This report analyses existing competitive research funding mechanisms and their effectiveness, taking into account a variety of contextual factors. It focuses on the efficiency of funding allocation mechanisms relative to their objectives. It is aimed both at the research funding community and policy-makers wishing to adapt competitive research funding strategies to different objectives. It includes a number of policy recommendations, which engage different actors and are derived from the analysis including identification of gaps in the available data and information.
Digitalisation is fundamentally changing science and the paper lays out some of the opportunities, risks and major policy challenges associated with these changes. More specifically, the paper lays out a conceptual framework for open science. This framework incorporates access to data and information, as well as civil society engagement, in the different stages of the scientific research process.
This report identifies the challenges faced by research infrastructure funders, managers and operators throughout the different phases of the research infrastructure life-cycle. It presents practical solutions arising from case studies and proposes a series of policy recommendations.
This report explores the challenges and enablers for the effective functioning of international research data networks. It includes a set of policy recommendations as a basis for building the shared understanding that is necessary to develop effective and sustainable international research data networks
Open research agenda setting
This report includes an analysis of 7 different initiatives to engage citizens in the co-design of research agendas. The report includes 10 key observations or lessons learned to help guide policy-makers, research funders and researchers who are interested in citizen engagement in science.
This report includes an analysis of 8 case studies of digital platforms that collate information and provide services to promote broader access to, and more effective use of, research infrastructures. A number of key issues are identified that can help guide policy-makers, funders, institutions and managers, who are interested in developing or contributing to such platforms.
This report explores the income streams, costs, value propositions, and business models for 48 research data repositories. It includes a set of recommendations designed to provide a framework for developing sustainable business models and to assist policy makers and funders in supporting repositories with a balance of policy regulation and incentives.
This report has been compiled by members of the Astroparticle Physics International Forum (APIF), which was established in 2011 following the recommendation of a GSF Working Group. The report serves a standard accountability function and details the activities and the value of APIF in the period up to the end of 2016, during which it has convened under the aegis of OECD-GSF. In 2017, the APIF secretariat was transferred to the Kavli Institute for Astroparticle Physics and Astrology at Stanford University, USA.
This report sets out some basic rules that underpin an ethical approach to research using new forms of data for social and economic research. These rules and the interpretation that we place on them give rise to a set of recommendations designed to provide a framework for the ethical governance of research using such data.
Governments would benefit from agreeing common principles for developing and communicating scientific advice, both in crisis situations and for long-term policymaking, according to a new OECD report. In light of recent controversies around science advice, the report proposes a checklist for countries to follow to ensure science advisory processes are effective and trustworthy.
A very significant proportion of global agricultural production originates from temperate countries, and this proportion may increase with climate change. The development of sustainable agriculture processes requires the development of new policies and management strategies. As a result of this OECD GSF activity, a new international research network was created, “TempAg”, for governments and institutions seeking to increase the impact and return on the investments that Members make in their national research programmes.
Global challenges, such as climate change and biodiversity loss, have increasingly become the subject of international policy deliberations. It is widely recognised that strong and effective international co-operation is required to address these issues. Co-operation in science and technology between developed and developing countries is considered to be of particular importance.
This report examines some of the economic and societal impacts of one of the largest global international research facilities: the European Organisation for Nuclear Research (CERN). By focusing on selected case studies, the report aims to shed light on generic questions that could be applicable more broadly to international research infrastructures.
International Distributed Research Infrastructures
This report presents findings and analyses regarding formal status, governance, establishment, funding, access and other issues. It is the result of a survey of existing infrastructures, followed by discussions among infrastructure practitioners: researchers, facility administrators, officials of ministries and funding agencies.
Global Science Forum report on data and research infrastructure for the social sciences.
The OECD has issued a Recommendation to its members on the Governance of Clinical Trials, a major initiative for facilitating medical research and improving public health. This Recommendation is the result of extensive work of the OECD Global Science Forum on the hurdles encountered by the clinical research community in setting up international clinical trials.
This report analyses existing gaps in data, knowledge and practices in the field of risk assessment for large and complex disasters. It proposes a series of policy recommendations aimed at improving international co-operation in two major areas: (i) assessing and modelling the risk of large-scale domino/cascading effects caused by natural hazards interacting with technological risks; and (ii) developing international standards, methodologies and tools for use at the local level, enabling consistency and interoperability of data and models.
This report identifies the hurdles encountered by the clinical research community in setting up international clinical trials and proposes a series of policy recommendations aimed at overcoming main challenges. As a follow up to this activity, a new international initiative, The Clinical Research Initiative for Global Health (CRIGH) was incubated under the auspices of the GSF and officially launched in January 2017.
