Agricultural digital governance systems can be analysed through a framework that combines data governance arrangements with a broader set of enabling conditions (Figure 1). This includes a data governance system that seeks to balance protection and access to data, creating trust and facilitating use. And it also includes a set of enablers that facilitate the adoption and delivery of results through the agricultural digital ecosystem. The information collected and analysed in this paper allows the identification of some stylised features that characterise different systems across countries.
Data governance arrangements should seek to balance protection and access and can be characterised along a spectrum (Figure 3). At one end, public-led systems rely mainly on public rules to define data protection and access conditions. On the other end, market-led systems rely more on contracts, voluntary arrangements and private governance mechanisms. In practice, intermediate systems are most common, combining public rules with contractual or private mechanisms. These categories should be understood as stylised descriptions of governance approaches, and are not intended to rank performance. A key characteristic of a data governance system is whether and how agricultural data, including machine-generated data, are covered by broader data protection rules, particularly when linked to identifiable persons.
Interoperability and portability emerge as key mechanisms for reducing the risk of lock-in. The range of initiatives related to interoperability and data portability introduced by different countries shows that effective access depends not only on legal or contractual arrangements, but also on whether data can be exchanged, combined and reused across systems in practice. Questionnaire responses show that lock-in is recognised by many countries as an existing or emerging concern, particularly where data rights or technical constraints limit switching and re-use. Countries are taking steps to address these issues, but the scope and intensity of initiatives vary, from comprehensive policy measures and infrastructure support to more limited direct government involvement (Figure 4).
Although this paper does not establish a formal typology for broader enablers, the questionnaire provides a basis for understanding differences across countries. Rural connectivity, the availability and affordability of digital tools, farmers’ digital skills and enabling market conditions affect whether stakeholders can access, adopt and effectively use data-driven services. Questionnaire responses suggest that most countries are actively advancing measures to accelerate adoption through broader digital ecosystem enablers. This reflects the practical recognition that adoption is constrained by multiple bottlenecks and depends not only on technology availability, but also on farmers’ capabilities, viable business models and trusted data and service ecosystems.