Income redistribution differs widely across countries. Several theories have been developed to account for such differences. However, we know little about their relative importance. This working paper fills this gap by contrasting the main theories of preferences for redistribution in a unified empirical framework. Using nationally representative samples of Germany, Italy, Japan, Slovenia, the UK and the US, we find that the belief in equal opportunities to get ahead in life is the strongest predictor of demand for redistribution. The perception of immigrants as a threat significantly reduces preferences for redistribution, whereas other factors such as self-interest, social capital, and experimentally measured pro-sociality play lesser roles. We uncover significant cross-country heterogeneity; for instance, beliefs in equal opportunities strongly influence redistribution preferences in the US, UK, and Germany but are less impactful elsewhere. Contrary to previous research, beliefs in equal opportunities show no significant differences by political orientation, indicating a widely accepted, ideologically neutral view of fairness.
What explains preferences for redistribution?
Evidence from an international survey
Working paper
Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Abstract
In the same series
-
18 November 202657 Pages
-
13 November 202666 Pages
-
Working paper
Practice insights for policy and service delivery
3 November 202660 Pages -
Working paper
A microsimulation framework enhanced by machine learning
13 October 202635 Pages -
Working paper
Evidence from European countries
1 June 202647 Pages -
Working paper
Implications for forward‑looking policy design
24 April 202665 Pages -
Working paper
Updated evidence to inform national data collections
25 June 202573 Pages
Related publications
-
18 November 202657 Pages
-
13 November 202666 Pages
-
Working paper
How transport modes, proximity and capacity shape accessibility across cities, towns and rural areas
30 June 202653 Pages -
Working paper
Does the apple fall far from the tree?
10 March 202687 Pages