How can funding mechanisms ensure long-term sustainability and adaptability of integration efforts? This chapter examines how integration is financed, how resources are organised and allocated, and how funding arrangements shape implementation, co‑ordination and accountability.
4. Financing integration. Sustainable and responsive funding models
Copy link to 4. Financing integration. Sustainable and responsive funding modelsAbstract
Integration financing is often subject to particular scrutiny, reflecting both broader fiscal pressures and the political sensitivity of migration-related spending. This increases the need to show that resources are used efficiently and deliver measurable outcomes. Cost-effectiveness, predictability and the ability to adjust resources when needs change are therefore central issues in integration governance. In practice, this requires attention to several key features:
Predictability: whether funding is stable enough to support planning, staffing and continuity.
Flexibility: whether resources can be adjusted when needs or arrivals change.
Allocation and contracting rules: how resources flow between levels of government and to non-governmental actors.
Administrative burden and reliance on project-based funding: whether funding structures support continuity or lead to fragmentation.
Integration financing shares these features with many other areas of public spending but combines several sources of complexity. It typically involves multiple levels of government, spans policy areas such as education, housing and employment, and is shaped by legal entitlements and migration-related decisions. As a result, funding arrangements do more than distribute resources. They influence who delivers services, how stable programmes are, and whether systems can adjust when needs change.
A central challenge is to balance stability and flexibility. Stable, multi‑year financing supports long‑term planning and capacity building, while flexible mechanisms allow systems to adjust to changing migration patterns and local pressures. In European OECD countries, reliance on EU or project-based funding adds a further dimension. This can support innovation but may also complicate continuity and long-term capacity building. The following sections examine how OECD countries organise these financing systems and how different approaches affect implementation, co‑ordination and sustainability.
4.1. Sources of integration financing
Copy link to 4.1. Sources of integration financingUnderstanding integration financing begins with identifying where the funding comes from. The mix of funding sources matters because each source carries different implications, giving different actors influence over priorities, accountability and flexibility.
National public budgets are the main source of integration financing in most OECD countries, even where implementation relies heavily on local authorities or contracted providers. These resources are typically allocated either through dedicated integration budget lines or through mainstream social policy budgets in areas such as education, employment and health.
In most OECD countries, regional and local authorities also contribute to the financing of integration measures, particularly where they are responsible for service delivery. In countries such as Norway and Sweden, municipalities play a central role in financing and delivering integration services, while in Germany responsibilities for financing and delivering integration services are shared between Länder and municipalities. These resources usually come from general municipal or regional budgets, funded through a mix of local taxes and transfers from the national government. Dedicated local integration budget lines are rare. More commonly, funding for housing support, social services or supplementary language provision is drawn from broader local public services budgets. The extent of subnational financial autonomy varies in OECD countries and influences how far local authorities can adapt resources and services to local integration needs.
In some countries, integration financing is also supported by supranational or international sources. In the European Union, the Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund (AMIF) and the European Social Fund Plus (ESF+) provide substantial support. Their role varies: in some countries, EU funds represent a major share of integration financing, while others use them primarily for innovation pilots or supplementary measures (see also Section The role of EU funds in national integration financing). Outside the EU, several countries collaborate with international organisations to support settlement and reception programmes, particularly where national systems are still developing.
Additional contributions may come from private philanthropic foundations or private sector actors, such as companies co-financing language training or job-related upskilling. These sources generally complement public funding rather than constituting core financing streams. Although smaller in scale and difficult to track systematically across countries, these sources can play a strategic role by supporting innovation, encouraging partnerships and promoting whole‑of-society approaches.
At the same time, reliance on non-public funding may raise concerns related to sustainability, accountability, alignment with policy objectives and equal access. In some systems, migrants themselves may also contribute to certain types of integration courses or assessments. Cost‑sharing arrangements differ widely. While some countries provide early-phase measures such as basic language training and civic orientation free of charge, others apply fees at various stages, and the level and structure of these contributions varies considerably across countries depending on eligibility rules, benefit entitlements and local practice.
Budget allocations are generally set through annual or multi-year budget cycles, based on factors such as expected numbers of arrivals, legal obligations to provide support and government priorities. In the European Union, funds such as AMIF and ESF+ follow multi‑year programming periods, while national and subnational budgets are adjusted annually to respond to demographic trends and policy developments.
4.2. Organising national integration budgets
Copy link to 4.2. Organising national integration budgetsBeyond the source of funding, countries also differ in how integration budgets are organised and how financial responsibilities are allocated between institutions and levels of government. In OECD countries, integration budgets are commonly organised in three broad ways, and many countries combine elements of more than one.
In centralised models, responsibility for integration funding is concentrated at the national level, typically within a single ministry or a designated agency. Germany and Spain, for example, organise integration budgets primarily through one ministry or federal agency, supported by implementing bodies such as Germany’s Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF).
In multi-ministry frameworks, responsibilities and budgets are shared between several departments, such as labour, education, health, and home affairs, and are often co‑ordinated through interministerial committees or agreements (OECD, 2018[1]). Australia distributes integration-related budgets between Home Affairs, Employment, Education, Health and Social Services, while Italy funds integration jointly through the Ministry of the Interior and the Ministry of Labour and Social Policies. Lithuania, Japan and Romania follow similar approaches, with resources spread across multiple portfolios.
In some countries, responsibility for funding and implementation is largely assigned to subnational or local authorities, such as municipalities or regions. In Denmark and Norway, for example, national governments allocate funding for newly arrived residents directly to municipalities, which are then responsible for organising and delivering integration services.
