How can co‑ordination between national, regional and local authorities be strengthened to support coherent and effective integration policies? This chapter explores the mechanisms that support both vertical co‑ordination between levels of government and horizontal co‑ordination between different ministries, agencies and policy fields.
2. Aligning national, regional, and local integration efforts
Copy link to 2. Aligning national, regional, and local integration effortsAbstract
Integration policy is rarely delivered by a single institution. A newly arrived migrant may learn the national language through one provider, receive employment support from another authority, access housing through municipal services and rely on schools, health services or civil society organisations for everyday support. Integration outcomes in these areas are often interrelated, meaning that barriers in one area may create disadvantages in others, including labour-market participation and educational outcomes. (OECD, 2023[1]).
In most OECD countries, national authorities set overall direction while regional and local actors adapt policy to local conditions and deliver services that shape migrants’ everyday lives. This means that effective integration governance relies on the ability of national, regional and local authorities to work together in a coherent and predictable way.
This creates two related co‑ordination challenges: aligning responsibilities between levels of government (vertical co‑ordination) and ensuring coherence across different policy sectors (horizontal co‑ordination). These challenges are often described through the concept of multi-level governance, defined as the dispersion of authority between different interacting levels of government, requiring co‑ordination mechanisms to align objectives and implementation (Hooghe and Marks, 2003[2]).
Research on integration governance also shows that co‑ordination is not always linear or hierarchical. Local authorities may adapt, complement or, at times, diverge from national policies to respond to practical needs (Zapata-Barrero, Caponio and Scholten, 2017[3]). These patterns reflect a broader shift, with cities and regions having an increasingly active role in shaping integration, particularly in areas such as service delivery and community-level support. This means that local implementation may diverge from national approaches as authorities adapt policies to local conditions and service needs.
Co‑ordination is therefore not only about aligning responsibilities. It also involves managing differences between levels of government so that local adaptation does not undermine overall policy coherence. In addition, formal institutional arrangements do not determine implementation outcomes on their own. Administrative capacity, organisational routines and the role of public officials also affect how policies are interpreted and co‑ordinated in practice. In multi-level systems, operational decisions taken by ministries, municipalities and frontline agencies can influence how national objectives are translated into local implementation (Caponio and Borkert, 2025[4]).
This chapter examines how OECD countries respond to these challenges by looking at how national authorities steer and co‑ordinate policy, how responsibilities are distributed across levels of government and policy areas, and which tools are used to connect policy design with implementation.
2.1. National responsibility for integration policy
Copy link to 2.1. National responsibility for integration policyResponsibilities for integration policy are shared between levels of government, but the balance between national direction and local implementation varies considerably between OECD countries. These differences reflect institutional traditions, administrative systems and the way migration policy has evolved nationally. Table 2.1 provides an overview of the central co‑ordinating bodies and co‑ordination mechanisms reported by OECD countries. Despite these differences, four broad organisational models can be identified, each with implications for co‑ordination, accountability and policy coherence. The rest of this section describes these models.
Table 2.1. Formal co‑ordination mechanisms for integration governance
Copy link to Table 2.1. Formal co‑ordination mechanisms for integration governance|
Country |
Central co‑ordinating body |
National – subnational co‑ordination |
Advisory/consultative body |
Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Australia |
Department of Home Affairs |
Federal – state/territory – local co‑ordination through SOSOG, the Senior Officials Settlement Outcomes Group |
Ministerial Forum on Multicultural Affairs; SOSOG |
Highly structured settlement co‑ordination system |
|
Austria |
Federal Chancellery (Minister for Europe, Integration and Family); ÖIF, Austrian Integration Fund operational |
National – regional (Länder) co‑ordination with municipal implementation |
Advisory Committee on Integration |
Integration Act defines responsibilities; Länder retain autonomy |
|
Belgium |
No single co‑ordinating body; regions and communities lead |
Regional/community co‑ordination with municipal implementation |
Regional bodies (e.g. Walloon Observatory; COCOM Brussels) |
Highly decentralised governance structure. Integration is a regional competence. |
|
Bulgaria |
National Council on Migration, Borders, Asylum and Integration |
National Association of Municipalities represented in the National Council |
National Council on Migration, Borders, Asylum and Integration |
|
|
Canada |
Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) |
