A total of 293 interactions involving NDBs were mapped for the period January 2018-June 2026, comprising 172 financial interactions (59%) amounting to USD 21 billion, 55 technical assistance interactions (19%), and 66 other institutional interactions (22%). Of these, 203 interactions involve 18 different MDBs,1 while 85 involve 14 bilateral development banks;2 a further 5 interactions include joint engagement with both multilateral and bilateral partners. The relative importance of interactions cannot be inferred from their frequency alone, as financial and non-financial interactions can differ substantially in scope and strategic importance.
Public development banks as a system
3. An overview of interactions
Copy link to 3. An overview of interactionsHalf of the interactions are sector-specific, with a strong concentration in energy and infrastructure across NDBs in the three emerging regions
Copy link to Half of the interactions are sector-specific, with a strong concentration in energy and infrastructure across NDBs in the three emerging regionsSectoral patterns reveal a strong concentration of NDB collaboration in energy and infrastructure, reflecting the centrality of climate and connectivity investments. Of the 293 interactions mapped, 147 target specific sectors while 146 are cross-cutting. Electricity and energy account for the largest share (35%), followed by construction (17%), transport and storage (11%), and agriculture (6%) (Figure 1, Panel A). The dominance of energy is driven by large-scale climate and transition financing, such as a USD 1.5 billion loan from the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) to BNDES (2020), and a EUR 325 million climate facility for DBSA supported by Agence Française de Développement (AFD) and the European Investment Bank (EIB) (2022). Interactions in transport and construction are largely tied to major infrastructure programmes, including support to Colombia’s FDN from the IDB, Development Bank of Latin America and the Caribbean (CAF), and the International Finance Corporation (IFC) for public-private partnerships (PPPs) such as Bogotá Metro Line 1 and the 4G road programme, as well as DBSA partnerships with the World Bank and the New Development Bank on regional corridors in Southern Africa. Although smaller in volume, agriculture remains strategically important, with examples such as the KfW-BNDES Amazon Fund supporting forest restoration and World Bank (IDA) financing to BRD Rwanda for irrigation, value chains, and agribusiness development.
Electricity and construction are also the most relevant sectors across NDBs in the three emerging regions, although the distribution of activities across other sectors varies widely (Figure 1, Panel B). In PT SMI and TKYB in Asia, and DBN, BRD and DBSA in Africa, for instance, no interactions are recorded in the public administration sector, whereas this sector accounts for 7% of interactions for Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES. Interactions targeting the public administration sector relate to the financing, design and strengthening of core state functions in public security and governance. This includes, for example, the IDB-BNDES loan for the Proseg Federativo programme aligned with Brazil’s national security policy (PNSPDS/SUSP), as well as advisory and knowledge exchange on prison PPPs (e.g. Blumenau) and initiatives such as Município Seguro. It also covers support to security information systems (e.g. Sinesp, Sisdepen) and capacity-building with public authorities to design and implement security investments. Interactions targeting waste management are absent in Africa but represent 9% of interactions for PT SMI and TKYB and 5% for Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES. A similar divergence is observed in agriculture, which accounts for 9% of interactions for PT SMI and TKYB and 8% for Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES, but is not recorded for DBN, BRD and DBSA. This cross-regional analysis should not be taken as representative of the region, as it does not capture the full spectrum of NDB activity within each region. Rather, it provides an indicative picture of the sectors that selected NDBs, together with other PDBs appear to be prioritising across some countries in emerging regions.
Figure 1. Sectoral targeting of interactions between PDBs, 2018-2026
Copy link to Figure 1. Sectoral targeting of interactions between PDBs, 2018-2026
Note: Percentages are calculated over 190 sector mentions across 147 sector-specific interactions; multi-sector entries contribute to more than one category. The ‘other’ category comprises wholesale and trade, mining, and arts and recreation. 20 interactions with a start date prior to 2018 are included in the database as they either remain active beyond 2018 or have an end date after 2018.
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
A closer examination of financial interactions by sector reveals a strong concentration of financial instruments targeting energy and infrastructure, reflecting a shift towards the clean energy transition. For instance, this trend is illustrated by Japan Bank for International Cooperation’s (JBIC) series of green loans to TKYB (totalling over USD 600 million) for renewable energy and efficiency projects in Türkiye, the EIB’s USD 500 million JETP-aligned facility for PT SMI in Indonesia, and AFD and EIB climate finance operations channelled through DBSA and BRD to support embedded generation and low-carbon investment. Construction and infrastructure follow, driven largely by FDN in Colombia, whose project finance mandate is reflected in major IDB- and CAF-backed programmes such as the 4G road network, Bogotá Metro Line 1, and PPP structuring for public services, alongside DBSA’s work on regional corridors in Southern Africa. Transport and storage interactions are similarly concentrated in Colombia and Brazil.
