This section describes the empirical approach used to map and analyse interactions between PDBs. It first presents the sample of NDBs, the sources used to identify interactions and the process followed to validate the data. It then introduces the typology developed to classify these interactions and the additional dimensions used to examine their financing modalities, sectoral focus and development objectives. The section concludes by discussing the main limitations of the dataset and analytical approach.
Public development banks as a system
2. Methodology
Copy link to 2. MethodologyData collection and sample
Copy link to Data collection and sampleThis paper maps interactions between PDBs between January 2018 and June 2026 across a sample of eight NDBs in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC), Africa, and Asia (Table 1), based on a systematic review of annual reports and publicly available information from the websites of these institutions. The selection of NDBs was guided by the aim of capturing variation in institutional size, market depth, mandates, and financial ecosystems, enabling comparison of how similar instruments and partnerships operate across different contexts. Another criterion for selection was the availability of relatively comprehensive public documentation and institutional data, which supports the consistency and robustness of the analysis. The selected NDBs are also broadly representative of PDBs in emerging markets and developing economies, with seven of the eight sampled banks having speculative grade ratings (BB+ and below), which may limit their attractiveness to mainstream financial market investors (Belin and Menville, 2025[11]).
The data were initially collected from NDBs’ public annual reports and other information available on their websites. These data were cross-checked against information published by lenders and subsequently shared with the NDBs for validation and, where necessary, clarification. The mapped interactions were reviewed and validated by four of the eight NDBs included in the study. While every effort was made to compile the most comprehensive dataset possible, some interactions may not have been captured due to limitations in the availability, accessibility, or completeness of publicly available information, as well as differences in reporting practices across institutions. Consequently, the database should be regarded as highly comprehensive but not necessarily exhaustive, and a limited number of projects or partnerships may have been omitted at the margins.
Table 1. Geographic scope of the paper
Copy link to Table 1. Geographic scope of the paper|
Region |
Country |
NDB |
Total assets (USD million) |
Equity/Assets |
International long-term ratings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
LAC |
Colombia |
Banco de Comercio Exterior S.A. (Bancóldex) |
2 015 |
19% |
BB+ |
|
LAC |
Colombia |
Financiera de Desarrollo Nacional (FDN) |
1 946 |
28% |
BB |
|
LAC |
Brazil |
Banco Nacional de Desenvolvimento Econômico e Social (BNDES) |
136 584 |
20% |
Ba1 / BB |
|
Africa |
Rwanda |
Rwanda Development Bank (BRD) |
562 |
17% |
B+ |
|
Africa |
Nigeria |
Development Bank of Nigeria (DBN) |
492 |
36% |
n.i. |
|
Africa |
South Africa |
Development Bank of Southern Africa (DBSA) |
6 579 |
48% |
Ba2 / BB |
|
Asia |
Türkiye |
Development Investment Bank of Türkiye (TKYB) |
4 342 |
13% |
BB- |
|
Asia |
Indonesia |
PT Sarana Multi Infrastruktur (PT SMI) |
7 401 |
36% |
Baa2 / BBB |
Note: Financial figures cover FY2024.
Source: Authors’ own elaboration based on (Jiajun et al., 2021[12]) and banks’ institutional websites.
Typology of PDB interactions
Copy link to Typology of PDB interactionsTo provide a consistent framework for analysing the different forms of co-operation identified in the database, the paper develops a typology of PDB interactions.
The typology distinguishes three main categories: financial, technical, and other institutional arrangements (Table 2). This typology is designed to capture the range of instruments, support mechanisms, and partnership modalities observed across cases, while recognising that some interactions may fall into more than one category. While recognising that a single interaction may include both financial and technical assistance components, these have been recorded separately for classification purposes. Accordingly, financial interactions capture only the financial component, while technical assistance interactions capture only the technical component, even where both form part of a broader engagement negotiated simultaneously. A complementary classification criterion is used to distinguish financial interactions by purpose: (i) thematic financing; (ii) general corporate purpose financing; and (iii) emergency or crisis response financing (see Annex A).
The classification framework also captures the sectoral focus and development objectives associated with each interaction. Interactions with a clearly defined sectoral target are classified using the International Standard Industrial Classification of All Economic Activities (ISIC Rev.4) developed by the United Nations. Interactions may span multiple sectors simultaneously; therefore, when presenting sectoral figures, a single interaction may be counted more than once – once under each relevant sector. In parallel, a Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) framework is used to identify the cross-cutting challenges addressed by each interaction, based on the 17 SDGs. Classification is based on a keyword-based assessment of the stated objectives of each interaction, supplemented by expert review by the analysts to identify the relevant SDGs.
It is important to acknowledge that the database covers a relatively small and selective sample of the broader universe of interactions between PDBs and should therefore be interpreted as capturing illustrative patterns rather than providing exhaustive or statistically representative coverage. The selection of cases is also partly driven by the availability and accessibility of public information, while differences in disclosure practices across institutions may introduce reporting bias and influence the observed distribution of instruments and partnerships. Against this background, the typologies and patterns identified in the analysis are intended to provide a structured analytical lens for understanding how development finance institutions interact, rather than to generate generalisable quantitative estimates for the development finance system.
Table 2. Typology of interactions between PDBs
Copy link to Table 2. Typology of interactions between PDBs|
Category |
Subcategory |
Description |
|
|---|---|---|---|
|
Financial |
Loan |
Direct |
Loan financing disbursed directly to an NDB for its own use, with a repayment obligation. |
|
On lending |
Loan financing provided to an NDB for on lending to final beneficiaries through participating financial institutions (PFIs). |
||
|
Grant |
Direct |
Non-reimbursable financing provided directly to an NDB, with no repayment obligation. |
|
|
Intermediated |
Non-reimbursable financing provided to an NDB for allocation to final beneficiaries through participating financial institutions (PFIs), with no repayment obligation. |
||
|
Guarantee |
A financial commitment or guarantee provided by a PDB that does not involve an immediate transfer or disbursement of capital but creates a potential financial obligation if certain predefined conditions or events occur. |
||
|
Equity and governance participation |
Another PDB holds an equity participation in the NDB or has representation on its governing board. |
||
|
Bond |
A debt instrument issued to raise financing from investors, including green, social, sustainability, and sustainability-linked bonds linked to specific sustainability objectives or targets. |
||
|
Other financial interactions |
Other financial interactions, including fund establishment and management, co-financing, deal co-structuring, and other collaborative financing arrangements. |
||
|
Technical |
Institutional strengthening and governance |
Support to strengthen the NDB’s internal systems, governance, policies, processes, and staff capacity. |
|
|
Beneficiary and partner capacity building |
Support to build the capabilities of external stakeholders, such as PFIs, SMEs, or public-sector partners. |
||
|
Support for the development of financial products and instruments |
Assistance to design or enhance a specific financial product, instrument, or framework for the NDB’s use. |
||
|
Project and transaction structuring advisory |
Advisory support to structure a specific project or transaction into a viable and bankable investment opportunity. |
||
|
Pre-investment and feasibility study support |
Analytical or feasibility work that informs future investments before a specific project or transaction is structured. |
||
|
Other |
Formal co-operation agreements |
A formal partnership established through a MoU, framework agreement, coalition, or membership arrangement. |
|
|
Knowledge exchange and joint research |
Collaboration to produce shared knowledge, research, studies, or analytical outputs. |
||
|
Event co-organisation and participation |
Joint organisation of, or participation in, events focused on stakeholder engagement and knowledge sharing. |
||
Source: Authors’ own elaboration.