Federal – provincial/territorial co‑ordination with municipal involvement through Local Immigration Partnerships (where applicable) |
Forum of Ministers Responsible for Immigration |
Quebec has special autonomy under the 1991 Canada-Quebec Accord |
|
Chile |
National Migration Service (SERMIG) |
National, regional and local co‑ordination through the Regional Management Model |
Interministerial Advisory Committee |
Coordination structured through the national migration policy framework |
|
Czechia |
Ministry of Interior (Department for Asylum and Migration Policy) |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through Integration Centers and municipalities |
Coordination Committee on Integration |
Major cities have developed local integration policies |
|
Denmark |
Ministry of Immigration and Integration |
National – local co‑ordination through municipalities under the Integration Act |
National Integration Council |
Municipalities have primary implementation responsibility |
|
Estonia |
Ministry of Culture (integration); cross-ministerial steering |
National – local co‑ordination with no regional tier |
Cohesive Estonia steering committee |
Tallinn provides additional local integration services. Recent policy developments also focus on strengthening municipal capacity across Estonia. |
|
Finland |
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment (KEHA, ELY Centers) |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through ELY Centers and municipalities |
Advisory Board for Ethnic Relations (ETNO) |
Municipalities have legal autonomy |
|
France |
OFII and Ministry of Interior (DGEF) |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through prefectures and departments |
No dedicated advisory body |
Strong central steering through prefectural system |
|
Germany |
Federal Ministry of Interior; BAMF operational |
Federal – Länder – municipal co‑ordination |
Conference of Integration Ministers |
Highly decentralised design and implementation |
|
Greece |
Directorate of Social Integration (Ministry of Migration and Asylum) |
National – regional co‑ordination through HELIOS+ and local partnerships |
No dedicated advisory body |
Implementation relies strongly on civil society organisations and IOs |
|
Hungary |
Ministry of Interior |
National – local co‑ordination with voluntary municipal involvement |
No dedicated advisory body |
Integration governance weakly institutionalised |
|
Iceland |
Ministry of Social Affairs and Housing |
National – local co‑ordination with no regional tier |
Immigration Council for project funding |
Municipal autonomy in service delivery |
|
Ireland |
Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration |
National – local co‑ordination through Local Authority Integration Teams and Community Integration Fora |
National Co‑ordination Team (LGMA) |
Local authorities develop local integration strategies |
|
Israel |
Ministry of Aliyah and Integration |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through ministry districts and municipalities |
Knesset Committee on Aliyah and Integration |
|
|
Italy |
Ministry of Labour and Social Policy and Ministry of Interior |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through regions and municipalities |
Interministerial committees; Territorial Councils for Immigration |
Regions retain strong competences |
|
Japan |
Immigration Services Agency; Cabinet Secretariat (co‑ordination) |
National – local co‑ordination with limited regional autonomy |
Ministerial Council on the Acceptance of Foreign Nationals and the Realization of a Society of Well-Ordered and Harmonious Coexistence |
Highly centralised co‑ordination model |
|
Korea |
Ministry of Justice; Korea Immigration Service |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through the Immigration Policy Commission |
Immigration Policy Commission, chaired by the Prime Minister; working committees |
Strong legal basis in Framework Act.. |
|
Latvia |
Ministry of Culture and Society Integration Foundation |
National – local co‑ordination with significant municipal variation |
No dedicated advisory body |
|
|
Lithuania |
Ministry of Social Security and Labour |
National – regional – local co‑ordination involving municipalities and civil society organisations |
Government Commission on Integration |
Municipalities adapt measures locally |
|
Luxembourg |
Ministry of Family Affairs, Solidarity, Living Together and Reception (MFSVA) |
National – local co‑ordination through communes and the Gemengepakt framework |
High Council for Intercultural Living-Together |
Law of 23 August 2023 defines governance framework |
|
Netherlands |
Ministry of Social Affairs and Employment |
National – local co‑ordination through municipalities implementing the Civic Integration Act |
No dedicated advisory body |
Municipal autonomy within national legislation |
|
New Zealand |
Immigration New Zealand (MBIE) |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through Regional Refugee Steering Groups |
Senior Officials’ Group; Refugee Advisory Panel |
Strong local – national partnership model |
|
Norway |
Ministry of Labour and Social Inclusion; IMDi |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through counties and municipalities |
No dedicated advisory body |
Regional responsibilities expanded in 2021 |
|
Poland |
Department of Social Integration (Ministry of Family, Labour and Social Policy) |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through voivodes, marshals and municipalities |
Interministerial Team for Migration |
Major cities have developed advanced local policies |
|
Portugal |
Agency for Integration, Migration and Asylum (AIMA) |
National-regional-local co‑ordination through municipalities, inter-municipal communities and local integration support networks |