Technical assistance interactions largely target the same sectors as financial ones, highlighting how financial and non-financial support operate along a continuous and mutually reinforcing spectrum. Of the 58 recorded technical interactions, 29 have a sectoral focus, with electricity, gas and energy supply leading. Energy dominates not only in volume but also in its strategic role: technical assistance in this area typically supports the development of financial products, market frameworks, and regulatory conditions that enable green investment, as illustrated by IDB's support to Bancóldex in designing Colombia's energy efficiency financing ecosystem and the SARAS sustainability risk assessment tool for financial intermediaries, JBIC's multi-year technical engagement with TKYB that preceded and structured the Green 3 and Green 4 loan series totalling over USD 590 million in renewable energy and energy efficiency financing, and the KfW and GIZ NAMA Facility collaboration with Bancóldex to develop a blended finance programme for the adoption of energy-efficient refrigeration technologies in Colombian manufacturing.
Regarding SDGs, the interactions on economic development and infrastructure that include climate-related objectives and target MSMEs play a predominant role
Copy link to Regarding SDGs, the interactions on economic development and infrastructure that include climate-related objectives and target MSMEs play a predominant roleThe distribution of interactions across the SDGs shows a strong concentration on economic development and infrastructure, and to a lesser extent on institutional partnerships. This distribution across SDGs is consistent with the literature on PDBs’ alignment which shows that development banks, whether national or multilateral, tend to favour these three SDGs in their activities (Jacouton, Marodon and Laulanié, 2022[13]). SDGs 8 and 9 – Decent Work and Economic Growth and Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure –dominate the portfolio, each targeted in approximately 65% of all interactions (187 and 191, respectively), reflecting the central role of economic development and infrastructure financing in these partnerships (Figure 2, Panel A). However, prevalence of some SDGs in the database should not be interpreted as an indication of their relative development impact or importance, as the scale and cost of investments vary substantially across sectors and objectives.
MSME targeting is a prominent feature of interactions under SDG 8. These are primarily aimed at expanding access to finance, supporting production transformation and export development. Of the 293 interactions in the database, 73 (25%) explicitly target MSMEs, accounting for 33% of interactions with NDBs in Africa and 19% of those with NDBs in LAC. The objectives behind MSME-targeted interactions fall into two main categories: access to finance, primarily through on-lending credit lines to MSMEs via participating financial institutions and production transformation and export development. This highlights the importance of participating financial institutions in reaching firms and translating international development finance into firm-level support.
SDG 5 (Gender Equality) is reflected across 90 interactions, highlighting the growing integration of gender considerations into PDB co-operation. Following the OECD DAC Gender Equality Policy Marker, 79 mapped interactions are classified as “significant” (score 1), meaning that gender equality is an important but not primary objective, while 11 interactions receive a score of 2, indicating that gender equality is the principal objective (OECD, 2025[14]). For score 1 interactions, gender considerations are often included as conditionalities or reporting requirements layered onto instruments primarily designed for energy, infrastructure, or economic growth. Examples include EIB and AFD climate finance facilities to DBSA with gender mainstreaming conditions, JICA loans incorporating gender-responsive criteria, and Bancóldex instruments backed by MIGA guarantees that include gender eligibility requirements. Among score 2 interactions, notable examples include AfDB’s USD 61 million Affirmative Finance Action for Women in Africa package to DBN, which provides a gender-focused credit line, concessional financing, and grant support, with more than 95% of the funding earmarked for women-owned and women-led MSMEs.
Climate-related objectives are increasingly embedded across interactions, with renewable energy, green finance, and climate-focused technical assistance emerging as key areas of engagement. SDG 7 (Affordable and Clean Energy) and SDG 13 (Climate Action) are highly targeted, reflecting the growing integration of climate objectives into financial and technical operations. Since 2018, the share of interactions incorporating green and climate-related objectives has increased from 27% to more than 60% in recent years. Overall, 44% of total interactions include climate-related objectives (Figure 2, Panel B). This trend is supported by the concentration of renewable energy investments, dedicated green finance instruments, and large-scale initiatives such as Amazon Fund-related investments. Climate-focused technical assistance is also increasingly present, particularly through support for green finance frameworks and climate risk management tools, suggesting a gradual shift towards more explicit climate-oriented capacity building.