This report identifies the existing tools and strategies for urban modelling and their current limitations, and proposes a series of policy recommendations aimed at improving the effectiveness and use of urban models.
This report describes issues and options that deserve the attention of scientists and administrators, in both industrialised and developing countries, as they seek to design, initiate and manage collaborative research programmes and projects that include both scientific and development goals.
This report sets out a strategic vision of the future of the field, reflecting the perspectives of agency officials, laboratory administrators, and scientists. It incorporates considerations of cost, schedule, human resources, benefits to society, and the prospects for international co-operation.
Large Research Infrastructures
This document contains both the report on Roadmapping of Large Research Infrastructures (2008) and the report on Establishing Large International Research Infrastructures: Issues and Options (2010).
Encouraging Student Interest in Science and Technology Studies
This report examines overall trends in higher education enrolments and the evolution of S&T compared with other disciplines. The results suggest that although absolute numbers of S&T students have been rising as access to higher levels of education expands in OECD economies, the relative share of S&T students among the overall student population has been falling.
The following reports from the Global Science Forum archives are available upon request.
Applications of Complexity Science for Public Policy: New Tools for Finding Unanticipated Consequences and Unrealised Opportunities
This report explores the concepts and methods that characterise complexity science and the implications of complexity science for public policy.
Improving the Dialogue with Society on Scientific Issues
This report provides practical recommendations for facilitating an efficacious dialogue with society on scientific issues.
Practical Guide for Investigating Research Misconduct Allegations in International Collaborative Research Projects
This short guide provides practical recommendations and tools to help in the investigation of possible cases of research misconduct in international research collaborations.
Facilitating International Research Misconduct Investigations
This report provides practical recommendations and tools to help in the investigation of possible cases of research misconduct in international research collaborations.
Mechanisms for Promoting Mathematics in Industry
This report provides practical reference regarding the options available to those (in industry, academia, or government) who wish to strengthen links between academic mathematics and industry.
Policy Issues Related to Scientific Research Collections
This report presents the findings and recommendations from two workshops, held in the Netherlands and the United States in 2007 and 2008, regarding the maintenance, utilisation and international co-ordination of scientific research collections. Following this report, a global consortium, Scientific Collection International (SciColl) was incubated and then set up between 2010 and 2017, to promote the use and impact of scientific collections and catalyse international and interdisciplinary collaboration
Roadmapping of Large Research Infrastructures
This report is based on an examination of some 20 roadmaps. It focuses on the process through which they were prepared, and identifies key considerations and good practices that deserve the attention of anyone contemplating the undertaking of a new roadmapping exercise.
Mathematics in Industry
This report contains findings emphasising the significant (and largely unrealised) potential of applying advanced mathematics to modern industrial problems. Mechanisms of proven efficacy are described, for implementation by universities, institutes, companies and government agencies.
Report of the Working Group on Nuclear Physics
The Working Group on Nuclear Physics was established to analyse the plans for nuclear physics in the various countries and regions, the mechanisms and rationales that underlie priorities and strategies, and the needs and opportunities for enhanced international collaboration and co-ordination.
International Polar Year (IPY) report
This survey examines the planning and initiation of the IPY as a role model for International Years in general. It is envisaged that further work will deal with the execution and outcomes of the ‘Year’.
Report from the Workshop on Best Practices for Ensuring Scientific Integrity and Preventing Misconduct
The goal of the workshop was to deepen the understanding of the underlying phenomena, identify the range of possible solutions and, based on experience, enumerate the pros and cons of various practical measures, lessons learned and good practices. This report summarises the deliberations that took place during the workshop.
Report from the Conference on Scientific Challenges for Energy Research
The GSF Conference on Scientific Challenges for Energy Research was held on 17-18 May 2006 at the French Ministry of Research in Paris. It brought together 180 technical and policy experts from 28 countries. Also available in French under the title: Rapport sur la conférence des défis scientifiques de la recherche énergétique
Report from the Workshop on Earthquake Science
The workshop explored the opportunities for new and/or enhanced international co-operation in the field of earthquake sciences in connection to their contribution to society. It was held in Potsdam, Germany on 1-2 June 2006. Following this activity, a unique global collaborative effort, the Global Earthquake Model Foundation (GEM) was developed between public and private stakeholders, that brings together state-of-the-art science, national, regional and international organisations and individuals aimed at the establishment of uniform and open standards for calculating and communicating earthquake risk worldwide.