Centralised systems provide clear accountability, making it easier to align with national priorities and international commitments, but they can be rigid and may be less responsive to local conditions. Multi‑ministry frameworks support cross‑sectoral collaboration and help mainstream integration into broader social policies, yet they can make co‑ordination more demanding and may reduce visibility of integration‑specific spending. Decentralised systems allow local authorities to tailor measures to local labour‑market conditions and community needs, but outcomes may vary if local authorities do not receive sufficient resources or if monitoring and accountability arrangements are weak.
In practice, many countries use hybrid arrangements that combine central funding decisions, multi‑ministry co‑ordination and local implementation. For example, Austria manages national integration funds centrally through the Federal Chancellery (BKA) and EU programmes such as AMIF, while federal states (Bundesländer) co-finance projects and deliver complementary measures. In Canada, both the federal government and the provinces/territories fund settlement support for newcomers. The federal government administers the federal Settlement Program, where third-party Service Provider Organizations are funded to deliver settlement supports to newcomers. Provinces and territories often target their support to migrants who are ineligible to receive federally funded settlement support. These governance models highlight the trade‑offs countries face between accountability, co‑ordination and local flexibility when organising integration financing.
4.3. Stability and flexibility in integration financing
Copy link to 4.3. Stability and flexibility in integration financingFinancing systems often involve a tension between stability and flexibility. In integration financing, stability supports long-term planning and sustained capacity. Flexibility helps governments respond to changing migration patterns and local pressures. Stable, multi‑year financing allows national and local authorities, as well as non‑governmental organisations, to plan activities, recruit and retain staff, and invest in quality improvements. Short-term funding cycles can undermine providers’ capacity and often favour large, professionalised organisations over smaller community‑based actors.
In Canada, multi‑year funding agreements in the federal settlement system align with expected volumes of newcomer arrivals and provide a higher degree of predictability for service providers. Austria’s national integration funds, managed through the Federal Chancellery, similarly offer multi‑year stability for key integration programmes. Finland also uses multi‑year frameworks for local integration planning, which help municipalities maintain staffing and programme continuity.
In EU Member States these dynamics are often shaped by the project-based nature of EU funding. In countries where AMIF or ESF+ represent a substantial share of integration financing, such as Lithuania, Romania, Poland or Slovenia, funding is often organised through time‑limited projects linked to EU programming cycles. Project-based financing can create gaps between funding periods, limit the ability to retain staff and reduce incentives for longer-term investment in organisational development.
Flexibility is equally important, especially in systems that experience fluctuations in arrivals or sudden pressure on services such as reception, case management or language training. Denmark and Norway provide examples of flexible allocation systems, where municipalities receive per‑capita funding that adjusts automatically to changes in the number of new migrants. In Germany, the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF) adjusts annual quotas and budgets for integration and language courses in line with demand, allowing providers to scale provision up or down in the short term.
Flexibility can also take the form of contingency funds (reserve budgets for unexpected needs), supplementary budgets approved during the year, or emergency envelopes issued when the number of migrants rises more quickly than anticipated. These mechanisms help governments respond to short term pressures, but challenges may arise in increasing capacity quickly. They can also make long-term planning more difficult if they replace stable baseline funding.
Countries often struggle to achieve both objectives simultaneously. Systems that prioritise flexibility may lack continuity, which can undermine quality and capacity. Systems that prioritise stability may be slower to respond to sudden changes in arrivals, leaving local authorities and providers with insufficient resources at critical moments.
This tension is particularly visible when funding depends on multiple government levels or external sources. Municipalities may receive stable block grants for long-term activities but rely on short-term project funding for specific groups or emerging needs. Civil-society organisations may deliver core services through annual contracts while depending on short-term EU funding for targeted or pilot initiatives. These mixed arrangements can result in uneven programme continuity and inconsistent service availability between regions.
Most OECD countries therefore combine a stable baseline with flexible adjustment mechanisms. Canada supplements its multi‑year funding with additional targeted envelopes, such as if additional funding is approved to support specific initiatives or in case of short-term mass arrivals. Germany uses national standards but adjusts budgets annually to match demand for language and integration courses. Denmark and Norway rely on per‑capita models that automatically track changes in newcomer numbers. Austria and Finland combine centrally managed multi‑year funds with regional co‑financing and local flexibility.
The balance between stability and flexibility is not fixed and depends on administrative rules, fiscal frameworks and political priorities. The challenge is to ensure that financing systems support predictable long-term planning while remaining responsive to new pressures and emerging needs. How this balance is managed affects implementation capacity, co‑ordination between levels of government and the overall efficiency of integration systems.
4.4. Allocation mechanisms between levels of government
Copy link to 4.4. Allocation mechanisms between levels of governmentWhile governance models set out who is responsible for managing integration budgets, allocation mechanisms determine how funding is distributed from national budgets to regional and local authorities and how resources reach the actors who deliver services. Well-designed allocation systems aim to balance predictability, equity and responsiveness, ensuring that funding reflects actual needs and supports coherent implementation. Four common allocation mechanisms can be identified. These approaches are often combined. A country may use formula-based transfers for municipalities, earmarked grants for specific priorities and competitive calls for smaller pilot initiatives.