Figure 2. Alignment of total interactions with the Sustainable Development Goals, 2018–2026
Copy link to Figure 2. Alignment of total interactions with the Sustainable Development Goals, 2018–2026
Note: 20 interactions with a start date prior to 2018 are included in the database as they either remain active beyond 2018 or have an end date after 2018. Panel A: An interaction may target one or more than one SDG at the same time. Panel B: An interaction is classified as green or climate-related when its primary or explicitly stated objective involves at least one of the following: the mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions or contribution to decarbonisation; adaptation to the physical risks of climate change; the development, financing or deployment of renewable energy or energy efficiency solutions; the protection, restoration or sustainable management of natural ecosystems, forests, biodiversity or water resources; the development of green financial instruments, frameworks or markets (including green bonds, sustainability-linked instruments and climate funds); or institutional capacity building explicitly aimed at integrating climate or environmental considerations into NDB operations or financial products.
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
A small number of funders account for a large share of total volumes
Copy link to A small number of funders account for a large share of total volumesFinancial commitments are unevenly distributed across institutions and regions, reflecting differences in mandate, geographic focus, and engagement with NDBs. Total commitments reached USD 21 billion over the 2018-2026 period, with MDBs accounting for the majority (USD 15.5 billion) and bilateral development banks contributing USD 5.5 billion. Of the 174 financial interactions recorded, 145 include financial data, while the remaining 29 lack financial figures due to data availability constraints. This highlights the importance of ongoing validation with NDBs to improve the completeness and reliability of the dataset. Commitment data should also be interpreted with caution, as they reflect approved financing rather than actual disbursements, which are often unavailable and may be lower than the original commitments.
MDB support, measured relative to Assets Under Management (AUM), varies significantly across NDBs in the three regions, indicating differing levels of financing intensity and balance sheet maturity. Based on 2024 assets, MDB’s support amounts to 6.2% of AUM in Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES, about 31.3% in PT SMI and TKYB, and around 40.4% in DBN, BRD and DBSA. Among MDBs, the World Bank leads with USD 4.7 billion in commitments across NDBs in the three emerging regions: This is followed by the IDB, with USD 2.6 billion in commitments directed to Bancóldex, FDN, and BNDES (Figure 3). The New Development Bank (NDB) also stands out, notably through a USD 2.6 billion commitment to BNDES and additional engagement in DBSA (USD 100 million). The European Investment Bank (EIB) shows a more geographically diversified footprint. It has committed around USD 475 million in Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES, USD 637 million in DBN, BRD and DBSA, and USD 648 million in NDBs in PT SMI and TKYB. In contrast, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) concentrates its operations in the two NDBs in Asia (USD 1 billion).
Figure 3. MDB financial commitments to selected NDBs (2018-2026)
Copy link to Figure 3. MDB financial commitments to selected NDBs (2018-2026)
Note: WB = World Bank; IDB = Inter-American Development Bank; NDB = New Development Bank; EIB = European Investment Bank; AIIB = Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank; CAF = Development Bank of Latin America and the Caribbean; AfDB = African Development Bank; AUM = assets under management. Percentages (flow thickness) represent the share of total MDB commitments received by selected NDBs. “Other MDBs” comprises the Islamic Development Bank (IsDB), the Asian Development Bank (ADB), and eight smaller multilateral lenders: the Black Sea Trade and Development Bank (BSTDB), the Council of Europe Development Bank (CEB), the Arab Bank for Economic Development in Africa (BADEA), the East African Development Bank (EADB), the African Export-Import Bank (Afreximbank), the Shelter Afrique Development Bank (ShafDB), the Development Bank of the Great Lakes States (BDEGL), and the Trade and Development Bank (TDB). Only interactions with available commitment data are shown. Flows represent committed amounts in USD million for financial interactions only (2018–2026); interactions classified as Technical or Other are excluded even when a partner MDB is involved. 20 interactions with a start date prior to 2018 are included in the database as they either remain active beyond 2018 or have an end date after 2018.
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
Bilateral development banks display distinct regional allocation patterns, with different institutions pursuing either broad cross-regional portfolios or more geographically concentrated strategies in their engagement with NDBs across emerging regions. Bilateral development banks support, measured relative to assets under management, varies significantly across regions, amounting to 12% of AUM in DBN, BRD and DBSA, 7.9% in PT SMI and TKYB and 2.6% in Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES (Figure 4). Among bilateral actors, the China Development Bank and KfW stand out as the largest contributors overall, committing USD 1.3 billion and USD 8 million, respectively. France’s AFD has a more diversified regional presence across NDBs in the different emerging regions, while Japan’s JBIC is more concentrated. Spain’s ICO focuses exclusively on FDN. Other bilateral institutions, such as JICA, Sida and SFD, tend to engage with a smaller number of NDBs through more targeted interventions and at a more limited scale. Overall, interactions between NDBs and bilateral development banks reveal a dual pattern: a small group of large institutions with diversified, multi-regional portfolios, and a wider set of more specialised institutions with narrower geographic focus.
