How can integration frameworks support innovation and respond to changing migration and societal needs? This chapter looks at how integration governance can move beyond reactive responses and remain effective when conditions change unexpectedly.
7. Navigating uncertainty. Innovation and policy adaptability
Copy link to 7. Navigating uncertainty. Innovation and policy adaptabilityAbstract
Migration is inherently dynamic and evolves over time in response to economic conditions, demographic change, labour-market demand, political developments and humanitarian crises. Integration systems must therefore operate under continuous change and uncertainty. At times, these changes can occur rapidly, placing integration systems under sudden pressure. Governance frameworks must therefore combine stability with adaptability. This requires systems that can test new approaches, learn from experience and adapt institutional frameworks without losing continuity or accountability.
This chapter examines how OECD countries organise integration systems that can respond to shocks while maintaining longer-term coherence. It brings together the governance dimensions discussed in earlier chapters and considers how they shape the ability of systems to adapt, learn and respond to changing conditions. It also looks at how pilot programmes and emergency measures are used in practice and whether temporary arrangements become part of longer-term governance structures or are phased out once pressures subside.
7.1. From emergency response to long-term integration governance
Copy link to 7.1. From emergency response to long-term integration governanceMigration-related shocks place integration systems under strain. Large‑scale displacement or changes in migration patterns can quickly reshape integration needs and increase demand for reception, housing, education, health services and labour-market support. Unlike more gradual migration processes, these situations unfold under pressure and uncertainty, often requiring immediate action before longer-term policy direction is in place. In this sense, crises function as stress tests for integration governance, revealing both the capacity of systems and their vulnerabilities.
Integration governance systems are especially exposed in these situations. Responsibilities are spread across multiple policy areas and levels of government, and access to services for migrants often depends on legal status. When arrivals increase rapidly or new protection statuses are introduced, existing co‑ordination mechanisms, funding arrangements and implementation capacities may no longer match the needs.
Governments typically respond with emergency governance measures. These often include temporary co‑ordination structures, such as inter-ministerial task forces, to speed up decision making and align action across policy areas and between different stakeholders. Funding is often mobilised more quickly, using emergency budgets or simplified allocation procedures, with additional resources frequently channelled to regional and local authorities, service providers and civil society organisations. Legal or administrative rules may also be adjusted, for example through temporary protection statuses, simplified registration, or exemptions from standard eligibility rules. In several countries responding to the arrival of displaced persons from Ukraine, dedicated registration procedures, temporary protection frameworks and targeted employment co‑ordination mechanisms were introduced alongside existing integration systems.
In some OECD countries, temporary arrangements have applied only to specific nationalities or migration categories, creating parallel access routes to services alongside existing integration systems. While such arrangements can improve responsiveness and accelerate access to services, they may also increase co‑ordination challenges, create uneven access to services between different target groups and blur institutional responsibilities over time. After Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine, the activation of the EU Temporary Protection Directive (see Box 7.1) led many OECD and EU countries to introduce temporary protection arrangements alongside existing integration systems. In Czechia, as in many other EU countries, these arrangements raised questions about how emergency frameworks fit with established responsibilities and co‑ordination structures (see Box 7.2).
Box 7.1. Crisis co‑ordination and temporary protection in the European Union
Copy link to Box 7.1. Crisis co‑ordination and temporary protection in the European UnionThe large‑scale displacement following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 tested the ability of European integration systems to respond rapidly under conditions of uncertainty. The activation of the EU Temporary Protection Directive created a common legal framework granting displaced persons immediate access to residence, labour markets, education, healthcare and social services across EU Member States.
The response highlighted how emergency governance mechanisms can shape reception systems as well as longer-term integration frameworks. Implementing temporary protection required rapid co‑ordination between migration authorities and mainstream service systems, including schools, employment services, healthcare providers and municipal administrations.
In many countries, existing integration frameworks were adapted at short notice to accommodate large numbers of displaced persons. Governments expanded language training, school capacity, housing support and employment services, often through temporary co‑ordination arrangements bringing together ministries, regional authorities and municipalities that did not normally co‑operate through established integration structures.
