leadership levels, the system relies on a decentralised organisational approach. The Ministry of Finance coordinates public administration and personnel policy, while individual organisations or sectors may develop their own frameworks or training arrangements. Interviewees indicated that this creates uneven practice across government because lower-level skills development depends heavily on organisational resources and leadership commitment.
Two-track skill development
Expert interviews show that the Top Civil Service Excellence Centre has had significantly more resources for its activities in recent years than the central training offer at the Ministry of Finance. This funding allowed Estonia's highest-ranking public officials to receive targeted training, including innovation initiatives like the Spinnaker programme (see Box 5.1). Similarly, the leadership pipeline is developed through a targeted training programme – the Newton Programme (Box 5.2). However, building innovative capacity at the top executive level does not naturally cascade down into organisational practice.
Box 5.1. Spinnaker Programme
Copy link to Box 5.1. Spinnaker ProgrammeThe Spinnaker programme (Spinnakeri programm) is a highly tailored leadership development initiative designed explicitly for Estonia's top-level civil service. Commissioned by the Top Civil Service Excellence Centre within the Government Office, the programme represents a strategic shift toward modern, relational, and future-proof public sector governance. Participants develop innovative solutions to policy problems, with the resulting innovation projects eligible to apply for financing from the Public Sector Innovation Fund.
Named metaphorically after the large, triangular sail used to propel racing boats at high speeds when running with the wind, the programme is built to help Estonia’s highest-ranking public officials navigate structural volatility, rapid technological shifts, and complex crisis management. It provides a highly sophisticated, multi-layered learning environment that combines intensive strategic modules with personalized executive support. Rather than relying on traditional, passive lectures, Spinnaker focuses heavily on interactive peer-to-peer learning, individual executive coaching, and professional mentoring.
Practically, the programme is built around three core operational pillars:
Strategic masterclasses and systemic simulation: Participants engage in multi-day modules led by academic and industry experts, focusing on practical applications of strategic foresight, crisis simulation, and technological integration (such as data governance and AI risk management). These sessions use real-world state data and ongoing policy dilemmas as live case studies.
Structured peer-to-peer problem solving: The programme utilises action learning sets – facilitated peer groups where executives bring active, unresolved institutional bottlenecks. Colleagues use a structured questioning methodology to help the owner reframe the problem and develop alternative intervention strategies, deliberately breaking down ministerial silos.
Individualised executive coaching and 360-degree feedback: The curriculum is anchored by a baseline and mid-point 360-degree competency assessment. This data directly informs individual coaching tracks, where executives work with certified coaches to align their day-to-day leadership style with the framework's benchmarks, specifically targeting emotional intelligence, resilience, and navigating institutional friction.
Rather than delivering generic management theory, the programme functions as an operational sandbox. It forces top leaders to align their individual agency strategies with broader state-level objectives while practicing the relational skills required to negotiate cross-ministerial initiatives.
Source: OECD based on expert interviews and the overview of the Spinnaker programme.
Current initiatives at the top-level focus heavily on personal mindsets, such as curiosity and resilience, but fail to address the institutional architecture required to manage innovation. Training an executive to accept risk does not change underlying regulations, rigid procurement laws, or budgetary lines that penalise experimental failure (see further in Chapter 2). Organisations also lack systematic innovation portfolio management.
The current Spinnaker approach treats innovation as a skill or attitude rather than a pipeline. To foster innovation systematically, organisations need concrete processes to source ideas, fund small-scale trials, evaluate outcomes, and scale successful experiments. Spinnaker trains leaders to appreciate innovation. However, it does not provide standard organisational frameworks to manage a balanced portfolio of incremental and radical projects. OECD data presented below highlights this gap.
Box 5.2. The Newton Programme
Copy link to Box 5.2. The Newton ProgrammeEstonia's Newton Programme is a leadership initiative operated by the Government Office (Riigikantselei) through its Centre of Excellence in Public Service Leadership. First launched in 2008, the programme cultivates and develops future top civil servants.
The programme identifies mid-level managers with the potential to advance and prepares them for senior positions across the administration. It sets targets for at least 75% of participants to apply for a senior executive position within two years of completion and at least 50% to be selected. By 2023, some 126 participants had completed the programme, with close to 60% experiencing a positive career transition thereafter.