Figure 4. Bilateral development banks financial commitments to selected NDBs (2018-2026)
Copy link to Figure 4. Bilateral development banks financial commitments to selected NDBs (2018-2026)
Note: CDB = Caribbean Development Bank; KfW = Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau; AFD = Agence Française de Développement; JBIC = Japan Bank for International Cooperation; ICO = Instituto de Crédito Oficial; JICA = Japan International Cooperation Agency; Sida = Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency; SFD = Saudi Fund for Development; FinDev Canada = Development Finance Institute Canada. Commitment figures reflect financial interactions with available data only. Not all interactions carry commitment data; flows shown represent committed amounts reported. 20 interactions with a start date prior to 2018 are included in the database as they either remain active beyond 2018 or have an end date after 2018.
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
MDB exposure tends to be more significant than bilateral development banks exposure across NDB balance sheets
Copy link to MDB exposure tends to be more significant than bilateral development banks exposure across NDB balance sheetsMDB exposure tends to be more significant than bilateral development banks exposure across NDB balance sheets, while bilateral flows are generally smaller and often emerge later or in a complementary role. MDB and bilateral development banks exposure of NDBs is measured as the share of financial commitments relative to total liabilities, capturing the relative weight of external development finance within NDB funding structures. However, this indicator should be interpreted with caution, as financial commitments may be disbursed over several years, meaning that their effective weight on NDB balance sheets at a given point in time may differ from the ratio of commitments to liabilities. In this sense, the indicator should be understood as a proxy, particularly where banks do not provide sufficiently detailed information on disbursements or the composition of their creditors. Results should also be interpreted carefully given differences in data availability, timing and reporting coverage across institutions.
Within this framework, the evidence shows marked heterogeneity in how MDBs and bilateral development banks feature in NDB balance sheets. In TKYB, for example, MDB exposure rose from 5.1% in 2018 to 26.3% in 2020 before moderating, while bilateral exposure remains smaller but became more relevant later, peaking at 8.4% in 2022, suggesting MDB-led engagement with bilateral complementarity. FDN shows a more limited scale of engagement, with a modest MDB ratio in 2022 (4.1%) and very low bilateral exposure in 2023 and 2024 (0.8% and 0.4%, respectively). Bancóldex also displays an MDB-driven profile, with twin peaks in 2019 and 2022 at 35% and 34% respectively, while bilateral exposure remained low throughout. DBSA and PT SMI illustrate more moderate and episodic MDB-led engagement, with MDB exposure reaching 12.4% in 2022 for DBSA, while PT SMI recorded 13.6% in 2018, 3.3% in 2020, 3.1% in 2022, and 13.6% in 2024, indicating intermittent but recurring reliance. On the other end, large institutions, such as BNDES, show persistently low exposure to both MDBs and bilateral development banks, reflecting strong domestic balance sheets.
Seen through the lens of country platforms, these patterns matter because they determine how easily NDBs can co-ordinate investment pipelines and integrate MDBs and bilateral partners. This makes co‑ordination between NDBs and other PDBs fundamental to the effectiveness of country-led investment approaches. Over the past years, country-platforms have emerged to describe programmatic approaches with national governments, to foster investment plans. By design, country platforms seek to overcome the inefficiencies associated with fragmented and uncoordinated interventions, promoting instead a more coherent, country-led investment framework. This shift raises a few critical questions regarding the current state and effectiveness of co-operation across PDBs.
A country-level perspective that considers NDBs alongside their interactions with MDBs can provide valuable insight into the strategic relevance of NDBs within MDB portfolios. It highlights the extent to which NDBs serve not only as vehicles for channelling MDB resources, but also as institutional partners that connect multilateral financing with national development priorities. Examining the case of Colombia, between 2018 and 2024, approximately 44.4% of World Bank-MIGA commitments in the country were channelled through FDN and Bancóldex combined, including 31.5% through Bancóldex alone and 12.9% through FDN. This indicates that a substantial share of the portfolio is implemented through NDBs, particularly in infrastructure development, climate-resilient infrastructure through FDN, and MSME financing through Bancóldex. Similarly, the World Bank (excluding MIGA) channels more than 37% of its commitments through FDN, while other PDBs such as the EIB and CAF intermediate around 27% and 16.5% of their portfolios, respectively, through Bancóldex and FDN. These patterns highlight the strategic role of NDBs in aligning MDB financing with national development priorities, sectoral agendas and broader country platforms, while bridging multilateral resources with domestic implementation capacity (Fernández-Arias, Hausmann and Panizza, 2019[15]).