National Council for Migration and Asylum (CNMA) |
AIMA co‑ordinates integration, migration and asylum policies across levels of government. |
|
Romania |
General Inspectorate for Immigration (IGI, Ministry of Internal Affairs) |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through prefectures, county agencies and municipalities |
No dedicated advisory body beyond EU project committees |
IGI co‑ordinates AMIF funding and monitoring |
|
Slovenia |
Ministry of Interior; Office for the Support and Integration of Migrants |
National – local co‑ordination with voluntary municipal initiatives |
Informal co‑ordination groups |
AMIF co-funding plays a central role |
|
Spain |
Ministry of Inclusion, Social Security and Migration |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through autonomous communities and municipalities |
Sectoral Conference on Immigration |
Strong regional competences in social policy |
|
Sweden |
Ministry of Education; Public Employment Service |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through County Administrative Boards |
No dedicated advisory body |
Agency-based co‑ordination model |
|
Switzerland |
State Secretariat for Migration (SEM) |
Federal – cantonal – municipal co‑ordination |
Swiss Conference of Integration Delegates |
Cantons retain strong autonomy |
|
Türkiye |
Presidency of Migration Management (PMM) |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through provinces, governorates and municipalities |
PMM co‑ordination structures; technical working groups |
|
|
United Kingdom |
No single co‑ordinating body; Home Office leads migration policy |
National – regional – local co‑ordination through devolved administrations and local authorities |
No dedicated advisory body |
No overarching national integration strategy |
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025).
2.1.1. Single national lead ministry or agency
OECD countries differ not only in the level of government responsible for integration policy, but also in the degree of institutional specialisation. Some countries have established dedicated integration agencies or authorities with operational responsibility for integration policy, while others locate responsibility within mainstream ministries such as labour, interior or social affairs ministries. Many countries combine elements of both approaches.
In the most common model, a single national ministry or agency co‑ordinates integration policy. This can strengthen accountability and provide other ministries and levels of government with a stable point of contact. In some countries, responsibility is assigned to a dedicated integration or migration ministry or agency with an explicit mandate for integration policy. This can increase the visibility of integration within government and help build specialised expertise and institutional relationships over time.
Countries using this model include Denmark, where the Ministry of Immigration and Integration develops national policy while municipalities deliver introduction programmes and language and employment support under national legislation. Israel has a more centralised variant, with overarching responsibility held by the Ministry of Aliyah and Integration. The ministry’s mandate focusses on Jewish immigrants and returning Jewish residents under the Law of Return and combines policy steering with direct responsibility for reception and integration measures. Implementation is supported by a nationwide network of regional and local offices that deliver services directly and work with municipalities and other public bodies.
In other countries, integration policy is co‑ordinated through a sectoral ministry, such as interior, labour or social affairs, linking integration more closely to broader policy areas, which can support mainstreaming but may also increase the need for co‑ordination. Australia provides an example of this approach, where the Department of Home Affairs provides strategic direction in close co‑operation with states, territories and contracted service providers. Variations of this model are also found in several other OECD countries, although the balance between national steering and local implementation differs considerably.
Dedicated integration authorities often combine policy co‑ordination with functions such as programme delivery, funding management, monitoring or data collection. Dedicated authorities are particularly common in countries where integration policy has evolved into a distinct policy field with its own operational infrastructure, such as the Office français de l’immigration et de l’intégration (OFII) in France, the Agency for Integration, Migration and Asylum (AIMA) in Portugal and the National Migration Service (SERMIG) in Chile. Countries where integration responsibilities remain embedded within mainstream ministries often rely more on interministerial and intergovernmental co‑ordination mechanisms to align integration objectives across policy areas. These different arrangements reflect broader administrative traditions rather than a single preferred model of integration governance.
2.1.2. Shared national responsibility between multiple ministries
A second group of countries distribute national integration responsibilities between several national ministries, reflecting the fact that integration policies involve employment, education, health, housing, social services and migration. This allows sectoral expertise to inform policy and helps ensure that integration is not treated as a standalone policy area, making it easier to embed integration objectives into mainstream institutions and services.