The 2016 cohort comprised four modules totalling 160 hours held across Tallinn, Helsinki and London. The material helped participants interpret long-term global trends and apply them within the public sector's legal, resourcing and management context.
The programme is financed by institutions and Government Office alongside European Union structural funds. Successive versions of the programme partnered with domestic and international bodies including Praxis, the Estonian Design Centre, Policy Lab (United Kingdom), Sitra (Finland) and the Ragnar Nurkse School of Innovation and Governance.
Newton is complemented by the Leadership Talent Program, established in 2012, which recruits early-career professionals into fixed-term posts alongside secretaries-general and their deputies. The two initiatives form a pipeline through which Estonia develops future leadership capacity.
Stakeholders noted that lower administrative levels below mid-level managers, which the Ministry of Finance coordinates centrally, face chronic underfinancing. Public organisations must commission their own training on an ad hoc basis using internal funds. This funding asymmetry has fragmented broader training. Specific, siloed target groups now drive specialised, advanced competencies. For instance, the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs (in accordance with the Government of the Republic Act) provides AI literacy training. Meanwhile, the Estonian Research Council is procuring specialised training for strategic foresight and anticipation, targeting ministerial science advisors first. These specialised offers are good in their own right and target the right gaps, but the Estonian Government overall lacks a uniform, nationwide human resource development plan to strategically align these disparate upskilling efforts across all public service tiers (see for example the approach in Finland in Box 5.3).
Box 5.3. Central Government Human Resources Strategy of Finland 2030
Copy link to Box 5.3. Central Government Human Resources Strategy of Finland 2030The Finnish Ministry of Finance adopted the current central government human resources strategy, titled Working for Finland, to guide public administration up to 2030. It functions through a rolling implementation framework across three distinct action periods, starting with the 2024–2025 cycle, followed by 2026–2027, and concluding in 2028–2030. This structured setup allows individual ministries and operating units to systematically adapt the overarching national guidelines to their specific operational contexts and staffing requirements.
The strategy entails a comprehensive framework designed to modernise the state workforce and modernise traditional public governance. Architecturally, it rests on three core pillars: cultivating a responsible operating culture rooted in shared civil service values; establishing people-oriented leadership that directly drives organizational productivity and effectiveness; and maintaining a renewing human resources policy capable of enabling operational success. Operationally, the strategy shifts state employment towards multi-location work, cross-departmental collaboration, and flexible employment terms tailored to individual life circumstances, ensuring the state remains an attractive and competitive employer.
The connection to public sector innovation is foundational, as the strategy frames continuous renewal and adaptation as prerequisites for modern public value creation. It actively supports innovation by transforming how public servants work and learn together, positioning human resource management as a strategic partner to leadership rather than a bureaucratic function. By embracing digital transformation and implementing shared government work environments, the strategy creates the structural conditions necessary for experimenting with new administrative practices. Ultimately, it links innovation directly to public sector capability, ensuring that individual civil servants possess the strategic vocabulary, structural mandate, and agility required to solve complex societal challenges and deliver sustainable public services.
Source: (Ministry of Finance, 2024[13]).
Differentiated training for senior leaders, mid-level managers and practitioners can be appropriate, but it needs to match where innovation work is actually designed, managed and delivered. Estonia’s focus on top-level development does not reflect how innovation is rarely executed at the elite executive level alone; mid-level managers and cross-functional teams often drive innovation. Concentrating resources on the top tier while underfunding lower levels creates a severe implementation gap. Top leaders return to their agencies with a better overall picture of the role of innovation, but putting innovation into practice runs into constraints such as iterative prototyping or human-centred design. Because Estonia lacks a uniform, government-wide human resource development plan, performance metrics, hiring practices, and promotion pathways within individual ministries do not align with innovation competencies. Estonia’s performance system lacks an integrated approach to innovation that coordinates strategic vision, recruitment, performance management, incentives and frameworks.
Innovation skills
Copy link to Innovation skillsEstonia’s public sector has a strong innovation skills base but confidence is uneven. The survey shows a gap between the importance leaders put on innovation skills and staff confidence applying those same skills.