Strengthening the role of NDBs is key to the success of country platforms and to more effective development outcomes. As long-term financial institutions embedded within national policy frameworks, NDBs are uniquely positioned to play a central role in these programmatic investment approaches. The example of Brazil, where the Brazilian Development Bank (BNDES) serves as the secretariat of the Climate and Ecological Transformation Platform, illustrates this potential. Ultimately, improving co-ordination across public development banks as a system is critical to advancing both socio-economic well-being and the preservation of local ecosystems.
Thematic investment loans are the most widely used financial instrument, with instrument choice reflecting distinct NDB roles
Copy link to Thematic investment loans are the most widely used financial instrument, with instrument choice reflecting distinct NDB rolesInvestment loans account for the largest share of PDB co-operation, combining high-volume programmatic lending with targeted concessional support. Investment loans represent 68%, accounting also for the highest total commitment volume (USD 16.3 billion). This is followed by guarantees (13%), equity and governance participation (7%), grants (5%) and bonds (2%) (Figure 5, Panel A).
Investment loans are predominantly direct, thematic financing operations aimed at supporting specific sectoral or policy objectives. On-lending credit lines account for 51%, with financing channelled through intermediary financial institutions to final beneficiaries, while direct loans account for 49% of investment loans and provide financing to NDBs for their own deployment. In terms of purpose, 92% of investment loans are thematic, linked to specific sectors or policy priorities, while 5% support emergency or crisis response and 3% correspond to general corporate purposes. Standout thematic loans include KfW’s USD 1 billion urban mobility loan to BNDES, the EIB’s USD 540 million JETP-aligned facility to PT SMI, and the IDB’s USD 138.5 million climate loan to FDN. Other examples include NDB and JBIC financing to BNDES and TKYB for sustainable infrastructure and energy transition. On-lending operations include KfW’s USD 200 million credit line to DBN, the World Bank’s USD 500 million FINCLUDE facility, and IDB and IDA credit lines to Bancóldex and BRD supporting MSMEs, productive transformation, energy access, housing, agriculture, and digital infrastructure.
Guarantees represent a smaller but important share of the instruments provided by MDBs and bilateral development banks. They help reduce NDBs’ risk exposure and catalyse private investment. This is illustrated, for example, by MIGA’s guarantee programme for Bancóldex, which covers obligations to JPMorgan Chase (USD 546.8 million, 2022) and a COVID-19 liquidity facility (USD 400 million, 2020). FDN also benefits from two MIGA non-honouring guarantees totalling USD 388 million, allowing the Colombian infrastructure bank to access commercial financing at lower costs for its PPP and 4G road portfolio. Beyond MIGA, the World Bank’s geothermal resource risk guarantee to PT SMI (USD 150 million, 2020) represents a technically innovative guarantee, as it contributes to sharing the risks associated to the exploration phase of geothermal development in Indonesia, where subsurface uncertainty often limits private sector financing.
Another important form of financial interaction is equity and governance participation. MDBs and bilateral development banks can act as formal shareholders or governance partners in NDBs, contributing to their institutional development and strategic direction. Key examples include IFC's 8.9% and CAF's 8.65% equity stakes in FDN, which give both institutions board representation with deliberative quorum rights. In Nigeria, AfDB and EIB provided founding equity of USD 50 million and USD 20 million respectively at DBN's establishment, anchoring its initial capitalisation alongside the federal government and embedding development finance governance standards from inception. An institutionally innovative example is the World Bank’s Observer Status at all DBN Board meetings, which provides access to board-level information without requiring an equity stake.
The “other financial instruments” category captures innovative forms of PDB collaboration. These arrangements enable NDBs to move beyond their role as borrowers and act as fund managers, co‑investors and institutional partners. For example, in 2021, DBSA was appointed fund manager of South Africa’s Infrastructure Fund, a blended finance vehicle designed to mobilise private capital alongside public resources and multilateral institutions, including the New Development Bank. DBSA oversees project preparation and financing across six municipalities. In 2024, the Development Bank of Nigeria (DBN) co‑invested USD 25 million as an anchor partner in the Nigeria Youth Entrepreneurship Investment Bank (YEIB) Investment Fund alongside the African Development Bank (AfDB). DBN was also tasked with managing the Credit Guarantee Facility through its subsidiary, InfraCredit Guarantee Limited (ICGL). This illustrates how NDBs can assume operational and risk-management functions within MDB-led programmes.