At the same time, it increases co‑ordination demands. When responsibilities are divided between multiple actors without clear co‑ordination, systems may face duplication, inconsistent delivery or gaps in support. Because integration involves many policy fields, these co‑ordination challenges can be particularly pronounced. The risk of fragmentation has been identified in research on multi-level governance integration systems, especially where responsibilities are shared between institutions and levels of government without strong co‑ordination mechanisms or clearly aligned objectives (OECD, 2018[5]) (Scholten, 2012[6]).
In Germany, integration responsibilities are shared between the Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community, the Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs and other sectoral ministries at federal level. Implementation largely takes place at Länder level, combining shared ministerial co‑ordination with significant decentralisation in practice. Italy similarly involves multiple ministries, including Interior, Labour, Education and Health ministries, alongside important roles for regions and municipalities. In Czechia, responsibilities are also distributed across multiple ministries, with funding for integration measures provided through interior, education and labour portfolios, co‑ordinated locally through municipalities and regional integration centres.
2.1.3. Dedicated co‑ordination bodies
In some countries, shared ministerial responsibility is brought together through dedicated national co‑ordination bodies established specifically to facilitate co‑ordination between ministries and, in some cases, between national and subnational authorities. These bodies support a whole‑of-government approach in a policy area that depends on alignment between sectors.
In some countries, co‑ordination is supported by dedicated ministers, state secretaries, commissioners or specialised bodies with mandates that extend across sectors. Portugal’s former High Commission for Migration introduced a model where integration co‑ordination was organised through a dedicated cross-sectoral body that worked with ministries, municipalities and civil-society organisations. Access to central decision-making structures, including the prime minister’s office or cabinet-level co‑ordination mechanisms, may strengthen the ability to align integration priorities between ministries. This can be particularly important because integration policy often depends on co‑operation between sectors that are not formally under the same authority.
Chile’s National Migration Service SERMIG serves as the central co‑ordinating body for integration policy. Its work is supported by an Interministerial Advisory Committee that monitors the National Policy on Migration and Integration and brings together relevant ministries for joint implementation. Switzerland has also established structured co‑ordination arrangements. The State Secretariat for Migration works closely with cantonal and municipal integration delegates, providing a stable point of contact between federal direction and subnational implementation.
2.1.4. Decentralised or regional governance
Finally, in a few countries there is no national institution that holds overall responsibility for integration policy, usually because the competence lies with subnational governments. In these cases, the national level provides only limited or programme‑specific co‑ordination. In Belgium integration governance is fully decentralised by constitutional design, with Regions and Communities responsible for integration policy and delivery. This results in structurally different frameworks in Flanders, Wallonia, Brussels and the German-speaking Community, supported by an Interministerial Conference that facilitates co‑ordination between levels. The United Kingdom also lacks a national integration authority. Integration is led independently by the devolved administrations in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, while in England co‑ordination occurs through ad‑hoc, programme‑specific arrangements rather than permanent structures.
Where national co‑ordination arrangements exist, they can help maintain consistency in a policy area involving many sectors and actors. In more decentralised systems, integration frameworks are shaped primarily at regional or local level. Responsibilities may also shift over time as governments reorganise ministerial portfolios or create new co‑ordination arrangements in response to changing policy priorities.
2.2. Implementation at different levels of government
Copy link to 2.2. Implementation at different levels of governmentBecause integration policies are defined at national level but implemented through a wide range of institutions and administrative systems at national, regional and local level, the way responsibilities are shared between levels of government is central to integration governance functions in practice. National authorities generally set overall direction, legal frameworks and funding arrangements, while regional and local authorities play a key role in translating these frameworks into institutional practices and concrete actions.
This includes not only the implementation of measures targeted at migrants, but also the adaptation and co‑ordination of mainstream administrative systems and procedures. For example, co‑ordination may involve population registers, tax and social security authorities, employment services and public information platforms, so that national rules are applied consistently, information is coherent between institutions, and responsibilities can be exercised effectively between levels of government. In practice, this also requires co‑ordination between mainstream public services such as schools, employment services, housing authorities and healthcare providers, which often operate under different administrative rules and funding structures.
2.2.1. Centralised implementation
In some countries, implementation remains largely centralised. National agencies are responsible for delivering key measures such as language programmes, civic‑orientation courses or certain forms of employment support. France and Greece are notable examples of predominantly centralised delivery. In France, for example, OFII operates through a network of territorial offices responsible for implementing the Contrat d’Intégration Républicaine. In Greece, central ministries and international organisations deliver the core components of the integration programme. Delivery is typically organised through regional or local offices and accredited providers, allowing nationally defined programmes to be implemented consistently across the country while maintaining uniform standards.