Leaders increasingly expect staff to apply innovation skills, such as experimentation, stakeholder engagement, evidence use, digital technology and AI. However, staff confidence does not consistently match these expectations. The lowest-confidence areas include AI literacy, public impact, portfolio management, strategic foresight, behavioural insights and co-design with users. There’s also a need to build innovation skills alongside non-innovation skills to ensure innovation projects do not founder for lack of core public sector capabilities.
Public servants across roles see practical learning as the most relevant way to build innovation skills. Average results across groups show that project learning, digital and e-government training, peer networks and method workshops are seen as more relevant than formal academic programmes. Estonia can therefore strengthen innovation skills by expanding work-based learning, while also collecting more systematic evidence on the training currently available beyond the top civil service.
Leadership innovation skills
The survey received 55 responses from public sector executives and 155 from middle managers who answered for themselves. Overall, public sector leaders in Estonia expressed moderate confidence in their innovation skills (see Figure 5.1 for skills definitions). Leaders who had previously participated in innovation (see Chapter 1) reported higher confidence than those who had not.
Figure 5.2. Leaders’ AI literacy
Copy link to Figure 5.2. Leaders’ AI literacy
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.3. Leaders’ enabling conditions
Copy link to Figure 5.3. Leaders’ enabling conditions
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.4. Leaders’ innovation orchestration
Copy link to Figure 5.4. Leaders’ innovation orchestration
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.5. Leaders’ knowledge integration
Copy link to Figure 5.5. Leaders’ knowledge integration
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.6. Leaders ‘public impact orientation
Copy link to Figure 5.6. Leaders ‘public impact orientation
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.7. Leaders’ trust-based leadership
Copy link to Figure 5.7. Leaders’ trust-based leadership
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Practitioner innovation skills
The survey received data from 391 professionals and 149 administrative staff. Practitioners expressed moderate confidence in their innovation skills. Practitioners who had participated in innovation reported higher confidence across all areas than those who hadn’t.
Figure 5.8. Practitioners’ AI literacy
Copy link to Figure 5.8. Practitioners’ AI literacy
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.9. Practitioners’ adaptive and future readiness
Copy link to Figure 5.9. Practitioners’ adaptive and future readiness
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.10. Practitioners’ changemaker collaboration
Copy link to Figure 5.10. Practitioners’ changemaker collaboration
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.11. Practitioners’ insight-driven action
Copy link to Figure 5.11. Practitioners’ insight-driven action
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Figure 5.12. Practitioners’ people-powered innovation
Copy link to Figure 5.12. Practitioners’ people-powered innovation
Source: OECD based on the Public Sector Innovation Capacity Survey (2026).
Importance and confidence applying innovation skills
Leaders across the Estonian public sector increasingly expect public servants to contribute to innovation as part of their core role. The Innovative Capacity Assessment found that senior managers place high importance on skills related to applied innovation, digital technology (especially AI) and evidence-informed decision making. These priorities reflect the growing importance of leaders and practitioners delivering programmes, adapting ways of working, experimenting responsibly, adopting new tools and ensuring that new technologies create public value.
While innovation skills are increasingly important, not all staff have confidence applying them. This is true of both leaders and practitioners. Confidence reflects whether they feel able to apply innovation skills in the public sector. It matters because innovation depends on staff feeling capable and being authorised to use new methods, take responsible risks and adapt when established routines are insufficient.
A central finding of the Innovative Capacity Assessment is a persistent gap between the importance leaders place on innovation skills and the confidence of the staff applying them. This gap is seen among leaders and practitioners. Leadership consistently rates innovation‑related skills as more important than staff rate their own confidence in applying those same skills in practice. The result is a form of latent capacity: innovation is expected, but officials often lack the confidence, permission or organisational support to meet those expectations consistently.
Project learning was seen to be the most relevant type of training
Survey and interview evidence suggests that Estonia primarily uses classroom-based training and structured development programmes to build innovation skills. For example, the Ministry of Finance commissions training for new civil servants (e.g., onboarding and ethics), as well as for managers and specialists (e.g., policy design, strategic capability building and digital and data skills), while the Government Office’s Top Civil Service Excellence Centre provides targeted development programmes, competency assessments and leadership training for senior officials.