Figure 5. Financial interactions by instrument type and across NDB groups
Copy link to Figure 5. Financial interactions by instrument type and across NDB groups
Note: Other financial interactions include fund establishment and management, co-financing, deal co-structuring, and other collaborative financing arrangements. 20 interactions with a start date prior to 2018 are included in the database as they either remain active beyond 2018 or have an end-date after 2018.
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
The distribution of financial instruments reveals structural differences in how NDBs across emerging regions interact with MDBs and bilateral development banks, reflecting their distinct institutional mandates and business models. Loans remain the predominant instrument overall, particularly for PT SMI and TKYB, where they account for 87.5% of financial interactions (Figure 5, Panel B). DBN, BRD and DBSA also rely heavily on loans, but predominantly through an on-lending model, with 88% of their loans channelled through intermediary PFIs to final beneficiaries, reflecting their wholesale financing role. In contrast, Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES primarily receive direct loans (81%) for their own deployment, consistent with their role as direct project financiers. PT SMI and TKYB present a more balanced approach, combining direct financing with on-lending operations, reflecting their dual role as infrastructure financiers and financial intermediaries. Beyond loans, guarantees and equity or governance participation represent important engagement modalities for several NDBs. Bancóldex and FDN stand out for their significant guarantee exposure, with combined MIGA contingent liabilities exceeding USD 1.3 billion, while DBN, BRD and DBSA show more selective use of targeted risk-mitigation instruments. Equity and governance interactions are particularly relevant for FDN and DBN where MDBs and bilateral development banks support institutional strengthening through ownership stakes or governance roles.
Technical assistance interactions are primarily geared towards institutional strengthening and enhancing financial capabilities
Copy link to Technical assistance interactions are primarily geared towards institutional strengthening and enhancing financial capabilitiesTechnical assistance (TA) interactions are concentrated in three areas: institutional strengthening and governance, support for the development of financial products and instruments, and capacity building for beneficiaries and partners. Together, these areas account for 79.3% (46 of 58) of recorded technical assistance interactions. Among the different types, institutional strengthening and governance TA accounts for the largest share (41%), followed by support for the development of financial products and instruments (19%) and beneficiary and partner capacity building (19%). Project and transaction structuring advisory accounts for 15.5%, while pre-investment and feasibility study support represents the smallest share at 5.2% (Figure 6, Panel A).
Technical assistance interactions play a foundational role in strengthening NDB capabilities, developing financial instruments, and building the institutional and project pipelines needed to mobilise future investment. Institutional strengthening and governance TA focuses on strengthening NDBs’ internal systems, governance frameworks, environmental and social management standards, and strategic capabilities. A key example is AFD and the World Bank’s multi-year engagement with BRD to enhance its Environmental and Social Management System (ESMS), integrate climate and gender KPIs, and develop a sustainability strategy, enabling subsequent sustainability-linked bond issuances and the Ireme Invest climate facility. Support for the development of financial products and instruments plays a catalytic role in enabling future financial operations, including World Bank support for BRD’s sustainability-linked bond framework, and IDB support to Bancóldex in developing Colombia’s energy efficiency financing ecosystem. Beneficiary and partner capacity building targets external actors, including financial intermediaries, SMEs, and cooperatives, using NDBs as delivery channels to strengthen the broader financial ecosystem, as illustrated by DBN’s Community of Practice for Nigerian microfinance banks and the IKI Small Grants programme supporting women-led MSMEs in Nigeria. Project and transaction structuring advisory focuses on making complex projects bankable. Finally, pre-investment and feasibility study support, despite representing the smallest share of technical interactions (5.2%), is also strategically important for building bankable project pipelines. Its limited share, together with project and transaction structuring support, highlights a potential gap, as scaling project preparation activities could help translate development priorities into financeable operations, particularly in emerging regions where limited project preparation capacity remains a key constraint to catalysing private investment.
The distribution of technical assistance interactions reveals distinct advisory patterns across the three NDB groups. Institutional strengthening and governance are the most common type of technical assistance across all groups, although its relative importance varies: it accounts for 57% of technical interactions for PT SMI and TKYB, 41% for DBN, BRD and DBSA, and 38% for Bancóldex, FDN and BNDES (Figure 6, Panel B). This highlights its foundational role in strengthening institutional capacity and enabling other forms of PDB engagement.