4.4.1. Formula‑based transfers
Formula-based transfers allocate funding to municipalities according to predefined criteria such as the number of newcomers, socio‑economic indicators or regional labour‑market conditions. These formulas are widely used to ensure predictability and horizontal equity. Denmark and Finland calculate municipal grants based on arrivals and estimated local costs, while Norway uses a similar approach with adjustments for specific needs or vulnerabilities. Formula-based systems promote transparency but can limit flexibility if criteria do not adjust quickly to changing circumstances.
4.4.2. Earmarked grants
Earmarked grants support specific priorities such as language training, employment assistance or civic orientation. France’s Programme 104 is an example where national allocations support core measures while regional prefectures issue calls for projects for local implementation. Earmarked funding can help maintain strategic focus but may lack flexibility if priorities evolve or if local conditions diverge from national assumptions.
4.4.3. Competitive calls for proposals
Competitive calls distribute resources through open competition among municipalities or service providers. These mechanisms are often used to stimulate innovation, pilot new approaches or encourage partnerships between public authorities and civil‑society organisations. The main risk is that they may favour short‑term initiatives over long-term system building and can disadvantage municipalities or organisations with less administrative capacity.
4.4.4. Formal agreements and negotiated arrangements
Some countries use bilateral agreements between national and regional or local authorities to set objectives, funding levels and responsibilities, linking national priorities with local implementation. These can be used to clarify expectations, ensure joint planning and tailor resources to regional conditions. Agreements may also specify co-financing, reporting obligations and performance indicators. For example, in France, Contrats territoriaux d’accueil et d’intégration are co-constructed between the government and local authorities based on a shared territorial diagnosis, combining financial support with agreed priorities and co‑ordination between sectors. In Switzerland, similar co‑ordination is achieved through multi-year programme agreements between the Confederation and cantons under the Cantonal Integration Programmes (KIP), which define shared objectives, co-financing arrangements and reporting requirements for integration measures.
In many OECD countries, settlement systems are closely tied to financial allocation. Sweden uses an allocation algorithm to distribute newcomers and corresponding grants to municipalities based on factors such as recent migrant arrivals, municipal reception capacity and local labour‑market conditions, intended to balance responsibilities between municipalities. The system has been criticised for limited flexibility in responding to changing local conditions. Some municipalities facing labour shortages argued that they could receive more newcomers, while others requested lower allocations, but opportunities for adjustment have been limited. A recent government inquiry has proposed a shift to a model where settlement and funding are more responsive to local reception capacity and housing conditions (Statens Offentliga Utredningar, 2025[2]).
4.4.5. Performance‑linked allocation
Performance‑linked mechanisms link a portion of funding to measurable outcomes. Austria includes reporting on course completion rates in multi‑year agreements. Canada weights its settlement funding formula to account for refugees’ higher expected support needs. Finland combines fixed compensation with outcome‑related elements tied to refugee employment, while Norway adjusts municipal grants based on support needs and progression. These mechanisms can enhance accountability but require robust monitoring systems and may risk incentivising “cream‑skimming” if not balanced by safeguards.
Allocation mechanisms distribute resources, but they also create incentives for municipalities and service providers. They influence settlement decisions, programme design and the types of support available in different regions. The challenge is to allocate resources in a way that provides predictable funding while remaining responsive to differences in local needs and changing circumstances.
4.5. Financing of non‑governmental actors – contracting and procurement
Copy link to 4.5. Financing of non‑governmental actors – contracting and procurementAllocation mechanisms determine how resources flow between levels of government. Financing arrangements with non‑governmental actors shape how integration services are delivered and how risks and responsibilities are shared. Civil‑society organisations, private providers, social enterprises and, in some cases, migrant‑led organisations play a central role in the delivery of language training, employment support, civic orientation and settlement services in OECD countries. Governments therefore use a range of contracting and grant mechanisms. These affect service quality, organisational stability and which providers are able to participate. Table 4.1 shows how widely non-governmental actors are involved in service delivery and the diversity of financing arrangements used.
Table 4.1. Use of contracted providers in integration service delivery in OECD countries
Copy link to Table 4.1. Use of contracted providers in integration service delivery in OECD countries|
Country |
Uses contractors |
Measures |
Providers |
Type of financing |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Australia |
Yes |
Settlement, employment, language |
Private providers; civil society organisations |
Tenders; grants |
|
|
Austria |
Yes |
Employment, education, language courses |
Private providers; civil society organisations |
Tenders; grants |
|
|
Belgium |
Brussels |
Yes |
Language courses, citizenship education, employment support, digital inclusion |
Civil society organisations |
Grants; project-based |
|
Flanders |
Yes |
||||
|
Wallonia |
Yes |
||||
|
Bulgaria |
No |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
|
Canada |
Yes |
Settlement services (includes employment-related services, language training) |
Community organisations; non-profits |
Tenders; programme‑based |
|
|
Chile |
No |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
|
Costa Rica |
No |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
|
Croatia |
Yes |
Language courses |
Private providers |
Tenders; per-participant |
|
|
Czechia |
Yes |
Adaptation and Integration Courses |
Migrant-led and civil society organisations |
Grants; outcome‑based |
|
|
Denmark |
Yes |
Language training; employment-related services |
Municipal contractors; private providers |
Tenders; per-participant |
|
|
Estonia |
Yes |
Language, civic orientation, labour market |
Private providers; civil society organisations |
Tenders; per-participant |