Public servants may prefer a greater range of learning modalities, not just classroom and structured programmes of learning. Survey participants indicated that the most relevant training was reported to be Project Learning, Digital / eGovernment, Peer Networks, and Method Workshops. These training types tend to be grounded in the worker’s actual work. This aligns with evidence suggesting that training linked directly to the worker’s job tasks tends to be more effective, see below (Lacerenza et al., 2017[14]). All roles within the Estonia public sector – executive, middle manager, professional and administrative – reported that formal training was the least relevant to them. Innovation Masters scored only 2.7 to 2.9 on a 5-point scale, depending on role, and Certificate/Diploma only 2.5 to 2.8; these courses may be seen as unsuited to public sector worker’s learning needs. There was broad consensus among all roles what types of innovation training are most relevant. Executives consistently rated most types of training as more relevant than did other roles. The gap was largest for Conferences, where executives often present the innovations, their organisation has developed. However, executives reported the same rank ordering of training type relevance – project learning, digital and eGovernment, peer networks, and method workshop were their top four most relevant types of training.
Systemic vulnerabilities and skills gaps
There is a stark asymmetry between the strategic intent of the Estonian public sector and its operational reality. Survey data suggest that leaders’ expectations of innovation consistently outpace staff confidence in their ability to innovate. This gap stems directly from a two-track model of skills development. The Top Civil Service Excellence Centre has successfully instilled an innovation vocabulary among top-level executives through the Spinnaker programme and other initiatives. By contrast, the Ministry of Finance manages lower administrative tiers under conditions of chronic underfunding. Top leaders return to their organisations from the Top Civil Service Excellence Centre with advanced strategic concepts. However, mid-level managers, professional staff and administrative staff, who turn strategies into programmes, often lack the budget, time and mandate to implement these concepts in practice:
Public sector leaders express low-to-moderate confidence in public impact orientation and project portfolio management. This represents the sharpest capability gap between innovators and non-innovators. Estonia still tends to treat innovation as an individual attribute or mindset rather than as an institutional pipeline. Training an executive to tolerate risk does not change rigid procurement rules, inflexible budget lines or traditional performance indicators that penalise experimental failure (Chapter 2). There is no institutional architecture to source, fund, trial and scale small experiments. Individual innovation competencies remain decoupled from the broader civil service lifecycle. Heads of organisations can help mitigate these issues internally if they have the right innovation management skills.
A capability gap exists between self-identified innovators and non-innovators across every assessed macro-competency. This divide suggests that innovative capacity is concentrated in siloed pockets. Because innovation competencies are not integrated into standard public service lifecycles, traditional compliance metrics continue to shape how effort is judged, rather than rewarding agile public value creation. This reinforces a closed loop in which confident individuals continue to innovate while the broader workforce feels structurally locked out.
In the survey, AI literacy emerged as the lowest-scoring competency area for both leaders and practitioners. Leaders expressed the least confidence in overseeing AI governance and managing public engagement on AI. Practitioners similarly struggled with co-designing AI with users. These are serious gaps given the government’s ambitious goals for AI (see Chapter 7). Under the knowledge integration pillar, futures thinking was the lowest-rated skill among surveyed leaders. This deficit contributes to the low levels of anticipatory innovation reported across the system (Chapter 1).
Qualitative evidence also suggests that a bottleneck to public sector innovation is weakness in foundational public sector skills. Stakeholders reported that public servants are less able to do innovation when foundational project management, communication and procurement capabilities are under-developed. These skills represent “O-Ring” failure points – named for the malfunctioning O-Rings that led to the failure of the Challenger space shuttle – where advanced systems are compromised by a failure of one basic but essential component (Kremer, 1993[15]). Therefore, strategies to build innovation skills must integrate them alongside non-innovation capability building to ensure innovation projects do not founder for lack of necessary skills.
A clear consensus emerged across all administrative roles that formal academic training is the least relevant method for developing innovation capabilities. Public servants overwhelmingly prioritise practice-based, work-grounded learning. They favour project learning, digital government modules and peer networks. Classroom-based training is often necessary, such as raising awareness of legislative changes, but is less suited to developing applied innovation skills. Despite this clear demand for connected forms of training, the wider environment remains highly fragmented. In the absence of a uniform nationwide human resource development plan, individual agencies continue to procure ad hoc, siloed upskilling initiatives.
