This section provides recommendations to the Philippines for developing and implementing its National Student Assessment Framework – referred to locally as the National Basic Education Assessment Framework – and specific assessments. The recommendations may also be of interest to other countries seeking to strengthen their student assessment systems.
Developing a National Student Assessment Framework for the Philippines
3. Recommendations for developing the Philippine National Basic Education Assessment Framework
Copy link to 3. Recommendations for developing the Philippine National Basic Education Assessment FrameworkUse the National Basic Education Assessment Framework to promote a more streamlined, coherent and stable set of national and international assessments and diagnostic tools
Copy link to Use the National Basic Education Assessment Framework to promote a more streamlined, coherent and stable set of national and international assessments and diagnostic toolsThe number of national and international assessments and diagnostic tools has increased steadily over the last decade in the Philippines. However, this expansion has taken place without an overarching framework to guide their development and ensure complementarity. It has also not adequately taken into account the capacity requirements of DepEd to deliver assessments of good quality. This has resulted in an overcrowded national student assessment system that lacks coherence and requires technical improvements in several areas.
As shown above, the problem of overcrowding is particularly apparent in the early years of primary education. This, combined with the lack of clarity in how different types of assessments complement each other, limits their potential to improve learning and creates an unnecessary burden for both teachers and DepEd. The use of diagnostic tools for system monitoring is also problematic, as these are not sufficiently standardised to be used to compare results across schools. Other national assessments – like ELLNA and the NATs – that are better designed for this purpose, have not been stable over time, with decisions on administration taken on an annual basis, weakening their value for monitoring and policymaking.
For these reasons, the OECD recommends that the Philippines should, as intended, use the development of the National Basic Education Assessment Framework to streamline its student assessment system to reduce overlap, ensure greater coherence between assessments and make more efficient use of limited available resources. This includes the technical expertise and organisational capacity of the BEA, which at present is limited but is being strengthened. Such a rationalisation of the assessment landscape is not only important to address current concerns with testing overload but also to enable the quality improvements (see Recommendations 2 and 3 below) that will be needed if assessments are promote better learning outcomes.
What can the Philippines do to promote a coherent set of national and international assessments, and diagnostic tools?
The National Basic Education Assessment Framework is scheduled for regular review, with the first review in 2030 and the second in 2033 (Department of Education, unpublished[3]), meaning that the first iteration of the Framework will cover the period 2026 to 2030. The Framework should remain stable during this time to allow for improvements to the design and implementation of several assessments to be successfully completed (see Improve the quality of centrally developed diagnostic assessment tools and Strengthen the design and reporting of results for the ELLNA and NATs) and ensure stability and predictability for schools, students and other stakeholders.
Table 2 presents an indicative assessment schedule for inclusion in the first Framework. It signals, first, that the DepEd should consider streamlining national assessments in the early grades of primary education, as these overlap in purpose, domains assessed and, to some extent, target grades, by maintaining only the ELLNA. While stakeholders view the EGRA and EGMA positively, these assessments are less well institutionalised for system-level monitoring. Policymakers also appear to place greater emphasis on the ELLNA, as reflected in its use to monitor progress towards the objectives and targets set out in the Philippines’ Basic Education Development Plan 2030.
Table 2. Proposal for an assessment schedule
Copy link to Table 2. Proposal for an assessment schedule|
Assessment |
Grade |
Cohort type |
Domains/subjects |
2026 |
2027 |
2028 |
2029 |
2030 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
National assessments |
||||||||
|
ELLNA |
3 |
Census |
Language, Literacy, and Numeracy |
X |
X |
X |
X |
X |
|
NAT |
6 |
Census |
English, Filipino, Mathematics, Science, Social Sciences |
X |
X |
X |
X |
X |
|
10 |
Census |
English, Filipino, Mathematics, Science, Social Sciences |
X |
X |
X |
X |
X |
|
|
NCAE |
9 |
Census |
Numerical reasoning, verbal reasoning (English), verbal reasoning, (Filipino), abstract-, logical-, mechanical-, and spatial reasoning, perceptual accuracy, response efficiency, career and occupational roles explorer (CORE) |
X |
X |
X |
X |
X |
|
National examinations |
||||||||
|
Upper secondary examination |
12 |
Census |
English, Filipino (including literacy and reading comprehension), mathematics and science |
X |
X |
|||
|
Centrally developed diagnostic tools |
||||||||
|
Standardised diagnostic assessment |
1, 2 |
Census |
English, Filipino and Mathematics |
X |
X |
X |
||
|
8 |
Census |
English, Filipino and Mathematics |
X |
X |
X |
|||
|
International assessments |
||||||||
|
To be confirmed |
||||||||
To help ensure stability, the Framework should also specify whether the ELLNA will be administered annually and whether it will be census-based or sample-based. The DepEd should consider administering the ELLNA as an annual, census-based assessment that serves both system monitoring and formative purposes. The latter is important for helping teachers and students develop the foundational skills needed for future learning and progression.