|
|
Finland |
Yes |
Language training; employment support; integration services |
Municipalities; civil society organisations; private providers |
Grants; per-participant |
|
|
France |
Yes |
Language training (linguistic and civic formation under the CIR), employment support (programme AGIR), civic orientation courses |
Civil society organisations; private providers; public institutions |
Tenders; grants; per-participant |
|
|
Germany |
Yes |
Integration courses |
Accredited private providers; civil society organisations |
Per-participant |
|
|
Greece |
Yes |
Language courses, vocational training, civic orientation, awareness courses |
Civil society organisations; international organisations |
Grants |
|
|
Hungary |
No |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
|
Iceland |
Yes |
Language training; empowerment; employment support |
Icelandic Red Cross |
Grants |
|
|
Ireland |
Yes |
Integration and employment support |
Civil society organisations |
Grants; programme‑based; outcome‑based |
|
|
Israel |
Yes |
Language and integration services |
Public interest and private providers |
Programme‑based |
|
|
Italy |
Yes |
Reception and integration services |
Civil society organisations; social co‑operatives |
Grants |
|
|
Japan |
Yes |
Language and settlement support |
Local Civil society organisations; foundations |
Grants |
|
|
Korea |
Yes |
Integration, language, employment support |
Civil society organisations |
Programme‑based |
|
|
Latvia |
Yes |
Language courses; integration courses |
Civil society organisations |
Grants |
|
|
Lithuania |
Yes |
Language, civic orientation, employment, psychosocial support, housing assistance |
Civil society organisations |
Grants; per-participant. |
|
|
Luxembourg |
No |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
|
Netherlands |
Yes |
Integration and employment services |
Private providers; municipalities |
Per-participant; outcome‑based |
|
|
New Zealand |
Yes |
Targeted integration services under the Refugee Quota Programme |
Civil society; private; public; migrant-led organisations |
Per-participant |
|
|
Norway |
Yes |
Language training; employment support |
Municipal contractors; civil society organisations |
Per-participant; outcome‑based |
|
|
Poland |
Yes |
Integration and social inclusion services |
Civil society organisations |
Grants |
|
|
Portugal |
Yes |
Language training; employment support; integration and reception services |
Municipalities; civil society organisations; migrant associations; international organisations |
Grants |
|
|
Romania |
Yes |
Integration and language support |
Civil society organisations |
Grants |
|
|
Slovenia |
Yes |
Language courses; civic orientation |
Accredited providers |
Per-participant |
|
|
Spain |
Yes |
Integration and employment services |
Civil society organisations |
Grants |
|
|
Sweden |
Yes |
Language, civic orientation, employment and integration courses |
Private providers; civil society organisations |
Tenders; Per-participant; outcome‑based |
|
|
Switzerland |
Yes |
Orientation, language, education, employment, social inclusion, protection against discrimination and interpretation support |
Cantons, municipalities, civil society organisations, private providers |
Programme‑based, grants |
|
|
Türkiye |
Yes |
Employment, vocational training, language and integration courses, psychosocial support |
Civil society organisations; private sector actors |
Grants; per-participant |
|
|
United Kingdom |
Yes |
Integration, employment and housing-related support |
Civil society organisations; private providers |
Grants; outcome‑based |
|
Note: Tenders: competitive procurement processes. Grants: direct funding to organisations. Per-participant: payments linked to enrolment, attendance or course completion. Programme‑based: multi-year contribution agreements. Outcome‑based: payments linked to measurable results.
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025).
Countries often combine grants, tenders, per-participant funding and programme‑based contracts, with outcome‑linked models used more selectively. These choices influence provider stability, administrative burden and the diversity of organisations able to participate.
Grants: Common for targeted programmes or community‑based initiatives, often used to support civil‑society organisations. Finland and Iceland use grant schemes to support Civil society organisations delivering language support, empowerment activities or targeted services for women and youth.
Competitive tenders: Frequently used where services are standardised and large in scale. Australia, Denmark and Estonia tender language or employment‑related services to private providers or municipal contractors. This model can foster innovation but may disadvantage smaller organisations with limited administrative capacity.
Per‑participant funding: Used when services are delivered at scale and participation can be tracked. Germany finances integration and language courses through per‑participant payments to accredited providers. Croatia and Slovenia use similar models for basic language and orientation courses.
Outcome‑based or performance‑linked funding: Used to reward providers that achieve specific outcomes. The Netherlands and the United Kingdom use outcome‑linked pilots for parts of their integration and employment services. Austria includes performance indicators in multi‑year agreements for language training.
Programme‑based contracting: Canada exemplifies this model. The federal settlement programme funds more than 500 service‑provider organisations through multi‑year funding agreements, offering stability and flexibility while maintaining clear reporting requirements.
Project‑based funding linked to EU programmes: In many EU Member States, civil‑society organisations deliver integration services under AMIF or ESF+ projects. This supports innovation but can lead to discontinuity between programming cycles, as seen in Lithuania, Greece, Latvia and Italy.
Involving non‑governmental actors can expand delivery capacity, bring specialised expertise and often improve service accessibility. However, financing arrangements can also create challenges. Funding and procurement rules can favour larger, more professionalised providers. This may improve administrative control, but it can also reduce diversity among providers and make it harder for smaller civil-society or migrant-led organisations to participate.
Key challenges include short-term funding cycles that undermine organisational stability, procurement rules that can disadvantage smaller providers, and project-based EU funding that may create gaps between funding cycles or shift attention toward fundable priorities rather than long-term needs. Administrative requirements, particularly in EU-funded programmes, can further limit participation by smaller or migrant-led organisations. Where monitoring frameworks are not proportionate, rapid expansion of contracted services may also affect quality and consistency.
