Chapter 2 has documented the institutional design of the five Nordic mediation offices and how they conduct the mediation process. This chapter assesses what they achieve. Two distinct contributions are examined: the maintenance of industrial peace and the support of wage co‑ordination to safeguard the competitiveness of the economy.
Previous work on mediation in the Nordic countries, notably Stokke (2009[1]) and Ibsen (2016[2]), has produced rigorous qualitative and comparative assessments of the role of mediation institutions, but no study has yet succeeded in isolating the independent contribution of mediation from the broader institutional environment in which it operates. Evaluation is not straightforward since, as discussed in Chapter 1, mediation offices are only one element in complex industrial relations systems, and attributing outcomes to any single component requires care. A further complication is that the five countries are not a homogeneous group. As the preceding chapters have shown, they differ significantly in how their mediation offices are designed, how their wage co‑ordination architectures function, and in the degree to which those architectures are currently under pressure. Evaluating “Nordic mediation” as if it were a single model obscures as much as it reveals. What this chapter attempts instead is a differentiated assessment: identifying where the evidence is strong, where it is mixed, and what the variation within the Nordic group itself teaches about the conditions under which mediation is likely to perform well or poorly.
Section 3.2 looks at strike intensity in Nordic countries and examines how social partners assess the mediation offices, drawing on stakeholders’ questionnaires and mission interviews. Section 3.3 analyses the wage co‑ordination function: its macroeconomic rationale, how different offices enforce or accommodate departures from the norm, and the distributional tensions co‑ordination generates. Section 3.4 distils key lessons from the comparative evidence and identifies the main challenges these systems face. Section 3.5 concludes by highlighting the main insights for other OECD countries.