Second, the DepEd should also consider administering the Grade 6 and Grade 10 NATs as annual, census-based assessments, and replacing the Grade 12 NAT with a national examination (see Recommendation 4). As with the ELLNA, the Framework should clarify that the Grade 6 and Grade 10 NAT serve both system monitoring and formative purposes. However, if the organisational capacity of the BEA and/or the available financial resources do not allow for the implementation of three annual census-based assessments (i.e. the ELLNA and the Grade 6 and Grade 10 NAT), the DepEd may consider prioritising the ELLNA, given its importance in helping ensure that children develop strong foundational skills early in their education.
In the longer term, possibly under the next National Basic Education Assessment Framework, the DepEd may wish to revisit whether maintaining three census-based assessments remains the most appropriate approach. In particular, if diagnostic assessments are strengthened (see Improve the quality of centrally developed diagnostic assessment tools), it could consider adopting a different approach to the Grade 6 and 10 NAT. For example, a sample-based approach, combined with an expanded focus on other domains or cross-cutting competencies, could be used to inform curriculum development, instructional resources and other system-level interventions.
In addition, the DepEd should pursue its plans to replace the Grade 12 NAT with a national examination (following an extended pilot), as this would reinforce curriculum standards, enhance the reliability of the SHS qualification and provide a fairer basis for selection into higher education (see Extend the pilot of the Grade 12 national examination to ensure a strong design, reporting of results and governance).
Third, the DepEd should maintain the NCAE and include it in the Framework. The rationale for keeping the assessment in Grade 9 – to allow for sufficient time for reflection and seeking additional guidance if desired – remains sound.
Fourth, in addition to announcing a review of centrally developed diagnostic assessment tools and setting the direction for their further development (see Improve the quality of centrally developed diagnostic assessment tools), the Framework should explain the complementarities between national assessments and these diagnostic tools in supporting national learning goals.
Finally, the National Basic Education Assessment Framework should reflect the participation of the Philippines in international assessments. It could describe how these complement other assessments and contribute to the monitoring of learning outcomes and national education objectives. As noted, some stakeholders have expressed interest in streamlining the country’s participation in international assessments. Such a possible decision is for the DepEd to take, in line with its strategic objectives.
Strengthen the design and reporting of results for the ELLNA and NATs
Copy link to Strengthen the design and reporting of results for the ELLNA and NATsThe ELLNA and the NATs are important tools for system monitoring in the Philippines. However, evidence points to concerns about their design, particularly regarding alignment with the curriculum and the quality of assessment items.
In addition, there appears to be a misalignment between the purposes of the ELLNA and NAT and the way results are reported. Reporting results as percentage scores, without statistical equating, limits comparability over time and across student populations, reducing their usefulness for system monitoring. Percentage scores and broad proficiency descriptors also provide insufficiently detailed information on students’ specific competencies to support formative use.
What can the Philippines do to strengthen the design and reporting of results for the ELLNA and NATs?