Where service delivery is delegated to external providers or subnational actors, governments often use accreditation systems, reporting requirements and performance monitoring to maintain common standards and monitor implementation. In Germany, BAMF accredits providers delivering federally funded integration and language courses and sets common standards for course content, teacher qualifications and reporting. In France, organisations receiving funding under Programme 104 are subject to reporting and performance requirements linked to implementation objectives and administrative follow-up. Canada illustrates a different approach, where competitive calls for proposals are established multi-year funding agreements with settlement providers and to support continuity and longer-term planning, while performance reporting is integrated into funding arrangements.1
4.5.1. Partnerships with employers and social partners
In several countries, employers and social partners contribute financially or through in‑kind support. Denmark’s workplace‑based Danish programmes and Germany’s job‑related German courses involve co‑financing from employers in sectors facing labour shortages. Social partners play a structured role in Austria, Germany, Belgium (Flanders) and the Netherlands, linking labour‑market integration to vocational training systems, apprenticeships and employment standards. These partnerships can help align integration services with labour-market needs, but they require clear rules on responsibilities, accountability and equal access.
Contracted providers are widely used, but financing arrangements vary between countries. These differences matter. They influence which organisations are able to participate and whether service provision remains stable over time or can adapt to changing needs.
Innovative financing instruments, such as Social Impact Bonds (SIB) and outcome‑linked pilots, have been tested in some countries. These remain relatively limited and are typically used in pilot settings rather than as part of regular financing systems. Finland’s Koto-SIB is one example. Private investors funded tailored employment services for refugees, and the government repaid only if agreed outcomes were met (see Box 4.1). Similarly, the United Kingdom Refugee Transitions Outcomes Fund piloted an outcome‑based model linking payments to refugee employment and housing outcomes. These approaches aim to strengthen efficiency and accountability by paying only for verified outcomes, however, they require safeguards against unintended effects, such as “cream skimming”, where service providers may prioritise participants who are easier to integrate, while neglecting those facing greater barriers.
Other approaches focus on supporting community participation and local involvement. For example, New Zealand’s Meaningful Refugee Participation Fund allocates resources to regional and national fund holders, which directly finance initiatives tailored to local priorities, helping improve responsiveness to local needs.
Box 4.1. Case study: The Koto-Social Impact Bond in Finland
Copy link to Box 4.1. Case study: The Koto-Social Impact Bond in FinlandThe Finnish Koto-SIB (Integration Social Impact Bond) demonstrates how outcomes-based financing can be applied to immigrant integration in practice. The initiative aimed to improve labour-market participation among highly educated immigrants and refugees through a public-private partnership that tested innovative service‑delivery approaches. The model brought together public and private actors in a results-based financing arrangement.
Private investors provided the initial capital, covering the upfront costs of integration services.
Service providers delivered targeted and individualised employment and upskilling support, with remuneration fully linked to the achievement of agreed outcomes.
The Finnish Government acted as outcome payer, reimbursing investors only if predefined results were achieved, thereby shifting financial risk away from the public budget.
Outcomes were measured using administrative data, in particular employment records and changes in benefit dependency, which allowed for relatively robust and standardised verification. This data-based approach strengthened accountability and reduced discretion in performance assessment.
The design created strong incentives for efficiency and adaptation. By linking payments to sustained employment outcomes, public funding was directed towards interventions that produced measurable results. Providers also developed more tailored approaches, including mentoring, skills matching and job coaching, moving beyond standardised programme models.
The model also revealed important limitations. Transaction costs were relatively high, reflecting the complexity of contracting, performance measurement and co‑ordination between actors. In addition, defining and verifying outcomes required significant administrative capacity. There were also concerns about equity. The reliance on outcome payments may create incentives to prioritise participants who are closer to the labour market, potentially limiting access for those facing more complex barriers.
Programme monitoring and reported results indicate improved employment outcomes for participants compared to baseline expectations, particularly faster entry into employment and reduced reliance on benefits. At the same time, results varied across participant groups, indicating that outcomes-based models may be more effective for individuals with relatively strong labour-market attachment. While the model strengthened performance orientation and accountability, it also required substantial investment in data systems and monitoring capacity. This may make the model more difficult to replicate in contexts where administrative data are less developed or co‑ordination between actors is weaker.
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025), Karinen, R. et al., (2024[3]), Impacts and practical implementation of the Koto-SIB experiment.
Financing arrangements do more than fund service delivery. They create incentives, influence which actors participate and affect how easily systems can be co‑ordinated. Where funding is stable and rules are proportionate, providers are better able to invest in capacity and maintain service quality. Where funding is fragmented or heavily project-based, providers may face discontinuities and higher administrative burdens, which can affect both access and outcomes.
4.6. The role of EU funds in national integration financing
Copy link to 4.6. The role of EU funds in national integration financingIn EU countries, EU funding complements national resources but also introduces governance requirements that shape how programmes are designed and delivered. This primarily takes the form of EU funds, notably the Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund (AMIF), the European Regional and Development Fund (ERDF), and the European Social Fund Plus (ESF+) (see Box 4.2). In some countries, these resources represent a substantial share of integration financing and influence both priorities and delivery models.
Box 4.2. Main EU funding instruments supporting integration
Copy link to Box 4.2. Main EU funding instruments supporting integrationSeveral European Union funding instruments support the integration of migrants and beneficiaries of international protection in OECD countries that are EU Member States. The main instruments include:
The Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund (AMIF), which supports reception, integration, asylum and migration-management measures, including integration measures implemented by local and regional authorities and civil society organisations. The European Social Fund Plus (ESF+), which finances labour-market integration, skills development, social inclusion and education measures relevant to migrants and their children.