Centralised implementation can help maintain consistent access and uniform standards across the country. This is particularly important when measures are closely linked to conditions for residence or benefits, because nationally defined legal requirements and eligibility rules must be applied consistently in all regions. A key limitation is that centralised systems may have less flexibility to tailor interventions to local labour‑market conditions or migrant populations.
2.2.2. Municipal delivery and local adaptation
In many OECD countries, implementation is delegated to municipalities. This is particularly common in the Nordic countries. In Denmark, Finland and Norway, municipalities organise introduction programmes, language training and labour‑market measures. National authorities set objectives and funding frameworks, while municipalities adapt service delivery to local conditions. Local delivery can make measures more relevant and easier to access, but it works well only when municipalities receive predictable funding and clear guidance to support consistency between regions. Switzerland follows a cantonal delivery model, in which cantons and municipalities deliver integration activities under federal – cantonal programme agreements. Local authorities also play an important role in Ireland and New Zealand. In Ireland, local authorities co‑ordinate integration plans and receive funding through national programmes such as the Social Inclusion and Community Activation Programme (SICAP), which supports disadvantaged individuals and communities through local development structures, including measures relevant to migrant integration. In New Zealand, the Welcoming Communities programme provides initial central funding to help municipalities build integration capacity. Over time, responsibility for continuing and financing these activities shifts to local authorities, which integrate them into regular service provision and local planning frameworks.
2.2.3. Federal and regional systems
Federal and highly decentralised countries follow a different pattern. In Belgium, integration competences rest primarily with regions and language communities. Germany combines federal legislation with Länder‑level strategies and municipal delivery. Switzerland relies heavily on cantonal structures, and in Spain, autonomous communities have legislative powers in social policy and are responsible for organising and delivering most integration services. In practice, these structures facilitate regional adaptation but depend on strong co‑ordination mechanisms to maintain overall coherence.
2.3. Subnational autonomy and role in policy design
Copy link to 2.3. Subnational autonomy and role in policy designRegional and local authorities also contribute to the design of integration policy, although the extent of this involvement varies. In OECD countries, the degree of autonomy granted to regional and local authorities varies widely, ranging from extensive design and implementation powers to highly centralised systems where local discretion is limited. Importantly, implementation responsibility and design autonomy do not always align. In several countries, local actors can both design and implement integration measures. In others their role is largely limited to implementing nationally defined programmes. Table 2.2 summarises reported differences in the degree of autonomy granted to regional and local authorities in the design and implementation of integration measures.
Table 2.2. Subnational autonomy in integration governance in OECD countries
Copy link to Table 2.2. Subnational autonomy in integration governance in OECD countries|
Autonomy level |
Characteristics |
Countries |
|---|---|---|
|
High autonomy |
Subnational authorities play a role in both policy design and implementation. |
Belgium, Switzerland, Canada, Spain. |
|
Moderate autonomy |
Subnational authorities primarily implement measures but can adapt delivery to local circumstances. |
Germany, the Netherlands, Estonia, Lithuania, Sweden, Portugal. |
|
Low autonomy |
Subnational authorities mainly implement nationally defined measures and have limited discretion. |
France, Greece, Japan, Korea, Hungary, Croatia. |
Note: Examples are illustrative and do not capture all institutional differences.
Source: OECD questionnaire on integration governance (2025).
In federal and highly decentralised systems, regions often hold formal responsibilities for both design and implementation. Belgian regions define their own strategies. Spain’s autonomous communities develop regional plans within national frameworks. German Länder adopt their own integration concepts to complement federal rules, and Swiss cantons develop and deliver integration measures within national – cantonal programme agreements. In Canada, most provincial and territorial governments also fund some settlement support for newcomers in addition to the federal Settlement Programme. They are also consulted extensively on the federal Settlement Programme. Portugal provides an example of substantial local autonomy despite operating within a nationally co‑ordinated framework. Municipalities can develop integration measures tailored to local circumstances through Municipal Plans for the Integration of Migrants, provided these remain consistent with national legislation. In some municipalities, local social-network platforms bring together public authorities, civil-society organisations and other actors to identify priorities and develop migrant-focussed initiatives.