The Philippines has recognised the need for improving the design and reporting of the ELLNA and NATs (Department of Education, unpublished[3]). The BEA should – as planned – initiate this work by reviewing the assessment frameworks of the ELLNA and NAT to ensure their alignment with the new curriculum and strengthen the item development process. This may include piloting a larger pool of items. In addition, BEA has started replacing the use of classical test theoretical modelling with item response theory (IRT) modelling which should be continued as this approach is more robust, scalable and diagnostically useful for item quality assurance, especially in large-scale assessments. For example, IRT allows for evaluating each item independently, estimating parameters such as difficulty and discrimination which have been found to be issues for the ELLNA and NAT in the past.
The review of the ELLNA and NAT assessment frameworks provides a timely opportunity to reconsider item types and introduce a broader range of item formats. Following the practice of several OECD countries, including Australia, France and Italy, the BEA may consider introducing short constructed-response items. The planned transition to digital assessment would facilitate the automated scoring and analysis of results, among other advantages.
Introducing more extensive open-ended items can support the assessment of more complex competencies, such as higher-order thinking and problem-solving skills, as emphasised in the Philippine school curriculum. While the use of extended open-response items in national assessments remains less common across OECD countries, this is changing due to rapid advances in AI-enabled assessment. AI‑enabled assessment allows for the analysis and scoring of both selected-response and constructed-response items (Okubo et al., 2023[18]; OECD, 2025[19]), making it feasible to include such items at scale in a more efficient manner.
The BEA should also pursue its plans for replacing percentage scores with proficiency levels. As suggested by the Second Congressional Commission for Education (2026[5]), the Philippines should consider establishing a common proficiency scale for the ELLNA and NATs. A common scale enables the identification of performance patterns across the education cycle, the detection of emerging learning gaps, and targeting interventions more effectively. The BEA may look towards examples of Australia’s National Assessment Program – Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) (NAP, n.d.[20]) and Brazil’s – SAEB for developing its own proficiency scale (see Box 1).
As part of its expansion of digital assessment the BEA should – as planned – introduce automatically generated school- and student-level feedback reports to support the assessments’ formative function. These reports could include item- and skill-level analyses to help teachers target instruction, support student learning, and inform school improvement planning. The BEA may look towards OECD countries such as Chile (see Box 3), France (French Ministry of National Education and Youth, 2022[21]), and Wales (United Kingdom) (Welsh Government, 2025[22]) for examples of such feedback reports.
The introduction of such fine-grained feedback reports should be accompanied by capacity development of teachers and school leaders in their use for tailoring instruction to meet students’ needs and school improvement planning.
Box 1. Using a vertical proficiency scale to report assessment results across grades: Examples from Australia and Brazil
Copy link to Box 1. Using a vertical proficiency scale to report assessment results across grades: Examples from Australia and BrazilAustralia’s National Assessment Program – Literacy and Numeracy
Australia’s National Assessment Program – Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) provides information to parents, schools, and authorities about students’ skills relative to national proficiency standards and supports system-level monitoring of achievement trends. Since 2023, results are reported using four proficiency levels – Exceeding, Strong, Developing, and Needs Additional Support – for each literacy and numeracy domain and for each tested year level (Years 3, 5, 7, and 9). These levels describe what students typically know and can do at the time of testing.
NAPLAN’s measurement scales are designed so that student achievement scores sit on the same underlying scale across year levels and cycles, enabling comparisons across grades and school cohorts and monitoring performance trends over time. Figure 4 illustrates the progression of proficiency levels from Year 3 to Year 9, while Table 3 provides an example of the placement of each proficiency level on the NAPLAN numeracy scale.
Figure 4. Illustration of NAPLAN proficiency levels across years
Copy link to Figure 4. Illustration of NAPLAN proficiency levels across years
© Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) 2011 to present, unless otherwise indicated. This material was downloaded from the National Assessment Program website (website) (accessed on 23 October 2026) and was not modified. The material is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY) licence. ACARA does not endorse any product that uses ACARA material or make any representations as to the quality of such products. Any product that uses ACARA's material should not be taken to be affiliated with ACARA or have the sponsorship or approval of ACARA. It is up to each person to make their own assessment of the product.