The European Regional Development Fund (ERDF), which can support infrastructure and local development projects linked to housing, education, health and social inclusion in areas affected by migration pressures.
The Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF), introduced following the COVID‑19 pandemic, which has in some countries supported reforms and investments affecting integration systems, including digitalisation and labour-market participation.
Other instruments, including Erasmus+, Horizon Europe and targeted emergency assistance, may also support specific integration-related projects and co‑ordination initiatives.
AMIF and ESF+ play complementary roles in supporting integration. AMIF primarily supports measures tailored to the needs of third-country nationals during the early stages of integration, such as language training, orientation services and targeted support for beneficiaries of international protection, while ESF+ more often supports longer-term inclusion through employment, education and social inclusion measures.
EU funding is generally implemented through shared management between the European Commission and Member States, often involving regional and local authorities as well as civil society organisations.
EU funds can support innovation and capacity building particularly where national resources are limited, but their longer-term contribution depends on how well they are embedded in national financing frameworks, implementation responsibilities and mainstream service systems. Transparent calls, reporting requirements and audit procedures can help manage complexity and support accountability. Where EU-funded projects are linked to national strategies and budget lines they are more likely to support sustainability and policy coherence. (OECD/European Union, 2018[4]).
The share of EU funding in integration financing varies widely between countries. Table 4.2 provides an overview of this, grouping countries by the share of EU funds in annual integration budgets and indicating the main programmes used.
Table 4.2. Share of EU funding for integration in European OECD countries
Copy link to Table 4.2. Share of EU funding for integration in European OECD countries|
Country |
Category |
Main programmes |
Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Austria |
Low |
AMIF |
Approx. 6% |
|
Bulgaria |
Moderate |
AMIF, ESF+ |
|
|
Croatia |
Moderate |
||
|
Czechia |
High |
||
|
Denmark |
Low |
N/A |
Small number of municipal projects receive EU funding. |
|
Estonia |
High |
AMIF, ESF+ |
70‑80% |
|
Finland |
Low |
AMIF, ESF+ |
<5%. EU funds are used mainly for pilots. |
|
France |
Low |
AMIF |
|
|
Germany |
Low |
AMIF |
|
|
Greece |
High |
AMIF, ESF+ |
Approx. 80%. |
|
Hungary |
High |
AMIF |
|
|
Ireland |
Moderate |
AMIF, ESF+ |
|
|
Italy |
High |
AMIF, ESF+ |
|
|
Latvia |
High/Moderate |
AMIF, ESF+ |
High reliance on EU funds for integration. Support for Ukrainians financed nationally. |
|
Lithuania |
High |
AMIF, ESF+ |
|
|
Luxembourg |
N/A |
AMIF, ESF+ |
Mainstreamed programmes and budgeting. |
|
Netherlands |
Low |
||
|
Poland |
High |
AMIF, ESF+, ERDF |
No permanent national budget for integration. |
|
Portugal |
High |
AMIF, ESF+, CERV |
EU funds complement public investment by national and local authorities |
|
Romania |
High |
ESF+, AMIF |
EU funds finance most integration activities. |
|
Slovenia |
High |
AMIF |
Approx. 66% |
|
Sweden |
Low |
AMIF, ESF+ |
EU funds used supplementary. |
Note: High: ≥ 50% of annual integration funding from EU sources; Moderate: 10‑49%; Low: < 10%. Classification based on annualised EU-share vs. annual national integration budget.
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025).
In countries such as Romania, Estonia, Slovenia and Italy, EU funds account for more than half of integration financing. By contrast, Finland, France and Denmark report a low share, using EU funds mainly for pilot projects or supplementary measures.
In some countries, integration financing is largely embedded in broader social policy budgets, making it difficult to isolate dedicated spending. For Luxembourg, no precise estimate of the share of EU funds in integration budgets is available, due to its mainstreamed integration policy framework, Vivre Ensemble Interculturel, which targets nationals, EU citizens, cross-border workers, and third-country nationals. Some countries also maintain separate national funding streams for specific groups, such as Ukrainians. In Latvia, while a large share of general integration measures is financed through EU funds, specific national budget allocations are provided under the Law on Assistance to Ukrainian Civilians.
Questionnaire responses suggest that differences in EU funding shares are closely linked to how integration systems are organised. Where EU funding represents a large share, financing is often structured through time‑limited projects linked to EU programming cycles.
EU funding can shape national integration programming by linking it to EU-level priorities. For instance, EU funds are often used to support pilot projects and experimentation that would be difficult to finance through domestic budgets. In Finland and France, AMIF resources have been used to support refugee employment pilots and testing alternative service delivery models. In some countries, EU funding has also been used to test digital tools or new partnerships with employers.
Estonia provides another example of using EU funds for innovation through its Adaptation and Integration Measure, which seeks to reduce linguistic, cultural, and social barriers faced by new immigrants and less-integrated residents. The project combines modular language courses, cultural orientation and digital tools to adapt services to local needs. ESF funding supported multilingual platforms, welcome programmes, integration courses, and capacity building for service providers, alongside mid-term evaluations to strengthen evidence‑based policy design (OECD, 2025[5]).
In addition, ESF+ introduces horizontal principles such as gender equality, anti-discrimination and social inclusion, which must be embedded in project design. These principles are reflected in both the content of funded activities and in how national calls for proposals are structured, as applicants are required to demonstrate how they will integrate them into implementation. This conditionality can help embed EU priorities in national programmes, although its effect on implementation varies between countries. EU funding can therefore influence not only what is financed, but also how projects are designed and assessed (OECD, 2025[5]).