At EU level, broader crisis-co‑ordination mechanisms also supported implementation and policy exchange during the crisis. The Integrated Political Crisis Response (IPCR) arrangements facilitated information sharing, political co‑ordination and shared situational awareness between Member States and EU institutions. In parallel, the EU Blueprint Network brought together national authorities to exchange operational experience and discuss challenges related to labour-market integration, skills assessment and access to services for displaced persons. These mechanisms helped support co‑ordination and institutional learning during a period of rapid policy adaptation.
Source: Directive 2001/55/EC on temporary protection; OECD (2022[1]), Rights and Support for Ukrainian Refugees in Receiving Countries.
Box 7.2. Adapting governance from emergency aid to long-term integration in Czechia
Copy link to Box 7.2. Adapting governance from emergency aid to long-term integration in CzechiaFollowing Russia’s full‑scale invasion of Ukraine, Czechia faced an unprecedented and rapid increase in arrivals under temporary protection. With limited recent experience of large‑scale displacement, the initial response relied on emergency arrangements to ensure immediate access to protection, housing and basic services. This required fast decision making, legal flexibility and co‑ordination between national, regional and local levels.
In the early phase, governance structures were largely temporary and operated alongside existing integration systems. Co‑ordination was led by the Ministry of the Interior, while municipalities and regional Integration Centres took on key roles in implementation. Civil society organisations also played an important role, particularly in reception, information provision and case management. Emergency funding, supported in part by EU funds, made it possible to scale up services quickly.
As the situation shifted from immediate response to longer-term settlement, challenges emerged around coherence and sustainability. Temporary protection created parallel access routes to services, raising questions about how these arrangements aligned with mainstream integration systems and responsibilities. This required clarifying roles between emergency structures and standard service provision, particularly at the municipal level. Integrating temporary measures into existing structures became increasingly important.
Over time, governance structures became more institutionalised. Integration Centres and municipalities took on a more central role in co‑ordinating longer-term support, while funding and co‑ordination mechanisms were gradually adjusted to more stable needs. The Czech experience highlights the challenges of integrating emergency arrangements into mainstream governance as displacement situations evolve over time.
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025); OECD (2022[1]), Rights and Support for Ukrainian Refugees in Receiving Countries.
Crisis responses often bypass established procedures and rely on more informal solutions. This can improve speed and flexibility in the short term, but it can make it harder to align policy frameworks, funding structures and implementation responsibilities over time. In federal and highly decentralised systems, an effective crisis response depends on co‑ordination between national, regional and local authorities. This can allow responses to be adapted to local conditions but also means that alignment between different levels of government becomes more challenging and also more important.
As the main actors responsible for delivering integration measures, local authorities are often required to operate both emergency and regular systems at the same time, with different funding rules, reporting requirements and eligibility criteria. This can increase administrative complexity and make it more difficult to ensure consistent service delivery between groups and territories, a challenge particularly visible in countries with strong municipal responsibility such as the Nordic countries, where local authorities are required to manage both emergency and regular systems simultaneously.
Governments often rely on existing networks of civil society organisations to deliver support quickly during periods of pressure, particularly in areas such as housing, language assistance, case management and community outreach. In practice, these organisations often function as an extension of public systems rather than alongside them. This can increase capacity and improve responsiveness, but it also raises questions about co‑ordination, accountability and the sustainability of services once emergency arrangements are withdrawn.
The COVID‑19 pandemic provides another example of how integration governance systems can adapt under pressure. In many OECD countries, integration services were rapidly digitalised, administrative procedures adjusted, and delivery responsibilities shifted towards local and non-governmental actors. Although not all emergency measures were retained some have persisted, particularly digital and hybrid service models. This shows that crises can accelerate changes in delivery mechanisms, even when the underlying governance structures stay the same.
Once pressures ease, governments need to decide whether temporary arrangements should be phased out, aligned with existing systems or developed into more permanent solutions. This transition can be difficult because temporary arrangements may operate under different rules and co‑ordination arrangements than mainstream integration systems and governments may need to clarify responsibilities between temporary and permanent actors. They must also decide whether temporary service structures should be integrated into existing systems or phased out. More broadly, crisis responses can expose co‑ordination gaps or capacity constraints that were less visible under normal conditions.
