Concurrence

Evaluation of Competition Interventions

 

Governments everywhere are increasingly interested in assessing the effects of their policies and the effectiveness of public institutions. Competition policy is no exception. Competition agencies affect the economy by taking decisions on mergers and allegedly anticompetitive behavious under competition law. Through their advocacy activities they can influence policy making and this have an impact on specific sectors and on the economy as a whole. Furthermore, they are often called to show the impact that their enforcement and advocacy activities have on the affected markets and on consumers, as well as more widely on macro-economic variables. 

From 2012 to 2016, the Evaluation of competition interventions was one of the strategic priorities of the OECD’s Competition Committee work. Through discussions, roundtables and workshops the OECD has gathered evidence of existing best practices in this area and has tried to expand the range of techniques that can be used. 

Broad categories studied and resulting outputs

The OECD work on improving the methods to measure the effects of competition interventions focused on three broad categories:

  • Evaluation for accountability
  • Ex-post evaluation of specific competition enforcement interventions. 
  • Evaluation of broader impact of competition policy on the economy

The in-depth analysis of each category allowed us to come up with three specific publications to address the issues under study. 

 

Evaluation for accountability and the Guide on Impact Assessment

Competition authorities, like other public bodies, need to regularly report about their activities to government, the public and other stakeholders typically on an annual basis.

Increasingly, such authorities are interested in providing measures of the expected 'impact' on consumers of the decisions on mergers and antitrust infrigements they took over the period under examination. These measures allow them to present in a concise manner the contribution that their work brings to society.

To help competition authorities in quantifying the value of their work the OECD has developed a simple methodology that authorities could refer to, when carrying out an impact assessment of their most recent activities. This methodology, together with examples and suggestions on how to present its results are illustrated in the Guide on competition impact assessment

 

Ex-post evaluation of specific competition enforcement interventions and the Reference Guide

The challenge faced by competition agencies when enforcing competition law is enormous. With limited information, resources and time, these agencies must evaluate the likely competitive impact of unprecedented changes in how markets operate and whether their interventions/non-interventions would lead to better market outcomes. The periodic ex post analysis of the actual effects of enforcement decisions a few years after these are taken is a tool that can help agencies better understand the impact of their interventions and to improve future decision making.

Some competition agencies are undertaking them many more are interested in starting to. To support them in this endeavour the OECD has published a Reference Guide  that provides an introduction to the topic, as well as numerous examples and extensive references to the work done so far in this area. 

 

Evaluation of broader impact on the economy and the Factsheet

Ultimately, competition policy should be justified by its beneficial effects on the economy and on consumers’ welfare (for example, its effects on growth, innovation, and employment). 

The links between competition policy interventions and macro-economic variables are not always well understood.  However, there is strong evidence demonstrating that more competitive industries typically have higher rates of productivity growth, and that less competitive sectors are slower to innovate.

The OECD has published a Factsheet that illustrates the links between competition and macroeconomic outcomes and presents the most recent academic analysis in this area.

Key publications

Reference guide on ex-post evaluation of competition agencies’ enforcement decisions

This reference guide presents an in-depth overview of all the issues linked to ex-post assessments. It contains numerous examples and references. It is a great tool for agencies who want to start performing such evaluations and for those who would like to improve the quality of evaluations they already make. More about the rerence guide.

 

 

 

Factsheet on competition and macroeconomic outcomes

To help competition agencies advocate their work, this factsheet summarises evidence on the links between competition and macroeconomic outcomes, such as productivity, growth, innovation and employment. Access the factsheet. 

 

 

 

Guide on competition impact assessment

This guide provides a simple and easy methodology for determining the likely benefits that consumers will derive from competition agencies’ decisions and suggestions on how to present the results of the assessment to ensure that they are correctly interpreted. Access the guide on impact assessment 

Documents and links

OECD workshops on on ex-post evaluation of enforcement decisions by competition authorities

Note by John Kwoka for April 2016 workshop on the ex-post evaluation of competition authorities'acitvities, 2016

Note by Tomaso Duso and Peter Osmosi for April 2015 workshop on the ex-post evaluation of competition authorities'enforcement decisions, 2015 

Evaluation of competitive impacts of government interventions, Discussion held in February 2014

Competition and macroeconomic outcomes factsheet, Discussion held in October 2013

Secretary-General Gurría talks about the role of competition in improving productivity and growth, Iceland, September 2013.

Evaluation of competition enforcement and advocacy activities: results of an OECD survey, 2013 (pdf). Also available in French.

Assessment of the Impact of Competition Authorities' Activities, Note by Stephen Davies, 2013 (pdf)

Evaluating the impact of competition law enforcement, Note by Peter Osmosi, 2012 (pdf)

Impact Evaluation of Merger Decisions, 2011 (pdf)

Evaluation of the Actions and Resources of Competition Authorities, 2005 (pdf)

Competition, Innovation and Productivity Growth, 2002 

Indicators of Product Market Regulation

OECD work on Regulatory Impact Analysis

Chronology of OECD work

2012

The OECD Competition Committee selects "Evaluation of competition interventions" as a priority topic for future work.

2013

OECD presents the outcome of a survey carried out among 46 competition agencies that were asked whether and how they assess the impact of their activities and what kind of information they provide to the government and the public on this impact.

2014

OECD publishes the Guide for helping competition authorities assess the expected impact of their activities in April and the Factsheet on how competition policy affects macro-economic outcomes in October. 

2015

A workshop on ex-post evaluation of competition enforcement decisions is held to provide capacity building to competition officials that are involved in ex-post evaluations. 

2016 A second capacity-building workshop is held in April and the Reference guide on ex-post evaluation of competition agencies' enforcement decisions is released. This concludes the 4-year programme of work on the topic. 

 

» Competition Home Page

Topics

Abuse of dominance & monopolisation

Cartels & anti-competitive agreements

Digital Economy and innovation

Enforcement practices

Evaluation of competition interventions 

International co-operation

Liberalisation & intervention in regulated sectors

Market studies

Mergers

Pro-competitive policy reforms  

Key materials, Tools & Guidance

Best practice roundtables

Calendar of activities

Competition assessment toolkit

Country reports & peer reviews

Fighting bid rigging in public procurement 

Recommendations

Reports by the Competition Committee

Reports by competition agencies

Work in progress

Global Relations

About global relations

Hungary centre

Korea centre

Global Forum on Competition

Latin American and Caribbean Competition Forum 

 

Documents connexes

 

Also AvailableEgalement disponible(s)