Summary of the Workshop on Science of Science Policy
The goal of this workshop was to strengthen the links between real-life, high-level science policy decisions and quantitative/analytical as well as qualitative models of the social and economic impacts of research and development (R&D) investments. Also available in French: Atelier sur l'étude de la politique scientifique: Améliorer notre compréhension des investissements scientifiques publics
Report from the Workshop on Science and Technology for a Safer Society
Modern societies are exposed to numerous natural and man-made hazards, and governments are keenly motivated to reduce the resulting harm to the lowest levels.
Evolution of Student Interest in Science and Technology Studies
Are student enrolments in Science and Technology studies really going down? What are the factors that affect students’ choices? What are the mechanisms that can be implemented to influence such choices? Also available in French: Rapport d'orientation sur l'évolution de l'intérêt des jeunes pour les études scientifiques et technologiques
Grids and Basic Research Programmes
Final consensus report from the workshop held in Sydney, Australia on 25-27 September 2005.
Template for Establishing, Funding, and Managing an International Scientific Research Project Based on an Agreement Between Governments or Institutions
This paper describes a template for establishing and managing international collaborative research, based on an agreement by governments, governmental institutions, or other organisations.
Report from the Workshop on Management Practices for Establishing Large International Scientific Research Projects
Convened in October 2004, the workshop gathered laboratory administrators and funding agency officials.
Report from the Workshops on Future Large-Scale Projects and Programmes in Astronomy and Astrophysics
Attended by prominent scientists and programme managers from scientific funding agencies of seventeen OECD member and non-member countries, these two workshops explored the challenges and opportunities of a new international era of research in astronomy. The final consensus report from the workshops is an 18-page document that contains findings and recommendations for actions by governments and scientific organisations.
Report of the Task Force on Radio Astronomy and the Radio Spectrum
Radio astronomers wish to conduct observations across the entire radio spectrum, not just within the confines of the narrow frequency bands allocated to them by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU).
Report from the Workshop on Best Practices in International Scientific Co-operation
Establishing, funding and conducting large-scale international research collaborations are complex tasks, involving scientists, research institutes, funding bodies, and various governmental and intergovernmental organisations.
How a Near-Earth Object Impact Might Affect Society
Report commissioned by the GSF for the Workshop on Near Earth Objects: Risks, Policies, and Actions held in Frascati, Italy in January 2003.
Workshop on Near Earth Objects: Risks, Policies and Actions - Final Report
This report summarises the Global Science Forum’s contribution to the dialog between scientists and policymakers regarding an appropriate response to the threat to lives and property of an impact by an asteroid or comet. A series of practical steps are recommended.
Report of the Neuroinformatics Working Group
The human brain is by far the most complex system known to man, and understanding it is a major scientific challenge for the 21st century. This fascinating task is made urgent by the potential for practical applications. As a result of the recommendations of the report, a new international non-profit organisation was created in 2005, the International Neuroinformatics Coordinating Facility (INCF). INCF develops collaborative neuroinformatics infrastructure and promote the sharing of data and computing resources to the international research community
Unofficial introductory paper on high-energy physics
High-energy physics seeks to answer basic questions: what is our world made of and how does it work?
Report of the Consultative Group on High-Energy Physics
The GSF established the Consultative Group on High-Energy Physics in June 2000.
Workshop on Large Facilities for Studying the Structure and Dynamics of Matter
This report contains the principal findings and conclusions of the workshop held in Copenhagen on 20-21 September 2001.
Compact High-Intensity Short-Pulse Lasers
Final report of the Workshop on Compact High-Intensity Short-Pulse Lasers: Future Directions and Applications, held at the JAERI Kansai Research Establishment in Kyoto, Japan on 28-30 May 2001 (lead country: Japan).
Proton Beam Facilities
Final report of the Workshop on Strategic Policy Issues Concerning Future High-Intensity Proton Beam Facilities held in Paris on 25-26 September 2000 (lead countries: France and UK).
Final report of the Workshop on Structural Genomics held in Florence on 8-9 June 2000 (lead country: Italy).
Deep-Sea Neutrino Observatory
Final report of the OECD Megascience Forum Workshop on Deep-Sea Neutrino Observatory held in Taormina, Italy on 22-23 May 1997 (lead countries: Greece, Italy).
Final report of the OECD Megascience Forum Working Group on Biological Informatics (lead country: United States). Following this report, a new international open-data research infrastructure was lanched in 2001, the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF), which makes scientific data on biodiversity available worldwide.