Table 3. NAPLAN numeracy scale score cut points between proficiency levels
Copy link to Table 3. NAPLAN numeracy scale score cut points between proficiency levels|
Domain |
Year |
Needs additional support/ Developing |
Developing / Strong |
Strong/Exceeding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Numeracy |
3 |
311 |
378 |
493 |
|
5 |
386 |
451 |
577 |
|
|
7 |
431 |
500 |
632 |
|
|
9 |
463 |
536 |
673 |
Brazil’s Basic Education Assessment System (Sistema de Avaliação da Educação Básica, SAEB)
Created in the early 1990s, the Brazilian Basic Education Assessment System (SAEB) is a set of large-scale external assessments and Brazil’s main national instrument for measuring student learning outcomes. It is designed to assess achievement in key subjects, primarily Portuguese language and mathematics, and in some cases science; to evaluate education quality across schools, states and regions; to provide evidence to inform education policy and resource allocation; and to track trends in student achievement over time.
SAEB combines sample-based and census-based components, depending on the assessment strand and grade level. Students in selected grades, commonly Grade 5, Grade 9 and the final year of secondary education, take standardised assessments.
SAEB reports student performance using a vertical proficiency scale. This means that results from different grades – Grades 5 and 9 in basic education and Grade 12 in upper secondary education – are placed on a single continuous measurement scale and are reported using four proficiency levels (Insufficient, Basic, Proficient and Advanced) at each tested grade. Each level is accompanied by a pedagogical description of the skills and knowledge students are typically able to demonstrate. Table 4 provides an example of the placement of each proficiency level on the Portuguese language scale.
The scale is constructed using Item Response Theory (IRT), which links student performance to item difficulty across different test forms. It also enables comparison of results across years and grades on a consistent basis, allowing the progression of student learning through schooling to be tracked and learning gaps to be identified.
Table 4. SAEB Portuguese language score cut points between proficiency levels
Copy link to Table 4. SAEB Portuguese language score cut points between proficiency levels|
Performance standard |
Grade 5 |
Grade 9 |
Grade 12 |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Insufficient |
Up to 150 |
Up to 200 |
Up to 250 |
|
Basic |
From 151 to 200 |
From 201 to 275 |
From 250 to 300 |
|
Proficient |
From 201 to 250 |
From 276 to 325 |
From 301 to 375 |
|
Advanced |
251 or more |
326 or more |
376 or more |
Source: NAP (n.d.[20]), NAPLAN – Results and reports, www.nap.edu.au/naplan/results-and-reports; Instituto Nacional de Estudos e Pesquisas Educacionais (2025[23]), Matrizes e Escalas, www.gov.br/inep/pt-br/areas-de-atuacao/avaliacao-e-exames-educacionais/saeb/matrizes-e-escalas; OECD (2021[24]), “National assessment reform: Core considerations for Brazil”, OECD Education Policy Perspectives, No. 34, https://doi.org/10.1787/333a6e20-en.
Improve the quality of centrally developed diagnostic assessment tools
Copy link to Improve the quality of centrally developed diagnostic assessment toolsLike many OECD countries, the DepEd has developed diagnostic assessment tools to help teachers identify students’ learning gaps early in the school year. However, there are concerns regarding both the design and use of these tools. Although they are intended for both system-level monitoring and diagnostic purposes, teacher-led administration and scoring limit the reliability of the data and reduce comparability across schools. In addition, the diagnostic tools are not as closely aligned with the curriculum as they could be. Weak links to specific competencies limits the identification of students’ learning needs and, in turn, reduces their formative value. Teachers also report a high workload associated with administering these tools.
Furthermore, the use of different proficiency scales across diagnostic tools, which also differ from those used in national assessments, can be confusing for teachers and students and does not support a shared understanding of expected learning standards. As a result, teachers receive fragmented information on student performance from different diagnostic tools and national assessments, limiting their ability to interpret results consistently, track learning progress and use the data effectively to inform instruction.
Taken together, these challenges point to the need for a comprehensive review of these diagnostic tools to bring them in line with international quality standards.
What can the Philippines do to strengthen the quality of centrally developed diagnostic assessment tools?