Figure 6. Technical interactions by instrument type and across NDBs
Copy link to Figure 6. Technical interactions by instrument type and across NDBs
Note: 20 interactions with a start date prior to 2018 are included in the database as they either remain active beyond 2018 or have an end-date after 2018.
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
Other interactions focus on co-operation agreements, knowledge exchange, joint research, events co-organisation, and innovative institutional collaborations
Copy link to Other interactions focus on co-operation agreements, knowledge exchange, joint research, events co-organisation, and innovative institutional collaborationsOther institutional interactions provide the relational foundation for NDB co-operation, with formal agreements, convening power and analytical work often paving the way for subsequent financial and technical engagements. Formal co-operation agreements account for 55% of these interactions, followed by event co-organisation and participation (30%) and knowledge exchange and joint research (15%). These agreements often serve as entry points for operational collaboration, defining financial pipelines before capital is committed, as illustrated by TKYB and KfW's 2018 co-operation agreement preceding a EUR 100 million solar energy loan the following year, and DBSA and AFD's renewed MoU extending co‑operation to 2030 across green transition, water and biodiversity finance. Event co-organisation highlights NDBs' convening role in shaping the development finance agenda. These include Bancóldex hosting the Finance in Common Summit (FiCS) in Cartagena (2023), DBSA and AIIB co-hosting the FiCS 2025 Summit in Cape Town, and BNDES's engagement in the G20 Rio Summit (2024), which generated financing memoranda with major international partners and catalysed the Green Coalition of 20 development banks focused on Amazon conservation and the energy transition. Finally, knowledge exchange and joint research represent another form of institutional interaction that can have significant long-term impact by producing frameworks, tools and diagnostics that reshape risk assessment, instrument design and policy. Examples include the ENCORE-AFD-SANBI study on nature-related financial risks, conducted with DBSA and later adopted by the South African Reserve Bank as a supervisory framework across the SADC region. These initiatives extend beyond information sharing, influencing regulatory frameworks, investment strategies and institutional approaches to risk management.
Innovative institutional arrangements are emerging across NDBs in different regions, ranging from agreements that precede major financial operations to innovations shaping future institutional systems and methodologies (Table 3). In South Africa, DBSA’s co-operation with Afreximbank through a 2026 Master Risk Participation Agreement established a standing legal framework to scale trade finance under the AfCFTA. In Brazil, BNDES and KfW implemented a blockchain-based TruBudget pilot to track Amazon Fund disbursements, demonstrating the potential of digital systems for transparent public resource tracking, while BNDES and IDB co-launched the Green Coalition in 2023, bringing together 20 development banks to advance biodiversity and climate finance in the Amazon. In Türkiye, TKYB’s signing of the IFC Operating Principles for Impact Management in 2021 – the first Turkish institution to do so – helped unlock subsequent financial operations, including JBIC’s green financing windows, and preceded a series of green loan tranches.
Table 3. Other selected interactions in emerging regions
Copy link to Table 3. Other selected interactions in emerging regions|
Region |
Country |
NDB |
Partner |
Instrument |
Year |
Description and relevance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Africa |
South Africa |
DBSA |
Afreximbank |
Formal Co-operation Agreement |
2026 |
Master Risk Participation Agreement signed at Mining Indaba 2026 – a standing legal framework to scale trade finance and accelerate beneficiation of critical minerals across Africa under AfCFTA |
|
LAC |
Brazil |
BNDES |
KfW |
Knowledge Exchange & Joint Research |
2018 |
Blockchain/TruBudget pilot to track Amazon Fund disbursements – an early experiment in transparent public resource tracking |
|
LAC |
Brazil |
BNDES |
IDB |
Formal Co-operation Agreement |
2023 |
BNDES and IDB jointly launched the Green Coalition at the Amazon Summit – a multilateral initiative bringing together 20 development banks around biodiversity, climate and social investments in the Amazon biome |
|
LAC |
Colombia |
Bancóldex |
CAF |
Formal Co-operation Agreement |
2019 |
CAF expressed interest in becoming the first multilateral investor in Bancóldex's Fund of Funds for venture capital – a pioneering equity-linked instrument |
|
Asia |
Türkiye |
TKYB |
World Bank – IFC |
Formal Co-operation Agreement |
2021 |
TKYB's signing of the IFC Operating Principles for Impact Management in 2021 – helped unlock several subsequent financial operations such as JBIC's green financing windows and preceded a series of green loan tranches. |
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
Early-stage non-financial interactions can lay the foundation for deeper and larger-scale partnerships
Copy link to Early-stage non-financial interactions can lay the foundation for deeper and larger-scale partnershipsNon-financial interactions can act as the entry point to deeper relationships between PDBs. The database provides some insights into a recurring pattern in which “other” interactions – such as MoUs, knowledge exchanges, events and co-operation frameworks – lay the groundwork for subsequent technical assistance and financial commitments. Across eight partnerships, the progression from initial engagement to first financing spans one to six years. These early engagements help build institutional familiarity, align priorities, and establish operational channels that can later facilitate funded operations. The trajectory is particularly visible in relationships such as BNDES-IDB, where sustained engagement through events, co-financing discussions, and knowledge exchange since 2018 has coincided with a progressive expansion of financial commitments – from initial loans to large-scale programmes such as PRO-AMAZÔNIA, a project aimed at increasing the availability of financing for productive investments by MSMEs in the Amazon region. Similar sequences appear in TKYB-KfW and TKYB-JBIC, where early co‑operation agreements or technical exchanges quickly evolved into sizeable green finance portfolios, as well as in DBSA partnerships with AFD, JICA and the New Development Bank, where non-financial collaboration preceded blended finance, loans or risk-sharing instruments.
