Guidelines for Fighting Bid Rigging in Public Procurement

The OECD Competition Committee has developed a specific methodology to help governments improve public procurement by fighting bid rigging. Drawing on the experience of more than 30 jurisdictions, the OECD Guidelines for Fighting Bid Rigging in Public Procurement assist procurement officials to, first, reduce the risks of bid rigging through careful design of the procurement process and, second, to detect bid rigging conspiracies during the procurement process. The Guidelines include two checklists: a Checklist for Detecting Bid Rigging in Public Procurement and a Checklist for Designing the Public Procurement Process to Reduce the Risks of Bid Rigging.

The official version of the Guidelines is available in English and French.

English

French

The Guidelines are available in a number of languages:

Arabic

Chinese

Czech

Finnish

Greek

Hungarian

Indonesian

Japanese

Korean

Lithuanian

Polish

Portuguese

Romanian

Russian

Slovak

Slovenian

Spanish

Turkish

In addition to the Guidelines, the OECD Competition Divison has prepared two brochures to facilitate the use and dissemination of the Guidelines:

An effective procurement policy must be designed to obtain goods and services at the lowest possible price or, more generally, to achieve the best value for money. Vigorous competition among suppliers helps governments realize this objective. However, the formal rules that govern procurement, the way in which an auction is carried out and the design of the auction itself can all act to hinder competition and help promote or sustain bid-rigging conspiracies. Bid-rigging conspiracies waste taxpayers’ money and cause governments to pay far more than a fair price.
Bid rigging occurs in all types of industries and circumstances, and in all parts of the world. When bid rigging impacts public procurement, it has the potential to cause great harm. One reason for this is that public procurement is often a large part of a nation's economy. In many OECD countries, it amounts to 15 per cent of the gross domestic product and in most developing countries, it is substantially more than this.  While bid rigging can emerge in both procurement and “ordinary” markets, it is critical that procurement regulations do not unwittingly facilitate collusive arrangements. The risks for competition in public procurement can be reduced by careful consideration of the various auction features and their impact on the likelihood of collusion. Designing auctions and procurement tenders to minimize collusion may contribute significantly to the fight against anti-competitive behaviour. A well-thought-through tender can reduce or even eliminate the ability of bidders to reach a collusive agreement.

The OECD Guidelines for Fighting Bid Rigging in Public Procurement help to identify:

  • Markets in which bid rigging is more likely to occur so that special precautions can be taken
  • Methods that maximize the number of bids
  • Best practices for tender specifications, requirements and award criteria
  • Procedures that inhibit communication among bidders
  • Suspicious pricing patterns, statements, documents and behaviour by firms, that procurement agents can use to detect bid rigging

The Guidelines provide the most comprehensive strategy available today for the design of tenders to hinder bid rigging and for the detection of bid rigging during the tender process. They can be applied in a decentralized manner across government at both national and local levels. The Guidelines can be used by public officials with no specialized economics or competition policy training.  The Guidelines are available in a number of languages in order to encourage broad consideration of the methods outlined. Comments are welcome on these materials in order to update them for future versions. They should be sent to: Antonio.CAPOBIANCO@oecd.org and Ken.DANGER@oecd.org.

 

Other OECD material on bid rigging and public procurement

 

Useful Links

 

Bookmark this page: www.oecd.org/competition/bidrigging

 

Top of page

Bookshop

The 2005 report focuses on four topics, including progress in member countries and observer countries in fighting cartels; public awareness of the harm casued by cartels, effective sanctions against cartel conduct, in particular sanctions against individuals; and international cooperation in cartel cases

Hard Core Cartels: Third Report on the Implementation of the 1998 Recommendation