As mentioned above, the DepEd should use the development of the National Basic Education Assessment Framework 2026-30 as an opportunity to review the diagnostic assessment tools with the aim of strengthening their quality. The review should start by revisiting their purpose which would guide all decisions on the desired features and design requirements. The DepEd needs to decide whether to maintain the current dual purpose of the diagnostic tools, or to restrict their use to diagnostic functions only. This decision will have implications for the degree of standardisation in administration and marking processes, as well as for the psychometric foundations of the tools.
Option 1: A high degree of standardisation and strong psychometric basis
If the decision is taken to maintain the diagnostic tools’ dual purpose, meaning also supporting system monitoring, that would argue for a high degree of standardisation and ensuring a strong psychometric basis to ensure comparability and measurement precision. A high degree of standardisation includes uniform administration conditions (e.g. identical instructions, timing, and procedures across all schools) and standardised scoring with clear rubrics and quality controls to ensure consistency, often best achieved through central marking. A robust psychometric foundation typically involves the use of IRT or a comparable scaling model to place student performance on a common proficiency scale, as well as equating procedures and anchor items to ensure score comparability across test forms and over time.
Assessments with a high degree of standardisation and strong psychometrics also typically use a mix of item types, with a significant use of selected-response items to support reliability, comparability and psychometric scaling, complemented by constructed-response items or performance-based tasks to capture more complex competencies (e.g. reasoning, critical thinking, communication or problem-solving). Northern Ireland’s CCEA Adaptive Assessments is an example of this (see Box 2).
Box 2. Northern Ireland’s CCEA Adaptive Assessments
Copy link to Box 2. Northern Ireland’s CCEA Adaptive AssessmentsNorthern Ireland’s CCEA Adaptive Assessments, introduced in the late 2010s, are computer-adaptive diagnostic assessments designed primarily to provide baseline information at the start of the school year. They are administered in Years 4 to 10 and assess key domains such as literacy (reading) and numeracy. The assessments are delivered on screen and are adaptive, with test duration varying according to student responses but typically lasting around 30‑60 minutes per assessment. Administration is relatively flexible within a defined window, allowing schools to schedule assessments at a time that supports teaching and learning, while maintaining standardised delivery conditions through the digital platform.
The assessments use mainly selected-response and short constructed-response item types, underpinned by item response theory (IRT) to ensure measurement precision and comparability. Results are reported on a standardised scale and are available shortly after completion. Feedback to teachers includes overall standardised scores, age-related comparisons, and diagnostic information on students’ performance across different strands or skill areas within literacy and numeracy.
Source: Council for the Curriculum, Examinations & Assessment (n.d.[25]) CCEA Adaptive Assessments, https://ccea.org.uk/learning-resources/ccea-adaptive-assessments.
There are several advantages to using standardised diagnostic assessments. These include enabling closer system-level monitoring of student progress, as well as providing reliable data to inform decisions on the targeting of additional resources to schools. However, a key limitation is the cost of developing technically robust items, which can be substantial, particularly if standardised diagnostic assessments are developed across multiple grades, as is currently the case in the Philippines. In addition, even where there are no direct consequences for schools, the use of such assessments for system monitoring may lead teachers to focus too narrowly on measured performance rather than learning, thereby undermining the formative purpose of diagnostic assessments.
For these reasons, many OECD countries administer standardised diagnostic assessments in only a limited number of grades, with several countries complementing them with other high-quality centrally developed diagnostic tools. Countries also tend to avoid administering standardised diagnostic assessments in the same years as national assessments or examinations to avoid overlap, limit assessment burden and contain costs.
Option 2: A more flexible approach to both standardisation and psychometrics
If diagnostic tools are to be designed solely for diagnostic purposes, the Philippines can adopt a more flexible approach to both standardisation and psychometrics. Administration and scoring procedures do not need to be fully standardised, and could allowing for classroom-based delivery and teacher-led marking if desired. Although possible, there is no requirement for common scaling, equating, or anchor items across test forms or over time. Instead, the focus shifts to diagnostic validity, with assessments aligned to the curriculum and learning progressions and designed to provide detailed, actionable feedback to support teaching and learning.