Recommendations
Copy link to RecommendationsEstonia can strengthen innovative capacity by building innovation skills across the civil service. The Assessment shows a consistent gap between leaders’ expectations and staff confidence. The chapter also shows that demand for innovation skills is rising because organisations face more complex problems, faster digital change and stronger pressure to adapt. Estonia therefore needs a coherent approach that builds skills, improves training quality and creates conditions for staff to use new skills in their daily work.
Systems-level changes
Co-design an integrated national human resources strategy. The Ministry of Finance and the Government Office should co-author a comprehensive, nationwide rolling HR strategy to align and unify the currently fragmented, agency-specific upskilling efforts across all public service tiers and break down traditional institutional silos. The Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs should also be involved as the authority responsible for developing digital skills and AI-related competencies. The strategy should establish training and upskilling needs across all levels (senior executives, middle managers and practitioners) and plan for organisational development. The national HR strategy should position innovation as a central element to help strengthen public servants’ links to innovation. It should also create incentives for organisations to build, attract and retain innovation skills, for example by linking innovation capabilities to recruitment profiles, career development, mobility opportunities and recognition systems.
Overhaul institutional innovation portfolio governance architecture. The Government Office should implement standardised organisational frameworks and portfolio management systems to transition public sector innovation from an ad hoc, individual mindset into a resilient, state-funded administrative pipeline for sourcing, trialling, evaluating, and scaling experiments. This requires capacity building that accompanies the ability of public organisations to develop innovation portfolio thinking. To operationalise this, the Government Office should together with the Ministry of Finance:
Develop a guide for public sector organisations for innovation portfolio management outlining clear lifecycles for state-funded innovation, establishing explicit criteria for sourcing ideas, trialling prototypes, evaluating societal impact, and scaling successful pilots across ministries.
Integrate portfolio reporting into the state budget strategy process (see also recommendations in Chapter 2). This ensures that funding for scaling experiments is tied to portfolio performance metrics rather than rigid, annual departmental allocations.
Create a Senior Innovation Management Programme for top executives. The Government Office should create a six-month programme to train senior executives to manage innovation within their organisations. It should cover leadership innovation skills: enabling conditions, knowledge integration, public impact, innovation orchestration, trust-based leadership and AI literacy. The Government Office should assess impact after 6 and 12 months based on changes in management practice, pilot quality and scaling decisions. If possible, access to this training should also be extended to mid-level managers.
Broaden central funding for training beyond senior levels. Innovation-related learning opportunities should reach professional, administrative and frontline staff as well as senior leaders. The Ministry of Finance must secure funding to rectify the chronic underfinancing of capacity building in lower administrative tiers, ensuring that practice-based training offers are adapted to the distinct daily operational responsibilities of non-executive staff. Training offers should reflect different roles and responsibilities so that staff at each level can build the skills most relevant to their work.
Create shared structures and resources for practice-based innovation learning. The Ministry of Finance together with the Government Office should establish system-level support that helps organisations develop innovation skills through live work, not just classroom training. This could include a centrally funded pool of facilitators, coaches and methodological experts who support teams working on real policy or service challenges; small grants for project-based learning pilots; reusable toolkits for experimentation, co-design, evaluation and digital government methods; and access to shared learning spaces where teams can test approaches across organisational boundaries.
Support innovation networks and communities of practice. The Ministry of Finance together with the Government Office should sponsor cross-government peer networks and communities of practice for priority innovation capabilities, such as experimentation, human-centred design, behavioural insights, strategic foresight, evaluation and AI in public services. These networks should have clear purposes, light-touch facilitation, regular meetings and links to live projects. They should help public servants exchange methods, troubleshoot common barriers, share examples of what worked and what did not, and diffuse practice-based learning beyond individual organisations.
Embed innovation skills in public service management
Embed innovation skills in workforce management and renew the associated competency frameworks. The Government Office and the Ministry of Finance should jointly define innovation competencies in a shared competency framework (or aligned modules) and use that framework across recruitment, development and career management. This will require a review of existing competency modules for senior executives and mid-level managers. This would help create a common language for the skills that public servants need and support more consistent investment in those skills across government. Furthermore, innovation should also be embedded in the Government Office’s annual management quality studies to provide an overview of the development of innovation capacity across organisations.
Strengthen leadership capability through future-readiness masterclasses. Senior leaders need stronger capability in areas where demand is rising, especially strategic foresight, digital technology and AI, and evidence-informed decision making. The Government Office should work with top-level civil service training providers to develop masterclasses focused on emerging technology governance and long-term risk management.