In more centralised systems, regional and local authorities may not have legislative powers but can still influence policy development in informal or consultative ways such as participation in national – local co‑ordination platforms, structured consultations during strategy development, feedback mechanisms linked to implementation, or pilot programmes whose results inform national reforms. These mechanisms help ensure that national frameworks reflect local conditions, but they also increase the need for co‑ordination to maintain coherence within the system. In some more centrally governed countries municipalities deliver nationally defined measures but have limited autonomy to adapt programmes locally. This pattern is observed for example in Korea, where municipalities are responsible for implementation but have limited influence over programme design.
2.4. Co‑ordination instruments
Copy link to 2.4. Co‑ordination instrumentsA clear division of responsibilities is important, but it is only the starting point. Effective integration governance also requires practical ways for different parts of government to work together. As national, regional and local authorities may interpret or adapt policies differently, co‑ordination mechanisms are needed to manage these differences and maintain overall coherence. In OECD countries, these co‑ordination instruments take different forms, including inter‑ministerial committees, multi‑level co‑ordination platforms and structured co‑operation between central, regional and local authorities. These tools support both co‑ordination between ministries and co‑ordination between levels of government.
Co‑ordination is not only required between ministries and levels of government but also within local implementation systems. Because integration measures are delivered through multiple services at local level, municipalities often develop their own local co‑ordination arrangements to align employment services, education providers, social services and other actors. These local mechanisms complement national governance structures and are essential for translating policy into coherent service delivery.
2.4.1. Horizontal co‑ordination between ministries and agencies
At national level, most countries use formal inter-ministerial committees or working groups to bring together relevant ministries to discuss priorities, respond to cross‑cutting issues and ensure that sectoral policies support shared integration objectives. They typically cover areas such as employment, education, health and housing. These arrangements differ in form, but they serve a similar function: to ensure that integration policy is not confined to a single ministry, but is taken into account between sectors, so that co‑ordination is organised in a structured way and policies reach the whole population.
Examples vary in structure. Austria has an Advisory Committee on Integration. Italy uses inter-ministerial bodies alongside provincial Territorial Councils for Immigration. Korea’s Immigration Policy Commission is chaired by the Prime Minister. Finland has a Co‑operation Group for the Promotion of Immigrant Integration, led by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment. Chile established an Inter-ministerial Advisory Committee in 2024 to support implementation of its national policy. Japan co‑ordinates through a central unit in the Cabinet Secretariat, which helps align decisions between the ministries responsible for labour, interior affairs, education and social policy.
In other countries, co‑ordination is less formal. Germany relies on regular Bund – Länder meetings and the Conference of Integration Ministers, which bring together senior officials to respond to shared priorities. Sweden’s Ministry of Education convenes national agencies periodically to co‑ordinate integration-related work. These approaches are not always anchored in legislation, but they still help reduce fragmentation through regular administrative routines.
2.4.2. Vertical co‑ordination between levels of government
Co‑ordination instruments also support collaboration between national, regional and local authorities. This reflects the fact that national governments define frameworks, while implementation often takes place at subnational levels. Instruments range from formal agreements and committees to more flexible dialogue platforms.
Switzerland provides a structured example. Multi-year programme agreements between the federal government and cantons define objectives, funding and reporting requirements, while allowing cantons a high degree of autonomy. Portugal supports co‑ordination through a network of Local Support Centres for the Integration of Migrants (CLAIM), operated by municipalities and other local partners in co‑operation with AIMA. The network provides a practical link between national integration structures and local implementation. In the Netherlands, national ministries meet regularly with the Association of the Netherlands Municipalities to discuss implementation issues and adjust guidance. Spain uses national – regional platforms to align measures taken by autonomous communities with national priorities.
Australia co‑ordinates between levels of government through the Ministerial Forum on Multicultural Affairs and supporting officials’ groups. Italy combines national co‑ordination with regional and provincial structures, including Territorial Councils for Immigration. New Zealand links national co‑ordination with regional steering groups to support alignment between strategy and local delivery. In Canada, the federal government collaborates with provinces and territories multilaterally via the Forum of Ministers Responsible for Immigration, and bilaterally via Settlement Memoranda of Understanding (MOUs) to align respective programming in an effort to minimise gaps and duplication.
These mechanisms differ in formality, but they serve a common purpose: to ensure that local implementation remains connected to national objectives. Co‑ordination is also important over time, as individuals move between programmes and services, particularly when responsibilities shift between institutions or levels of government. Even where mandates are clearly defined, institutions may lack incentives or formal responsibilities to align their activities. As responsibilities change, existing co‑ordination arrangements may not adapt at the same pace, increasing the risk of gaps between services or policy areas.