Such diagnostic tools can draw on a broad mix of item types, including constructed-response items, selected-response items and performance-based tasks – chosen for their ability to reveal student understanding and misconceptions, rather than to maximise psychometric comparability. Chile’s Integral Learning Diagnosis (Diagnóstico Integral de Aprendizajes, DIA) is an example of such an assessment tool (see Box 3).
Less standardised diagnostic tools may have several advantages, including offering greater flexibility and stronger instructional relevance, as they can be closely aligned with what is taught in a specific classroom. They may also encourage a stronger focus on student learning and formative use of assessment data. However, a key limitation is that such tools may not generate reliable and comparable data that can inform policy decisions.
Box 3. Chile’s Integral Learning Diagnosis (Diagnóstico Integral de Aprendizajes, DIA)
Copy link to Box 3. Chile’s Integral Learning Diagnosis (Diagnóstico Integral de Aprendizajes, DIA)Created in 2021 during the COVID-19 pandemic, DIA is a formative student assessment tool designed to support teachers and schools in identifying students’ learning needs and informing instructional planning throughout the school year.
The DIA is applied across primary and secondary education, from Grade 1 to 12. It covers key learning domains, including reading and mathematics, as well as writing in selected grades and socio-emotional learning across most grade levels. The assessment is structured to reflect curriculum expectations at different stages of schooling. The DIA is administered multiple times per year, typically at key points in the school cycle (diagnostic, intermediate, and end-of-year applications). This enables schools to monitor student progress over time and adjust instruction during the academic year.
The assessment is primarily delivered through an online platform, but with paper-based versions available where digital access is limited. A mix of item types is used, including selected-response and constructed-response tasks, complemented by socio-emotional questionnaires in some cycles.
A key feature of the DIA is the integration of assessment and feedback through digital dashboards. Results are automatically processed and reported at multiple levels of granularity, including individual student, class, grade, and school levels. The dashboards provide breakdowns by learning domain and skill area, enabling teachers to identify specific strengths and learning gaps. At the individual level feedback reports include:
Overall achievement level in the assessed domain (e.g. reading or mathematics), expressed through a performance category or proficiency level.
Skill-level indicators, identifying more specific competencies or learning objectives where the student demonstrates mastery or difficulty. These are aligned with curriculum-based learning progressions.
Item-level feedback (where applicable), indicating whether the student answered specific questions correctly or incorrectly, sometimes grouped by skill type.
Interpretive descriptors, which translate performance into qualitative statements (e.g. emerging, developing, or proficient relative to expected learning progression).
This granularity is intended to support targeted instructional planning and timely remedial action.
Source: OECD (2026[26]), Towards Chile’s next plan for student assessments, OECD Education Policy Perspectives, No. 135, https://doi.org/10.1787/e703ddc4-en.
Importantly, these two options are not mutually exclusive. The DepEd may wish to consider different designs for different grades. First, there would be redundancy in administering additional standardised assessments in Grades 4, 7 and 11, given that the ELLNA in Grade 3 and the NAT in Grades 6 and 10 are conducted at the end of the previous school year for the same cohorts. Avoiding this overlap could help ease the assessment burden on students and teachers, lower costs and free up time for more effective use of assessment results.
However, additional reliable data from standardised diagnostic assessments may be useful in selected grades, for example in Grades 1 and/or 2 in the early years of primary education, where such information could help teachers identify learning gaps early and take timely remedial action, and in Grade 8 in secondary education – assuming measures are in place to ensure that Grade 6 NAT results are shared in a timely manner with Grade 7 teachers for formative use at the start of the following school year. In that case, a standardised diagnostic assessment may be more appropriately positioned at the start of Grade 8 than Grade 7.
Administering standardised diagnostic assessments in a limited number of grades can help free up resources for the DepEd to invest in other diagnostic tools designed more deliberately for teachers’ classroom use. In addition to Chile’s DIA (see Box 3), the Philippines might look to New Zealand’s e-asTTle Assessment Tool as an example of the type of resource that could be created. This tool generates standardised assessments for classroom use in reading, mathematics, writing. Teachers can create tests online by selecting content domains and levels from a 10 000-item bank. The system then auto-assembles the test or applies an adaptive algorithm if delivered online. Closed items are auto scored, while open items are marked by teachers using rubrics and exemplars. After the marking, e-asTTle generates interactive graphic reports that help analyse student achievement against curriculum objectives. This can help teachers understand what their students know and might need to learn next (OECD, 2023[27]).
