The public sector is most frequently identified as the primary holder of agricultural data in 16 countries (48.5%), followed by farmers in seven countries (21.2%), other private entities in seven countries (21.2%), and machinery and service provider companies in three countries (9.1%) (Q2.2). When the categories “other private entities” and “machinery and service provider companies” are combined, the private sector accounts for ten countries (30.3%), making it the second-largest category after the public sector.
While this indicates an overall predominance of the public sector among respondents, more detailed country information suggests that different types of data are often held and controlled by different stakeholders. Government registries tend to play a more prominent role in administrative and statistical data, whereas private providers are more prominent in machine-generated and platform-based operational data. However, these responses should be interpreted with caution. Recent work suggests that “data ownership” in agriculture is not a uniformly defined concept and often refers in practice to a bundle of rights relating to access, control, sharing and re-use, rather than ownership in the strict sense (Ryan et al., 2024[51]). The questionnaire results therefore provide a useful indication of which actors are perceived as primarily holding or controlling agricultural data, rather than a fully comparable statement of legal ownership.
Responses on how rules governing the use of agricultural data are generally determined provide important context for assessing how private contracts allocate rights in practice. Questionnaire responses (Q2.5.1) show “Other” is the most frequent answer when asked who owns agricultural data. This suggests not only diverse contractual arrangements, but also broader ambiguity around the concept of data ownership itself. The “Other” category includes the cases where there is no specific legal rule. In some cases, respondents indicated that rights vary by provider and contract; in others, they referred to hybrid arrangements in which farmers retain certain use rights while service providers hold broader rights to process, aggregate or share data. The large “Other” category therefore points to a fragmented and often unclear governance landscape, underscoring the need for more transparent and standardised approaches to agricultural data governance.
In practice, data rights are largely shaped by private contracts. Many countries state that farmers retain title to raw data, but grant service providers broad licences to process, aggregate, re-use and commercialise information, sometimes with limited transparency about secondary uses or onward transfers. This means that legal title and practical control do not always coincide. Even where farmers retain legal title, providers may still exercise significant practical control over how data are accessed, processed, shared and monetised.
Contractual terms vary across providers and countries, and bargaining power is often asymmetric. Typical clauses specify who may access and transfer data, allow use of anonymised or aggregated data, and define purposes such as analytics, product development or benchmarking. In the European Union, the new Data Act is intended to rebalance some of these relationships by strengthening users’ rights to access and use non-personal data co-generated by connected machinery and by constraining unfair terms.
Similar concerns have been raised in the United States. Agricultural data contracts often define what data are collected, who can access them, and how they may be used, while farmers’ ability to negotiate contractual protections with large technology providers or input suppliers remains limited (Zwagerman, 2021[52]). The technical complexity and uncertain future value of agricultural data can make it difficult for producers to fully understand the implications of contractual terms, even where data protection provisions are included.