Not all countries have formal or institutionalised co‑ordination mechanisms. In the United Kingdom, co‑ordination at national level is largely programme‑based, while regional administrations operate their own systems independently. Croatia and Hungary also report limited formal co‑ordination between ministries or levels of government. In such cases, integration governance may remain more fragmented, as there is no stable mechanism linking actors within the system.
In practice, countries rarely rely on a single mechanism. Formal bodies help align policy direction, dialogue platforms support information-sharing, and programme agreements or planning cycles provide predictability for subnational actors. The way these tools are combined and used influences how well integration systems function in practice.
Co‑ordination instruments also need to adapt, as countries adjust institutional structures or respond to new policy priorities. Several countries, including Chile, Ireland and Lithuania, have recently strengthened or restructured their co‑ordination mechanisms. In some cases, co‑ordination is supported by digital tools that facilitate information-sharing and monitoring, such as Switzerland’s ELSI platform, which supports information exchange between integration actors, or Latvia’s Integration Measures Database, which tracks integration measures and their implementation. The wider role of digital tools is discussed in chapter 5.
Co‑ordination mechanisms may also operate above the national level. In the European Union, the EU Action Plan on Integration and Inclusion 2021‑2027 provides a framework for policy co‑ordination, funding and exchange between Member States. Although responsibility for integration policy remains national, these frameworks support Member States through funding instruments, peer learning and implementation guidance (see Box 2.1).
Box 2.1. EU frameworks supporting integration governance and co‑ordination
Copy link to Box 2.1. EU frameworks supporting integration governance and co‑ordinationThe European Union supports its Member States through funding, policy exchange and co‑ordination frameworks, while integration policy remains the responsibility of the Member States.
The EU Action Plan on Integration and Inclusion 2021‑2027 provides a framework for strengthening co‑ordination across policy areas and levels of government. The Action Plan promotes a cross-sectoral approach linking integration to employment, education, housing, health and social inclusion policies. It also encourages co‑operation between national authorities, regional and local governments, civil society organisations and social partners. A mid-term review published in 2025 highlighted progress in implementation but also pointed to continuing governance challenges, including co‑ordination between levels of government and the need to strengthen partnerships with local actors and civil society. The Action Plan supports Member States through:
policy co‑ordination and exchange of practices between Member States.
financial support through instruments such as the Asylum, Migration and Integration Fund and the European Social Fund Plus. (see Chapter 4).
support for multi-level partnerships and local implementation capacity.
More recently, the EU Pact on Migration and Asylum has introduced a stronger focus on preparedness, co‑ordination and implementation capacity. Although the Pact primarily concerns asylum and migration management, it also places greater emphasis on early integration and inclusion, particularly for applicants for, and beneficiaries of, international protection. Recent reforms strengthen access to integration related support, including labour market participation, language learning and civic orientation, and reinforce the links between reception, asylum and longer-term integration policies.
The implementation of the Pact is expected to affect integration governance through increased co‑ordination requirements, stronger monitoring and reporting obligations, and greater emphasis on reception and contingency planning.
The implications are nevertheless likely to vary between countries. Existing governance structures, administrative capacity and co‑ordination arrangements differ considerably across EU Member States, which may influence how EU-level frameworks are implemented in practice.
Source: European Commission (2020), Action Plan on Integration and Inclusion 2021‑2027; European Commission (2025), Mid-term Review of the Action Plan on Integration and Inclusion 2021‑2027; European Union (2024), Pact on Migration and Asylum.
2.5. Institutional stability and governance change
Copy link to 2.5. Institutional stability and governance changeInstitutional arrangements for integration change over time. These shifts occur when governments adjust ministerial portfolios, update political priorities, re‑organise administrative structures or respond to new migration patterns. As responsibilities move between ministries or are re‑allocated to different levels of government, these shifts may in some cases reflect efforts to link integration more closely with specific policy fields such as employment, education, housing or social services, or to strengthen co‑ordination within the system.
Such re‑organisations bring both benefits and risks. They can strengthen co‑ordination between policy areas, increase the visibility of integration within government, or align responsibilities more closely with the policy instruments needed for implementation. But institutional change can also interrupt established routines, create uncertainty about who does what and weaken institutional memory. Because integration policy depends on co‑operation between ministries and levels of government, disruptions to these relationships can have direct implications for implementation.