Regardless of the option(s) chosen and the number of grades in which diagnostic assessment tools are administered, the DepEd should consider several design features in reviewing the current diagnostic tools. First, it should ensure conceptual alignment of assessment domains across assessment frameworks and develop common proficiency levels across diagnostic assessment tools and national assessments as recommended above. This would help establish a shared understanding of curriculum standards and enable better tracking of learning progression, among other benefits.
Second, feedback should be sufficiently granular to support targeted instruction. The digital administration of diagnostic tools could enable the automatic generation of fine-grained skill-level and item-level analysis to identify learning gaps and better target instruction.
Third, while literacy and numeracy are also the most common focus of diagnostic assessment in OECD countries at primary and secondary levels, the Philippines could – in due time – consider expanding coverage to other domains or competencies. The National Basic Education Assessment Framework 2026‑30 could announce such ideas for further development of the diagnostic assessment tools, even if implementation does not occur within this period.
Extend the pilot of the Grade 12 national examination to ensure a strong design, reporting of results and governance
Copy link to Extend the pilot of the Grade 12 national examination to ensure a strong design, reporting of results and governanceIn response to concerns about the Senior High School (SHS) qualification, the Philippines is initiating a pilot Grade 12 national examination that is set for administration in the 2026/27 school year. The examination aims to determine whether students meet SHS curriculum standards and support a fair selection into higher education. It is intended to strengthen the reliability and comparability of the SHS diploma by contributing 30% of the final grade and to replace the various entrance examinations currently administered by higher education institutions. It is delivered digitally, representing an innovation in the national context.
While this represents a promising policy response, the pilot period is unclear at present. Extending the pilot beyond the 2026/27 year would be important to fully test and refine the assessment design. This is particularly important given concerns that the piloted examination may place greater emphasis on student selection than on certification against SHS curriculum standards, potentially disadvantaging students in non-academic tracks. If the Grade 12 examination is to effectively serve a dual function, then the government will need to trial a passing threshold for the examination and determine how to ensure comparability of results across school years. These are technically challenging and may require adjustments, which argues for a process extending beyond a one-year pilot. Furthermore, the governance arrangements for the national examination appear relatively weak compared with those in many OECD countries. These, too, will need to be clarified before such a consequential new assessment is introduced.
What can the Philippines do to ensure a strong design, report of results and governance of the Grade 12 examination?
The Philippines should consider extending the pilot of the Grade 12 national examination – for example, by an additional two or three school years – to allow sufficient time to test and refine the assessment design and reporting of results, as well as to strengthen its governance arrangements.
Building on plans to establish an Inter-Agency Committee, the DepEd should establish a clear governance framework that promotes more balanced stakeholder input into examination design, alongside professional independence and robust quality assurance. This may include an expert Board that oversees the development, administration and quality assurance of the examination. It is important for the DepEd to set the overall mandate for the Board, i.e. the direction and purpose(s) of the examination. The Philippines may look to countries such as the Finland and New Zealand for example (see Box 4).
Box 4. Independent and inclusive governance frameworks of upper secondary examinations: Examples from Finland and New Zealand
Copy link to Box 4. Independent and inclusive governance frameworks of upper secondary examinations: Examples from Finland and New ZealandFinnish Matriculation Examination Board
Finland’s matriculation examination, taken at the end of general upper secondary education, is overseen by the Finnish Matriculation Examination Board, an independent body established in 1852 and operating under the Ministry of Education and Culture. The Board is responsible for the development, administration and quality assurance of the examination, which certifies student achievement and supports selection into higher education.
A key feature of the Finnish system is its balanced governance structure, which brings together representatives from universities, upper secondary schools and the education administration. This helps ensure alignment between the examination, the national curriculum and expectations for further study, while limiting the influence of any single stakeholder group. Subject-specific expert groups, including experienced teachers and academic specialists, contribute to item development and marking, supported by clear quality assurance and moderation processes.