At the same time, EU funding introduces specific governance challenges. Reporting and audit requirements increase administrative burdens, which can limit access for smaller civil-society organisations. Eligibility thresholds, including minimum project size and reimbursement rules, tend to favour larger organisations and may reduce diversity among providers. (European Commission, 2025[6]). These challenges may be particularly pronounced for smaller municipalities and rural areas, which often have more limited administrative capacity to prepare applications, manage reporting requirements and secure co-financing.
Sustainability is a recurring issue identified by several countries in the questionnaire responses. Where EU funds make up a large share of financing, continuity may be difficult to maintain between funding cycles. Several countries have developed approaches to strengthen continuity, including integrating EU-funded activities into national budget lines or providing national funding to continue successful initiatives beyond the lifetime of individual projects.
For national and regional authorities, these funds can be difficult to use in practice because programming requirements, co-financing rules and audit procedures are often complex. Flexibility to reallocate resources may also be limited, which can delay implementation and make it harder to respond to evolving priorities. In addition, once programmes are agreed, resources are often tied to predefined objectives and timelines, reducing the scope for adjustments during implementation.
Countries have adopted different approaches to manage these challenges. Austria complements AMIF with national funding to maintain continuity beyond EU cycles. France integrates AMIF-funded initiatives into Programme 104, reducing reliance on EU funding. Lithuania combines AMIF with national resources and support from international organisations to maintain more stable programming.
4.7. Inclusive integration financing
Copy link to 4.7. Inclusive integration financingA sustainable financing system for integration should ensure that funding reaches different groups targeted by integration policies and supports broader social cohesion. This requires structuring funding and service delivery so that resources are accessible, including for individuals facing gender-related barriers or multiple obstacles to participation. These issues are particularly relevant for groups with weaker labour-market attachment, such as low-skilled refugees or migrant mothers with care responsibilities, who may face overlapping barriers to participation (Liebig and Tronstad, 2018[7]).
Gender-responsive budgeting integrates a gender perspective throughout the budget cycle, from planning and allocation to implementation and evaluation, to ensure that public resources are used effectively and reach intended groups. For integration policy, this means asking which measures are funded, whom they target, and under what conditions. Effective gender-responsive budgeting relies on gender-disaggregated data and analysis of care responsibilities, employment barriers, access to services and gender-specific risks. Available evidence suggests that gender-responsive financing can improve labour-market participation and reduce longer-term dependency (OECD, 2023[8]).
Funding choices, even when formally neutral, can generate unintended gender impacts that affect labour-market participation and access to services. For example, cash-for-care schemes or family-based benefits may discourage labour-market participation among migrant women, slowing integration outcomes. A gender-responsive approach helps identify and mitigate such effects, and can improve access to language training, employment programmes, childcare and other services (OECD, 2023[9]).
Several OECD countries embed gender considerations in public budgeting processes. In Sweden, gender budgeting has been integrated into the government budget process since the early 2000s, with budget proposals and allocations assessed for their gender-equality impacts. The Swedish Government’s “BUDGe for Gender Equality”-tool supports this analysis, ensuring that revenue and expenditure decisions are assessed in relation to gender-equality objectives. Integration-related funding undergoes the same gender review, aligning integration policy with broader gender-equality commitments.
In Belgium, the 2007 Gender Mainstreaming Law requires public administrations to integrate a gender perspective into policies and budgets. A 2010 circular further requires draft budgets to include a “gender note” outlining allocations linked to gender equality. Regional authorities, including Wallonia and Flanders, apply gender mainstreaming in social and cohesion funding. European Social Fund (ESF+) programme managing authorities in these regions apply gender as a horizontal principle in project calls, selection criteria, and budget allocations. As a result, regional funding channels relevant for migrant integration formally include gender considerations.
Other countries have adopted more targeted gender-sensitive initiatives in integration policy. In Iceland, the Ministry of Justice operates a Gender Equality Fund that finances projects such as language and empowerment workshops for migrant women, mentoring schemes and partnerships with civil society. In Finland, the municipal state‑subsidy system includes funding aimed at promoting the employment of migrant mothers, reflecting OECD findings on the importance of childcare and targeted outreach (OECD, 2023[9]).
Together, these examples show how financing arrangements can influence access to services and labour-market participation, and how integrating a gender perspective can help reduce barriers for specific groups.
4.8. Building transparent and accountable funding systems
Copy link to 4.8. Building transparent and accountable funding systemsTransparency and accountability are essential for effective integration financing, particularly because funding for integration often passes through several levels of government and a wide range of providers. They help ensure that resources are used as intended, reduce the risk of misuse and allow policymakers and the public to assess whether funding reaches intended groups and supports consistent outcomes. Without these safeguards, even well-funded systems may struggle to deliver services effectively.
Many countries embed transparency requirements in budget legislation and procurement frameworks. In integration financing, this also involves clarifying how funds are allocated between national, regional and local levels and how contracted providers report on activities and results. For example, Norway’s Freedom of Information Act ensures public access to government documents, including budget allocations, while Austria’s Federal Budget Act requires detailed reporting on integration expenditures. Public procurement rules further reinforce transparency by setting clear eligibility criteria and selection procedures for grants and tenders. In France, calls for projects under Programme 104 are published with explicit guidelines on objectives, funding amounts, and reporting obligations.
