The increasing adoption of digital technologies in agriculture, including sensors, platforms and automated machinery, generates large volumes of data that increasingly shape innovation, productivity pathways and market dynamics. These technologies can contribute to more sustainable and resilient agricultural systems by improving resource efficiency, bolstering resilience against risks, and enabling more precise monitoring of environmental outcomes.
Policymakers face the challenge of ensuring that data and digital governance frameworks support economic efficiency and innovation while protecting farmers’ rights and maintaining trust. This paper provides a structured comparison of how different countries govern agricultural digitalisation and the growing use of data in the sector. The paper consolidates cross-country evidence on how different governance approaches address these objectives and identifies common policy challenges.
A coherent analytical framework is used to examine agricultural digital governance systems across OECD Member and non-OECD Member countries. This framework is applied through a questionnaire designed to capture key features of countries’ approaches to agricultural data and digital governance. It considers how countries balance protection and access, as well as broader enablers of digital ecosystems. This approach facilitates cross-country comparison while reflecting institutional specificities.
The paper examines how agricultural data are collected, accessed and regulated, and how countries promote the digitalisation of agriculture. The questionnaire received responses from 33 countries in 2025 and was complemented by a literature review. The methodology identifies patterns to provide a comparative understanding of policy choices and their implications.
A central finding is that agricultural data governance is not uniform across countries. Rather than following a single model, countries operate along a spectrum ranging from more public-led to more market-led models.
Most of the countries that participated in the questionnaire lean towards public-led approaches for data protection, while access and use are often governed by contracts and private-sector arrangements.
A recurring policy issue concerns the legal status of agricultural data, particularly whether existing frameworks adequately cover machine-generated datasets when they can be linked to individuals (personal data). Managing this potential uncertainty shapes the design of governance systems and the allocation of responsibilities among stakeholders.
Private actors also shape governance through voluntary codes of practice and, in some cases, certification schemes that promote transparency, responsible data practices and trust in data sharing.
The paper identifies “lock-in” as a prominent concern in agricultural data systems. Lock-in refers to situations where farmers face high costs or technical barriers when attempting to switch between digital service providers. Many surveyed countries identified lock-in as an existing or potential concern. The main drivers are technical constraints, such as incompatible data formats, as well as contractual and governance constraints affecting data export, transfer, access and re-use.
Many countries report ongoing efforts to promote interoperability (the ability of different systems to work together) and portability (the ability to transfer data easily between systems) to reduce the risks of lock-in, but the extent of these efforts varies. Some have developed stronger policy frameworks and supporting infrastructure such as national agricultural data standards and application programming interfaces (APIs), while others have only a limited number of such arrangements in place, with limited direct government involvement. This variation affects the degree to which farmers can exercise choice in digital service markets.
Countries continue to calibrate their governance approaches to balance competing objectives. On one side is the need to protect data, including privacy and security considerations and the rights of farmers over data generated on their farms. On the other side is the need to enable access to data so that technology providers can develop and deploy innovative services. The paper identifies this trade-off as core for digital governance: maximising the value derived from the use of data while keeping sufficient safeguards to build and preserve trust. Different countries resolve this trade-off in different ways, reflecting national institutional contexts and policy priorities. Regardless of the model, coherence in the policy package is essential to avoid fragmentation that could hinder both innovation and trust.
Despite increasing availability of digital tools, adoption of these tools is constrained by multiple factors, including skills, infrastructure and business viability. The paper shows that most countries are implementing policy measures to address these constraints. These measures typically combine financial incentives, development of digital platforms, training programmes and investment in enabling infrastructure. This combination reflects that adoption depends not only on technology itself but also on the broader ecosystem in which farmers and other actors operate. The findings also indicate that policy cannot treat data governance, competition, trust and adoption as separate domains. Effective strategies integrate these elements by clarifying data rights, enabling secure and usable data sharing, and ensuring that markets for digital services remain contestable. This integration would support both innovation and the ability of farmers to benefit from it.
The comparative evidence highlights that no single model dominates, but that an effective approach needs to recognise the interdependence of data governance, market dynamics and users’ trust. The findings provide a basis for further analysis of how different governance configurations perform over time and how they influence digital transformation in agriculture.