New Zealand Qualifications Authority
New Zealand’s upper secondary qualification, the National Certificate of Educational Achievement (NCEA), is overseen by the New Zealand Qualifications Authority, established in 1990 as the central body responsible for qualifications and assessment. NZQA manages the development, administration and quality assurance of both internally and externally assessed components of NCEA, ensuring that national standards are applied consistently across schools.
A defining feature of the system is NZQA’s structured engagement with a wide range of stakeholders. The Authority works closely with the Ministry of Education, secondary schools, tertiary education providers, subject experts and industry representatives to develop and review achievement standards and assessment practices. Schools play a key role in delivering and marking internal assessments, while NZQA oversees external examinations and implements robust moderation processes to ensure consistency and comparability of results nationwide.
While adapted to their respective national contexts, the examples from Finland and New Zealand illustrate how inclusive and well-defined governance frameworks can strengthen the validity, reliability and credibility of national examinations, while maintaining stakeholder trust and supporting multiple policy objectives.
Source: Finnish Matriculation Examination Board. (2026[28]), About the Matriculation Examination. Finnish Matriculation Examination Board, www.ylioppilastutkinto.fi/en/matriculation-examination; New Zealand Qualifications Authority (2025[29]), About NZQA, www.nzqa.govt.nz/about-us/.
Under this governance framework, the Philippines should, as part of an extended pilot, review the design of the national examination to ensure that it supports the dual purpose of recognising student achievement against SHS curriculum standards and enabling fair and transparent selection into higher education.
In relation to the first purpose, the proposed review should include an examination of the assessment framework and test instruments to ensure alignment with SHS curriculum standards. It should also include an analysis of examination results to assess whether all students, including those in less academically oriented tracks such as Technical-Vocational-Livelihood (TVL), Arts and Design, and Sports (Technical Professional from 2026/27 onwards), are able to achieve a minimum level of proficiency consistent with curriculum expectations. In addition, the review could analyse examination results in relation to school-based assessment outcomes. The findings of such analysis could inform decisions on the appropriate weighting of examination results relative to school-based assessment.
In relation to the second function, the review will need to determine how the examination will differentiate students with more advanced competencies at the higher end of the distribution. An in-depth analysis of examination results will help the Philippines ensure items are sufficiently discriminating and answer key questions, such as whether it might be helpful to set some subjects at different levels, as is the case in some OECD countries, such as England (United Kingdom), Ireland and several states in Australia (OECD, 2026[15]).
Beyond questions of test design, the Philippines will need to pay particular attention to how it sets the passing threshold for the national examination and reports results. This is important for an assessment, but in particular for those that carry high stakes for students. Following practice in many OECD countries, the Philippines could report results as percentage scores for certification purposes and trial a minimum passing threshold (e.g. 40% or 50%). Statistical analyses could then be used to assess whether results are consistent with expectations and the passing threshold appropriately reflects basic curriculum standards at Grade 12.
The pilot should also examine an approach to reporting examination results that ensures comparability of outcomes across years. Many OECD countries use statistical methods to assess whether results are in line with expectations, often complemented by qualitative information such as examiner reports, to support adjustments where necessary. The Philippines may draw on international experience to define its own approach. For example, in Ireland, marking schemes for the Leaving Certificate are adjusted during the marking process, informed by statistical analysis, when results diverge from expected distributions, to help ensure that standards remain consistent across years (2018[30]).
Another, slightly different example is provided by the Netherlands. To ensure comparability across school years, exam results are statistically equated using anchor items and pre-tested questions, and centrally coordinated grading standards are applied. The national examination board, the College for Tests and Exams, monitors yearly score distributions to detect shifts in difficulty and makes adjustments accordingly (College for Tests and Exams, n.d.[31]).
The Philippines should use the evidence gathered through these piloting efforts to inform the next steps in the development and potential nationwide implementation of the Grade 12 national examination. The challenge – as for all countries – will be to strike an appropriate balance between the two purposes of certification and selection. This takes time and provides further justification for an extended pilot period.