How can governance systems strengthen transparency and accountability in integration policy? This chapter explores how institutional processes, ranging from clear legal mandates to reporting, monitoring and accountability mechanisms help ensure that policymakers and service providers are answerable for their decisions and performance.
6. Transparent and accountable policies
Copy link to 6. Transparent and accountable policiesAbstract
Monitoring and evaluation systems provide information on implementation and outcomes. Transparency and accountability mechanisms determine how that information is scrutinised, reviewed and used to hold institutions responsible for their actions.
In integration policy, accountability can be complex because outcomes depend on co‑ordination across multiple policy areas and levels of government. This can make it harder to determine which institutions are responsible for outcomes or implementation failures. Clearly defined mechanisms for reporting, accountability and access to information can help make integration systems more transparent and easier to scrutinise. In addition, where the public can see how systems are organised and what results they produce, this can also strengthen confidence that public resources are being used as intended and that institutions are acting fairly. This chapter examines how OECD countries organise reporting, accountability and access to information within integration systems.
6.1. Legal foundations for accountability
Copy link to 6.1. Legal foundations for accountabilityWell-defined legal mandates support accountability by clarifying institutional responsibilities. When responsibilities are defined in legislation, it becomes easier to assess performance, understand how decisions are made and hold institutions accountable.
As outlined in Chapter 1, countries use different legal and regulatory instruments to allocate responsibilities for integration policy. Some rely on dedicated integration acts, while others use migration, education or labour legislation. In federal and decentralised systems, responsibilities may also be defined through regional frameworks. These legal frameworks shape how responsibilities are distributed between ministries, public agencies, regional authorities and municipalities.
The majority of responding countries have integration policy supported by a legal or regulatory framework. Exceptions are Croatia, Ireland, Latvia, Poland and the United Kingdom. In these countries, integration responsibilities are often defined through policy documents, programme frameworks or administrative guidelines rather than legislation.
Where mandates are not set in law, they can be easier to change but it may be more difficult to assign responsibility for policy decisions or implementation shortcomings. Fragmented or implicit mandates can make it more difficult to collect comparable information, establish consistent reporting practices and assess performance.
In Germany, federal legislation governing integration and language courses establishes shared reporting obligations and accreditation requirements for the Länder, helping to standardise data collection despite decentralised delivery. Switzerland similarly combines shared responsibilities at federal, cantonal and municipal levels with a common legislative framework that defines roles and reporting arrangements. Where responsibilities are divided between multiple ministries or levels of government, co‑ordination mechanisms and shared reporting frameworks help clarify responsibilities and support accountability.
6.2. Reporting and public scrutiny
Copy link to 6.2. Reporting and public scrutinyTransparency in integration policy depends on whether information on implementation, spending and outcomes is publicly available and accessible for scrutiny. Regular reporting to parliaments and the publication of performance indicators support democratic scrutiny and informed public debate. Transparent reporting can strengthen public confidence in integration systems and support more informed discussions on integration policy (OECD, 2025[1]).
Transparency also requires that information on how policies are implemented and what results they produce is accessible to parliaments, researchers and the wider public. Several OECD countries publish integration strategies, monitoring reports, evaluation findings or administrative statistics online. In some cases, governments also provide public dashboards tracking integration outcomes or programme performance. These tools can strengthen transparency and support accountability by making information on objectives, implementation and results more accessible.
There is substantial variation in how OECD countries organise public reporting on integration outcomes. Some countries publish regular national reports covering areas such as employment, education, housing, language learning and participation in integration programmes. Others rely more heavily on programme‑level reporting, internal monitoring documents or regional arrangements that are not always consolidated or publicly accessible, limiting comparability between programmes and over time.
In most responding countries, reporting is co‑ordinated by national ministries or specialised agencies, often in co‑operation with statistical offices. In some systems, reporting obligations are linked to legislation, budget processes or formal strategy cycles, requiring regular publication and parliamentary review. In other systems, publication is more discretionary and depends on administrative capacity or political priorities. Many OECD countries collect more administrative data than they publish systematically. In several cases data are gathered at municipal or regional level without being aggregated nationally.
Transparency tends to be stronger where reporting is built into legal requirements, regular publication cycles or budget and strategy processes. Sweden, for example, integrates reporting into the national budget process, allowing annual parliamentary scrutiny. Finland and Norway have reporting cycles set out in law, while France publishes regular reporting on the Contrat d’intégration républicaine (CIR) and complements administrative data with surveys tracking newcomer pathways. In Flanders, Belgium, legislation requires the government to report to parliament every three years on how the integration programme is being implemented and whether it is working.
By contrast, where there is no legal requirement to publish, reporting is often more fragmented and sometimes limited to internal or project-level documents. This makes it harder to compare integration outcomes between programmes and over time, and reduces the scope for public scrutiny.
Most publicly available reporting focusses on core indicators such as participation in language courses, civic-orientation outcomes, employment and education. Fewer countries publish regular information on broader dimensions of integration, such as social inclusion, discrimination, access to services or user satisfaction. This suggests that transparency depends not only on data availability, but also on how reporting systems are organised, co‑ordinated and made publicly accessible.