National reforms can also significantly reshape local room for manoeuvre even within systems with strong municipal autonomy. Municipalities may retain responsibility for implementation, but with less flexibility over priorities, timing or settlement arrangements.
Countries with stable co‑ordination mechanisms generally manage transitions more smoothly. Chile, Japan and Switzerland make use of formal bodies that continue operating even when responsibilities shift, helping ensure continuity during administrative change. Several Nordic countries highlight that municipalities value predictable national guidance and stable funding rules during reforms. In federal systems such as Germany and Switzerland, clearly defined legal mandates and established national – regional relationships help prevent unintended consequences when responsibilities change at one level of government. Other recent reforms include Ireland’s creation of a cross‑government Strategic Migration Policy Group in 2024 and Lithuania’s effort to strengthen co‑ordination between migrant reception, labour-market integration and municipal service delivery. In Canada and Belgium, responsibilities are periodically reallocated between federal and regional authorities, but long-standing intergovernmental arrangements help support continuity during these transitions.
Maintaining institutional memory is also critical. Integration policy relies on long‑standing co‑operation and practical experience that can be difficult to rebuild once lost. Some countries maintain continuity through standing working groups, documented guidance and shared data systems. Switzerland’s network of cantonal and municipal integration delegates provides a consistent point of contact with the federal level. Norway’s Directorate of Integration and Diversity has maintained leadership through several ministerial re‑organisations. Australia’s multiyear agreements and established federal – state platforms likewise help sustain implementation despite periodic administrative adjustments.
Stable governance frameworks, predictable procedures and clear communication can help systems adapt to new demands without losing coherence. This is particularly important in multi-level systems, where changes at one level of government can affect implementation practices and responsibilities elsewhere in the system.
2.6. Key takeaways
Copy link to 2.6. Key takeawaysNational responsibility for integration policy varies between OECD countries, with systems ranging from single‑ministry leadership as in Denmark, to shared ministerial arrangements as in Germany and Italy, and decentralised or subnational-led models in Belgium and Canada. Implementation structures similarly vary, from centralised delivery as in France to municipal models in the Nordic countries and federal or regional systems. These differences reflect institutional traditions and shape how co‑ordination is organised in practice. Despite this variation, there are a few key considerations worth bearing in mind:
Horizontal co‑ordination, between ministries and policy areas, is essential because implementation typically involves mainstream services such as employment, education, housing and social protection. Dedicated co‑ordination bodies that bring together the relevant ministries around shared integration objectives can help ensure alignment, particularly where no single ministry has full responsibility.
Vertical co‑ordination, between national and subnational levels, is complicated by the fact that implementation responsibilities and policy autonomy do not always align. In many countries, local authorities deliver integration measures but operate within nationally defined frameworks and funding structures. Where local authorities have delivery responsibility without the autonomy to adapt measures to local conditions, or autonomy without the capacity or resources to use it, this mismatch can itself be a reason integration outcomes fall short.
Both forms of co‑ordination depend on continuity. Institutional arrangements rarely remain static. Responsibilities, mandates and governance structures are regularly adjusted in response to changing migration patterns, labour-market needs and policy priorities. Many countries use standing co‑ordination mechanisms, such as a designated lead institution, a network of regional or local contact points and shared data and reporting systems, that can help maintain coherence across both ministries and levels of government during periods of change.
References
[4] Caponio, T. and M. Borkert (2025), The local dimension of migration policymaking, Routledge.
[2] Hooghe, L. and G. Marks (2003), Unraveling the central state, but how? Types of multi-level governance, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055403000649.
[1] OECD (2023), Introduction Measures for Newly-Arrived Migrants, Making Integration Work, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/5aeddbfe-en.
[5] OECD (2018), Working Together for Local Integration of Migrants and Refugees, OECD Regional Development Studies, OECD Publishing, Paris, https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264085350-en.
[6] Scholten, P. (2012), “Agenda dynamics and the multi-level governance of intractable policy controversies: the case of migrant integration policies in the Netherlands”, Policy Sciences, Vol. 46/3, pp. 217-236, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-012-9170-x.
[3] Zapata-Barrero, R., T. Caponio and P. Scholten (2017), “Theorizing the ‘local turn’ in a multi-level governance framework of analysis: a case study in immigrant policies”, International Review of Administrative Sciences, Vol. 83/2, https://doi.org/10.1177/0020852316688426.