Target middle managers as a priority group. Middle managers play a decisive role in whether staff can apply innovation skills in practice. The Ministry of Finance should work with public service training providers to equip middle managers with the innovation skills needed to coach teams, support experimentation and remove barriers to implementation.
Use performance management to signal that innovation matters. The Government Office and the Ministry of Finance should develop performance review templates to guide management-level discussions and evaluation systems that recognise experimentation, learning, collaboration and improvement. This would help translate leadership expectations into everyday management practice and strengthen demand for innovation skills across organisations.
Create organisational conditions for innovation learning
Create practical learning-by-doing opportunities. Government Office together with the Ministry of Finance should explore ways to complement formal training with project-based learning, coaching and problem-solving on live policy or service challenges. Staff prioritise practical training over formal education, so shift the training budget from seminar-based learning to project-based coaching, where teams learn innovation methodologies while working on live policy problems. This would help staff build confidence in applied innovation and make training more relevant to their daily work.
Integrate innovation skills with foundational public sector capability building. Government Office together with the Ministry of Finance should ensure that strategies to build innovation skills are designed alongside capability building in project management, procurement, communication, evaluation and other core public sector skills. Innovation projects often fail when teams lack these enabling capabilities, even when they have access to innovation methods. Estonia should therefore assess innovation skills and foundational skills together, identify where non-innovation skills create bottlenecks for innovation (including AI literacy together with the Ministry of Justice and Digital Affairs), and address these gaps through integrated training and workforce development plans.
Strengthen cross-government learning and diffusion. Government Office together with the Ministry of Finance should sponsor structured opportunities for organisations to share methods, lessons and examples from their innovation, such as networks and communities of practice. Research from health administrations have suggested that communities of practice are most effective when they have a clear scope, are facilitated with a light-touch, are held regularly and work towards clearly stated objectives (Li et al., 2009[16]; Ranmuthugala et al., 2011[17]).
Build targeted capability in high-demand skills areas, especially AI. There is strong and growing demand for skills in strategic foresight, digital technology and AI, stakeholder engagement and evidence-informed decision making. AI literacy was a particular gap for both leaders and non-technical staff. The Government Office should encourage organisations to develop these skills through their learning strategies, ranging from basic awareness and use for all staff to advanced technical governance for programme managers.
Strengthen inclusion in innovation processes. Government Office should create mechanisms that give junior staff and under-represented groups a clearer role in shaping innovation work. This could include mixed-seniority project teams, structured idea calls and facilitation methods that ensure different voices are heard in problem definition and solution design.
Embed evidence-informed content and learning formats in central learning strategy. Government Office together with the Ministry of Finance should recommend that central training allocations and learning strategy be redirected away from isolated, one-off formal seminars towards practical, task-grounded formats. They should prioritise project-based learning, digital/eGovernment solutions, method workshops, and peer networks, which survey data suggests are most relevant to public servants.
Improve the quality and relevance of innovation learning
Government Office together with the Ministry of Finance should nudge public sector organisations towards participating in better, evidence-informed innovation training. Evidence on training effectiveness suggests that learning is stronger when organisations identify real skill needs, use practice-based methods, spread learning over time, and support staff to apply new skills on the job (OECD, 2026[18]). These principles should inform innovation learning across the public service.
Use practice-based and work-related learning methods. Training should focus on concrete tasks, real cases and direct application. Participants should practise skills, receive feedback and reflect on results. This approach is more likely to build confidence than training that focuses mainly on abstract concepts or passive listening.
Deliver learning over time. Avoid relying only on one-off seminars. Multi-session formats, coaching and repeated opportunities to practise can help staff consolidate learning and apply it in their work.
Plan for transfer from training to work. Teams should define in advance how participants will use new skills in their role, what support they will receive from managers and what barriers may prevent application. This would help convert learning into practice.
Use workplace learning to reinforce formal training. After-action reviews, peer exchange, communities of practice and team debriefings can help staff retain and refine new skills. Research suggests that this type of structured, informal learning can improve team performance (Keiser and Arthur, 2021[19]; Tannenbaum and Cerasoli, 2012[20]).