Digital tools are increasingly used to strengthen transparency and monitoring. Estonia’s EU fund management system provides real-time tracking of allocations and compliance with reporting requirements, and Germany and Finland are piloting dashboards that combine financial data with performance indicators. These tools are particularly relevant in integration policy, where funding is often fragmented and delivered through multiple programmes, making it more difficult to track how resources translate into outcomes.
In Israel, where integration policy is directed at Jewish immigrants relocating under the Law of Return, a multi-layered system of legal, administrative and financial controls supports transparency and accountability in the allocation and use of integration funds. Parliamentary approval through the Knesset, open tender procedures, public reporting, and external audits are combined with result-based funding and compliance checks.
When financial reporting is linked to digital tracking and performance data, it becomes easier to assess not just whether funds were spent correctly, but whether they achieved results. EU co-financing rules reflect this by requiring public disclosure of funded projects and beneficiaries.
Applying these principles to integration financing has clear benefits. Stronger digital tracking of integration funding could help policymakers and citizens assess not only how much money is spent, but also how spending relates to results. This could strengthen accountability, improve resource allocation, and make progress toward inclusion goals more visible and measurable.
Transparency and accountability are not only compliance requirements. In integration financing, they are practical tools for tracking how resources are used, whether they reach intended groups and how spending relates to results. This is particularly important in systems where funding is fragmented and delivered through multiple actors. These issues are examined in further in Chapter 6.
4.9. Key takeaways
Copy link to 4.9. Key takeawaysIntegration financing in OECD countries is organised through different governance models, ranging from centralised budget frameworks to decentralised or formula-based transfers to municipalities, as in the Nordic countries, and programme‑based systems relying on funding agreements with service providers, as in Canada. EU funding instruments, particularly AMIF and ESF+, also play an important role in shaping national financing arrangements in many EU countries. Despite these differences, there are a few key considerations worth bearing in mind:
Funding for integration is typically drawn from multiple sources. In addition to dedicated integration budgets and programmes, many countries finance integration measures through mainstream education, employment, housing and social policy budgets. This reflects the cross-cutting nature of integration policy but can make it harder to track total spending and identify gaps across policy areas. Mapping integration-related spending across these different budgets, even where funding remains decentralised, makes it easier to identify where resources are concentrated and where gaps remain.
How funds are allocated shapes how integration is delivered. The criteria used to distribute funding between levels of government may influence where migrants settle, which services are available and how municipalities and providers plan their work. Allocation systems that do not reflect actual needs can create mismatches between resources and local needs. Allocation criteria that are reviewed periodically and adjusted in light of changing settlement patterns or service demand can help reduce this kind of mismatch over time.
How resources are allocated can also influence who benefits from integration measures. Funding choices that appear neutral can have unequal effects in practice, for example when care responsibilities or other participation barriers are not accounted for. Several countries have introduced gender-responsive budgeting and targeted financing criteria to improve access and ensure resources reach their intended target groups. This can also help identify gaps that are not always visible in standard monitoring data.
Funding rules influence which organisations can participate in service delivery. Short funding cycles, heavy procurement requirements and complex reporting obligations tend to favour larger providers. Smaller civil-society and migrant-led organisations may find it harder to participate. Multi-year funding arrangements and procurement or reporting requirements proportionate to the size of the grant can help smaller organisations participate on a more sustained basis.
In many EU Member States, EU funds cover a large share of integration financing. This can support innovation and capacity building. It also introduces continuity risks between programming cycles. Countries have adopted different approaches to strengthen continuity, including embedding EU-funded activities in national budget frameworks and providing national funding to continue successful initiatives beyond the lifetime of individual projects.
Financing arrangements determine how resources are allocated, which actors are involved and how services are delivered. However, understanding how these resources translate into outcomes requires reliable data and monitoring systems. The next chapter examines how OECD countries track integration outcomes and use evidence to inform policy decisions.
References
[6] European Commission (2025), Mid-term Evaluation of the Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund (AMIF) 2021-2027, European Commission, Brussels.
[3] Karinen, R. et al. (2024), Impacts and practical implementation of the Koto-SIB experiment, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment, Helsinki, https://urn.fi/URN:ISBN:978-952-327-620-8.
[7] Liebig, T. and K. Tronstad (2018), “Triple Disadvantage? : A first overview of the integration of refugee women”, OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers, No. 216, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/3f3a9612-en.
[5] OECD (2025), Starting, Scaling and Sustaining Social Innovation: Evidence and Impact of the European Social Fund, Local Economic and Employment Development (LEED), OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/ec1dfb67-en.
[8] OECD (2023), Gender Budgeting in OECD Countries 2023, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/647d546b-en.
[9] OECD (2023), International Migration Outlook 2023, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/b0f40584-en.
[1] OECD (2018), Working Together for Local Integration of Migrants and Refugees, OECD Regional Development Studies, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264085350-en.
[4] OECD/European Union (2018), Settling In 2018: Indicators of Immigrant Integration, OECD Publishing, Paris/European Union, Brussels, https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264307216-en.
[2] Statens Offentliga Utredningar (2025), Etableringsboendelagen - ett nytt system för bosättning för vissa nyanlända. (SOU 2025:35).
Note
Copy link to Note← 1. Canada’s National Settlement Funding Formula is used to align the distribution of funding invested in each jurisdiction based on historical and projected share of arrivals, relative to other jurisdictions, with an additional weight to account for refugees’ higher expected settlement needs.