These patterns point to a phased progression in how partnerships between PDBs can evolve over time (Figure 7). Initial interactions (year 0-1) are generally non-binding and focused on signaling intent – through co-operation agreements, joint events or analytical work. This is followed by a deepening phase (years 1-3), where technical assistance, small grants and advisory support help build internal capacity, structure projects and develop financial instruments. In more mature stages (year 3+), relationships tend to scale into larger and more complex operations, including thematic investment loans, climate finance facilities and capital market instruments. In some cases, this culminates in equity participation or long-term governance arrangements, reflecting a shift from transactional co-operation to more structural partnerships. It is important to note, however, that the evolution of relationships between PDBs does not always follow a linear trajectory, nor do all partnerships progress sequentially through each phase. Rather, this framework should be understood as a theoretical perspective that helps illustrate how institutional relationships are often built progressively over time, even though many early-stage interactions may never evolve into more consolidated forms of co-operation.
Taken together, this sequencing highlights the strategic role of “other” interactions as relationship infrastructure. Rather than being peripheral, these engagements function as a preparatory layer that enables more complex and higher-value operations. The typical lag between initial co-operation and financial commitment ranges from one to three years, although in some cases the transition is more immediate. Analytically, this suggests that understanding PDB collaboration requires looking beyond financial flows alone, as early-stage institutional and knowledge-based interactions are often decisive in shaping the scale, direction and sophistication of subsequent investments.
In a context of increasing financial constraints on development finance, this result highlights the importance for development banks to maintain a broad set of activities – including research, analytical work, and innovation – that can foster sustained policy dialogue with peer institutions. So-called non-financial interactions form a continuum through which financial engagements are later triggered and progressively consolidated into more structured partnerships.
Figure 7. Example trajectory of PDB relationships
Copy link to Figure 7. Example trajectory of PDB relationships
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.
Notes
Copy link to Notes← 1. The database includes interactions with 18 distinct multilateral institutions: the World Bank Group (encompassing IBRD, IDA, IFC, MIGA, the Clean Technology Fund, the Global Environment Facility and PPIAF), the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB, including IDB Invest), the CAF – Development Bank of Latin America and the Caribbean, the African Development Bank (AfDB), the European Investment Bank (EIB), the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB), the Asian Development Bank (ADB), the New Development Bank (NDB), the Islamic Development Bank (IsDB), the Black Sea Trade and Development Bank (BSTDB), the Council of Europe Development Bank (CEB), the Eurasian Development Bank (EDB), the East African Development Bank (EADB), the African Export-Import Bank (Afreximbank), the Eastern and Southern African Trade Development Bank (TDB), the Development Bank of the Great Lakes States (BDEGL), the Arab Bank for Economic Development in Africa (BADEA), and Shelter Afrique.
← 2. The database includes interactions with 14 distinct bilateral development banks and development agencies: KfW – Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau (including KfW IPEX-Bank), the Agence Française de Développement (AFD, including its private sector arm Proparco), the Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC), the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), the China Development Bank (CDB), the Export-Import Bank of India (India Exim Bank), the Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations Group, the Small Industries Development Bank of India (SIDBI), Bpifrance – Banque Publique d'Investissement, Export Development Canada (EDC), the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida), the Official Credit Institute of Spain (ICO – Instituto de Crédito Oficial), the Saudi Fund for Development (SFD), FinDev Canada.