Similar patterns can also be observed outside Europe. As Colombia’s response to large‑scale Venezuelan displacement shows (see Box 7.3), temporary or emergency arrangements may gradually evolve into longer-term structures as displacement becomes more prolonged and integration needs expand.
Box 7.3. Large scale reception and integration of Venezuelan migrants in Colombia
Copy link to Box 7.3. Large scale reception and integration of Venezuelan migrants in ColombiaOver the past decade, Colombia has faced significant governance challenges associated with becoming the main destination for Venezuelan migrants and refugees in Latin America. This shift has transformed Colombia from a country historically characterised by emigration into a major country of reception, requiring rapid and sustained institutional adaptation.
The initial response focussed on broad regularisation measures to respond to the scale and urgency of arrivals. The Temporary Protection Statute for Venezuelan Migrants granted legal status and access to the labour market for large numbers of people, helping to reduce irregularity and provide a basis for early inclusion. It also established a common registration and identification framework, facilitating access to formal employment and public services.
As displacement has continued, the main governance challenge has moved from access to status toward how to support integration over time, particularly in regions and cities where arrivals are concentrated. This has required expanding the capacity of existing systems for employment, education, health and social services, and strengthening co‑ordination between national frameworks and subnational delivery, although progress has remained uneven and continues to evolve.
Colombia’s experience highlights that frameworks designed for large‑scale reception may need to evolve as governance priorities shift over time. Managing entry at scale and sustaining system capacity over the longer-term place different demands on governance systems and require different policy tools.
7.2. Pilot programmes and experimentation
Copy link to 7.2. Pilot programmes and experimentationMany OECD countries use pilot programmes to test new instruments or delivery models on a limited scale. Unlike emergency measures, which are reactive and time‑critical, pilots are used more deliberately to find out what works and inform future decisions. They are usually time‑limited, targeted at specific groups or locations, and operate within defined administrative or legal settings. Some pilots respond to needs identified during crises. Others are introduced when existing systems are seen as insufficiently effective or flexible, for example in service co‑ordination, access to labour markets or the use of digital tools.
Pilots allow governments to test new approaches without committing to system-wide reform, limiting financial and political risks while gathering information before scaling up. They can also create space for co‑operation between sectors and levels of government, where existing structures make this difficult. The effectiveness of pilots depends on having clear mandates, adequate funding and the ability to monitor and document results.
Pilots are more likely to be sustained and scaled up when they are embedded in existing governance structures rather than operating as standalone projects dependent on temporary funding. In Denmark, for example, pilot approaches are often embedded within a broader performance framework, allowing municipalities to test new approaches while maintaining alignment with national objectives.
Many countries report difficulties in moving beyond the pilot phase. Where pilots are not linked to broader strategies or decision-making processes, successful initiatives may remain isolated or dependent on temporary funding. In other cases, pilots continue beyond their original purpose without a clear decision on whether they should be scaled up, adapted or discontinued, adding to institutional complexity. Estonia provides an example of how pilot initiatives in digital service co‑ordination can gradually become integrated into mainstream integration governance frameworks (see Box 7.4).
Box 7.4. Innovative digital integration governance and service co‑ordination in Estonia
Copy link to Box 7.4. Innovative digital integration governance and service co‑ordination in EstoniaEstonia has a long-standing use of digital governance tools to simplify access to integration services and improve co‑ordination between institutions. The Settle in Estonia programme, introduced in 2015, provides newly arrived migrants with access to language training, orientation modules and practical information through a centralised digital platform. The programme includes thematic modules covering areas such as employment, education and everyday life in Estonia.
In Estonia, digitalisation has increasingly been integrated into broader integration policy. Pilot initiatives have included the Settle in Estonia portal and the Eestis kohanemine event-based service model, which combines information from different state registries to support more personalised integration pathways. Two of these pilot-initiatives have since been integrated into mainstream national integration policy. This process has continued with the launch, in December 2025, of the first phase of the personalised Settling in Estonia event-based service, which brings together information from different public authorities and provides newcomers with personalised guidance and service recommendations based on their individual circumstances.