Pair training with opportunities to apply skills. Skills weaken when staff do not use them. Confidence grows through practice, feedback and repetition. Link training to real work, protected time for experimentation and clear managerial support for new approaches.
Assess the impact of training. Effective programmes measure impact to understand whether training has, or has not, built participants’ capability. Participant engagement and satisfaction are useful intermediary measures, but civil servants will benefit most from measuring the long-term knowledge and behavioural impact of training through frameworks such as the Kirkpatrick Model (Kirkpatrick, 1959[21]). Public administrations should use this data to scale-up effective training programmes and improve or discontinue ineffective innovation training.
References
[12] Government Office of Estonia (2026), Newton program, https://www.riigikantselei.ee/en/supporting-government-and-prime-minister/top-civil-servants/newton-program (accessed on 9 July 2026).
[4] Hanson, A. and J. Collao (2025), Toward a new approach to innovation skills and applied capabilities, https://oecd-opsi.org/blog/toward-a-new-approach-to-innovation-skills-and-applied-capabilities/.
[1] Kaur, M. et al. (2022), “Innovative capacity of governments: A systemic framework”, OECD Working Papers on Public Governance, No. 51, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/52389006-en.
[19] Keiser, N. and W. Arthur (2021), “A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of the after-action review (or debrief) and factors that influence its effectiveness”, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 106/7, pp. 1007-1032, https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000821.
[21] Kirkpatrick, D. (1959), “Techniques for Evaluating Training Programs”, Journal of the American Society for Training and Development, https://doi.org/10.4236/ce.2016.74065.
[15] Kremer, M. (1993), “The O-Ring Theory of Economic Development”, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 108/3, pp. 551-575, https://doi.org/10.2307/2118400.
[14] Lacerenza, C. et al. (2017), “Leadership training design, delivery, and implementation: A meta-analysis”, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 102/12, pp. 1686-1718, https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000241.
[16] Li, L. et al. (2009), “Use of communities of practice in business and health care sectors: A systematic review”, Implementation Science, Vol. 4/1, https://doi.org/10.1186/1748-5908-4-27.
[11] Ministry of Finance (2026), Keskastmejuhtide kompetentsimudel, https://www.fin.ee/media/8292/download.
[8] Ministry of Finance (2026), Keskne koolitus, https://www.fin.ee/riigihaldus-ja-avalik-teenistus-kinnisvara/avalik-teenistus/keskne-koolitus.
[13] Ministry of Finance (2024), Working for Finland: Central Government Human Resources Strategy 2030, https://vm.fi/documents/10623/201480519/Central+Government+Human+Resources+Strategy.pdf/9bc40508-2ad3-597f-dd96-d5777ef56ee4?t=1724323721632.
[18] OECD (2026), Applying Behavioural Science in the Italian Public Administration: A Blueprint for Best Practices, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/a7d9d7d9-en.
[7] OECD (2024), Strengthening the Innovative Capacity of the Public Sector of Bulgaria, OECD Public Governance Reviews, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/39fa2eed-en.
[6] OECD (2023), Strengthening the Innovative Capacity of the Public Sector of Latvia, OECD Public Governance Reviews, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/8d3102d9-en.
[3] OECD (2019), Declaration on Public Sector Innovation, https://legalinstruments.oecd.org/en/instruments/oecd-legal-0450.
[2] OECD (2017), Innovation Skills in the Public Sector: Building Capabilities in Chile, OECD Public Governance Reviews, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264273283-en.
[5] OECD (Forthcoming), Strengthening the innovative capacity of governments through skills development.
[17] Ranmuthugala, G. et al. (2011), “How and why are communities of practice established in the healthcare sector? A systematic review of the literature”, BMC Health Services Research, Vol. 11/1, https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6963-11-273.
[10] Raun, M. et al. (2022), Keskastmejuhtide kompetensimudeli uuendamine.
[9] Republic of Estonia (2023), Competency Framework of Estonian Top Civil Service (TCS), https://www.riigikantselei.ee/en/supporting-government-and-prime-minister/top-civil-service/competency-framework.
[20] Tannenbaum, S. and C. Cerasoli (2012), “Do Team and Individual Debriefs Enhance Performance? A Meta-Analysis”, Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Vol. 55/1, pp. 231-245, https://doi.org/10.1177/0018720812448394.