6.3. Accountability mechanisms
Copy link to 6.3. Accountability mechanismsAccountability mechanisms help ensure that authorities at all levels implement their responsibilities and use public resources as intended. In integration governance, accountability is complicated by the number of institutions involved. Responsibilities for funding, implementation and monitoring are frequently divided between ministries, municipalities and contracted providers, which means that no single institution may be clearly accountable for outcomes. When results fall short, it can be difficult to establish whether the problem lies with policy design, insufficient funding, co‑ordination gaps or local capacity.
At national level, accountability is typically organised through reporting, monitoring and external scrutiny. Ministries are generally required to report on integration policies, explain how funds are used and assess progress against government objectives. Parliamentary committees review performance and examine spending, and in some cases request follow-up measures. National audit institutions and parliamentary budget offices have a formal role for integration in some countries, reviewing integration spending and assessing whether programmes are on track. In France, Sweden and Estonia, for example, the national audit office evaluates integration programmes and reports findings to parliament. Where EU funds such as AMIF and ESF+ are involved, the European Court of Auditors provides an additional layer of independent scrutiny, examining how these resources are used and whether they are achieving their intended objectives. These arrangements make independent scrutiny a more formal part of this process, complementing ministerial reporting.
In multi-level systems, accountability can be diffuse. Several actors may contribute to the same outcome without any one of them being clearly responsible, which makes it harder to assess performance or take corrective action when things go wrong.
In decentralised systems, accountability also operates between levels of government. Municipalities and regions are often required to report to national authorities on how programmes are implemented and how funds are used. In Denmark and Finland, municipalities report regularly to national authorities. In Germany, reporting is organised through the Länder, creating shared accountability for service delivery and funding. In Italy and Spain, national steering is combined with regional accountability, particularly for EU-funded measures.
Where local authorities rely on central funding, accountability is often linked to funding conditions. This can include performance agreements, indicator-based reviews or audits of spending and outcomes. In Canada, accountability is maintained primarily through contractual arrangements with third party service providers, reporting requirements and performance monitoring rather than through direct administrative control (see Box 6.1).
Box 6.1. Decentralised service delivery and accountability in Canada
Copy link to Box 6.1. Decentralised service delivery and accountability in CanadaCanada provides an example of how accountability and performance management can be integrated into a decentralised service delivery model.
A network of over 530 service provider organisations, funded under the federal Settlement programme, deliver integration services for newcomers. These organisations include non-profit organisations, community associations and other service providers.
The federal government influences service delivery primarily through funding conditions, reporting obligations and evaluation requirements rather than through direct administrative control.
Service providers are required to report regularly on activities and outputs, such as participation in language training, employment services and orientation programmes. These reporting requirements are standardised, allowing the federal government to monitor service delivery across a large and diverse network of providers.
Accountability is also supported through programme reviews, third-party evaluations and beneficiary surveys. Evaluation findings are used to inform programme adjustments and the design of future calls for proposals, linking evidence to policy and operational decisions.
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025).
There are recurring challenges. In some systems, accountability relies more on informal co‑ordination than on formal reporting and review mechanisms. In others, national authorities have limited capacity to follow up on municipal performance. Differences in reporting quality between regions can also make it difficult to compare results and ensure consistent monitoring and accountability. Some countries have sought to strengthen accountability by requiring regular review of implementation in legislation. The Netherlands, for example, designed the 2021 Civil Integration Act as a learning system, with regular stakeholder meetings to review implementation findings and adjust the programme accordingly. This creates a more direct link between evidence, review and adjustment in practice.
In some OECD countries, accountability is also supported by independent institutions that oversee equal treatment and provide avenues for complaint and review. Norway’s Equality and Anti-Discrimination Ombud, for example, has a cross-cutting role that extends to integration governance.
Overall, accountability tends to be stronger where mandates are clearly defined, responsibilities can be traced, and reporting is linked to funding or regular review processes. However, well-developed data collection and reporting systems do not automatically ensure that findings are acted upon. As Chapter 5 shows, the gap between data collection and policy adjustment is a wider pattern across OECD countries.
6.4. Key takeaways
Copy link to 6.4. Key takeawaysOECD countries have developed a range of mechanisms to support transparency and accountability in integration governance, although important gaps remain, particularly where responsibilities are shared between several institutions and levels of government.
Clear legal mandates make it easier to assign responsibility and reduce fragmentation between ministries, agencies and levels of government.
Regular and comparable reporting strengthens transparency by making it easier for policymakers, parliaments and the public to follow implementation and assess results over time. Reporting tends to be most effective when it is linked to established processes such as budget cycles, parliamentary review or strategy updates.
Independent scrutiny complements internal reporting and monitoring. National audit institutions, parliamentary review and, where EU funds are involved, the European Court of Auditors can provide additional scrutiny of how integration measures are implemented and financed. Around half of responding countries report having independent bodies that review or assess integration policies and outcomes, although the extent to which findings influence policy varies.
Transparency and accountability depend on more than data collection. Monitoring can provide information on implementation and outcomes, but accountability also requires clear responsibilities, mechanisms for review and institutions that can act on findings. These mechanisms can also support learning and adaptation, helping integration systems respond to changing circumstances.
References
[1] OECD (2025), Government at a Glance 2025, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/0efd0bcd-en.