Local pilot projects in Tallinn are being used to explore how municipalities can be more systematically involved in Estonia’s integration governance framework. Recent efforts have increasingly focussed on providing dedicated capacity-building support to municipalities across the country. Estonia has also expanded flexible learning formats, including e‑learning and blended language training, in response to demographic and labour-market changes. Over time, these initiatives have become an integrated part of Estonia’s broader integration framework.
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025).
Pilot programmes are often initiated by individual ministries, agencies or local authorities, sometimes in partnership with non-governmental actors. They can adapt to local needs and support innovation, but without clearly defined roles and responsibilities, findings may be difficult to connect to broader national objectives or scale up into mainstream systems.
In decentralised systems, locally driven pilots can generate valuable experience, but scaling them up requires co‑ordination between levels of government and integration into national frameworks. In Canada, for example, pilot initiatives are often implemented through funding agreements with service providers, allowing new approaches to be tested within existing funding frameworks.
Financing arrangements shape how pilots are governed and how long they last. Project-based or external funding can make it easier to start new initiatives but can also create uncertainty about sustainability and make it difficult to retain knowledge once funding ends. Deliberate choices about funding arrangements are therefore part of governing experimentation well, not just a technical detail.
Overall, pilot programmes provide an important way for integration systems to adapt under uncertainty. They allow governments to test new solutions while limiting risk. However, the contribution of pilot programmes to long-term adaptability depends on whether the lessons they generate are captured and used. Pilots that are clearly defined, time‑limited and linked to decision making processes are more likely to lead to lasting change than those that remain isolated or disconnected from broader systems. The next section examines how institutional learning mechanisms support this process.
7.3. Institutional learning mechanisms
Copy link to 7.3. Institutional learning mechanismsCrises and pilot initiatives often generate new practices, but these do not automatically become part of regular governance systems. Whether systems actually learn depends on whether experience is documented, assessed and used to adjust existing policy and governance frameworks.
This remains uneven across OECD countries. Many systems still lack structured processes for documenting experience and using it systematically to adjust policies. In many cases, emergency arrangements and pilot initiatives end once pressures ease or funding expires. When this happens without structured review, valuable experience may be lost, and systems may revert to previous arrangements without resolving co‑ordination gaps or capacity constraints exposed during the crisis.
Several governance tools can support institutional learning. One is the use of formal evaluation and reporting requirements linked to emergency measures or pilot programmes. Where initiatives have clear objectives, timelines and documentation requirements, governments are better able to assess whether they should be integrated into mainstream systems, adapted, or discontinued. Where experimentation takes place through ad hoc projects or informal arrangements, decisions about next steps are often more fragmented or delayed. This also reflects broader patterns identified in monitoring and evaluation systems (see Chapter 5), where data collection is not always systematically linked to policy adjustment or institutional change.
A second area concerns co‑ordination and knowledge transfer between institutions and levels of government. Standing inter-ministerial bodies, multi-level co‑ordination platforms, and permanent advisory structures can help retain institutional memory and ensure that experiences from crises or pilots inform future reforms. In decentralised systems, mechanisms that support exchange between municipalities or regions are particularly important, as they allow locally generated knowledge to be shared and reduce duplication. Without such channels, learning may remain confined to individual organisations or projects. In some cases, experiences from repeated crises have also led to broader institutional reforms. At the EU level, the Pact on Migration and Asylum reflects efforts to strengthen preparedness and information-sharing within migration governance.
Institutional learning is also shaped by how responsibilities are organised once emergency conditions subside. Transitions from temporary to longer-term arrangements can be difficult where mandates are unclear or when emergency responses rely heavily on actors outside regular governance systems. If responsibilities are not clearly reassigned, temporary solutions may continue alongside existing systems. This can increase complexity and make it harder to integrate lessons into regular governance systems. Clear decisions about who takes responsibility once emergency arrangements end are therefore central to institutional learning.
In practice, structural factors often limit institutional learning. High staff turnover, reliance on short-term funding and frequent changes in institutional responsibilities can weaken institutional memory. In crisis situations, administrative capacity is often focussed on immediate operational needs, leaving limited scope for documentation, reflection or evaluation. As a result, learning may remain fragmented rather than systemic, and opportunities to strengthen governance systems can be missed.
7.3.1. International learning and policy exchange
Learning processes are also shaped by exchanges beyond national governance systems and administrative structures. A range of international networks at the OECD, EU and other international fora provide structured spaces for exchange between governments, joint problem solving and the sharing of practical experience, complementing national evaluation and co‑ordination mechanisms. Although such exchanges take place continuously, they tend to become particularly important during periods of rapid change or crisis. The COVID‑19 pandemic and the arrival of displaced persons following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine increased the need for rapid information-sharing and operational co‑ordination between countries and levels of government.
At both OECD and EU level, policy networks facilitate learning by enabling discussion of common challenges, including capacity constraints, service co‑ordination and adaptation under uncertainty. Unlike international data-sharing frameworks, which primarily support transparency and comparability, these networks focus more directly on practical experience and shared policy challenges. Learning and adaptation can also be supported through broader international review and benchmarking frameworks that connect integration-related challenges to wider economic and social policy discussions (see Box 7.5).
Box 7.5. The European Semester and integration governance
Copy link to Box 7.5. The European Semester and integration governanceThe European Semester is the European Union’s main framework for co‑ordinating economic, employment and social policies between Member States. Through country reports, country-specific recommendations and monitoring of national reforms, it supports policy co‑ordination, benchmarking and mutual learning across a broad range of policy areas.
Although integration is the responsibility of the Member States and migrant integration is not a standalone component of the Semester, integration-related challenges feature in discussions on labour-market participation, skills, education, housing, social inclusion and public-service capacity.
Similar dynamics can also be observed in OECD Economic Surveys and related country reviews, where integration-related challenges appear in discussions on labour-market performance, skills and social inclusion. More detailed analysis of integration governance is also carried out in OECD country reviews and thematic publications, particularly through, for example, the OECD’s Working Together series on selected member countries.
Findings and recommendations emerging from these frameworks could be taken more systematically into account in national integration governance frameworks and policy co‑ordination processes.
By making experience from other countries easier to access and reducing uncertainty around policy change, international networks can help governments adapt policies and respond more quickly to new challenges. They may also help preserve institutional memory through continued exchange and documentation. International policy networks can therefore complement national co‑ordination and learning arrangements. Institutional learning does not happen automatically. It depends on deliberate governance choices, including investment in evaluation capacity, co‑ordination structures that extend beyond crisis periods, and procedures that link experience to policy development. Where such mechanisms are in place, integration governance systems are generally better able to adapt over time without losing coherence or accountability.
7.4. Key takeaways – building resilient integration governance
Copy link to 7.4. Key takeaways – building resilient integration governanceHow well integration governance functions has a direct impact on the lives of migrants, refugees as well as on the communities that receive them. With responsibilities that are clearly defined, co‑ordination that reaches the relevant actors, financing that supports continuity, and monitoring systems that provide timely information, integration systems can adapt to changing conditions without missing key target groups or becoming difficult to sustain over time.
At the same time, strong governance cannot compensate for weak policy design. Even well-functioning systems may struggle to deliver sustained outcomes when policy objectives or instruments do not reflect practical realities, such as housing shortages, labour-market barriers or unequal access to services. Frequent shifts in integration objectives driven by short-term political pressures rather than longer-term implementation needs can also weaken outcomes over time. Strengthening how governance arrangements function in practice is therefore central both for current outcomes and for how well systems can respond to future pressures.
References
[3] OECD (2025), International Migration Outlook 2025, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/ae26c893-en.
[2] OECD (2024), International Migration Outlook 2024, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/50b0353e-en.
[1] OECD (2022), Rights and Support for Ukrainian Refugees in Receiving Countries, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/09beb886-en.